"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?


Which does show that merely making abortion illegal does not stop women from getting abortions.

I've also wondered how the drug RU486 would affect abortion rates if abortion became illegal in the US. Getting drugs from other countries through the internet is not impossible. If there was a demand for an abortion pill, would there be a market?
 
Fiona,

I'm not denying that there are cultural components and random variations in mating strategies adopted by men and women. After all, without them evolution would not be possible!

Here is a far more detailed overview explaining how short and long term strategies are explained from an evolutionary point of view (or perspective, if you will):

http://pzacad.pitzer.edu/~dmoore/2007_Buss_Evolution_of_human_mating.pdf

However, the general strategy I outlined is true. In the conclusions:

The empirical evidence supports the evolutionary psychological hypothesis that men have evolved a more powerful desire for a variety of sex partners than have women. The evolutionary logic for this sex difference is straightforward—men who succeeded in securing sexual access to a variety of women would have achieved greater reproductive success than men who did not. Ancestral women, in contrast, could not increase their reproductive output by having sex with many men. Nonetheless, there is a hidden side to female sexuality, and some women some of the time also pursue short-term matings. Because women’s short-term mating can be risky, it is reasonable to hypothesize that ancestral women received benefits from short-term mating that outweighed the costs. The leading hypotheses for why women engage in short-term mating, especially extra-pair mating, are the possibility of acquiring good genes that can be passed to her offspring, increasing her access to material resources, and switching to a better mate.

There's also plenty of evidence both within the document and referenced for you to check out.
 
Which does show that merely making abortion illegal does not stop women from getting abortions.

Which, to be fair, Avalon never contested. He agreed that there was no evidence to the contrary.

I think our negatives are piling up a bit.


I've also wondered how the drug RU486 would affect abortion rates if abortion became illegal in the US. Getting drugs from other countries through the internet is not impossible. If there was a demand for an abortion pill, would there be a market?

I think the market would be thriving, whether legal or not.
 
Which, to be fair, Avalon never contested. He agreed that there was no evidence to the contrary.

No, I agreed that no evidence has been presented to the contrary. I also agree that outlawing abortion has not dropped abortion rates to zero in countries where it has been tried.
But as an aside (because I don't think these issues are central to the OP), the fact that some illegal abortions would still take place doesn't dictate whether or not we should illegalize abortions. After all, that's not the standard we use for any other law respecting a person's right to be free from harm. We wouldn't use this justification to make any other sort of homicide or violence against others illegal, would we? I think it's something of a red herring.
 
Which does show that merely making abortion illegal does not stop women from getting abortions.

There are no widely accepted statistics on the frequency of abortion in the U.S. prior to Roe, and no consensus on how returning abortion to the domain of state criminal law would affect the rates of legal and illegal abortion.
 
Assuming abortion was illegal, what should be the punishments for women who have an abortion and the people who help them?
 
Last edited:
There are no widely accepted statistics on the frequency of abortion in the U.S. prior to Roe, and no consensus on how returning abortion to the domain of state criminal law would affect the rates of legal and illegal abortion.

Not surprising, given it was illegal. However there are widely accepted statistics on the death rate from botched abortions. In fact that scandal was one of the main drivers for the change to the law
 
No, I agreed that no evidence has been presented to the contrary. I also agree that outlawing abortion has not dropped abortion rates to zero in countries where it has been tried.
But as an aside (because I don't think these issues are central to the OP), the fact that some illegal abortions would still take place doesn't dictate whether or not we should illegalize abortions. After all, that's not the standard we use for any other law respecting a person's right to be free from harm. We wouldn't use this justification to make any other sort of homicide or violence against others illegal, would we? I think it's something of a red herring.

The problem here is that almost all the people arguing for abortions do not consider it in any way comparable to homicide or violence. I do understand that you hold strong views to the contrary, but nevertheless, if you wish to debate the subject honestly, you will have to accept that 'abortion is a crime' cannot be used as a premise.

That is why the analogy you are making is flawed. You see, there are two reasons laws forbid things. First is the obvious reason, like forbidding murder; murder is simply an undesirable and immoral thing in and of it self. The second one is indirect. Several things are forbidden not because they are in themselves evil, but because allowing them would lead to problems. Examples of this latter category include for example jaywalking, speeding and recreational drug use.

From your point of view, abortion falls under the first category. However, from a pro-abortion point of view it falls under the second. Terminating a pregnancy in it's first trimester is not considered a terrible crime in itself - if it was, there would be no argument. That's why the actual question is whether or not having abortions be legal leads to better or worse outcomes.

And that's why the point about abortions still continuing despite them being illegal is really quite relevant. History shows that abortions happen in any case. And it also shows that when abortions are not legal, there can be no system guaranteeing their safety. That's why many, many women become victims of quacks, risking their own health and paying disproportionate sums.

So the question isn't really about killing fetuses. Fetuses will be killed in any case, whether it's objectively right or not. What outlawing abortions would do is condemn thousands of women to bodily harm caused by unskilled abortionists. And I simply cannot understand how anyone could want that.
 
There are no widely accepted statistics on the frequency of abortion in the U.S. prior to Roe, and no consensus on how returning abortion to the domain of state criminal law would affect the rates of legal and illegal abortion.

Just like there are no widely accepted statistics on how making abortion illegal would specifically affect the income levels of women. Since there are statistics on the income levels of single parent families and the promotion rates of women with children vs men with children, it is possible to draw the conclusion that more children and having children at a younger age equals less income for women, especially single women.

Before you cry misandry, Avalon, we also have statistics for single parent families with a male parent.
 
Thank you for the sermon, Ivor. It was very nice :)

Well I could have paraphrased at great length what was in the paper I linked to and from other references, but as I knew it wouldn't make any difference to what you think I decided against it.
 
In my opinion, making a sarcastic remark, or using several related rhetoric tools, is dishonest, if the goal is not deception. In this case, the true goal of LL's suggestion was clearly visible, and I've no reason to think he intended differently.

The problem is not the goal. The problem is the logic. It's intellectual dishonesty. The intended conclusion (154 was a hypocrite) doesn't flow from the actual argument. Logic doesn't permit the leap, only emotion does.

The original claim was essentially that 154 would invest a significant amount of his personal resources to further the well-being of unwanted children.

Yes: under a particular set of circumstances that he specified. It was not an open-ended offer to help any unwanted children under any circumstances. It should not be taken as such.

The response was essentially a suggestion he invest a small amount right now.

Would you save someone from a burning building? Yes? Then why aren't you donating a bit of money right now to your local fire department? If you aren't doing so, I can only conclude that you wouldn't really save anyone from a burning building.

The logic is crap, and you aren't even trying to defend it when it's applied elsewhere. In fact, you even concede as much:

I understand your general argument; in many situations, the argument you describe truly is a dishonest tactic. But in my opinion, here it was fair play.

But you've got nothing to describe why it's "fair play" here. Did 154 simply "deserve" it? Not good enough. Again, this isn't about courtesy. It's about whether or not the argument is valid. And it's not. Not in other situations, and not here.
 
Well I could have paraphrased at great length what was in the paper I linked to and from other references, but as I knew it wouldn't make any difference to what you think I decided against it.

You are right: it makes no difference to what I think for several reasons: first, none of it is new: second, it does the usual: it makes predictions: claims it has support for those predictions (and we could argue about the status of those studies, but we won't bother): recognises that there is quite a lot of the real world behaviour of people and animals which directly contradicts those predictions: then explains those away with another nice story.

But that article supports my position rather more than it supports yours: though to be sure the writers do not really notice that. Such is the way of faith :)
 
I've also wondered how the drug RU486 would affect abortion rates if abortion became illegal in the US. Getting drugs from other countries through the internet is not impossible. If there was a demand for an abortion pill, would there be a market?


RU486 is legal in the US, although rather harder to get than it should be. Plan B is widely available.


whether or not we should illegalize abortions.


I think the word is criminalize. Prohibit and Outlaw would also work.




This is my understanding of the current generally accepted view among biological anthropologists.


First is the obvious reason, like forbidding murder; murder is simply an undesirable and immoral thing in and of it self.


Not necessarily. There is no such thing as obhective morality. This is evidenced by the fact that there are many, many successful societies where murder is allowed. Babylon had human sacrifice, and they were the civilization that basically gave birth to the concept of civilization. The Azteks practiced ritual murder, and were the dominant culture in the Americas until the Spanish coughed on them (and then shot them). Even the US has capital punishment which, while I think it's wrong, doesn't make us much less of an economic and social leader in the world.

Murder isn't bad because its wrong. Murder is bad in certain situations taking certain subjective social values as given.

The main problem with murder is that it is the ultimate use of physical force by one person against another. Society, law and government exist to level the physical playing field - to assure the weak equal access to justice as the physically strong. The power to use physical force in order to get one's way is reserved, by consent of the governed, to the government. Since we are all weak at some point, and we are not all necessarily strong at some point, it's a rule that offers maximum opportunity to participate in public life (and the public marketplace) to everyone.

Murder isn't illegal because it's wrong. Murder is illegal because it disrupts the basic functions of a democratic and capitalistic government.

And we can see this follow through in our approach to abortion. Fetuses aren't exonomic actors. Women killing their own unborn fetuses are not robbing the marketplace of an income-generating actor (in any measurable way, at least). And they may be doing some economic good for themselves and the community as a whole. Also, allowing women power over their own bodies, helps empower them in general - increasing their contributions to the marketplace.

Abortion will stay safe and legal because murder isn't immoral. Unwanted children, however, are a drag on personal finances and community's resources.

Incidentally, it's the exact same reason why Teri Schiavo and Karen Ann Quinlan should have been allowed to die (or at least why their families should have had the choice whether to continue their care). It's just not always immoral to kill somebody.


But that article supports my position rather more than it supports yours: though to be sure the writers do not really notice that. Such is the way of faith


I don't know, Fiona. This seems to be a pretty radical departure from the traditional view of women as "nesters," towards one where they actively try to game the system. Scientists have changed their opinions based on evidence, and found evidence based on their hypotheses. It doesn't see much like faith to me.

Perhaps, it can be agreed, that such evidence is interesting but as of yet insufficient to form a conclusion. It raises avenues for exploration.
 
The problem is not the goal. The problem is the logic. It's intellectual dishonesty. The intended conclusion (154 was a hypocrite) doesn't flow from the actual argument. Logic doesn't permit the leap, only emotion does.



Yes: under a particular set of circumstances that he specified. It was not an open-ended offer to help any unwanted children under any circumstances. It should not be taken as such.



Would you save someone from a burning building? Yes? Then why aren't you donating a bit of money right now to your local fire department? If you aren't doing so, I can only conclude that you wouldn't really save anyone from a burning building.

The logic is crap, and you aren't even trying to defend it when it's applied elsewhere. In fact, you even concede as much:



But you've got nothing to describe why it's "fair play" here. Did 154 simply "deserve" it? Not good enough. Again, this isn't about courtesy. It's about whether or not the argument is valid. And it's not. Not in other situations, and not here.
Ahhh, but here it is a valid argument. Precisely for the reason Mirrorglass posted.

When a person attempts to take the 'moral highground' as 154 did, it is entirely reasonable for another person to attack that position - as was done, in an appropriate manner.

The claim was made by 154 that 154 was more than willing to assist in the care of unwanted babies.
This claim was challenged by LL.
154 refused to respond to the challenge in a manner that supports his original assertion.

Game, set, match to LossLeader.


This is in no way a dishonest form of debate unless you wish to start with the dishonesty of 154's position (as demonstrated by LossLeader's challenge).
 
Ahhh, but here it is a valid argument. Precisely for the reason Mirrorglass posted.

When a person attempts to take the 'moral highground' as 154 did, it is entirely reasonable for another person to attack that position - as was done, in an appropriate manner.

The claim was made by 154 that 154 was more than willing to assist in the care of unwanted babies.
This claim was challenged by LL.
154 refused to respond to the challenge in a manner that supports his original assertion.

Game, set, match to LossLeader.


This is in no way a dishonest form of debate unless you wish to start with the dishonesty of 154's position (as demonstrated by LossLeader's challenge).

Stop lying.

You have a baby you want to get rid of?

I'll take it.

Promise.

You want to donate to an orphanage?

You go right ahead.

Case dismissed.



- Nice, nice. That was beautiful. What? 25, 30 posts all devoted to attempting to impugn me. Lovely.

Why?

- And thank you Ziggurat. Whether or not we agree wherever on whatever, I certainly respect your intellectual ability, honesty and integrity.
 
Last edited:
Ahhh, but here it is a valid argument. Precisely for the reason Mirrorglass posted.

The reasons Mirrorglass stated don't withstand scrutiny.

When a person attempts to take the 'moral highground' as 154 did, it is entirely reasonable for another person to attack that position - as was done, in an appropriate manner.

It wasn't done in an appropriate manner. That's the whole point. I'm not saying it can't be with some other argument, but it wasn't.

The claim was made by 154 that 154 was more than willing to assist in the care of unwanted babies.
This claim was challenged by LL.

No. 154 made a specific offer of assistance contingent upon certain conditions. LL demanded different assistance be rendered under different conditions. There's nothing appropriate about that.

This is in no way a dishonest form of debate unless you wish to start with the dishonesty of 154's position (as demonstrated by LossLeader's challenge).

LL's challenge doesn't demonstrate dishonesty in 154's position, it only demonstrates dishonesty in LL's position, because the challenge was dishonest. That's true whether or not 154's position was honest. You seem to be claiming that the logic LL used, which nobody seems willing to argue is actually valid in other circumstances, is somehow justified in its use against 154 because 154 was dishonest, but that's not how it works. The sins of your opponent don't excuse yours.
 
You have a baby you want to get rid of?
No, but for the sake of the argument lets assume that I do have a baby that I want to get rid off.

I'll take it.
How? When?

You'll need to do better then this. I have zero reason to believe that you will live up to this promise. Lots of people make empty promises, what guarantee do I have that this isn't the case here? What gesture are you willing to make that would establish:
a) your willingness to actually take the baby of my hands
b) your ability to actually place the baby in a stable and loving home
 
No, but for the sake of the argument lets assume that I do have a baby that I want to get rid off.

Why?

I've been defending 154 from some dishonest attacks, but now I'll level a bit of criticism. His offer, regardless of how real it is, is rather irrelevant. That's the ultimate problem with what he said. It's got no real impact on what is a nationwide issue, not simply an issue for members of this board.

When you challenge his offer, you challenge his honesty. And the reason that's a bad idea is because you've got no reason to. And I say that both in the sense that we don't have any reason to actually doubt him, but also because it doesn't matter if he's honest about it. His willingness to personally ensure the welfare of unwanted children doesn't make abortion wrong (and conversely, even if you could prove him a liar that wouldn't make abortion right), and it's not an offer that actually changes the options available for any significant fraction of the population either. So why pick what amounts to a personal fight when you really don't need to? His offer doesn't need to be challenged because it never mattered to begin with.
 
Stop lying.

You have a baby you want to get rid of?

I'll take it.


Promise.

You want to donate to an orphanage?

You go right ahead.

Case dismissed.



- Nice, nice. That was beautiful. What? 25, 30 posts all devoted to attempting to impugn me. Lovely.

Why?

- And thank you Ziggurat. Whether or not we agree wherever on whatever, I certainly respect your intellectual ability, honesty and integrity.

If you reall wanted to, there are enough children in orphanages that don't have anyoone taking care, want the adress of some? For how moan children have room in your house? 4? 5?
PM me your adress.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom