"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

I really don't care for the concept of "personhood" in this debate because it is regarded as an all or nothing category which renders the debate very black and white and polarised. I prefer to think in terms of the amount of harm done. I think an early embryo is so undeveloped that it cannot have a great amount of harm done to it - whereas forcing a woman to carry said embryo to term does a lot of harm to the woman. As the foetus becomes more mature, these relative harms shift, and can also be altered by the circumstances of the woman, and whether or not the foetus has a severe disability. I believe this leads to a more nuanced debate, less polarization and therefore even leads some people to change their minds.

The evidence for this last assertion is that I was one of those who changed their mind (while I was still a catholic) because I began to think about it in those terms. The arguments about a foetus not being a person until birth, and about a woman having the absolute right to control their own body had previously been unpersuasive to me because they didn't address my own viewpoint in the slightest.

What do you think you're doing displaying a reasonable position on abortion this late in the thread?

If you can't be extremist stay out of the thread!
 
The responsibility argument is the weakest I have ever heard.
Yet at least one poster here presents it, and steadfastly denies it has anything to do with punishment.
Just how an unwanted pregnancy can be enforced because the woman didn't take enough care, and not be punishment for failing to take enough care, is beyond me.
Of course it would be better if unwanted pregnancies were prevented, but to enforce them once they occur, because they are the result of carelessness, and for no other reason, is punishment.
If abortion is denied for reasons other than carelessness, then the responsibility argument is redundant.

I think part of the reason they don't see the argument as punishment-based is that they don't see pregnancy or parenthood as punishments.
Do you view mandatory child support payments as punishment? I don't believe the State does.
 
if there is no verifiable number of people wanting to adopt a baby, how can anyone be sure that the demand would continue to outpace the supply were abortions to be criminalized?

The problem is your attempt to characterize this as my argument. This is opposing an argument by the other side -- by those who claim that stopping X abortions means creating X orphans.
If we agree that we don't know how many adoptive parents exist, but we know there are a lot -- then that's not a valid argument anymore. Stopping X abortions might result in some number of orphans, but we don't know.

To put it another way: "There is no evidence to support the argument that stopping abortions will create any number of orphans. Therefore this is not a good reason to support abortion."
 
Last edited:
Except for fetuses, it's not possible. And unless you want to permit abortions up to the point of birth (and the consensus is that we shouldn't), then yes, fetuses do get to do exactly that.

Personally I do think it is the woman's choice right up to the moment of birth, yes. In practice that is so rare as to not be worth discussing and I can live with indulging the control freakery/existential angst or whatever it is that leads people to think there is a point when they can take control of MY body against my will.

Of course it is not possible for people to live inside other people's bodies: and that settles the question as to whether a foetus is a person, actually. But that aside the question was one of the "rights" of the foetus in this part of the discussion. And those who oppose abortion were said to be driven to that position because they believe that the foetus is a person. If you think a foetus is a person then it gets the same rights as everybody else: that is, it has no right to use anyone else's body for its own "purposes" without their consent. And that is an end of it, if you found on personhood

So now we wriggle: it is a person when it suits them but it is a "special" person with "special" rights (ie it is a decoy duck and not a duck at all) when that suits them. Where does it get those special rights from, then? I have no idea how the argument goes from there but I imagine it gets them from having no other way to live: that is moot but let me give you it. The person who needs your kidney, if it happens you are the only match, has no other way to live either. So you presumably agree that if you are the only match you should be forced to give up your kidney whether you want to or not: or does the person lose the "special" rights after birth? Or is it not a person after all?

We can of course fall back on practicality, as you did. You will probably not be the "only" match so it is not your problem: but in practice organ donars are quite scarce compared to demand. Much like babies for adoption, in fact. So there is no doubt you can save a life by donating a kidney. But somehow that is different? I wonder why

For me I think it is quite telling when men come on here with their fanciful scenarios which cannot and will not happen and purport to have shown their moral superiority. If one of you shows the evidence you have donated a healthy kidney to save a life I will concede you at least have the moral right to an opinion (though not to control). If you can't show that then get off my lawn.
 
Last edited:
Does a fetus who's going to be given up for adoption have a family?


