"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Just for a bit of balance, I've heard some pro-choicer points of view that have seemed just as morally inconsistent as some of the pro-lifers'. For example some of them talk about babies and foetues as if something magical happens at the moment of birth that imbues the child with personhood. I don't know how anyone can believe that its perfectly ok to abort a foetus in the 38th week (where there is no medical reason for it), but a terrible crime to kill a newborn slightly premature baby. Now I know such a late abortion for non medical reasons just doesn't happen, but I have still heard some pro-choicers argue this point.
 
You can practice safe/protected sex and still get pregnant. The best birth control is only around 99% effective. In that case, a choice of abortion would be valid. I, personally, don't see that abortion should be used as birth control. However, mistakes happen, and as such, abortion is an option. If it was my daughter, I certainly wouldn't want her messing up her life by having a child before her time. A fetus is not a child, IMO.

It is interesting that it seems that this all takes on magical importance when the sperm is introduced to the process.
 
Just for a bit of balance, I've heard some pro-choicer points of view that have seemed just as morally inconsistent as some of the pro-lifers'. For example some of them talk about babies and fetuses as if something magical happens at the moment of birth that imbues the child with personhood. I don't know how anyone can believe that its perfectly ok to abort a fetus in the 38th week (where there is no medical reason for it), but a terrible crime to kill a newborn slightly premature baby. Now I know such a late abortion for non medical reasons just doesn't happen, but I have still heard some pro-choicers argue this point.

Agree with this, Kathy (or is it Cathy?).

How does going through the vaginal canal (or in the case of a C-section, being pulled from the uterus) suddenly make you a person? How is birth after 9 months the line to draw? Especially given the complicating factor that many babies are born very prematurely and survive.

It's an arbitrary and problematic position to take.
 
Agree with this, Kathy (or is it Cathy?).

How does going through the vaginal canal (or in the case of a C-section, being pulled from the uterus) suddenly make you a person? How is birth after 9 months the line to draw? Especially given the complicating factor that many babies are born very prematurely and survive.

It's an arbitrary and problematic position to take.

The only way I can look at it is that there are often situations where there is no action you can take that is 100% right. When someone is pregnant with an unwanted child, the best we can hope for is that they will do the "least wrong" thing.

It's Katy BTW.
 
The difference I would see is that a foetus, no matter how close to term it is, relies on the mother's body to survive. After birth, whilst hardly independant, it doesn't have to rely on the mother's body if some other person takes care of it. So I guess for me the magical difference that birth makes isn't that the foetus suddenly changes, but that the mother now has bodily autonomy from the foetus. That's why I think killing a new-born baby is more morally wrong than late-term abortion, because it's just needless killing. If that makes sense?
 
Wow, way to miss the point, Xephyr. That wasn't what I said at all. Rather, YOU claimed that abortion opponents wanted to force women to raise unwanted children.

And now you're just being a comedian.

Please do point to any one of my posts where I come even remotely close to saying what you claim I did.

You're confusing me with another poster.
 
I think many in the anti abortion crowd see pregnancy as a consequence of poor choices. Thus they want women to suffer through it. However, rape isn't a choice...
 
The difference I would see is that a foetus, no matter how close to term it is, relies on the mother's body to survive. After birth, whilst hardly independant, it doesn't have to rely on the mother's body if some other person takes care of it. So I guess for me the magical difference that birth makes isn't that the foetus suddenly changes, but that the mother now has bodily autonomy from the foetus. That's why I think killing a new-born baby is more morally wrong than late-term abortion, because it's just needless killing. If that makes sense?

See that's a position I can understand, even though I might not agree with it, because it's about putting a subjective weighting on two wrongs. the wrong of killing a being which is to all intents and purposes the same as a new born baby, versus the wrong of requiring a woman to continue "leasing out her body" for a little longer. At earlier stages of pregnancy we come to the same conclusion, but at later stages I put more weight on the foetus/baby's right to life and less on the harm done to the woman compared to you so we come out with different answers.

But I have talked to people who utterly deny any kind of humanity to a foetus as long as it is pre birth (even to the point of talking about it as "just a bunch of cells" no matter how developed) and then suddenly confer human/person status on it once it is born. There aren't that many people that think like that, but they do exist.
 
I think many in the anti abortion crowd see pregnancy as a consequence of poor choices. Thus they want women to suffer through it. However, rape isn't a choice...

Whilst I am sure these people exist, they bear no resemblance to how I felt, or to anyone else I know (including many of my relatives) in the pro life movement. My (and their) focus was on the baby and we put more emphasis on that than we did on the woman's right to control her body - even at early stages. At no point did I ever hear any of the talk about punishing women and making them suffer. TBH I think the effect on the woman was just disregarded as unimportant in comparison to the new life. And even then many of them did feel a lot of compassion for women who found themselves in this position - I know I did.
 
I hear the argument from the anti abortion crowd quite often. "consequence of your actions"
 
If one has an abortion one is dealing with the consequences of one's actions. This has already been pointed out. Why do those who claim that they want people to take responsibility not want them to take it in the way that seems best to them?
 
I've heard from plenty of anti abortionists that abortion isn't a responsible choice.
 
If one has an abortion one is dealing with the consequences of one's actions. This has already been pointed out. Why do those who claim that they want people to take responsibility not want them to take it in the way that seems best to them?
Because that's the way our society works. If you drive drunk and end lose your leg in a car accident as a result, the law doesn't allow you to get a prosthesis -- you have to take responsibility for your actions by living for the rest of your life with one leg. If you play with matches and start a fire that causes third-degree burns on your body, no doctor in his right mind will give you skin grafting treatment. If you smoke and contract lung cancer in any civilized country, you die a horrific death because lung cancer treatment is reserved for those who didn't contract the illness in a stupid way.

We're grown-ups who take responsibility for our actions. It's that simple.
 
Just for a bit of balance, I've heard some pro-choicer points of view that have seemed just as morally inconsistent as some of the pro-lifers'. For example some of them talk about babies and foetues as if something magical happens at the moment of birth that imbues the child with personhood. I don't know how anyone can believe that its perfectly ok to abort a foetus in the 38th week (where there is no medical reason for it), but a terrible crime to kill a newborn slightly premature baby. Now I know such a late abortion for non medical reasons just doesn't happen, but I have still heard some pro-choicers argue this point.


There are precious few at ease/With moral ambiguities/And so they act as though they don't exist
 
Because that's the way our society works. If you drive drunk and end lose your leg in a car accident as a result, the law doesn't allow you to get a prosthesis -- you have to take responsibility for your actions by living for the rest of your life with one leg. If you play with matches and start a fire that causes third-degree burns on your body, no doctor in his right mind will give you skin grafting treatment. If you smoke and contract lung cancer in any civilized country, you die a horrific death because lung cancer treatment is reserved for those who didn't contract the illness in a stupid way.

We're grown-ups who take responsibility for our actions. It's that simple.
Thats good satire.
 
No, aborting the fetus during the 39th week would be called a third trimester abortion.



It doesn't require someone wait. They could change their mind. And yes, given the range of human behavior (including murdering your own children), I think it would happen.

But that's irrelevant to what fuelair believes. Regardless of how often he thinks the question might arise, he still either finds it acceptable or unacceptable. And so do you. Would YOU care to state which?

Oh, sorry, thought you were trying to make a point. And thought I was perfectly clear. I believe in a woman's right to have an abortion right up to the time the birth is occuring but not after that (Actual laws that were not made up just to criminalize abortion take over then). I do not believe the born child should be
able to be put in a sack or otherwise killed at that point, though I do believe given the likely psychological condition of the new mother care should be taken before criminalization is implied/brought in if she does something like that in the heat of the birthing/close to same. Would prefer not though.

After any reasonable time, though, I am totally against harming the child. I actually like children, also for reasons stated multiple times in various threads.
 
Oh, sorry, thought you were trying to make a point. And thought I was perfectly clear. I believe in a woman's right to have an abortion right up to the time the birth is occuring but not after that (Actual laws that were not made up just to criminalize abortion take over then).

And on what basis have you chosen the moment of delivery as the dividing line between when it's OK to kill the baby and when it's not?

I do not believe the born child should be able to be put in a sack or otherwise killed at that point

Why not? It's not substantially different than it was a minute ago, when you were in favor letting someone kill it. What's special about delivery?
 
The difference I would see is that a foetus, no matter how close to term it is, relies on the mother's body to survive. After birth, whilst hardly independant, it doesn't have to rely on the mother's body if some other person takes care of it. So I guess for me the magical difference that birth makes isn't that the foetus suddenly changes, but that the mother now has bodily autonomy from the foetus. That's why I think killing a new-born baby is more morally wrong than late-term abortion, because it's just needless killing. If that makes sense?

If the foetus is in, say, its 39th week (and even earlier), then abortion isn't the only option to remove its dependency on its mother. It could be removed alive, making aborting it "just needless killing".

I'm afraid Loss Leader's quote above applies even to this reasoning.
 
If one has an abortion one is dealing with the consequences of one's actions. This has already been pointed out. Why do those who claim that they want people to take responsibility not want them to take it in the way that seems best to them?

Because if a foetus is a person, then this innocent person is involuntarily paying the biggest consequence of all for something they had no choice in. Abortion then becomes primarily making someone else pay the consequences.

If you believe a foetus is a person, then this follows logically. If you do not believe a foetus is a person, it does not. That is, has been, and probably always will be the central moral question regarding abortion: what constitutes a person. And there is no definitive answer, no way to prove one side right or wrong. Which is why the most annoying position on the abortion issue is when someone cannot even respect the opposing viewpoint (edit: I'm not directing that last bit at anyone in particular).
 
That is, has been, and probably always will be the central moral question regarding abortion: what constitutes a person. And there is no definitive answer, no way to prove one side right or wrong.


That only applies if you think of abortion as a moral issue. If you think of it as only a pragmatic, evolutionary or economic issue, the concept of "personhood" becomes much less important.

It is undeniably true that humans, like many species, practice infanticide. At times in history and in places in the world with no option for abortion, humans have killed newborn babies. They have done this for reasons of population control in the community, to conserve resources for the family, and to remove deformed and disabled babies who would be too difficult to care for.

Abortion, then, is a more economically viable way of doing what people have always done. It removes the infant from the population much earlier - preserving more of the economic and physical resources of the mother.

A late-term abortion (or the murder of a live infant) is just inefficient. It should be discouraged for that reason alone.

The whole concept of "personhood" never has to enter into it.

(Of course, now many may say that I have opened the door to the forced sterilization and even murder of people with disabilities, degenerative diseases and even late-life traumatic brain injuries. These people would be right. My argument has some internal inconsistencies. As I said before, these types of inconsistencies appear unavoidable. Otherwise all of philosophy could fit on a three-by-five card.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom