"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

If you reall wanted to, there are enough children in orphanages that don't have anyoone taking care, want the adress of some? For how moan children have room in your house? 4? 5?
PM me your adress.

This is another dishonest response. There's a major difference in the adoptability of children and infants, and you cannot be so ignorant as to be unaware of this fact. 154 didn't offer to raise children without parents himself, he offered to find homes for unwanted babies. Can you honestly not understand the difference? No, I'm sure you can. You just chose not to.
 
This is another dishonest response. There's a major difference in the adoptability of children and infants, and you cannot be so ignorant as to be unaware of this fact. 154 didn't offer to raise children without parents himself, he offered to find homes for unwanted babies. Can you honestly not understand the difference? No, I'm sure you can. You just chose not to.

what is wrong with kids now in orphanages, why is she/he not looking for parents for them?
Making such an offer to prevent abortions is pretty mean against the kids living in orphanages now.
 
Last edited:
We have over 150,000 children in this country in foster care or a ward of the state.

I challenge that for EVERY pro-lifer that wants to stop abortion they they'd be teh first in line to at least adopt 3 children in order to provide homes for these unwanted babies.

Their actions in the fact that very few pro-lifers do this, speaks louder than their gripes.


By the way, ADOPTION isn't easy. Why do you think that most couples are turning to foreign countries to adopt.
 
what is wrong with kids now in orphanages

It doesn't matter what's "wrong" with them, the fact is that they are in far less demand from potential adoptive parents.

Making such an offer to prevent abortions is pretty mean against the kids living in orphanages now.

Bull****. His offer doesn't change their situation at all.
 
We have over 150,000 children in this country in foster care or a ward of the state.

I challenge that for EVERY pro-lifer that wants to stop abortion they they'd be teh first in line to at least adopt 3 children in order to provide homes for these unwanted babies.

Children != babies.
 
It doesn't matter what's "wrong" with them, the fact is that they are in far less demand from potential adoptive parents.



Bull****. His offer doesn't change their situation at all.

1. pls? can you rephrase it? i dont understand what you mean.

2. That is why it is mean, making others getting their unwanted baby and directly finding a place for it is pretty mean for a kid that is alerady waiting for parents, why let a new child grew when there is already one in need of parents?
 
instead one should encourage parents that want a baby, to adopt one, instead of making a new one.
 
Not necessarily. There is no such thing as obhective morality. This is evidenced by the fact that there are many, many successful societies where murder is allowed. Babylon had human sacrifice, and they were the civilization that basically gave birth to the concept of civilization. The Azteks practiced ritual murder, and were the dominant culture in the Americas until the Spanish coughed on them (and then shot them). Even the US has capital punishment which, while I think it's wrong, doesn't make us much less of an economic and social leader in the world.

Murder isn't bad because its wrong. Murder is bad in certain situations taking certain subjective social values as given.

The main problem with murder is that it is the ultimate use of physical force by one person against another. Society, law and government exist to level the physical playing field - to assure the weak equal access to justice as the physically strong. The power to use physical force in order to get one's way is reserved, by consent of the governed, to the government. Since we are all weak at some point, and we are not all necessarily strong at some point, it's a rule that offers maximum opportunity to participate in public life (and the public marketplace) to everyone.

Murder isn't illegal because it's wrong. Murder is illegal because it disrupts the basic functions of a democratic and capitalistic government.

And we can see this follow through in our approach to abortion. Fetuses aren't exonomic actors. Women killing their own unborn fetuses are not robbing the marketplace of an income-generating actor (in any measurable way, at least). And they may be doing some economic good for themselves and the community as a whole. Also, allowing women power over their own bodies, helps empower them in general - increasing their contributions to the marketplace.

Abortion will stay safe and legal because murder isn't immoral. Unwanted children, however, are a drag on personal finances and community's resources.

Incidentally, it's the exact same reason why Teri Schiavo and Karen Ann Quinlan should have been allowed to die (or at least why their families should have had the choice whether to continue their care). It's just not always immoral to kill somebody.

I think this part of your post raises some of the underlying problems in this debate and so it quite useful. As I understand it, your position is that there is no such thing as objective morality, and therefore all such decisions are primarily pragmatic? That may be a misrepresentatin and some other word might reflect your stance better: but let me proceed on the assumption it is close

To support your position you have effectively redefined murder to include the lawful killing of individuals by the state. And therin lies the real problem because that is not what the word means. So you point up quite nicely the parts of our thinking that need more elaboration in order to clarify what each of us is saying.

When you state there is no such thing as objective morality what force does the word objective have? I am not trying to be awkward: if honestly find that a central issue. Some who make such a statement appear to be looking for the same kind of objectivity which one finds in hard science: so they want a moral principle which exists no matter what one believes in the same way as gravity does. But that is perhaps a useful example: we talk about the "law" of gravity and we talk about the "law" against murder. We all clearly recognise these are not "laws" in the same sense. In fact the use of the word in a scientific context is a metaphor: and it is a metaphor because scientists are people first: they spoke "ordinary language" before they spoke "science" and all concepts must in the end derive from how we speak, because that reflects how we think and because if we cannot communicate what we discover it might as well not exist: in a very real sense it does not.

You point to civilisations which practised legal executions of various kinds: but this rather undermines your case unless you can show that such civilisations did not recognise the concept of murder as we understand the term: that is, illegal killing. I have the impressin that all civilisations do recognise that concept and have a word for it. It is perfectly true that societies vary in where they draw the line: life is messy like that and grey areas at the margins are the norm for a lot of things to do with people and how they live and organise. But that kind of evidence does not show there is no objective morality. The existence of lawful and unlawful killing, if universal, tends to show the opposite, IMO.

There are very interesting discussions to be had about how and why we draw the lines where we do. Moral philosophy is a difficult subject but that does not mean it is nothing or that it is not important. People have discussed and thought about it forever, and that in itself demonstrates that the flat statement that there is no such thing as objective morality can only work for values of objective which have no leverage in this context. So far as I can tell the opposition you seem to be making is that between the kind of "fact" science discovers and "taste". That does not cover the range of things in the world, and if my understanding of what you are saying is correct then we definitely need a different conceptualisation for moral utterance and behaviour: because nobody will actually lose their temper if you say you prefer dark chocolate: but they will kill you over a moral difference. Thus the humour in Swift's description of "big enders and little enders" in Gulliver's travels: it is a category mistake.

I don't know, Fiona. This seems to be a pretty radical departure from the traditional view of women as "nesters," towards one where they actively try to game the system. Scientists have changed their opinions based on evidence, and found evidence based on their hypotheses. It doesn't see much like faith to me.

Perhaps, it can be agreed, that such evidence is interesting but as of yet insufficient to form a conclusion. It raises avenues for exploration.

It is a forced departure in one sense: and it is based on evidence: but if you read the article what you will see is that they made a predicition: the evidence did not support it: but they did not give it up. Now I do not quarrel with hanging on to a hypothesis and trying to elaborate it to accommodate facts which appear to contradict it: that is what we try first in hard science, and that is as it should be. But this is not a hypothesis that is readily testable, as the authors themselves acknowlege. The twists and turns are beyond what is reasonable, and that is what we see in faith dialogues. This is because this sort of thing is the wrong realm of discourse for what they are trying to do. Perhaps there is some prospect of furthering our understanding of human behaviour through sciene: but the history of psychology gives no grounds for optimism so far. It is a fields where anecdote and observation (fact gathering by any other name) is crucial because we have so little knowledge: what we are seeing is phlogisten and humours: they were plausible when we had few facts but they were wrong and they were wrong because we did not have the basic concepts. Those ideas persisted in the same way and they were not overturned by forcing the facts into the theory, as these people are doing. They were overturned by a radically different approach to what counts as relevant. (That is a crude and simplistic characterisation but I hope you get what I mean)
 
The problem is not the goal. The problem is the logic. It's intellectual dishonesty. The intended conclusion (154 was a hypocrite) doesn't flow from the actual argument. Logic doesn't permit the leap, only emotion does.

I think I see the root of the problem. You see, this isn't a 'logic'. This is a conversation. Logic is certainly one of the tools used, but that does not mean a conversation has to flow like a continuous series of logical operations. It is acceptable to bring in new, reasonable assumptions - for example, the assumption that if a person is truly willing to take personal responsibility of helping an unwanted child, that person is likely willing to make some other, smaller investments to similar causes. It is not an emotional argument; it is a logical argument when viewed in the context of the real world.

Yes: under a particular set of circumstances that he specified. It was not an open-ended offer to help any unwanted children under any circumstances. It should not be taken as such.

If 154 truly meant to say that he will help children in these, specific circumstances, but in no other, then the argument is already so ridiculous it bears pointing out. I don't see how a reasonable person could believe 154's claim is anything but a blatant lie, if he cannot provide any evidence of actively working for the benefit of charities. If you wish to simply accept his bald assertion, it is your prerogative, but I would call you naive.

Would you save someone from a burning building? Yes? Then why aren't you donating a bit of money right now to your local fire department? If you aren't doing so, I can only conclude that you wouldn't really save anyone from a burning building.

Well, the thing is, I didn't promise to rescue you out of a burning building whenever you are in trouble and proceed to gloat my superiority.

If I did make such a claim, you would be quite sensible in questioning whether or not I truly possess such bravery - although in this case, donating money to the fire department is not a particularly good test.


The logic is crap, and you aren't even trying to defend it when it's applied elsewhere. In fact, you even concede as much:

But you've got nothing to describe why it's "fair play" here. Did 154 simply "deserve" it? Not good enough. Again, this isn't about courtesy. It's about whether or not the argument is valid. And it's not. Not in other situations, and not here.

See, this is you being dishonest. You misrepresent my quote, attempting to make it seem as if I'd said the strategy is dishonest everywhere else. You are speaking as if what I called 'the argument you describe' referred to LL's argument here, when it clearly referred to the argument you describe - a subtly different form of argumentation, which I do consider dishonest.

Then you simply dismiss all my points, saying 'I've got nothing', continue to suggest I ever argued 154 'deserved' anything. And a few subtler things.

All in all, if this is the way you intend to continue this discussion, I see little reason to explain my reasons any further. After all, I've no reason to believe your next reply will be anything else than a repeated insistence that 'I've got nothing'.
 
1. pls? can you rephrase it? i dont understand what you mean.

There are more prospective parents who want to adopt a baby than want to adopt a child. What about that do you not understand?

2. That is why it is mean, making others getting their unwanted baby and directly finding a place for it is pretty mean for a kid that is alerady waiting for parents

Except that 154 finding parents for a baby doesn't impact children wanting a parent, because there's a waiting list of people who want to adopt a baby but there isn't a waiting list of people who want to adopt a child.

why let a new child grew when there is already one in need of parents?

154 has no power over the fact that more people want to adopt babies than want to adopt children. He can't make people want to adopt children instead of babies.
 
I think I see the root of the problem. You see, this isn't a 'logic'. This is a conversation. Logic is certainly one of the tools used, but that does not mean a conversation has to flow like a continuous series of logical operations.

That's a garbage excuse for using bad logic.

If 154 truly meant to say that he will help children in these, specific circumstances, but in no other

He never said he would help in no other circumstances. But his offer wasn't for any other circumstances. It is for him to determine when and how else he would help, not you, and not LL.
 
There are more prospective parents who want to adopt a baby than want to adopt a child. What about that do you not understand?



Except that 154 finding parents for a baby doesn't impact children wanting a parent, because there's a waiting list of people who want to adopt a baby but there isn't a waiting list of people who want to adopt a child.



154 has no power over the fact that more people want to adopt babies than want to adopt children. He can't make people want to adopt children instead of babies.

ah now i understand it, good point. I didn't think about that.
 
<snip>

It is a forced departure in one sense: and it is based on evidence: but if you read the article what you will see is that they made a predicition: the evidence did not support it: but they did not give it up. Now I do not quarrel with hanging on to a hypothesis and trying to elaborate it to accommodate facts which appear to contradict it: that is what we try first in hard science, and that is as it should be. But this is not a hypothesis that is readily testable, as the authors themselves acknowlege. The twists and turns are beyond what is reasonable, and that is what we see in faith dialogues. This is because this sort of thing is the wrong realm of discourse for what they are trying to do. Perhaps there is some prospect of furthering our understanding of human behaviour through sciene: but the history of psychology gives no grounds for optimism so far. It is a fields where anecdote and observation (fact gathering by any other name) is crucial because we have so little knowledge: what we are seeing is phlogisten and humours: they were plausible when we had few facts but they were wrong and they were wrong because we did not have the basic concepts. Those ideas persisted in the same way and they were not overturned by forcing the facts into the theory, as these people are doing. They were overturned by a radically different approach to what counts as relevant. (That is a crude and simplistic characterisation but I hope you get what I mean)

The author acknowledges that there are many factors which influence human mating behaviour in the short term, as do I. E.g., cultural values and specific circumstances. Over the long term these all get filtered through evolution via natural and sexual selection.

I know being a strident feminist you really want to believe women = men in every meaningful way, but that's not what the evidence suggests. But my point of view should give you hope: If you want men to change all you have to do is convince your revolutionary sisters to breed more often with the men who behave the way you'd prefer them to.
 
That's a garbage excuse for using bad logic.



He never said he would help in no other circumstances. But his offer wasn't for any other circumstances. It is for him to determine when and how else he would help, not you, and not LL.

And now you've resorted to snipping parts of sentences off my post to have something to argue with. I think it's time we accept that what we consider dishonesty in debate differs substantially.
 
And now you've resorted to snipping parts of sentences off my post to have something to argue with.

The rest of the sentence doesn't rescue the part I quoted from being false. It's just as wrong with the full sentence, it's only longer. Here, watch:

If 154 truly meant to say that he will help children in these, specific circumstances, but in no other, then the argument is already so ridiculous it bears pointing out.

As I already pointed out, there's no reason to think 154 meant that he would not help children in any other circumstances, so this statement falls flat at the starting gate. It is, to borrow a phrase, so ridiculous it bears pointing out.

I think it's time we accept that what we consider dishonesty in debate differs substantially.

I've been aware of that since you started defending LL's bad logic.
 
The rest of the sentence doesn't rescue the part I quoted from being false. It's just as wrong with the full sentence, it's only longer. Here, watch:



As I already pointed out, there's no reason to think 154 meant that he would not help children in any other circumstances, so this statement falls flat at the starting gate. It is, to borrow a phrase, so ridiculous it bears pointing out.

Indeed. It is also an idea you proposed. Remember?

Yes: under a particular set of circumstances that he specified. It was not an open-ended offer to help any unwanted children under any circumstances. It should not be taken as such.

It was you who suggested we should only consider the specific claim of finding foster homes to unwanted children of forumites. I merely pointed out that if we did that, the statement would already be completely unbelievable. That may not be obvious outside of context, which is of course part of the reason I consider quoting only parts of posts very dishonest. But you wouldn't know anything about that sort of thing, I'm sure.

I've been aware of that since you started defending LL's bad logic.

Of course you have.
 
I know being a strident feminist you really want to believe women = men in every meaningful way, but that's not what the evidence suggests. But my point of view should give you hope: If you want men to change all you have to do is convince your revolutionary sisters to breed more often with the men who behave the way you'd prefer them to.


Oooh Ivor, I don't really usually go in much for fallacy and attribution of motive: but since you want to play, how can I deny you?

I know being singularly unsuccessful at finding sexual partners you really want to believe that women are different from men and that is what accounts for it, but that is not what the evidence suggests. But my point of view should give you hope: If you want women to fancy you all you have to do is stop treating them as if they were all the same and stop insulting them by ignoring everything substantive they say. :)
 
Oooh Ivor, I don't really usually go in much for fallacy and attribution of motive:

But you do like your anecdotal evidence.

but since you want to play, how can I deny you?

<snip>

Well you're a woman, so denying me should come naturally.:)

If you want women to fancy you all you have to do is stop treating them as if they were all the same and stop insulting them by ignoring everything substantive they say. :)

Really? Are women not interested in the physical attributes, health, financial status or intellect of men? All I have to do is treat every brain fart a woman has as a profound statement on the nature of reality and she'll shag me?

Fiona, you're so wise. Have I ever told you that before?
 
I am sorry Ivor: I did not realise you were ugly and ill and poor and stupid. But I assure you that is not an insurmountable barrier: look around you
 
I am sorry Ivor: I did not realise you were ugly and ill and poor and stupid. But I assure you that is not an insurmountable barrier: look around you

Oh, I do look around and agree with you. I'm reasonably fit, financially stable and degree educated. That's why I have to work so hard fooling myself that it isn't my hideous personality which turns women off.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom