It's for me to call a dishonest argument dishonest. I'm not sure why anyone should object to me pointing out how to counter an argument honestly.
But I concede the point: I should not demand honesty from others.
(Edit: in the interests of honesty, that last line was sarcasm)
*Gasp!*

How
could you?
You can point out all you like. It doesn't make your opinion the standard, however, and the whole point is that I do not believe the argument was dishonest.
It was transparently dishonest, and it was intentionally dishonest. I do not know or care if it was "intentionally transparent". But given how much effort has been spent on trying to defend the argument as if it were honest, I can only conclude that people wanted it to be treated as if it were honest.
Given that you've been vehemently arguing
for honesty, your decision to misrepresent the intentions of others is somewhat puzzling. But I suppose I'll let it slide, if you truly can do nothing else.
Whether or not anyone was deceived becomes somewhat beside the point: we should not participate in a charade.
It is my opinion that human communication is a touch more complex than what you seem to suggest. In my opinion, making a sarcastic remark, or using several related rhetoric tools, is dishonest, if the goal is not deception. In this case, the true goal of LL's suggestion was clearly visible, and I've no reason to think he intended differently. Thus, even though the words spoken were not exactly true, there was no actual deception going on. That is why I don't think your accusations of dishonesty are warranted.
No, it wasn't. Was that intentional or unintentional dishonesty on your part? I don't know, I don't care, but it's dishonest. He responded that he would make sure that they were taken care of, he did not promise to raise them himself.
Perhaps I could have worded myself better. My intention was not to suggest that 154 had promised to take care of the children for the rest of their lives, but merely that he promised to take care of arranging them proper foster parents.
That may be. But it's also irrelevant to this meta-debate.
That wasn't a "reductio ad absurdum". And it's strange that you would try to suggest it was, given that much of the defense of the tactic centered around the idea that the requested action was supposedly more reasonable than the offer 154 made. Do you not see a problem when you're offering mutually contradictory defenses?
I simply have a bad habit of assuming that people can easily follow my lines of thought, which often leads to confusion.
The original claim was essentially that 154 would invest a significant amount of his personal resources to further the well-being of unwanted children. The response was essentially a suggestion he invest a small amount right now. Admittedly, RAA may not be the best description, after all, but in my opinion, it is rather close. Anyway, since what's being reduced here is not the investment, but the time allowed to make it, I do not believe there is a contradiction.
In any case, I admit that part of my post was a little difficult to follow. But I assure you my motives were free of dishonesty.
This isn't a matter of courtesy. Sometimes, discourtesy is justified. This is a matter of honesty, and the response was intellectually dishonest. And I see no justification for dishonesty in debate.
This is what we call begging the question, I believe. I disagree with you about the response being dishonest, so you can't simply slip it in as a premise. If you wish to concentrate on one point, then courteousness is beside it, but so is justification.
I'm very well aware of the distinction. That, in fact, was my entire point of jumping in: not to prove 154 is right about abortion, but to address a rhetorical tactic which is cheap and dishonest. And I wanted to do so because I tire of seeing it wherever it pops up, and it pops up in lots of other debates.
I understand your general argument; in many situations, the argument you describe truly is a dishonest tactic. But in my opinion, here it was fair play.