As I understand it, your position is that there is no such thing as objective morality, and therefore all such decisions are primarily pragmatic?
I would rephrase that to say that certain social systems necessitate a set of rules, which you could call morals. For instance, capitalism carries with it (in my opinion) the mandate that people have equal access to the marketplace regardless of race.
To support your position you have effectively redefined murder to include the lawful killing of individuals by the state. And therin lies the real problem because that is not what the word means.
No, we're not having a problem because I've defined the word wrong, but because each of us is using it differently.
You've defined murder as "unlawful killing." However, that begs the question. Some killing is lawful because the society chooses to find it moral, some is unlawful because society has deemed it immoral. By defining murder in that manner, it is impossible to discuss how murder came to have those particular boundaries. The boundaries just show up as part of the definition of the word.
Since, I am arguing a step backwards, before the formation of any particular society, I am using "murder" differently. Murder, by my terms, is any killing of another person by anybody for any reason, including military action, the death penalty, and abortion. This allows us to discuss the concept in the fullest form. If you would rather call it "killing," that's fine. Just read my previous post as "killing" where I wrote "murder." (Unless I was talking about a group of crows. That will remain "murder" no matter what.)
When you state there is no such thing as objective morality what force does the word objective have?
Objective morality: A set of rules that is necessarily true for all humans in all circumstances.
I know of no such rules. Nor do I know of a source from which such rules could be derived.
You point to civilisations which practised legal executions of various kinds: but this rather undermines your case unless you can show that such civilisations did not recognise the concept of murder as we understand the term: that is, illegal killing.
Quite the opposite. Since those civilizations had a different definition of when killing was legal or illegal than we do, it shows that there is no generally-accepted prohibition against killing.
All of those civilizations had governments, and all of them were designed to alienate the use of physical force by the populace in order to ensure the safety of the weak. So, all of them will share some aspects of the way they define murder. I initially said that government is the legitimator of force. (I was not, by any means, the first person to say this.)
But just about every government that abhors killing within its boundaries, has no problem ceding the choice to be violent back to its citizens in at least one case - when the violence is directed outside the civilization. War allows regular people to kill regular people, and allows the strong to completely subjugate the weak. Many armies have celebrated the soldiers with the most "confirmed kills."
if my understanding of what you are saying is correct then we definitely need a different conceptualisation for moral utterance and behaviour
Such conceptualizations already exist and have been expounded upon by far more capable political philosophers than me. See Max Weber, to start.
It is a forced departure in one sense: and it is based on evidence: but if you read the article what you will see is that they made a predicition: the evidence did not support it: but they did not give it up.
You talk as though Female Plan B was posited in one article after one study. My understanding is that there is more than thirty years of philosophy and reasearch into the behavior of humans, chimps, various birds and other animals by a number of different researchers and authors.