I was looking forward to your argument in reply, SC, but you didn't really bring an argument in reply. Instead, you mostly begged the question of the personhood of a fetus. You did this by conflating the concept of the moral definition of "person" with the legal definition:


Oh sure, the fetus has a mother, but it's not a member of a family in the same way that Aunt Bessie is. You don't invite it to weddings or have it sign your christmas card. And a name isn't conferred until a certificate of live birth or stillbirth is issued. Neither of my fetuses had a name before they were born; of course, I didn't even know if they would be male or female. So you don't think a birthday is in any way important? It's actually the dividing line between being a fetus and being a person. You get a certificate and you can apply for a social insurance number and be considered a dependent for tax purposes. None of that happens before an actual date of birth when you stopped living off your mother's body and started living on your own. ...
I would classify them as persons (were I queen of the world) with the right to medical care. They are still issued birth certificates and can be counted as dependents for tax purposes or welfare benefits...
But so far the pro-life side is "winning" based on the concepts of personhood. A fetus is not legally counted as a person.


I asked what definition of personhood excluded all unborn and included all people who have been born. You responded, basically, that this is the law. But the law has already made a moral and/or practical decision. The law comes after people determine these issues.

A thing is not moral or immoral depending on the law. I think that discrimination against homosexuals is immoral (to the extent morality exists), but it's still legal. Hell, in some instances (DADT, DOMA), it's actually required.

Similarly, law has been used to define black people, Jews and hosts of others. Had I asked you in 1925 what it was about a black person that necessarily defined him as having to go to a separate school, it would not have been a sufficient moral defense that this was the law.

So, I am unimpressed that you define a person as someone who has been born because the law confers certain rights on those who have been born. The question is whether those laws are right. In order to answer that, we must ask what definition of a person (in a lawless world) necessarily includes those who have been born and necessarily excludes those who have not.

Personally, I think no such definition exists. A 34 week-old fetus has more in common with a newborn baby than an 84 year-old person in a persistent vegitative state. I think the concept of personhood is either: 1) irrelevant to the entire abortion debate; or 2) is only one factor that must be weighed.

If we state that personhood does NOT confer an absolute right to life, but only a right to have one's interests weighed against all others, then perhaps we will find that abortion should be allowed while beating 3 day-olds to death should not.

I'll ask you and anyone else again, how can you define "personhood" (without respect to itself or, by extension, a law that has already defined it) in such a manner that all unborn fail that test and all born people pass it?


So if you see a comatose patient in the hospital, you sometimes do a double take because for a second you thought you were looking at a pregnant woman?


That's silly. A 6'4" black man can hardly be mistaken for a 4'11" Korean woman, and yet they are both defined exactly the same way when they bring a suit in court.


A fetus is living inside a woman's body. Sometimes I wish holodeck technology of some kind was possible so that men could understand exactly what it's like to have a creature living inside their abdomen. Once it happens, you'll understand how a fetus is nothing like a baby, and most definitely nothing like a comatose patient.


All that means is that there may be rights that can trump whatever rights automatically obtain to "personhood"; or that "personhood" may not come with any innate rights whatsoever.
 
Last edited:
Of course it is not possible for people to live inside other people's bodies

Only if you DEFINE people as not including fetuses.

and that settles the question as to whether a foetus is a person, actually.

It is no surprise that if you define "person" to not include fetuses, then fetuses are not people.

Amazing how much you can prove with circular logic.

We can of course fall back on practicality, as you did. You will probably not be the "only" match so it is not your problem: but in practice organ donars are quite scarce compared to demand. Much like babies for adoption, in fact. So there is no doubt you can save a life by donating a kidney. But somehow that is different? I wonder why

The answer is obvious (so either you're clueless or you din't want to find it). I had no role in creating the situation of a transplant patient in need of an organ. The same is simply not true with the vast majority of fetuses and mothers. Your role in creating a situation has quite a lot to do with your responsibilities towards those involved. Is that really a difficult or controversial notion?

For me I think it is quite telling when men come on here with their fanciful scenarios which cannot and will not happen and purport to have shown their moral superiority. If one of you shows the evidence you have donated a healthy kidney to save a life I will concede you at least have the moral right to an opinion (though not to control).

Translation: oh, you men!

Tip of the day, Fiona: if you need to resort to your gender in order to justify your position, you're on weak ground.
 
Of course it is not possible for people to live inside other people's bodies: and that settles the question as to whether a foetus is a person, actually.


Does it settle the question of personhood, or does it settle the question of whether personhood confers an absolute right to life? It seems that your position is consistent with both.


If one of you shows the evidence you have donated a healthy kidney to save a life I will concede you at least have the moral right to an opinion (though not to control). If you can't show that then get off my lawn.


But that's only true of men who disagree with you. Would you claim that men who agree that a woman has an absolute right to choose abortion have no right to an opinion?

And what of women who cannot have children? Since it is impossible for my 66 year-old mother to become pregnant (she had a hystorectomy), does she lose her right to a say in the debate? Be careful if you answer that she can stay on your lawn by virtue of having at least once been pregnant; she may well have found Jebus and changed her mind since then. I mean, if Jane Roe (Norma McCorvey) can do it, surely others can.

Abortion is part of the fundamental set of issues that define how we treat those among us who cannot advocate for themselves - 39-week fetuses, 3 day-old babies, the comatose, those dying in pain, even criminals to an extent. That seems to be an important enough set of topics to ask everybody's opinion.

Why do you disagree?
 
I think part of the reason they don't see the argument as punishment-based is that they don't see pregnancy or parenthood as punishments.
Do you view mandatory child support payments as punishment? I don't believe the State does.

Forced pregnancy can be nothing but a punishment.
Dragging in child support payments is, quite frankly, too silly to even consider.
 
And there are consequences for people who harm or kill a child which DOES belong to them. You think the two situations are different because you think children are people and fetuses are not. But not everyone shares that opinion. The problem is that you can't even acknowledge that this is what they believe, and that given such a belief, opposition to abortion follows naturally.
Then you have to provide a compelling reason that fetuses either are persons, or should be given some kind of rights of personhood, or that all people need to live under the laws which follow from the assertions of others. If Mary Jones asserts that a fetus is a person, and Barb Smith asserts that a fetus is not a person, then who gets to decide what happens to Barb Smith's fetus? As the law stands right now, a fetus is not a person in the US or Canada. If you want, give me the most compelling argument that you can that would change my mind and convince me that a fetus is a person, or that a fetus should have some rights.
Wow. Can you twist logic any further? If I don't tell you who to have sex with or whether or how to use birth control, if in fact those choices remain yours, then how on earth am I telling you with whom you must breed and when? I'm not.
I know that sex and breeding are intertwined, but in reality, most people have a lot more of the recreational kind than the procreational kind. If I want to have sex with BillyBob because he's cute and I'm horny, it doesn't necessarily follow that I want to have his baby. In fact, I take precautions to make sure it doesn't happen. But if I still wind up pregnant, then abortion is another option to keep me from breeding with BillyBob.
The state outlawing abortion would restrict your options. But it would NOT do what you claimed it would do.
If the state outlaws abortion in cases of rape, then it most certainly would be telling a woman that she had no choice in her breeding partner.
There is no reason you find compelling. But there are reasons that others find compelling. And that is enough to make the question central to the debate, even if you don't want it to be, even if you don't think it should be. It is.
I'll repeat myself. Give me the most compelling reason.

And that excuses you from conflating babies and children... how?
I never conflated babies and children. That was part of the adoption debate, which I just think is muddying the waters. Another forum member accused somebody of conflating babies and children, when this same forum member has continued to refer to fetuses as babies.
I was looking forward to your argument in reply, SC, but you didn't really bring an argument in reply. Instead, you mostly begged the question of the personhood of a fetus. You did this by conflating the concept of the moral definition of "person" with the legal definition:
No I'm not. I agree with the definition of person as somebody who's been born. I think the definition is most decidedly moral.
I asked what definition of personhood excluded all unborn and included all people who have been born. You responded, basically, that this is the law. But the law has already made a moral and/or practical decision. The law comes after people determine these issues.
Again, I think agree that the definition is a moral one.
A thing is not moral or immoral depending on the law. I think that discrimination against homosexuals is immoral (to the extent morality exists), but it's still legal. Hell, in some instances (DODT, DOMA), it's actually required.
It's not legal in Canada.
Similarly, law has been used to define black people, Jews and hosts of others. Had I asked you in 1925 what it was about a black person that necessarily defined him as having to go to a separate school, it would not have been a sufficient moral defense that this was the law.
And I'm not saying anything like that. I believe - morally - that a person is somebody who's been born. That person then has certain civil rights, and will eventually have civil responsibilities. I don't find any compelling moral reason to confer rights on a fetus.
So, I am unimpressed that you define a person as someone who has been born because the law confers certain rights on those who have been born. The question is whether those laws are right. In order to answer that, we must ask what definition of a person (in a lawless world) necessarily includes those who have been born and necessarily excludes those who have not.
I like to be unimpressive at times. :) If you don't think that birth is a good dividing line, then tell me where you think it should be. I'll stick with conferring personhood on individuals who've been born.
Personally, I think no such definition exists. A 34 week-old fetus has more in common with a newborn baby than an 84 year-old person in a persistent vegitative state. I think the concept of personhood is either: 1) irrelevant to the entire abortion debate; or 2) is only one factor that must be weighed.
Now I'm confused. I thought you said the personhood thing was central to the abortion debate and were castigating me for not recognizing other people's opinions. If it's one factor that must be weighed, then you must decide when or where we confer personhood.

Frankly, I don't see how a 34-week fetus has much in common with a newborn baby. One lives in a watery environment inside a woman's body, and the other breathes oxygen in the air. Neither has much in common with the 84-year old. (Who I'm guessing is breathing with a ventilator and kept alive by artificial means.)
I'll ask you and anyone else again, how can you define "personhood" (without respect to itself or, by extension, a law that has already defined it) in such a manner that all unborn fail that test and all born people pass it?
By doing exactly that. I get that you don't like where the line is drawn. I'm comfortable with it, for myself and for other people. If you've managed to get successfully born, congratulations, you're a person and the state will help protect your rights. If you've yet to be born, then you're at the mercy of the people around you to protect you until you get to that point. And that's what happens. Most pregnant women are extremely protective of their unborn children because they want to have healthy babies. Most doctors won't abort a healthy 38-week fetus, because it's easier to deliver it live.
Forced pregnancy can be nothing but a punishment.
Dragging in child support payments is, quite frankly, too silly to even consider.
Agreed.
 
Last edited:
Only if you DEFINE people as not including fetuses.

Rather missing the point, Ziggurat: I do define people as separate from foetuses, and that remark was an aside to show why I do: but for the purpose of the post I was giving you your point. I thought I made that plain. So your snark about circular argument really does not apply


The answer is obvious (so either you're clueless or you din't want to find it). I had no role in creating the situation of a transplant patient in need of an organ. The same is simply not true with the vast majority of fetuses and mothers. Your role in creating a situation has quite a lot to do with your responsibilities towards those involved. Is that really a difficult or controversial notion?

It is neither difficult nor controversial. It neatly disposes of any idea that this is about the right to life, however. What it is, is special pleading. I will go through it again. I have given you the curious idea that foetus is a person, for the sake of argument. As such it should logically get exactly the same rights as every other person. The kidney donation example shows that people do not have the right to the use of other people's bodies without their consent. Since you argue a foetus is a person: and since people have no such right: it follows that foetuses have no such right. Is that really a difficult or controversial notion?

To get around this you wish to give the foetus special extra rights. And I wondered where they came from. You have not answered that: you have skipped a step. If the foetus has a special right the rest of us do not have then someone has a corresponding duty, presumably. And you locate that duty with the woman and not with anyone else. And you do so on the basis of her role in creating it. But you have not established it has any such special right in the first place. Without that right there is no concomitant duty, and so you have to do that bit. You haven't. As you said upthread, in relation to the case for abortion, you may be right but you have to make the case.

I can imagine a number of ways it might be done. I have already mentioned one: if nobody has that duty then it does not have the possibility of life: but neither does the kidney patient, so that does not get us any further forward. The foetus, according to you, has a right to life that people do not have: so it cannot have them on the basis that it is a person.

It has been argued that since she had sex the woman assumed that responsibility. But she quite clearly didn't if she wants an abortion: similarly you may choose to donate your kidney and people will probably be quite admiring if you do: but you are not forced to assume that responsibility and there is no reason I can think of why you should be

You say that the difference that makes a difference is that you had no role in causing the situation: so let us imagine that you did. Is it your position that if you damage someone's kidneys in a bar fight or a car crash or just by accidentally injuring them with no intent to harm, that you should then be forced to donate your kidney to them (assuming a match or very good anti rejection drugs or whatever)? I suppose some people would think that was a reasonable proposition, but I do not think it is the law in any country I ever heard of. As has been pointed out, law is not the same as morality and perhaps that is the more moral stance: I personally do not think it is. But it is at least curious that it is not the law in those countries which take for granted that women should be forced to carry children they do not want in order to take responsibility for actions that do not seem to logically confer any more or different duties, by their nature.

In the end unless you can demonstrate why the foetus gets special rights on some other basis your argument really does come down to punishment. And you cannot do it on the basis that it is a person. Or if you can I have not yet seen you do it.

It is this kind of problem which leads some of us to the conclusion that this is some version of punishment/control and not what it purports to be. The issue is not between a woman and a foetus: it is between a woman and other adults. If you take control of someone else's body you have denied them the very foundation of personhood: but that does not seem to be a problem for you so long as the person so denied is a woman. Why is that case different?


Translation: oh, you men!

Tip of the day, Fiona: if you need to resort to your gender in order to justify your position, you're on weak ground.

Indeed. I do not know if those who have preached their moral superiority on this thread are men: so that was bad of me. But in my defence I will say this: the casual insults are so ingrained that I am perfectly prepared to believe that those making those insults are unaware of their nature: and since many of them are predicated on a conception of pregnancy as a "blessing" or as a minor inconvenience akin to a summer cold, I will be very suprised if they are not. It is deeply annoying to have the kind of nonsense we have seen: I will take any baby you care to send, is a prime example. I am not attacking that in the terms you have been defending: I am attacking it because it is not something that is ever going to happen: and that, I think, was in line with your own point.

I would have a great deal more respect if people founded on something that could actually happen to them and they could actually do something about. Men cannot become pregnant: it is difficult for them to understand the enormity of what they are asking when they blithely talk about carrying a foetus they do not want to term, just because it suits others.

There are indeed women who are against abortion and it was wrong to talk as if all such statements are from one gender: of course they are not. I have no respect for women who wish to impose their will on others either: I just don't usually come across them arguing it as if it was nothing, which has been at strand in this thread: so for those who are women and are making that case, and for the avoidance of doubt: you can become pregnant: so show me that you carried an unwanted foetus to term, and it was a walk in the park. Do not tell me that it worked out fine and you would not be without the consequent baby now that it is here: I can admire it if you had the principle and saw it through: but what I want to hear from you is your conviction that this is the right solution for every woman who finds themselves in that situation.

And again, for men who take that view, you cannot experience this: but you can donate a kidney: that is not a ridiculous scenario; it does not require the participation of anyone else who must give a baby to you knowing nothing about you at all, thus ensuring there is no danger of you having to deliver: if there is no element of punishment in your attitude to abortion, and if you found on a right to life, I can see no possible objection to your doing so. I think the recovery time for kidney donation is less than nine months in fact: so you are getting off quite lightly and you don't even have to look after the recipient for the next 16 years. :)
 
Last edited:
What do you think you're doing displaying a reasonable position on abortion this late in the thread?

If you can't be extremist stay out of the thread!

Yeah, I'll go away again. Its seems most people prefer to be polarised.

But one last thought experiment. Imagine a baby that is born that cannot tolerate (for whatever reason...it is just a thought experiment) formula milk and has an allergic reaction to any milk other than it's own mother's milk. The mother had never contemplated breastfeeding and assumed she would formula feed. Do you think the mother should be entitled to either kill her child, or let it starve to death?
 
Last edited:
Let's say 24+ week abortions were legal. What should happen to the foetus? Should it be killed before being removed? If the foetus is still alive after it is removed from the woman's body should it be killed, or should effort be expended to keep it alive? If the latter, how much?

ETA: If the foetus is dead (either before or after being removed), is it treated as a person or medical waste?
 
Last edited:
Does it settle the question of personhood, or does it settle the question of whether personhood confers an absolute right to life? It seems that your position is consistent with both.

For me it settles the question of personhood: there is no absolute right to life. I agree with Sun Countess: personhood begins at birth.


But that's only true of men who disagree with you. Would you claim that men who agree that a woman has an absolute right to choose abortion have no right to an opinion?


I was angry and did not express myself well: I am quite happy for people to have an opinion: I just don't think I have to take that opinion seriously if they will never have to deal with the consequences of that opinon. I do not think anyone has the right to force a woman to remain pregnant if she does not want to be. But to the extent that a woman who wants to make rules for others may actually have to face the consequences of the rules she makes, then I think she has the moral right which a man does not have. Rawl's veil of ignorance is relevant here: one cannot make moral prescriptions if one cannot find oneself in the worst place those presciptions will impose. I do not respect those who suffer other people's pain with great fortitude :)


And what of women who cannot have children? Since it is impossible for my 66 year-old mother to become pregnant (she had a hystorectomy), does she lose her right to a say in the debate? Be careful if you answer that she can stay on your lawn by virtue of having at least once been pregnant; she may well have found Jebus and changed her mind since then. I mean, if Jane Roe (Norma McCorvey) can do it, surely others can.

No. As I hope I have already made clear, my position is not wholly defensible: but I honestly think that one should not impose rules on others where it is literally impossible to suffer the consequences. There are not many situations like that but where the veil of ignorance does not help I think it is difficult to argue that one has a stake

Abortion is part of the fundamental set of issues that define how we treat those among us who cannot advocate for themselves - 39-week fetuses, 3 day-old babies, the comatose, those dying in pain, even criminals to an extent. That seems to be an important enough set of topics to ask everybody's opinion.

Why do you disagree?

See above
 
But one last thought experiment. Imagine a baby that is born that cannot tolerate (for whatever reason...it is just a thought experiment) formula milk and has an allergic reaction to any milk other than it's own mother's milk. The mother had never contemplated breastfeeding and assumed she would formula feed. Do you think the mother should be entitled to either kill her child, or let it starve to death?
Let's say 24+ week abortions were legal. What should happen to the foetus? Should it be killed before being removed? If the foetus is still alive after it is removed from the woman's body should it be killed, or should effort be expended to keep it alive? If the latter, how much? ETA: If the foetus is dead (either before or after being removed), is it treated as a person or medical waste?


The problem with solving the problem by simply defining it away (life begins at birth) is that it only solves that problem. It doesn't do anything to create any sort of moral or practical structure which could be used to guide behavior in more generalized circumstances. Nor does it even provide much insight into the moral or practical concerns of those who did the defining.
 
Yeah, I'll go away again. Its seems most people prefer to be polarised.

Well that is an interesting statement. You appear to imagine that the right answer is always in the middle and that in some way that is self evident. It is not self evident to me. I can see absolutely no reason why someone else should be allowed to take control of my body: and since you do think that is reasonable I have to tell you that I think you are an extremist. If I have misunderstood your position I apologise and I will read your correction with interest.

I have aleady said that I have made what I consider to be major concessions on this issue. I believe absolutely that the woman has the right to choose right up to birth. But I accept that this is too hard for many and so I concede there is a cut off point somewhere, though that is absolutely at odds with what I think is the moral stance.

Of course some of those who wish to ban abortion altogether only see that as a step along the way: and so we see them voting again and again to restrict that choice more and more: they are not making any permanent compromises that I can see: and the terms of the debate are emotive very often: They found on things which are frankly silly: to wit: you cannot remove this foetus from your body because a. it is viable and b. it will die. I do not understand how they can say such things with a straight face: but there you are.

But given that I have made that compromise may I ask if you can say the same? I suspect that you have, from what you have said upthread: perhaps you oppose abortion but have done what I have done: compromised at some number of weeks you can live with? If that is the case then what is the difference which leads to your conclusion that people prefer to be polarised? There are people in this thread who are completely opposed to abortion, maybe: but I think nearly everyone has made some compromise, and it is just as hard for each of us to do that. Perhaps I have missed what you are referring to?
 
Forced pregnancy can be nothing but a punishment.
Dragging in child support payments is, quite frankly, too silly to even consider.

I'm going to ask you the question anyway: are child support payments punishment? Do you believe that the State considers them to be punishment?
If not, then we know that the State can force you to do something, not for punishment but because a child requires it.
So if child support payments are not punishment, why is pregnancy?
 
Well I just can't imagine taking a position that a 39 week old foetus has no rights at all, whilst a baby born at 31 weeks has all the rights accorded to any other human being, merely because of where it happens to be at that moment. Its just not something I can comprehend. I can understand someone taking the position that the rights of the woman are greater than the rights of the 39 week old foetus. Even though I don't agree with it, I can understand their position. The change from having no rights to having full rights for the same being at the same level of development seems utterly absurd and illogical to me.
 
The problem with solving the problem by simply defining it away (life begins at birth) is that it only solves that problem. It doesn't do anything to create any sort of moral or practical structure which could be used to guide behavior in more generalized circumstances. Nor does it even provide much insight into the moral or practical concerns of those who did the defining.

I disagree. I think the basis of our disagreement is that you are assuming there is only one moral principle in play: I think there are two and, further, that the one you are not focussing on is the more important.

The problem with that is that competing moral principles are not supposed to exist, and it may be that there is a meta-principle which would help us to resolve the apparent problem.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom