"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

This. You specifically said "mothering is a woman's greatest instinct" (not true) and then followed up with the lamentation "What happened to us?" So OBVIOUSLY you are implying that you think it is a bad thing when women do not have a maternal instinct. Also, saying that mothering is a woman's greatest instict would mean that ALL women should not only want to be mothers, but want to be mothers more than they want to do anything else in the world, more even than they want to breathe. We should just be baby machines that think baby baby baby all day long, after all, if that's our GREATEST instinct, which would mean it surpasses our instincts even when it comes to our basic bodily needs like eating, sleeping, breathing, etc.

I.
His points are basically replays of what I was reading in magazines and newspapers and seeing occasionally on tv in the late 50's early 60's. That war was mostly won a long time back. Fighting abortion is really the only leftover of it. It was a pantsload then, it's a pantsload now.:mad:
 
No. 154 made a specific offer of assistance contingent upon certain conditions. LL demanded different assistance be rendered under different conditions. There's nothing appropriate about that.
Exactly. Simple. Thank you again.

You'll need to do better then this.
No, I do not need to do anything.

I've been defending 154 from some dishonest attacks, but now I'll level a bit of criticism. His offer, regardless of how real it is, is rather irrelevant. That's the ultimate problem with what he said. It's got no real impact on what is a nationwide issue, not simply an issue for members of this board.
...His willingness to personally ensure the welfare of unwanted children doesn't make abortion wrong (and conversely, even if you could prove him a liar that wouldn't make abortion right), and it's not an offer that actually changes the options available for any significant fraction of the population either. So why pick what amounts to a personal fight when you really don't need to? His offer doesn't need to be challenged because it never mattered to begin with.
Correct.

This is another dishonest response. There's a major difference in the adoptability of children and infants, and you cannot be so ignorant as to be unaware of this fact. 154 didn't offer to raise children without parents himself, he offered to find homes for unwanted babies. Can you honestly not understand the difference? No, I'm sure you can. You just chose not to.
Yes. Another. Again.

...I don't see how a reasonable person could believe 154's claim is anything but a blatant lie,...
Wow. I'm terrible...

There are more prospective parents who want to adopt a baby than want to adopt a child. What about that do you not understand?

Except that 154 finding parents for a baby doesn't impact children wanting a parent, because there's a waiting list of people who want to adopt a baby but there isn't a waiting list of people who want to adopt a child.
Again, simple. It's very revealing that this must be re-emphasized.

He never said he would help in no other circumstances. But his offer wasn't for any other circumstances. It is for him to determine when and how else he would help, not you, and not LL.
Is it not aggravatingly clear that the truth of the matter is irrelevant to them? They are arguing against. However, wherever, whatever, against. Period.

ah now i understand it, good point. I didn't think about that.
Excellent. A pleasant surprise. A man willing to honestly yield in consideration, not simply and immediately leap to another antagonism.

...I think it's time we accept that what we consider dishonesty in debate differs substantially.
Indeed.

His statement was an offer contingent upon a specific set of circumstances. It is wrong to think that the offer extends to other circumstances. But 154 never stated he would NOT help children under other circumstances either. So it is also wrong to conclude that he would not help under other circumstances. His willingness to help under other circumstances may not always be yes, and it may not always no. It's unknown to us, it may be yes in some circumstances and no in others, and we do not know which is which. Nor is a lack of willingness in some circumstances an invalidation of the willingness to help in other circumstances. Why is that a hard concept for you to grasp?
Precisely.

Fine.
154, I have a baby. His name is Harry (short for Harrison). I do not want Harry anymore. I want to get rid of him. I have a baby I want to get rid of.
How convenient.

As it turns out, I actually am a family law attorney.
That's what this is to you. Although it would have been the lucrative option, I refused law school. We are why. I'm not playing, counselor.

And if you think he's not willing to, well, then using LL's argument amounts to just calling him a liar, but couching it in terms to make the accusation appear more substantive. If you think 154 is just lying about what he's willing to do, you should drop the act and simply say so. Keep your ad hominems out in the open, don't hide them under a bushel.
Their animosity consumes their logic.

154 made an offer. I wrote back accepting the terms of his offer. I believe that he has the responsibility to show that he is serious.
Would you like to attach a contractual wager, counselor, before Judge Ziggurat?

If you merely wanted to point out that nobody on this board is in a position to accept his offer because they can't trust him, you'd have a point. In fact, you'd be totally correct. But you didn't do that. Instead, you went for the cheap shot.
It is already quite apparent that honesty is not the priority with LL. Advocacy is.


I repeat my unanswered question to the hostiles:
- Nice, nice. That was beautiful. What? 25, 30 posts all devoted to attempting to impugn me. Lovely.

Why?
Why such vehemence in opposition to me and/or my position?
Why am I such a threat that I must be so resisted?
What is so unacceptable?

Of course, these are rhetorical questions. Take the 5th.
 
No, I do not need to do anything.
Assuming that you are somewhat serious about your offer, and if you want to prevent this fetus from being aborted, then yes, you need to do something (besides making the offer).

Surely that is a small price to pay to prevent 'murder'?
 
Sorry I haven't been back but I have a real life too. I'm not going to go through 5+ pages of posts and so if I don't answer questions, sorry.

What I want to do however is finish off with these thoughts:

There are 43 million women in the US who are sexually active and do not want to become pregnant. [1]
In 2005 the US there are 1.2 million abortions [2], this seems to be a reasonably static number.

Based on that, 1 in 36 non-pregnancy wanting, sexually active women in the US suffer a totally unwanted pregnancy each year (assuming that there are few women having multiple abortions in a single year.)

We also know that properly used contraceptive is way better than this, so why is the rate so high?

7% of all sexually active women are at risk for unintended pregnancy but are not currently using contraceptives. 85% of these will get pregnant, that's 2.5 million pregnancies, already twice the number of abortions a year, though according to studies only around 20% of these are aborted (about 50% of all US abortions[3].)

Another 6.5% use poor forms of contraceptive with high failure rates even when performed perfectly.

In fact only 58% of sexually active US women use an effective form of contraceptive, and most do so poorly (87% of pill users and 86% of condom users who have abortions report having used their method poorly or didn't know if it was poor or not.) Only 13.5% use multiple forms of contraceptive, which is far more effective. Just using the pill and a male condom can drop the rate from 9% and 15% of pregnancy over a year of use respectively to 1.5% with poor usage. Use them correctly and that rate drops to just 0.006%.

Consider this. If the availability of contraception was improved and people were shown how to use it correctly, and did use it, it could drop the total number of accidental pregnancies in the US to just 645,000. Get people to use it correctly and it could be just 2500! What would be the effect on abortion rates if this could be done?

Now I have been accused of believing that women should be punished for getting pregnant, or that tightening the controls over abortion would somehow "make me feel better", both of which are untrue, however I can't stop people believing what they will. I do believe that just like the rest of the Universe, people move towards doing the least effort, and in a permissive society that they will gravitate to what they perceive to be the path of least effort (not saying that abortion actually is the path of least effort, it's not. Not bothering with contraceptives at all or not using them right is the path of least effort and the one taken.) It's already quite clear that the majority of people either don't use, or poorly make use of contraceptives. Now some might argue that this is a result of poor education; however I believe that it is also because there is no incentive to actually use it and learn to use it properly. I want to be clear about this, contraceptives very rarely fail, what fails are people in their use of them. Get type of contraceptive and the use right and a lot of the problem vanishes.

I want to make it clear, I can certainly accept that there are cases were abortion is required when it is discovered that the life, health, or mental wellbeing of the mother is in serious danger should she carry to term. I can also accept that there is a very good case to be made where the child is the result of sexual abuse or attack because of the mental dangers of the mother having to carry to term. However I also believe that there are many cases where if abortion was not such an easily available option, the pregnancies would never have occurred in the first place because the mothers would have been far more careful about their and their partner's actions, meaning that there would have been no need for those abortions to have happened.

Personally I'd like to see much better education (and not just teenagers) along with readily available, easy to use, very cheap, methods of contraception for everyone. This would hopefully reduce the need for abortion, but I also know human nature, and while a believed "easier" option is available, few people are willing to take the harder route. I think that we already see this with the current poor use of contraceptives.

Would there be people caught out by things changing? Almost certainly, and that'd be unfortunate, but the reality is that whether you move from a permission society to a more resistive one, someone gets caught in the middle until things stabilise at the new line of what behaviours is allowed. It might be considered by some to be hard-hearted, but unless you are willing to accept that there will be those caught up in the change and left in an unhappy position, the only change that can ever occur is to become more and more permission with our society, and to be honest, a lot of social experiments over the past 30 years have resulted in failure, from literacy levels to violent crime.

I also have to note that it seems very telling that people are willing to attack my position (and on occasion me) but they refuse to answer any of the questions posed to them.

As I said, this is my last word on the matter, I have better things to do that spending hours looking up statistics that are quite clear and having to defend a position that in my mind is merely common sense.
 
Last edited:
Depends on who you talk to. Everyone agrees that the demand exceeds the supply today; there's quite a bit of disagreement by how much.

Ok, so, here's the problem with your argument then:

if there is no verifiable number of people wanting to adopt a baby, how can anyone be sure that the demand would continue to outpace the supply were abortions to be criminalized?
 
I've been reading this thread, but haven't posted thus far because I've already had enough abortion debates on this forum. :)

However, I'm wondering why there's so much talk about adoption in this thread. What do adoption and abortion have to do with each other? It's like somebody started a thread lamenting the decrease in university entrance spots and it spawned a giant debate on how few people are entering trade schools and what can be done to make trade schools more attractive. A student wanting to go to university doesn't want easier access to trade school. And a woman wanting an abortion does not want easier access to adoption. Decreasing legal abortions will not necessarily add any healthy infants to the adoption pool.

Abortions aren't done just because women don't want to have a baby; they're often done because the woman doesn't want to be pregnant. It's not exactly a walk in the park. It's nine months that can completely change every aspect of your life. Guys, just for fun, imagine all the things that you do on a day-to-day basis. Now imagine doing them when you're several months pregnant. Now imagine that you're one of those lucky women who's throwing up several times a day for months on end, or needing injections for gestational diabetes, or put on bed rest and completely unable to work or care for yourself. Don't even bother applying for a school program or a new job.

PhantomWolf just posted a tutorial on how women are using contraception incorrectly. Naughty naughty women. In order to get them to use it to standards that he finds more acceptable, he wants to take away one of their outs. But why? Why does it matter to you how other people manage their birthing? Should we enforce the use of condoms by taking away IUDs and birth control pills? After all, if a woman didn't have access to birth control pills, she'd be more likely to use condoms, which would lower the rates of STIs. Surely that's a worthwhile goal?

Honestly, why is it your business what other grown people are doing when it comes to planning their families? Do you really care how many people some random woman has? Does it really bother you that she neglected to insert her diaphragm in the heat of the moment, and then went in to get a morning after pill? If that doesn't bother you, why would it bother you if she decided to have an abortion at 6 or 8 weeks? Where's the cut-off where a stranger gets to decide that the naughty woman must be punished because she didn't avail herself of option 1 or option 2 in a timely manner?

Think about driving. Clearly, the best option is to follow all the rules of the road all the time and not get into an accident. But if you do get into an accident, you have insurance to "make it all go away." PhantomWolf is saying that if somebody doesn't follow the rules of the road, they shouldn't have secondary insurance, as that only encourages people to get into accidents. Should we punish all the naughty drivers by making them chauffeur around the people whose cars they wrecked, and also requiring that they fix the cars themselves?

I guess it must be pretty easy to talk about how other people are so irresponsible and shouldn't be allowed to make their own decisions because you just know that you would make all the responsible ones yourself, if you were actually a part of that group of "other people." When you'll never be a part of that group, you should really ask yourself how you know how your life would be or what decisions you would want to make for yourself.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, why is it your business what other grown people are doing when it comes to planning their families? Do you really care how many people some random woman has? Does it really bother you that she neglected to insert her diaphragm in the heat of the moment, and then went in to get a morning after pill? If that doesn't bother you, why would it bother you if she decided to have an abortion at 6 or 8 weeks? Where's the cut-off where a stranger gets to decide that the naughty woman must be punished because she didn't avail herself of option 1 or option 2 in a timely manner?

I'm very pro-choice, but I hate when I see either side use Loki's wager as an argument. Where's your cut off? What if she waits until the baby is three weeks out of the womb? Should she be punished then?
 
Abortions aren't done just because women don't want to have a baby; they're often done because the woman doesn't want to be pregnant.

Quite true.

Honestly, why is it your business what other grown people are doing when it comes to planning their families?

Honestly, why is it your business what other grown people are doing when it comes to abusing or killing their children?

If a fetus is a person, it's logically very much society's business what a mother does to that person. Time and again I've seen abortion advocates try to turn the issue into one of mere privacy alone, but it's not. It is, fundamentally, a question of personhood. There's a damned good case to be made that an early fetus isn't a person, and that's why I'm in favor of keeping abortions legal, but that case must be made. Pretending that the anti-abortion argument is about trying to punish women, rather than protecting what they see as people, is fundamentally dishonest.
 
Quite true.



Honestly, why is it your business what other grown people are doing when it comes to abusing or killing their children?

If a fetus is a person, it's logically very much society's business what a mother does to that person. Time and again I've seen abortion advocates try to turn the issue into one of mere privacy alone, but it's not. It is, fundamentally, a question of personhood. There's a damned good case to be made that an early fetus isn't a person, and that's why I'm in favor of keeping abortions legal, but that case must be made. Pretending that the anti-abortion argument is about trying to punish women, rather than protecting what they see as people, is fundamentally dishonest.

I'm actually in agreement with you here.
 
Assuming that you are somewhat serious about your offer, and if you want to prevent this fetus from being aborted, then yes, you need to do something (besides making the offer).

What fetus? There is no fetus.

Look, I understand that his promise isn't enough to entice someone to hand over a baby, or even carry it to term. But this is an internet message board. The problem is not that he hasn't proven himself serious, it's that there's no realistic way for him to do so here. There's no sense in trying to show his offer isn't serious (would it undermine your position if he could prove he was?), it's enough to point out that his offer doesn't matter.
 
I'm very pro-choice, but I hate when I see either side use Loki's wager as an argument. Where's your cut off? What if she waits until the baby is three weeks out of the womb? Should she be punished then?
I was actually trying to determine where PhantomWolf would cut-off family planning options to women. He wants 100% compliance on contraceptives, but I wondered if that included the morning-after pill. Does he have a window where if a woman is not as responsible as he himself would be - were he a woman - she must carry a fetus to term?

As far as my own cut-off, it's a live birth. I don't have any problem understanding the difference between a fetus and a baby. It's really not that hard. One lives inside a woman's body and the other one lives in the outside world with the rest of us.

Ziggurat said:
Honestly, why is it your business what other grown people are doing when it comes to abusing or killing their children?
Because I don't want to live in a society which allows living children to be abused or killed. I have children, and there need to be consequences for anybody who would dare to harm or kill them.

I also don't want to live in a society which has a governmental body determine who should breed, with whom, and how often. It's up to individuals to decide their own family planning, a topic which has absolutely nothing to do with the mistreatment of citizens. As much as I would love for families on welfare to quit having kids they can't financially care for, I'm against the government or anybody else legislating the number of children they have. I don't want the government telling any woman that she must have an abortion (in a case where the fetus won't survive or the woman's health is in danger), because the choice must be hers. The anti-choice movement is about people outside the immediate family determining who must procreate, so what's to stop them from determining who must NOT procreate? I'm just wondering why people get so involved in what other people are doing, from using contraception correctly, to deciding on the timing and number of children they want to raise.

If a fetus is a person, it's logically very much society's business what a mother does to that person.
That's a really big IF.

Time and again I've seen abortion advocates try to turn the issue into one of mere privacy alone, but it's not. It is, fundamentally, a question of personhood.
That's a pretty big assertion. I don't see it as a question of personhood at all. I think the anti-choice people want to make it into a question of personhood, because they don't at all respect the autonomy of actual grown women/persons to make their own decisions. In what way is a fetus a person?

There's a damned good case to be made that an early fetus isn't a person, and that's why I'm in favor of keeping abortions legal, but that case must be made.
So you agree that a fetus isn't a person. What case then do you think can be made that a fetus IS a person? Forget Guantanemo; there are tens of thousands of embryos in frozen storage all over North America. Nobody seems to be up-in-arms over them being denied due process.

Pretending that the anti-abortion argument is about trying to punish women, rather than protecting what they see as people, is fundamentally dishonest.
I completely disagree. At its core, it has always been about controllling women. Yes, there are several on the "pro-life" side who really think that blastocysts are little babies with "souls" and hopes and dreams, but the leadership can never hide their contempt for women very well. Oh sure, it's all about fetal rights, and those poor women suffering through unwanted pregnancies is just an added bonus unfortunate biological circumstance. If men got pregnant, first off, they wouldn't be such whores, and secondly they would never place such minor things like their health, education, or career above the sanctity of human life. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Children != babies.

OMG. are you seriously going to resort to these semantic games? Really?

Babies are children; its the period of life for a human between BIRTH and puberty, then they become teenagers, then adults.

Really, you have to resort to such childish antics?
 
I completely disagree. At its core, it has always been about controllling women. Yes, there are several on the "pro-life" side who really think that blastocysts are little babies with "souls" and hopes and dreams,
I disagree. I think this is merely another mechanism for the "pro-abortion side" to impugn those they disagree with and avoid the realities they defend, excuse and advocate directly or indirectly.

Some of us really do believe in God, take God seriously, believe that He said what He said, and believe what He said, and therein is the simple wisdom and clarity of right and wrong, good and evil that is so lacking in this increasingly God-rejecting society. All of this is merely a symptom of our souls.

"By the God of your father who will help you, And by the Almighty who will bless you With blessings of heaven above, Blessings of the deep that lies beneath, Blessings of the breasts and of the womb."

"And He will love you and bless you and multiply you; He will also bless the fruit of your womb and the fruit of your land, your grain and your new wine and your oil, the increase of your cattle and the offspring of your flock, in the land of which He swore to your fathers to give you."

"Did not He who made me in the womb make them? Did not the same One fashion us in the womb?"

"Behold, children are a heritage from the LORD, The fruit of the womb is a reward."

"Before I formed you in the womb I knew you; Before you were born I sanctified you; I ordained you a prophet to the nations."


but the leadership can never hide their contempt for women very well.
I don't know of any "leadership" that has "contempt for women" or "has always been about controlling women." Neither do I. I love individuals. I have contempt for humanity as a whole. There is no honest way to separate men and women in this debate. Men are every bit as responsible and accountable as women.

Oh sure, it's all about fetal rights, and those poor women suffering through unwanted pregnancies is just an added bonus unfortunate biological circumstance. If men got pregnant, first off, they wouldn't be such whores, and secondly they would never place such minor things like their health, education, or career above the sanctity of human life. :rolleyes:
Absolutely true. We agree. And if women did not have the means to so easily eliminate "the evidence" of their whoring, they would not behave as and be such whores, nor would they allow men either to behave as such whores. In this way, women were the guardians of the virtue of a society and the check on the behavior of men. This is progressive, but is it progress for good and for the better? Now, women behave as the same dogs as men. You're right, it's whoring, at the constant cost of the lives of the very definition of innocence. It is the selfish-first decadence, degradation and shame of society. It is horrible. It is Choice.
 
It is women's responsibility to control men's sexuality and they are to be punished if they fail to do this? That is one of the nastiest approaches to the whole question I have ever read. I have no quarrel with how you relate to your god: and I don't interefere with it in any way. But your own god gave you no mandate whatsoever to make everyone else bend to your will. And it is your will: not his: he was against the kind of thing you propose at least as believers tell the NT story.

You are not godly: you are not even a good person: you are a wannabee tyrant. Nothing more
 
Why are you so intolerant and judgmental?

He will judge between us. I accept His Judgment. See you there.
 
I

Abortions aren't done just because women don't want to have a baby; they're often done because the woman doesn't want to be pregnant. It's not exactly a walk in the park. It's nine months that can completely change every aspect of your life.

Finally! .. I as dieing to say something .. but my previous "being-a-man" argument :) .. left me out of bring the subject up.

I think most people in the argument have no real life experience or personal contact with a pregnant (or in the case of RU46 / morning after) possibly pregnant girls who had to deal with an unwanted pregnancy, and make choices.
 
I disagree. I think this is merely another mechanism for the "pro-abortion side" to impugn those they disagree with and avoid the realities they defend, excuse and advocate directly or indirectly.

Some of us really do believe in God, take God seriously, believe that He said what He said, and believe what He said, and therein is the simple wisdom and clarity of right and wrong, good and evil that is so lacking in this increasingly God-rejecting society. All of this is merely a symptom of our souls.

<snipped bible quotes>
Well, good for you. I don't believe in your magic man anymore than I believe that magical fairies make my flowers bloom. What does this have to do with other people? If you want to live by arbitrary rules set by your magical sky daddy (which are really your own rules in disguise), have at it. Don't force anybody else to live by them. If it comes down to it, I'll make up my own magical woman whose rules I have to live by, and surprise surprise, she's going to want me to behave in the exact same way that I would choose for myself.

I don't know of any "leadership" that has "contempt for women" or "has always been about controlling women." Neither do I. I love individuals. I have contempt for humanity as a whole. There is no honest way to separate men and women in this debate. Men are every bit as responsible and accountable as women.
Falwell. Robertson. Terry whats-his-face from Operation Rescue. You don't have to look far to find contempt for women. (Your mirror is probably the closest place.) And in what world are men every bit as responsible as women when it comes to carrying unwanted pregnancies to term?

Absolutely true. We agree. And if women did not have the means to so easily eliminate "the evidence" of their whoring, they would not behave as and be such whores, nor would they allow men either to behave as such whores. In this way, women were the guardians of the virtue of a society and the check on the behavior of men. This is progressive, but is it progress for good and for the better? Now, women behave as the same dogs as men. You're right, it's whoring, at the constant cost of the lives of the very definition of innocence. It is the selfish-first decadence, degradation and shame of society. It is horrible. It is Choice.
Oh, yes, I see that you really "love" women. Punish those filthy filthy whores, who aren't doing the bidding of your magic man. Just don't look behind the curtain at the tiny little man who's putting words in his mouth. Funny how everybody's god always thinks their exact same thoughts. My magical goddess told me that what happens in my body is my business. She is very very wise.
 
OMG. are you seriously going to resort to these semantic games? Really?

It's not a semantic game. The foster care system you referred to is NOT dominated by babies but by older children, but the pool of prospective adopters IS dominated by parents who want to adopt babies and not older children. You brought the issue of adoption and foster care into the debate, and you did so by conflating babies and children. The difference matters. Maybe it shouldn't, but the numbers don't lie: it does.
 
Because I don't want to live in a society which allows living children to be abused or killed. I have children, and there need to be consequences for anybody who would dare to harm or kill them.

And other people don't want to live in a society which allows living fetuses to be killed. Some of them have fetuses, and there need to be consequences for anybody who would dare to harm or kill them.

You keep making assumptions in your argument that you don't even realize you're making.

I also don't want to live in a society which has a governmental body determine who should breed, with whom, and how often.

Outlawing abortion wouldn't do that.

That's a really big IF.

Of course it's a big "if". That's why it's a debate. If it wasn't a big "if", then we wouldn't have such division on the issue. But that is where the division is, and you seem intent on pretending it lies elsewhere. It doesn't. The question of personhood for the fetus is THE central issue in the abortion debate.

So you agree that a fetus isn't a person.

I agree that an early fetus isn't a person (though I wouldn't say that about a 39 week fetus), but others don't. And unlike you, I can recognize the beliefs of people I disagree with, and I can understand how their opposition to abortion flows logically and inexorably from that belief.

I completely disagree. At its core, it has always been about controllling women.

You're wrong. You want it to be about that, because then you can paint your opponents as not only wrong but evil. But that is a bad-faith argument. It is no better than those who think abortion rights supporters want more abortions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom