Only if you DEFINE people as not including fetuses.
Rather missing the point, Ziggurat: I do define people as separate from foetuses, and that remark was an aside to show why I do: but for the purpose of the post I was giving you your point. I thought I made that plain. So your snark about circular argument really does not apply
The answer is obvious (so either you're clueless or you din't want to find it). I had no role in creating the situation of a transplant patient in need of an organ. The same is simply not true with the vast majority of fetuses and mothers. Your role in creating a situation has quite a lot to do with your responsibilities towards those involved. Is that really a difficult or controversial notion?
It is neither difficult nor controversial. It neatly disposes of any idea that this is about the right to life, however. What it is, is special pleading. I will go through it again. I have given you the curious idea that foetus is a person, for the sake of argument. As such it should logically get exactly the same rights as every other person. The kidney donation example shows that people do not have the right to the use of other people's bodies without their consent. Since you argue a foetus is a person: and since people have no such right: it follows that foetuses have no such right. Is that really a difficult or controversial notion?
To get around this you wish to give the foetus special extra rights. And I wondered where they came from. You have not answered that: you have skipped a step. If the foetus has a special right the rest of us do not have then someone has a corresponding duty, presumably. And you locate that duty with the woman and not with anyone else. And you do so on the basis of her role in creating it. But you have not established it has any such special right in the first place. Without that right there is no concomitant duty, and so you have to do that bit. You haven't. As you said upthread, in relation to the case for abortion, you may be right but you have to make the case.
I can imagine a number of ways it might be done. I have already mentioned one: if nobody has that duty then it does not have the possibility of life: but neither does the kidney patient, so that does not get us any further forward. The foetus, according to you, has a right to life that people do not have: so it cannot have them on the basis that it is a person.
It has been argued that since she had sex the woman assumed that responsibility. But she quite clearly didn't if she wants an abortion: similarly you may choose to donate your kidney and people will probably be quite admiring if you do: but you are not forced to assume that responsibility and there is no reason I can think of why you should be
You say that the difference that makes a difference is that you had no role in causing the situation: so let us imagine that you did. Is it your position that if you damage someone's kidneys in a bar fight or a car crash or just by accidentally injuring them with no intent to harm, that you should then be forced to donate your kidney to them (assuming a match or very good anti rejection drugs or whatever)? I suppose some people would think that was a reasonable proposition, but I do not think it is the law in any country I ever heard of. As has been pointed out, law is not the same as morality and perhaps that is the more moral stance: I personally do not think it is. But it is at least curious that it is not the law in those countries which take for granted that women should be forced to carry children they do not want in order to take responsibility for actions that do not seem to logically confer any more or different duties, by their nature.
In the end unless you can demonstrate why the foetus gets special rights on some other basis your argument really does come down to punishment. And you cannot do it on the basis that it is a person. Or if you can I have not yet seen you do it.
It is this kind of problem which leads some of us to the conclusion that this is some version of punishment/control and not what it purports to be. The issue is not between a woman and a foetus: it is between a woman and other adults. If you take control of someone else's body you have denied them the very foundation of personhood: but that does not seem to be a problem for you so long as the person so denied is a woman. Why is that case different?
Translation: oh, you men!
Tip of the day, Fiona: if you need to resort to your gender in order to justify your position, you're on weak ground.
Indeed. I do not know if those who have preached their moral superiority on this thread are men: so that was bad of me. But in my defence I will say this: the casual insults are so ingrained that I am perfectly prepared to believe that those making those insults are unaware of their nature: and since many of them are predicated on a conception of pregnancy as a "blessing" or as a minor inconvenience akin to a summer cold, I will be very suprised if they are not. It is deeply annoying to have the kind of nonsense we have seen: I will take any baby you care to send, is a prime example. I am not attacking that in the terms you have been defending: I am attacking it because it is not something that is ever going to happen: and that, I think, was in line with your own point.
I would have a great deal more respect if people founded on something that could actually happen to them and they could actually do something about. Men cannot become pregnant: it is difficult for them to understand the enormity of what they are asking when they blithely talk about carrying a foetus they do not want to term, just because it suits others.
There are indeed women who are against abortion and it was wrong to talk as if all such statements are from one gender: of course they are not. I have no respect for women who wish to impose their will on others either: I just don't usually come across them arguing it as if it was nothing, which has been at strand in this thread: so for those who are women and are making that case, and for the avoidance of doubt: you can become pregnant: so show me that you carried an
unwanted foetus to term, and it was a walk in the park. Do not tell me that it worked out fine and you would not be without the consequent baby now that it is here: I can admire it if you had the principle and saw it through: but what I want to hear from you is your conviction that this is the right solution for every woman who finds themselves in that situation.
And again, for men who take that view, you cannot experience this: but you can donate a kidney: that is not a ridiculous scenario; it does not require the participation of anyone else who must give a baby to you knowing nothing about you at all, thus ensuring there is no danger of you having to deliver: if there is no element of punishment in your attitude to abortion, and if you found on a right to life, I can see no possible objection to your doing so. I think the recovery time for kidney donation is less than nine months in fact: so you are getting off quite lightly and you don't even have to look after the recipient for the next 16 years.
