"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

What has that to do with anything? What part of "it is none of you business" are you having trouble with ?

Perhaps you need to read the thread and realise that many here do seem to believe that pregnancy is a terrible thing like a permanent disablity or deadly disease, something that causes great suffering and is as bad as losing a limb, or suffering 3rd degree burns over your body. I was trying to establish if you were amongst them.
 
Ah well: suicide is a personal choice so we will just have to put up with it ;)

Actually attempted suicide is illegal in the majority of Western Countries. Obviously suicide isn't because it's hard to prosecute a dead person.
 
Ah, can't have them foreigners taking over now can we?
So, compulsory permanent pregnancy I guess it is. Preferably using fertility drugs to ensure multiple feotuses per pregnancy.

Did you leave a little bit of straw for the farmer?
 
Could you possibly be a little more vague?

Sorry, I didn't know at the time that I was going to have to save the paper to quote and cite it for you. Had I known, I would have also applied for the RF's Million Dollar Prize.
 
So I ask again: should a woman with an unwanted pregnancy be forced to continue with that pregnancy?
 
Perhaps you need to read the thread and realise that many here do seem to believe that pregnancy is a terrible thing like a permanent disablity or deadly disease, something that causes great suffering and is as bad as losing a limb, or suffering 3rd degree burns over your body. I was trying to establish if you were amongst them.

Of course it's not comparable to a third degree burn but pregnancy does make permanent changes to a woman's body. In addition to health issues during pregnancy there are also potential long term affects, including but not limited to scarring, incontinence, wider hips, temporary or permanent injury to the back, potential for future infertility, uterine prolapse, post-partum depression, etc.

That doesn't even take into account the social problems like job performance or promotion. Pregnancy is expensive and time consuming. In a competitive society it can set a woman's career back even if she gives the child up for adoption.

Carrying a child to term isn't a casual event.
 
Perhaps you need to read the thread and realise that many here do seem to believe that pregnancy is a terrible thing like a permanent disablity or deadly disease, something that causes great suffering and is as bad as losing a limb, or suffering 3rd degree burns over your body. I was trying to establish if you were amongst them.

Perhaps you need to understand that it makes no difference whatsoever whether anyone sees it as a terrible thing or not. The only thing that makes a difference is if the pregnant woman does not want to be pregnant.
 
I have no idea what you mean by this or how it is relevant to the post you appear to be responding to.

Exactly what I asked. NZ Law states that abortion is only legal when there is a significant danger to the life, health, or mental well-being of the mother.

Do you think that it is acceptable to break the law to have an abortion as a form of birth control?
 
Exactly what I asked. NZ Law states that abortion is only legal when there is a significant danger to the life, health, or mental well-being of the mother.

Do you think that it is acceptable to break the law to have an abortion as a form of birth control?

I am not discussing NZ law or any other law. I am discussing women's rights to abortion as they should be, not as they are.

Do you think an unwillingly pregnant woman should be compelled to continue the pregnancy?
 
A bit of a derail, but can you cite the countries?

Checking up, I'll have to retract, it appears that most countries, including the US, have actually repealed these laws over the past 20 years, though some non-western ones (Singapore and India for example) do still have them. Assisted suicide is still on the books in most countries.
 
Is it really silly when there are actually people that belive such a thing is not only acceptable, but a fun and exciting thing to do?

I'd like to see some evidence to back up this claim. I've heard a lot of tall stories, but I haven't come across anyone claiming to have undergone an abortion because it's fun and exciting. Nonetheless it's something that anti-abortionist keep bringing up.
 
So I ask again: should a woman with an unwanted pregnancy be forced to continue with that pregnancy?

Sorry for the long answer, but this really depends on the situation. If there is a serious threat to the mother's health (mental or physical), then the mother should be the first priority. If the preganacy is merely unwanted because she doesn't want it interferring in her career, then this is different.

I believe that life is important, all life. A fetus is genetically unique from its mother, and was brought into being their her actions. I believe that in doing so she adopts the responsiblity to protect that life.

In the end I will sum it up this way. If you aren't willing to take on the responsibility of having a child, then make sure you don't get pregnant. Saying "contraceptive don't always work" is a cop out. There are ways to make virtually 100% sure you won't get pregnant even without abstaining, but honestly, if you don't want to take any risk, don't get involved in the activity.

Destroying a life simply because it doesn't fit in with your lifestyle is considered wrong in our society, except it seems when it comes to the most vulnerable of all, the ones who don't have voices.

You ask "should a woman with an unwanted pregnancy be forced to continue with that pregnancy?" but to me this is not just a yes or no answer. I believe that women should be forced to take responsiblity to actually not get pregnant in the first place if they don't want to have a baby (and no that doesn't mean that I believe that contraception is solely the woman's responsibility, I mean it's her responsibility to make sure that it's being used and used correctly by both partners.) With the current lax system where the law is ignored and abortion is on demand, we are giving out the message that it doesn't matter if you don't take responsibility for preventing pregnancy because you can just get rid of it afterwards, so women do just that. If the law was properly enforced and proper education was given then there would be little need to have any woman with an unwanted pregnancy being forced to continue with that pregnancy simply because the number of unwanted pregnancies would drop significantly. But then, hey, responsibility is a dirty word now days...
 
I'd like to see some evidence to back up this claim. I've heard a lot of tall stories, but I haven't come across anyone claiming to have undergone an abortion because it's fun and exciting. Nonetheless it's something that anti-abortionist keep bringing up.

Thanks for misunderstanding me, I never said that they found having an abortion fun and exciting, it's the risk of getting pregnant through un-protected sex they find exciting.
 
Of course it's not comparable to a third degree burn but pregnancy does make permanent changes to a woman's body. In addition to health issues during pregnancy there are also potential long term affects, including but not limited to scarring, incontinence, wider hips, temporary or permanent injury to the back, potential for future infertility, uterine prolapse, post-partum depression, etc.

That doesn't even take into account the social problems like job performance or promotion. Pregnancy is expensive and time consuming. In a competitive society it can set a woman's career back even if she gives the child up for adoption.

Carrying a child to term isn't a casual event.

Just as well the Human race doesn't rely on it for survival, we'd have died out centuries ago.
 
Sorry for the long answer, but this really depends on the situation. If there is a serious threat to the mother's health (mental or physical), then the mother should be the first priority. If the preganacy is merely unwanted because she doesn't want it interferring in her career, then this is different.

I believe that life is important, all life. A fetus is genetically unique from its mother, and was brought into being their her actions. I believe that in doing so she adopts the responsiblity to protect that life.

In the end I will sum it up this way. If you aren't willing to take on the responsibility of having a child, then make sure you don't get pregnant. Saying "contraceptive don't always work" is a cop out. There are ways to make virtually 100% sure you won't get pregnant even without abstaining, but honestly, if you don't want to take any risk, don't get involved in the activity.

Destroying a life simply because it doesn't fit in with your lifestyle is considered wrong in our society, except it seems when it comes to the most vulnerable of all, the ones who don't have voices.

You ask "should a woman with an unwanted pregnancy be forced to continue with that pregnancy?" but to me this is not just a yes or no answer. I believe that women should be forced to take responsiblity to actually not get pregnant in the first place if they don't want to have a baby (and no that doesn't mean that I believe that contraception is solely the woman's responsibility, I mean it's her responsibility to make sure that it's being used and used correctly by both partners.) With the current lax system where the law is ignored and abortion is on demand, we are giving out the message that it doesn't matter if you don't take responsibility for preventing pregnancy because you can just get rid of it afterwards, so women do just that. If the law was properly enforced and proper education was given then there would be little need to have any woman with an unwanted pregnancy being forced to continue with that pregnancy simply because the number of unwanted pregnancies would drop significantly. But then, hey, responsibility is a dirty word now days...

In the case of a woman who has made very effort to avoid conception, but contraception fails, do you think she should be compelled to continue the pregnancy?
Do you think a woman who doesn't bother with contraception should be forced to carry the pregnancy to term?

You keep referring to responsibility. Why is it not responsible to terminate an unwanted pregnancy?
 
I am not discussing NZ law or any other law. I am discussing women's rights to abortion as they should be, not as they are.

Personally I perfer to discuss things within the currently established framework rather than therotical maybe.

So a question back to you, when do you believe it is no longer to terminate one's off-spring, and how do you justify that transistion from killable to not killable?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom