"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

It was you who suggested we should only consider the specific claim of finding foster homes to unwanted children of forumites. I merely pointed out that if we did that, the statement would already be completely unbelievable.

His statement was an offer contingent upon a specific set of circumstances. It is wrong to think that the offer extends to other circumstances. But 154 never stated he would NOT help children under other circumstances either. So it is also wrong to conclude that he would not help under other circumstances. His willingness to help under other circumstances may not always be yes, and it may not always no. It's unknown to us, it may be yes in some circumstances and no in others, and we do not know which is which. Nor is a lack of willingness in some circumstances an invalidation of the willingness to help in other circumstances. Why is that a hard concept for you to grasp?

The whole point of only considering the conditions of his offer is not because he's unwilling to help otherwise, but because that's the only condition under which we know in either direction what he's willing to do. It's an issue of our knowledge, not his willingness. Our knowledge is limited, and we should act accordingly.

That may not be obvious outside of context, which is of course part of the reason I consider quoting only parts of posts very dishonest.

Context isn't the issue, bad logic is.
 
You have a baby you want to get rid of?

I'll take it.

Promise.


Fine.

154, I have a baby. His name is Harry (short for Harrison). I do not want Harry anymore. I want to get rid of him. I have a baby I want to get rid of.

I will be in Bismark, North Dakota from today through the end of October. Please purchase airplane tickets in and out of the Bismark airport for October. Please post photos of your airline tickets here.

If you intend to drive into Bismark, please post a receipt showing that you have purchased a brand new baby seat, send pictures of it installed in your car, and give me your name and contact information as well as the name and contact information of the person who will be accompanying you.

When I see that you are serious in your plans to come to Bismark, I will give you further information about our location.
 
Because some people still seem to be mixing up the two, I'll make this clear:
Demand exceeds supply for healthy newborn babies. There are many, many couples in the United States right now who wait a long time for an opportunity to adopt them. If you are pregnant and the fetus has no diagnosed health problems, you will have no problem finding parents to adopt the resulting baby.
Supply exceeds demand for older and special needs children. If you are pregnant and decide to have the baby, try to raise it until it is 10 years old, and then give it up for adoption, you will have a problem finding parents to raise this older child.
The vast majority of aborted fetuses would have resulted in high-demand babies if they came to term. In the U.S. right now, the decision is not between killing your child and letting it rot as a state ward. It's between killing your child and giving it a chance with a family that wants it.
 
It is nothing at all to do with killing a child and that is where the dispute lies. The fact, and it is a fact, that there are fewer babies for adoption than people who wish to adopt has nothing at all to do with the issue
 
Fine.

154, I have a baby. His name is Harry (short for Harrison). I do not want Harry anymore. I want to get rid of him. I have a baby I want to get rid of.

I will be in Bismark, North Dakota from today through the end of October. Please purchase airplane tickets in and out of the Bismark airport for October. Please post photos of your airline tickets here.

If you intend to drive into Bismark, please post a receipt showing that you have purchased a brand new baby seat, send pictures of it installed in your car, and give me your name and contact information as well as the name and contact information of the person who will be accompanying you.

When I see that you are serious in your plans to come to Bismark, I will give you further information about our location.

Let me take the time to interject that you can't just hand off a child. Changes in legal guardianship usually require more than that. If you're looking at doing this you need to consult a lawyer or at least the appropriate department of the state where you currently reside.
This post does not constitute legal advice.
 
The fact, and it is a fact, that there are fewer babies for adoption than people who wish to adopt has nothing at all to do with the issue

It only has something to do with the issue because of the pro-abortion arguments on this thread claiming that each abortion prevents a child from becoming orphan -- that stopping X abortions would be creating X orphans. This is clearly not the case; at least today, stopping X abortions of healthy babies creates approximately X adoptions of healthy babies.
 
So are you suggesting the right to abortion should be predicated on the supply/demand of babies for adoption?
 
Let me take the time to interject that you can't just hand off a child. Changes in legal guardianship usually require more than that. If you're looking at doing this you need to consult a lawyer or at least the appropriate department of the state where you currently reside.
This post does not constitute legal advice.


Thank you, Avalon. As it turns out, I actually am a family law attorney. I have taken care of changes in guardianship before. I have all of the proper forms and information necessarily to legally shift guardianship over Harry to 154, provided he tells me his real contact information.
 
So are you suggesting the right to abortion should be predicated on the supply/demand of babies for adoption?

Not really, no. But it seems that some of the more pro-abortion posters here believe that -- specifically, they have argued that one of the reasons that abortion is appropriate is that the alternative isn't much better. So to the extent that their argument relies on an incorrect assessment of what will happen if a baby is born rather than aborted, it makes sense to address it. I hope that's clear.

Thank you, Avalon. As it turns out, I actually am a family law attorney. I have taken care of changes in guardianship before. I have all of the proper forms and information necessarily to legally shift guardianship over Harry to 154, provided he tells me his real contact information.

That makes me feel much better. Thank you.
 
It only has something to do with the issue because of the pro-abortion arguments on this thread claiming that each abortion prevents a child from becoming orphan -- that stopping X abortions would be creating X orphans. This is clearly not the case; at least today, stopping X abortions of healthy babies creates approximately X adoptions of healthy babies.

How long, approximately, is this waiting list for adoptable babies?
 
His statement was an offer contingent upon a specific set of circumstances. It is wrong to think that the offer extends to other circumstances. But 154 never stated he would NOT help children under other circumstances either. So it is also wrong to conclude that he would not help under other circumstances. His willingness to help under other circumstances may not always be yes, and it may not always no. It's unknown to us, it may be yes in some circumstances and no in others, and we do not know which is which. Nor is a lack of willingness in some circumstances an invalidation of the willingness to help in other circumstances. Why is that a hard concept for you to grasp?

The whole point of only considering the conditions of his offer is not because he's unwilling to help otherwise, but because that's the only condition under which we know in either direction what he's willing to do. It's an issue of our knowledge, not his willingness. Our knowledge is limited, and we should act accordingly.

You seem to claim our limited knowledge means we have no way of assessing the feasibility of the original claim, and should just accept it. I'm saying since we actually do know some things about the world, we can make some conclusions about the likelihood of the claim, and the question about charity was relevant to that.

For some reason or other, you wish to narrow thought down to that one statement, simply refusing to consider any other variables. And that tunnel vision is what I have trouble with.

I'd ask why you have trouble grasping that, but it's fairly obvious you're simply ignoring my points as a debate tactic.



Context isn't the issue, bad logic is.

The issue is you are deliberately viewing a part of an exchange out of context to make it appear as bad logic. It's silly, useless, and yes, dishonest.
 
As I understand it, your position is that there is no such thing as objective morality, and therefore all such decisions are primarily pragmatic?


I would rephrase that to say that certain social systems necessitate a set of rules, which you could call morals. For instance, capitalism carries with it (in my opinion) the mandate that people have equal access to the marketplace regardless of race.


To support your position you have effectively redefined murder to include the lawful killing of individuals by the state. And therin lies the real problem because that is not what the word means.


No, we're not having a problem because I've defined the word wrong, but because each of us is using it differently.

You've defined murder as "unlawful killing." However, that begs the question. Some killing is lawful because the society chooses to find it moral, some is unlawful because society has deemed it immoral. By defining murder in that manner, it is impossible to discuss how murder came to have those particular boundaries. The boundaries just show up as part of the definition of the word.

Since, I am arguing a step backwards, before the formation of any particular society, I am using "murder" differently. Murder, by my terms, is any killing of another person by anybody for any reason, including military action, the death penalty, and abortion. This allows us to discuss the concept in the fullest form. If you would rather call it "killing," that's fine. Just read my previous post as "killing" where I wrote "murder." (Unless I was talking about a group of crows. That will remain "murder" no matter what.)


When you state there is no such thing as objective morality what force does the word objective have?


Objective morality: A set of rules that is necessarily true for all humans in all circumstances.

I know of no such rules. Nor do I know of a source from which such rules could be derived.


You point to civilisations which practised legal executions of various kinds: but this rather undermines your case unless you can show that such civilisations did not recognise the concept of murder as we understand the term: that is, illegal killing.


Quite the opposite. Since those civilizations had a different definition of when killing was legal or illegal than we do, it shows that there is no generally-accepted prohibition against killing.

All of those civilizations had governments, and all of them were designed to alienate the use of physical force by the populace in order to ensure the safety of the weak. So, all of them will share some aspects of the way they define murder. I initially said that government is the legitimator of force. (I was not, by any means, the first person to say this.)

But just about every government that abhors killing within its boundaries, has no problem ceding the choice to be violent back to its citizens in at least one case - when the violence is directed outside the civilization. War allows regular people to kill regular people, and allows the strong to completely subjugate the weak. Many armies have celebrated the soldiers with the most "confirmed kills."


if my understanding of what you are saying is correct then we definitely need a different conceptualisation for moral utterance and behaviour


Such conceptualizations already exist and have been expounded upon by far more capable political philosophers than me. See Max Weber, to start.


It is a forced departure in one sense: and it is based on evidence: but if you read the article what you will see is that they made a predicition: the evidence did not support it: but they did not give it up.


You talk as though Female Plan B was posited in one article after one study. My understanding is that there is more than thirty years of philosophy and reasearch into the behavior of humans, chimps, various birds and other animals by a number of different researchers and authors.
 
You seem to claim our limited knowledge means we have no way of assessing the feasibility of the original claim, and should just accept it.

LL wasn't addressing the feasibility of the original claim. That's got nothing to do with what LL said.

I'm saying since we actually do know some things about the world, we can make some conclusions about the likelihood of the claim, and the question about charity was relevant to that.

No, it isn't. Feasibility is about whether or not 154 can do what he claimed. LL was trying to suggest 154 wasn't actually willing to. If you think 154 can't do what he claimed, well, nothing about him satisfying LL's demands would actually change that. You cannot justify LL's argument on the basis of feasibility when satisfying LL's demand tells you nothing about feasibility of doing something else.

And if you think he's not willing to, well, then using LL's argument amounts to just calling him a liar, but couching it in terms to make the accusation appear more substantive. If you think 154 is just lying about what he's willing to do, you should drop the act and simply say so. Keep your ad hominems out in the open, don't hide them under a bushel.

For some reason or other, you wish to narrow thought down to that one statement

Because that's the one statement LL challenged with his demand.

The issue is you are deliberately viewing a part of an exchange out of context to make it appear as bad logic.

It's not out of context. The "missing" context you've tried to provide here is simply wrong. It's fiction, invented out of whole cloth.
 
Fine.

154, I have a baby. His name is Harry (short for Harrison). I do not want Harry anymore. I want to get rid of him. I have a baby I want to get rid of.

I will be in Bismark, North Dakota from today through the end of October. Please purchase airplane tickets in and out of the Bismark airport for October. Please post photos of your airline tickets here.

If you intend to drive into Bismark, please post a receipt showing that you have purchased a brand new baby seat, send pictures of it installed in your car, and give me your name and contact information as well as the name and contact information of the person who will be accompanying you.

When I see that you are serious in your plans to come to Bismark, I will give you further information about our location.

Please post a birth certificate showing that Harry is in fact a baby. Please post your own identification to demonstrate that you are in fact the parent of said baby. Please post a signed and notarized affidavit from the other parent consenting to adoption.

Surely you didn't think such an interaction would be a one-way street, did you?
 
Please post a birth certificate showing that Harry is in fact a baby. Please post your own identification to demonstrate that you are in fact the parent of said baby. Please post a signed and notarized affidavit from the other parent consenting to adoption.

Surely you didn't think such an interaction would be a one-way street, did you?


154 made an offer. I wrote back accepting the terms of his offer. I believe that he has the responsibility to show that he is serious. I'm not about to give out details about myself and my son without at least some indication that 154 is honestly interested in coming to take him.

This interaction won't be a one way street. 154 will end up with a baby. All he has to do is show some degree of dedication to his own words.

And, for a person who has spent pages arguing about the exact conditions of the deal 154 chose to make, you have injected a fair number of conditions yourself that did not exist in 154's statement. First of all, you are not him and cannot speak for him. Second of all, he said nothing about adoption. He said nothing about needing the consent of both parents, a birth certificate or a signed affidavit of any sort. He said he would take a baby I didn't want. That's not even adoption. That's just a change in custody.

Heck, if I was somehow in possession of a baby that I DIDN'T have the right to, it would make the need to get him out of my custody even more important.

In fact, you argued that 154's offer and my response were irrelevant to the entire thread. Now, you're representing him in the negotiations for my youngest?

Don't make yourself guilty now of the exact things you've been accusing me of.
 
Last edited:
154 made an offer. I wrote back accepting the terms of his offer.

You did more than that.

I believe that he has the responsibility to show that he is serious.

That may be, but that's not what you demanded. You demanded that he spend money when he has no assurance that you are serious.

I'm not about to give out details about myself and my son without at least some indication that 154 is honestly interested in coming to take him.

But you're demanding more than details from 154. You're demanding that he actually spend money.

This interaction won't be a one way street. 154 will end up with a baby.

That's if you've actually got one you want to give him. Given how the debate has progressed so far, how can you possibly think that 154 could trust you, even if BOTH you and 154 are completely sincere? He can't, and you know he can't. You're trying to use the fact that YOU can't be trusted by him in this situation in order to try to prove that 154 is actually lying. But that's bull****. If you merely wanted to point out that nobody on this board is in a position to accept his offer because they can't trust him, you'd have a point. In fact, you'd be totally correct. But you didn't do that. Instead, you went for the cheap shot.
 
LL wasn't addressing the feasibility of the original claim. That's got nothing to do with what LL said.



No, it isn't. Feasibility is about whether or not 154 can do what he claimed. LL was trying to suggest 154 wasn't actually willing to. If you think 154 can't do what he claimed, well, nothing about him satisfying LL's demands would actually change that. You cannot justify LL's argument on the basis of feasibility when satisfying LL's demand tells you nothing about feasibility of doing something else.

And if you think he's not willing to, well, then using LL's argument amounts to just calling him a liar, but couching it in terms to make the accusation appear more substantive. If you think 154 is just lying about what he's willing to do, you should drop the act and simply say so. Keep your ad hominems out in the open, don't hide them under a bushel.



Because that's the one statement LL challenged with his demand.



It's not out of context. The "missing" context you've tried to provide here is simply wrong. It's fiction, invented out of whole cloth.

All right, that's enough. I pointed it out several times, yet you persist. There's nothing to be gained by debating what constitutes dishonest argumentation with a guy who insists on snippin off relevant portions of posts, shifting the goalposts, attributing opinions of other people on me, and a half-dozen other tactics you've repeatedly employed. Agree to disagree, I'm out.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom