The problem is not the goal. The problem is the logic. It's intellectual dishonesty. The intended conclusion (154 was a hypocrite) doesn't flow from the actual argument. Logic doesn't permit the leap, only emotion does.
I think I see the root of the problem. You see, this isn't a 'logic'. This is a
conversation. Logic is certainly one of the
tools used, but that does not mean a conversation has to flow like a continuous series of logical operations. It is acceptable to bring in new, reasonable assumptions - for example, the assumption that if a person is truly willing to take personal responsibility of helping an unwanted child, that person is likely willing to make some other, smaller investments to similar causes. It is not an emotional argument; it is a logical argument when viewed in the context of the real world.
Yes: under a particular set of circumstances that he specified. It was not an open-ended offer to help any unwanted children under any circumstances. It should not be taken as such.
If 154 truly meant to say that he will help children in these, specific circumstances, but in no other, then the argument is already so ridiculous it bears pointing out. I don't see how a reasonable person could believe 154's claim is anything but a blatant lie, if he cannot provide any evidence of actively working for the benefit of charities. If you wish to simply accept his bald assertion, it is your prerogative, but I would call you naive.
Would you save someone from a burning building? Yes? Then why aren't you donating a bit of money right now to your local fire department? If you aren't doing so, I can only conclude that you wouldn't really save anyone from a burning building.
Well, the thing is, I didn't promise to rescue you out of a burning building whenever you are in trouble and proceed to gloat my superiority.
If I
did make such a claim, you would be quite sensible in questioning whether or not I truly possess such bravery - although in this case, donating money to the fire department is not a particularly good test.
The logic is crap, and you aren't even trying to defend it when it's applied elsewhere. In fact, you even concede as much:
But you've got nothing to describe why it's "fair play" here. Did 154 simply "deserve" it? Not good enough. Again, this isn't about courtesy. It's about whether or not the argument is valid. And it's not. Not in other situations, and not here.
See, this is
you being dishonest. You misrepresent my quote, attempting to make it seem as if I'd said the strategy is dishonest
everywhere else. You are speaking as if what I called 'the argument you describe' referred to LL's argument here, when it clearly referred to the
argument you describe - a subtly different form of argumentation, which I do consider dishonest.
Then you simply dismiss all my points, saying 'I've got nothing', continue to suggest I ever argued 154 'deserved' anything. And a few subtler things.
All in all, if this is the way you intend to continue this discussion, I see little reason to explain my reasons any further. After all, I've no reason to believe your next reply will be anything else than a repeated insistence that 'I've got nothing'.