And other people don't want to live in a society which allows living fetuses to be killed. Some of them have fetuses, and there need to be consequences for anybody who would dare to harm or kill them.
And there are consequences for people who harm or kill a fetus which doesn't belong to them. What does that have to do with a woman choosing to terminate a pregnancy which is taking place in her own body? I even said that I don't want to live in a society which places those decisions on other people. I don't want to live in a society where I'm either forced to remain pregnant or forced to abort.
Outlawing abortion wouldn't do that.
Huh? If we outlaw abortion, then yes, somebody else is telling other people when and with whom they must breed, namely at the time and with the person who created the pregnancy. If abortion is kept legal, then I can decide that I don't want to have BillyBob's baby, and I can decide that I'd rather have my first child a few years from now. If abortion is illegal, then I'm forced to have BillyBob's baby now, even though that's not my choice.
Of course it's a big "if". That's why it's a debate. If it wasn't a big "if", then we wouldn't have such division on the issue. But that is where the division is, and you seem intent on pretending it lies elsewhere. It doesn't. The question of personhood for the fetus is THE central issue in the abortion debate.
No it's not the central issue. There is no compelling reason to say that a fetus is a person with rights or responsibilities. It's only become a part of the debate because it's no longer okay to treat women like second-class citizens. We're allowed to vote, we're allowed to work, we're allowed to serve in the military, and we're allowed to decide when and whether we want to use our bodies for breeding.
I agree that an early fetus isn't a person (though I wouldn't say that about a 39 week fetus), but others don't. And unlike you, I can recognize the beliefs of people I disagree with, and I can understand how their opposition to abortion flows logically and inexorably from that belief.
I can recognize their beliefs too. But that doesn't mean I have to live under them. I don't have to follow Sharia law, I don't have to follow Jewish orthodox rules, I don't have to believe that a fetus has a soul or is a person. I completely recognize that other people have differing belief systems. Can any one of them give me a compelling reason that I need to live by the rules of their belief system? I don't believe in drinking alcohol, but I'm not out there telling other adults that they're not allowed to drink.
You're wrong. You want it to be about that, because then you can paint your opponents as not only wrong but evil. But that is a bad-faith argument. It is no better than those who think abortion rights supporters want more abortions.
My experience tells me that I'm not wrong. Anti-choice movements in the 20th and 21st centuries are all about controlling women. The thread title says it all. Only the worst monsters would tell a woman that she shouldn't be allowed to have an abortion if she's raped or if her life is in jeopardy (which guess what? that's just a fact of pregnancy - you could die from it). The anti-choicers somehow have a problem with a woman deciding to have an abortion because it's somehow
convenient. She had sex, she knew the possible consequences, and now she must pay.
Have you been reading a different thread than me? The anti-woman rhetoric is all over the place.
Maybe you could point me to some "pro-life" people who argue for personhood without condemning women in their next breath. (And I said earlier, I've seen a few simple-minded folk who think that there are little babies, living in wombs, dreaming of puppies and rainbows - but they're not the core of the movement.)