"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

154:
Some of us really do believe in God, take God seriously, believe that He said what He said, and believe what He said, and therein is the simple wisdom and clarity of right and wrong, good and evil that is so lacking in this increasingly God-rejecting society. All of this is merely a symptom of our souls.

Ahh, the cows finally come home to roost ..

Did you know that many more pregnancies end in miscarriages and still-births than abortions ?

That would make your God the greatest abortionist of all..
 
are you freaking serious?


I am. I'd like to know a consistent definition of "personhood" that includes all people who have been born, no matter what, but excludes all those yet born, no matter at what stage.

At least, I'd like to know a definition that isn't self-referential (or isn't ends-oriented).

I'm PRO-CHOICE, but I am still willing to grant that personhood is a sliding concept that definitely includes some percentage of the unborn.
 
And other people don't want to live in a society which allows living fetuses to be killed. Some of them have fetuses, and there need to be consequences for anybody who would dare to harm or kill them.
And there are consequences for people who harm or kill a fetus which doesn't belong to them. What does that have to do with a woman choosing to terminate a pregnancy which is taking place in her own body? I even said that I don't want to live in a society which places those decisions on other people. I don't want to live in a society where I'm either forced to remain pregnant or forced to abort.

Outlawing abortion wouldn't do that.
Huh? If we outlaw abortion, then yes, somebody else is telling other people when and with whom they must breed, namely at the time and with the person who created the pregnancy. If abortion is kept legal, then I can decide that I don't want to have BillyBob's baby, and I can decide that I'd rather have my first child a few years from now. If abortion is illegal, then I'm forced to have BillyBob's baby now, even though that's not my choice.
Of course it's a big "if". That's why it's a debate. If it wasn't a big "if", then we wouldn't have such division on the issue. But that is where the division is, and you seem intent on pretending it lies elsewhere. It doesn't. The question of personhood for the fetus is THE central issue in the abortion debate.
No it's not the central issue. There is no compelling reason to say that a fetus is a person with rights or responsibilities. It's only become a part of the debate because it's no longer okay to treat women like second-class citizens. We're allowed to vote, we're allowed to work, we're allowed to serve in the military, and we're allowed to decide when and whether we want to use our bodies for breeding.
I agree that an early fetus isn't a person (though I wouldn't say that about a 39 week fetus), but others don't. And unlike you, I can recognize the beliefs of people I disagree with, and I can understand how their opposition to abortion flows logically and inexorably from that belief.
I can recognize their beliefs too. But that doesn't mean I have to live under them. I don't have to follow Sharia law, I don't have to follow Jewish orthodox rules, I don't have to believe that a fetus has a soul or is a person. I completely recognize that other people have differing belief systems. Can any one of them give me a compelling reason that I need to live by the rules of their belief system? I don't believe in drinking alcohol, but I'm not out there telling other adults that they're not allowed to drink.
You're wrong. You want it to be about that, because then you can paint your opponents as not only wrong but evil. But that is a bad-faith argument. It is no better than those who think abortion rights supporters want more abortions.
My experience tells me that I'm not wrong. Anti-choice movements in the 20th and 21st centuries are all about controlling women. The thread title says it all. Only the worst monsters would tell a woman that she shouldn't be allowed to have an abortion if she's raped or if her life is in jeopardy (which guess what? that's just a fact of pregnancy - you could die from it). The anti-choicers somehow have a problem with a woman deciding to have an abortion because it's somehow convenient. She had sex, she knew the possible consequences, and now she must pay.

Have you been reading a different thread than me? The anti-woman rhetoric is all over the place.

Maybe you could point me to some "pro-life" people who argue for personhood without condemning women in their next breath. (And I said earlier, I've seen a few simple-minded folk who think that there are little babies, living in wombs, dreaming of puppies and rainbows - but they're not the core of the movement.)
 
It's not a semantic game. The foster care system you referred to is NOT dominated by babies but by older children, but the pool of prospective adopters IS dominated by parents who want to adopt babies and not older children. You brought the issue of adoption and foster care into the debate, and you did so by conflating babies and children. The difference matters. Maybe it shouldn't, but the numbers don't lie: it does.
The anti-choice people conflate babies and fetuses all the time.

I understand the difference between fetuses, babies, and older children. Do I get a lollipop?

(Just adding a reminder that IMO adoption has absolutely nothing to do with the abortion debate.)
 
In what way is a comatose patient on life support who is expected to recover (with years of rehab) a person?
The patient has a birthday, a name and a family. The patient has done some living in the material world. How is that patient NOT a person? They may not be fully functioning at the moment, so they shouldn't be allowed to cast a vote, but they also shouldn't have their property stripped from them.

I'm just trying to figure out how this^^ factors into granting personhood to a fetus.
 
I tend to agree with Sun Countess: in my experience, pro-lifers do argue a bit about the fetus's alleged personhood, but they almost invariably insist about the "consequences" of having sex, and how the woman should take "responsibility" (somehow, doing a convenient thing such as an abortion is "not taking responsibility"). They hardly ever complain about the discarded frozen embryos, for instance.
 
, and how the woman should take "responsibility" (somehow, doing a convenient thing such as an abortion is "not taking responsibility").
The responsibility argument is the weakest I have ever heard.
Yet at least one poster here presents it, and steadfastly denies it has anything to do with punishment.
Just how an unwanted pregnancy can be enforced because the woman didn't take enough care, and not be punishment for failing to take enough care, is beyond me.
Of course it would be better if unwanted pregnancies were prevented, but to enforce them once they occur, because they are the result of carelessness, and for no other reason, is punishment.
If abortion is denied for reasons other than carelessness, then the responsibility argument is redundant.
 
The patient has a birthday, a name and a family.


Once again, I'm pro-choice. But I think it's making a distinction without a difference to divide a 32 week-old fetus from a coma patient based on any of this. A fetus has a family. It's impossible for it not to have a family. And it can have a name. Visit any cemetary to see the names of fetuses who died before birth. I went to a funeral after a mother miscarried at 5 months.

And a birthday? Some cultures don't even celebrate birthdays. If you're referring to having been born, this is just defining the terms in a way that lets one win. If I call anything that gets past the 20 yard line a "touchdown," then my team won today.


The patient has done some living in the material world. How is that patient NOT a person?


How is having done some living in the material world different from being about to do some living in the material world? And what does that make those very sick babies who are born and remain unconscious? Do they never gain personhood?


They may not be fully functioning at the moment, so they shouldn't be allowed to cast a vote, but they also shouldn't have their property stripped from them.


Funny you should mention that. As a family and elder law attorney, I spend a great part of my workday stripping the property from elderly, ill and unconscious people.


I'm just trying to figure out how this^^ factors into granting personhood to a fetus.


I see nothing in the definition of a comatose patient (whether he will or will not recover) that necessarily differentiates him from a fetus - unless of course you just say "birth is necessary for personhood by definition." But I see no necessarily true reason to say such a thing.

Thus, to my mind, the pro-choice position is not going to win based on concepts of personhood. I think it would be easier to defend the idea that "personhood" does not, in and of itself, confer an absolute right to life.
 
LOL irony.
What is that "irony," Morrigan?


154:Ahh, the cows finally come home to roost ..

Did you know that many more pregnancies end in miscarriages and still-births than abortions ?
What cows come home to roost?
I know that you meant, or at least I reasonably assume that you meant "crows."

So then, what "crows have come home to roost," Skeptical Greg?

And no, I did not know that there were more miscarriages and still-births than abortions,
not that it matters to my point or position.

So then, Skeptical Greg,
what is your evidence and citation that there are more than
approximately 42,000,000 abortions worldwide per year or 115,000 per day worldwide,
and/or more than
approximately 1,370,000 abortions per year or 3,700 per day in the United States of America?
http://abortionno.org/Resources/fastfacts.html


Loss Leader,
I noticed that you did not answer, so now again, I now challenge you.
Would you or would you not like to attach a contractual wager to your challenge to me?


And Sun Countess,
I ask for your answer to this previous question:
Has any woman ever said "Put your hand here, you can feel my fetus kick."?
 
Last edited:

So, it does not matter to you, that your God kills more unborn babies than abortionists do ?
Why did you not answer my question concerning the justification of your assertion, Skeptical Greg?

Please give me any acceptable basis for your assertion first, Skeptical Greg,
and then, if you like, we can pursue your question and I will answer, Skeptical Greg.
 
Last edited:
If a mother's baby dies in mysterious circumstances, an investigation is opened to see if there was criminal negligence. The mother (or father, or both really) might be convicted of manslaughter.

If fetuses are people, shouldn't we open investigations for many miscarriages? Perhaps the mother was negligent in her pregnancy and caused the miscarriage after all.

If you think that's a ridiculous suggestion but still think fetuses are people, please explain why. Thanks.
 
Why did you not answer my question concerning the justification of your assertion, Skeptical Greg?

Please give me any acceptable basis for your assertion first, Skeptical Greg,
and then, if you like, we can pursue your question and I will answer, Skeptical Greg.

I'm sure any source I provided, would be as acceptable to you as your " abortionno.org " link is acceptable to me...

The information is there, should you care to look for it..

Don't peek behind the curtain, whatever you do ...


Every day when I drive to work, there are protesters outside of a clinic where abortions are performed. Some of their signs read:

" Pray to end abortion .. "

Surely there are many, many people praying to end abortions..
Do you pray for the end of abortions?

How is that working for you ?
 
Loss Leader,
I noticed that you did not answer, so now again, I now challenge you.
Would you or would you not like to attach a contractual wager to your challenge to me?


I don't know what a "contractual wager" is. Gambling, as far as I know, is illegal.

You made a statement about your own behavior in a pathetic attempt to try to shore up the ridiculous position that there are adoptive families out there for all the mothers considering abortion. I accepted your offer ON YOUR TERMS. Rather than do anything whatsoever to attempt to turn that into reality, you instead tried to bet me about which one of us is more serious.

Here's an idea, either take a positive step to come get my baby, or shut up.

As has been pointed out, your pretend offer was a poor debating tactic to begin with. And your obvious display that you have no intention of fulfilling your own words shows that you can't even follow through on that.

Don't address me again without tickets in hand to come get my son.

And, honestly, I'm starting to doubt the wisdom of handing the baby over to a person who can't even be bothered to live up to his own promises. You'd tell him that you'd get him dinner. Then when he says he's hungry, you'll demand that he submit a CAT scan of his stomach to prove it, then offer to bet him whether you really will ever get him any food of any sort. When he doesn't answer you because he's passed out from hunger, you'll declare yourself the winner, throw his body in a ditch, and go back to making asinine statements on the internet.
 
I'm sure any source I provided, would be as acceptable to you as your " abortionno.org " link is acceptable to me...
Try me. Unless you have no source because your assertion was pulled straight out of your a**. You are surely wrong. I am not opposed to the truth.
Surely there are many, many people praying to end abortions..
Do you pray for the end of abortions?

How is that working for you ?
No, I never have, not once. Now what?

What is the reason for your antagonism to me?
 
Last edited:
I don't know what a "contractual wager" is. Gambling, as far as I know, is illegal.

You made a statement about your own behavior in a pathetic attempt to try to shore up the ridiculous position that there are adoptive families out there for all the mothers considering abortion. I accepted your offer ON YOUR TERMS. Rather than do anything whatsoever to attempt to turn that into reality, you instead tried to bet me about which one of us is more serious.

Here's an idea, either take a positive step to come get my baby, or shut up.

As has been pointed out, your pretend offer was a poor debating tactic to begin with. And your obvious display that you have no intention of fulfilling your own words shows that you can't even follow through on that.

Don't address me again without tickets in hand to come get my son.

And, honestly, I'm starting to doubt the wisdom of handing the baby over to a person who can't even be bothered to live up to his own promises. You'd tell him that you'd get him dinner. Then when he says he's hungry, you'll demand that he submit a CAT scan of his stomach to prove it, then offer to bet him whether you really will ever get him any food of any sort. When he doesn't answer you because he's passed out from hunger, you'll declare yourself the winner, throw his body in a ditch, and go back to making asinine statements on the internet.

I'll address you, defeat you, and dismiss you every time you affront me first counselor.

Otherwise, in case you haven't noticed counselor, I don't care about you because there is no wisdom in your counsel that I have yet seen.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom