"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Thanks for misunderstanding me, I never said that they found having an abortion fun and exciting, it's the risk of getting pregnant through un-protected sex they find exciting.

This is arrant nonsense: it is deeply insulting: and it says a lot about your attitudes to other people. You are not the superior moral being you think you are.
 
Of course it's not comparable to a third degree burn but pregnancy does make permanent changes to a woman's body. In addition to health issues during pregnancy there are also potential long term affects, including but not limited to scarring, incontinence, wider hips, temporary or permanent injury to the back, potential for future infertility, uterine prolapse, post-partum depression, etc.

That doesn't even take into account the social problems like job performance or promotion. Pregnancy is expensive and time consuming. In a competitive society it can set a woman's career back even if she gives the child up for adoption.

Carrying a child to term isn't a casual event.

BTW, abortion is not exactly a safe option ethier.
 
In the case of a woman who has made very effort to avoid conception, but contraception fails, do you think she should be compelled to continue the pregnancy?

If a reasonable case can be made for why such a pregnancy would be determental.

Do you think a woman who doesn't bother with contraception should be forced to carry the pregnancy to term?

If no effort was made to avoid preganacy, then I think that ir would be very hard to prove such a pregnacy was unwilling. "Please your honour, I know I loaded the gun, pointed it, and pulled the trigger, but I didn't willingly mean for him to die." I can see that defence working really well.

You keep referring to responsibility. Why is it not responsible to terminate an unwanted pregnancy?

Terminating a life is not accepting the responsibily of caring for it, it's washing your hands of it.

Now how about you answer some of my questions?
 
Last edited:
This is arrant nonsense: it is deeply insulting: and it says a lot about your attitudes to other people. You are not the superior moral being you think you are.

Sheeze, Fiona do you do anything other than half read things and then take offence at them? Try going back in the thread and figure out what was being discussed and then come back and talk about it rationally.
 
I read it. According to you people play "russian roulette" with pregnancy for fun. And you think I am irrational?
 
I read it. According to you people play "russian roulette" with pregnancy for fun.

And what would you consider it, based in students havung unprotected sex parties where the idea is for the girl to have unprotected sex with all the guys, who pay money ro get an abortion if she gets pregnant?

And you think I am irrational?

Since you seem to have been "deeply insulted" by my "arrogant nonsence" of stating what a newspaper reported students in New Zealand were doing, then yes, I do think that.
 
OK you believe everything you read in the papers. Fair enough. Then you wish to discuss a serious issue on the basis that we should make law or policy or even come to moral conclusions on that kind of anecdote which, even if true, is hardly usual. You want us to believe that this made the papers because it is not news, in other words.

I am perfectly prepared to believe that you have no idea how insulting you truly are: after all you need these kinds of stories of 39 week abortions and russian roulette because you have no case, otherwise. I cannot do anything about that mindset: I am free to laugh at it when I am in a good mood: and to call if the insult it is when I am not.
 
OK you believe everything you read in the papers. Fair enough. Then you wish to discuss a serious issue on the basis that we should make law or policy or even come to moral conclusions on that kind of anecdote which, even if true, is hardly usual. You want us to believe that this made the papers because it is not news, in other words.

I am perfectly prepared to believe that you have no idea how insulting you truly are: after all you need these kinds of stories of 39 week abortions and russian roulette because you have no case, otherwise. I cannot do anything about that mindset: I am free to laugh at it when I am in a good mood: and to call if the insult it is when I am not.

You totally twist what I say, claim I say things I don't, and say I have no arguement... wow.

My mindset is very simple. abortion is currently used a a form of birth control. Proper education and use of contraceptions should be what is used for birth control, and done right would mean less need for abortion. By removing abortion on demand, and thus the ability to use it as a form of birth control, it puts the responsibility back on where it should be to take adequate precautions to avoid pregnancy proir to getting it on, not to get rid of it when it happens.

I'm neither pro-life nor pro-chioce, I'm anti-unwanted pregnancies.

My mindset is that abortion is a symptom of a larger issue, the ambulance at the bottom of the cliff. Attack the larger issue, solve that with a good fence at the top of the cliff while actively discouraging people from relying on the ambulance below, and we won't need have the ambulance at the bottom in most cases.

Surely you'd have to agree that not having unwanted pregnancies is by far a better solution than on-demand abortion.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for misunderstanding me, I never said that they found having an abortion fun and exciting, it's the risk of getting pregnant through un-protected sex they find exciting.

Really? You really think that the prospect of falling pregnant through unprotected sex with multiple people excited them? Interesting..... that would have never occurred to me.
 
You totally twist what I say, claim I say things I don't, and say I have no arguement... wow.

You didn't say you read in the paper that people were playing russian roulette with pregnancy? Oh ok: who was it said that then? Someone did. Or you did say it but you did not use it as some kind of support for your position? You did not suggest that this is a reason for banning abortion except in the circumstances that you happen to think make it ok?



My mindset is very simple. abortion is currently used a a form of birth control.

I believe I read that this was true in Japan in the 1970's (and maybe still is, for all I know). I have seen no evidence whatsoever that it is routinely used in that way in this country. But if it was, so what? What business is it of yours? Are you pregnant?


Proper education and use of contraceptions should be what is used for birth control, and done right would mean less need for abortion.

Certainly

By removing abortion on demand, and thus the ability to use it as a form of birth control, it puts the responsibility back on where it should be to take adequate precautions to avoid pregnancy proir to getting it on, not to get rid of it when it happens it results in forcing people to have babies they don't want for the sole purpose of making you feel better.

FTFY

I'm neither pro-life nor pro-chioce, I'm anti-unwanted pregnancies.


If you are not pro-life then why do you wish to force people to do as you wish rather than as they wish?

My mindset is that abortion is a symptom of a larger issue, the ambulance at the bottom of the cliff. Attack the larger issue, solve that with a good fence at the top of the cliff while actively discouraging people from relying on the ambulance below, and we won't need have the ambulance at the bottom in most cases.

And you need to make law to enforce this, why? If education and good contraception will do the job then you don't need to take control of someone else's body to get your own way: if it won't then you have absolutely no right to force your particular view on anyone else. If you don't like abortion don't have one: that is where your responsibility starts and finishes

Surely you'd have to agree that not having unwanted pregnancies is by far a better solution than on-demand abortion.

I believe we should avoid unwanted pregnancy and that we should have abortion on demand when that fails.
 
Last edited:

I suppose it depends where you define the line for "safe" It's unsafe in the way that an appendectomy, or y'know driving are unsafe in that risks do exist.

But I assure you, that no intelligent doctor is going to tell you that the risks of an early term abortion are even near those of pregnancy to term and delivery.

In fact, in the developed world, mortality from childbirth is 11 times that of mortality from abortion. By carrying that child full term, you are increasing your risk of death more than ten fold.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion#Health_risks

Not only that, but there is a lot of misinformation about those risks.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/13908074/

What is unsafe is an illegal, unregulated abortion. In places in the world where abortion is illegal, this procedure that normally ranks among the safest surgical procedures performed, can become quite dangerous.
 
Care to cite this stat? For instance Depo-Provera® Hormonal Injections are claimed at greater than 99% effectiveness, and obviously if you use more than one form, for example, Hormonal Injections, a male Condom, and spermacide, then even using the typical failure rates you would drop your chance of getting pregnant to around 0.000364% or about 1:3,000. If you use them properly you can drop the chance to 0.000045%, or 1 in 20,000.

Ok, so let's play with your numbers a little bit.

There are approx 310mil people in the US. Roughly half are female, and roughly half of those females are between the ages of 15 and 50. That makes somewhere in the neighborhood of 77.5 million women who would be considered at risk of pregnancy.

Given your "best" chances of avoiding an unwanted pregnancy, allowing each of these women to have sex only once in a year's time, we would find that approx 3875 women would still become pregnant. Now, factor in that the average for sexual encounters for women in this demographic is likely to be quite a bit higher than once/year, and you can just multiply that 3875 by whatever that number is, for example: let's say the average number of sexual encounters in a year for this demographic is 10 (that's not even once/month, on average) - and that's now 38,750 women with unwanted pregnancies every year.


Of course, the number we see in actuality is higher as I'm probably estimating low for the average of sexual encounters and these numbers are given the assumption that all fertile women in the US would use the means of protection you have included in your 1/20,000 estimate.




Moving past a strictly numerical look at this issue, we find that there are health risks inherent to being pregnant. That's why it's covered under insurance plans, and that's why it's about 4x as expensive for my GF (24yo) to obtain health insurance as it is for me (28yo working in a hazardous environment).

Granted that abortions come with risks, generally those risks are far lessor than the risks to a woman's health associated with carrying the fetus to full-term.


Seems someone's just jealous that other people are having fun with their bodies - and thus need to be punished for that fun. Enjoying one's body is a sin, after all.





My personal stance on the matter is along the lines of what Prof Yaffle was discussing yesterday: I believe abortion should be possible up to the point of labor. Not for any reason other than this is a completely arbitrary, but (relatively) easily defined point. The viable argument fails in that what is viable in this particular county may not be what is viable 2 counties to the left (or right) which leads to: "You say I can't have an abortion because the fetus is viable here, well...I'll just go to a different county where the fetus is not viable and have my abortion."
 
Last edited:
There are approx 310mil people in the US. Roughly half are female, and roughly half of those females are between the ages of 15 and 50. That makes somewhere in the neighborhood of 77.5 million women who would be considered at risk of pregnancy.

Given your "best" chances of avoiding an unwanted pregnancy, allowing each of these women to have sex only once in a year's time, we would find that approx 3875 women would still become pregnant. Now, factor in that the average for sexual encounters for women in this demographic is likely to be quite a bit higher than once/year, and you can just multiply that 3875 by whatever that number is, for example: let's say the average number of sexual encounters in a year for this demographic is 10 (that's not even once/month, on average) - and that's now 38,750 women with unwanted pregnancies every year.

I agree with your general position, but you're calculating contraceptive effectiveness as though the percentage number refers to risk of pregnancy per session of intercourse. Effectiveness percentage actually measures the risk over a year of typical sexual activity.

http://www.condomeffectiveness.com/

So your first number would actually be the appropriate one for this method of birth control, not multiplied by the amount of intercourse. If the risk is 0.000045%, that's for a full year of typical sexual activity in a sexually active woman.
 
I agree with your general position, but you're calculating contraceptive effectiveness as though the percentage number refers to risk of pregnancy per session of intercourse. Effectiveness percentage actually measures the risk over a year of typical sexual activity.

http://www.condomeffectiveness.com/

So your first number would actually be the appropriate one for this method of birth control, not multiplied by the amount of intercourse. If the risk is 0.000045%, that's for a full year of typical sexual activity in a sexually active woman.

Thank you, this was something I wasn't aware of either.
 
Possession is 9/10ths of the law.

The great thing about these threads is you come to realise how deluded men are who come out with statements such as "We're having a baby" or "She's carrying our baby" are. No chaps, the reality is that it's 100% her foetus/baby, to do with as she sees fit up until birth, whether you or anyone else likes it or not.

Not that many a woman won't try to fool a man into thinking that the foetus inside her body is somehow partly his responsibility despite him having no rights over it at all.
 
And on what basis have you chosen the moment of delivery as the dividing line between when it's OK to kill the baby and when it's not?



Why not? It's not substantially different than it was a minute ago, when you were in favor letting someone kill it. What's special about delivery?

Legality, for one. But let's get to the real point - a game I do not play. If I were to say "OK I'll give you say 5 minutes before birth." You respond with "What is the big difference between that and 5 minutes and 1 second?" and so on endlessly. I am not willing to play silly games with this and I am way on the side of woman's right to choose so, there you are. YMCV.

That is also why I do not "hide behind" (meaning I don't consider it hiding behind but a lot of anti-abortion/choicers do) Pro-choice but clearly state I am and have been since I first understood the concept pro-abortion - with the assumption that it is the woman's choice.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, I didn't know at the time that I was going to have to save the paper to quote and cite it for you. Had I known, I would have also applied for the RF's Million Dollar Prize.

The fact remains that "I read an article in an unknown newspaper an unknown period of time ago" does not constitute a cite.
 
Perhaps you need to read the thread and realise that many here do seem to believe that pregnancy is a terrible thing like a permanent disablity or deadly disease, something that causes great suffering and is as bad as losing a limb, or suffering 3rd degree burns over your body. I was trying to establish if you were amongst them.
Of course it's not comparable to a third degree burn but pregnancy does make permanent changes to a woman's body. In addition to health issues during pregnancy there are also potential long term affects, including but not limited to scarring, incontinence, wider hips, temporary or permanent injury to the back, potential for future infertility, uterine prolapse, post-partum depression, etc.

Here it is again:

Of course, the perineal tissues almost always bloodily tear during
delivery, particularly in a first birth. If a woman doesn't have an
episiotomy these tears are commonly anterior (forward), ripping
through the urethra and labia--injuries which are difficult to repair
and exceedingly painful. On the other hand, with an episiotomy, a
woman is at increased risk of a tear into the anal sphincter and
rectum. All except the most superficial perineal lacerations are
accompanied by varying degrees of injury to a woman's lower vagina
which must be carefully repaired or she can wind up with a painfully
scarred, misshapen, and/or relaxed vaginal outlet, rectocele
(herniation of the rectum through the fascia into the vagina),
cystocele (herniation of the bladder into the vagina), or uterine
prolapse.

And/or, a woman can have lacerations to the upper part of her vagina
which typically extend deep into the underlying tissue, giving rise to
hemorrhage and requiring extensive surgical repair also. And/or, a
woman's levator ani muscle may be separated or injured such that
relaxation of the entire pelvic floor results, which can lead to
urinary incontinence too if the pubococcygeus muscle is involved.
And/or, there can be deep cervical tears, and in some cases the entire
cervix can be torn away from the vagina, sometimes extending to
involve the lower part of the uterus, the uterine artery and its major
branches, and even ripping through the peritoneum into the abdomen.

Naturally, cervical lacerations of merely an inch or so are inevitable
in childbirth, which in healing permanently change the shape of the
woman's cervix from round to elongated and as a consequence typically
turn the cervix inside-out with exposure of the delicate
mucus-producing endocervical glands, which frequently results in
persistent inflammation, irritation, discharge, and bleeding.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom