"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Only if you're actually considering taking him up on the offer.

The "show of commitment" demanded of him was different than the offer he made, so there isn't any logical requirement that he satisfy the former in order to prove the latter. But more fundamentally, you're trying to impose on him a burden that's simply unreasonable for an internet discussion forum. When someone says what they believe (and that's ultimately what 154 did), we're not in any position to demand that they prove it by performing some action for us. You can either believe him or not, but you can't reasonably demand that he do anything. And it's particularly foolish since believing him wouldn't even undermine your own position, would it?

I viewed the exchange differently. 154 himself made a show of shouldering a burden - undoubtedly an unreasonable one - and used it to condemn every poster on the forum who accepts abortions. He was offered a much, much more reasonable burden instead. The way I see it, the purpose was never to truly get 154 to give anything to charity, but to get him to admit he would not really take care of any unwanted babies. I do not believe this is dishonest.

Admittedly, I haven't read the thread carefully, and if 154's 'offer' was a response to a post the argued all anti-abortion people should adopt babies, then that original post was equally foolish. But that doesn't change the fact that 154 made an insupportable claim and used it to condemn his opponents. And I stand by my position that the charity-suggestion was a reasonable counter.
 
it is a common attitude among pro-choice folks that all pro-life folks need to be actively adopting babies (ignoring the fact that there are currently far more parents wanting healthy newborns than there are healthy newborns being put up for adoptions).


I like the fact that the negation of the entire argument is included by you in the argument itself. Does it occur to you that babies brought to term by mothers who would have opted for a safe and legal abortion are likely not to be healthy?

In any case, I was not demanding that "all pro-life folks need to be actively adopting babies," I was responding to one particular pro-life folk who personally and positively took on the responsibility of seeing through the adoption of any unwanted baby. 154 made a personal pledge regarding his own behavior. I asked him for something far, far, far less than he went out of his way to claim he was willing to do. And, as suspected, he revealed that his position had been nothing but rhetoric.
 
I viewed the exchange differently. 154 himself made a show of shouldering a burden - undoubtedly an unreasonable one - and used it to condemn every poster on the forum who accepts abortions. He was offered a much, much more reasonable burden instead.

It isn't for you to decide what he might find reasonable. And if you think he used his offer as an unjustified attack, then that should have been the response. But it wasn't.

The way I see it, the purpose was never to truly get 154 to give anything to charity

Of course it wasn't. Everyone and their mother knew that. Because the response to 154 was dishonest, and transparently so.

but to get him to admit he would not really take care of any unwanted babies.

But you don't know that he wouldn't (hell you don't know that he doesn't already do what you demanded of him). Oh, you could try to claim that if he was flooded with hundreds of babies they he would be unable to, but that's so unrealistic as to be irrelevant. There's no way he would ever get more than a few from this board, if that, and it's entirely possible he COULD do exactly what he said he would for any vaguely realistic numbers.

And more importantly, it shouldn't matter to your position whether or not he would. Does it matter? If not, then you're better off avoiding ad hominems (and claiming that he's not being honest about himself is an ad hominem). And if it does matter, well, your position was probably weak to begin with.
 
Yes it does. Evolution weeds out the genes of the members of a species who don't feel inclined or are unable to reproduce and rewards those who are fecund with a better chance at playing for one or more rounds of the game (up to a point). Have fewer than two children (or four nephews/nieces, etc.) and the fraction of the gene pool represented by your genes in the next generation gets smaller.

That is not a perspective, Ivor. Stuff happens

I am not sure where to start with the rest, but I will have a go.

As for the differences in strategy that are generally most successful for men and women to use to get their genes the best share of the gene pool in the next round, the (observed time and time again) differential in male and female sex drive should be a clue as to why my previous post is correct.

You make a lot of assumptions here and it is difficult to tease them out. First you assume there is a difference in strategy and I do not think you have even shown there is "strategy" at all. So you might like to answer whether you think folk go through the kind of thought process I outlined above: and if you do you could perhaps supply some evidence for that.

Or it may be you are using the word "strategy" in a peculiar way: just as you used "perspective". I fully concede you may not have meant that evolution has a perspective: but rather that this is the kind of narrative you find helpful in interpreting what you see: but that merely reinforces my point: it is a story, or a model, if you prefer. Narratives and models necessarily leave things out and if we leave out what is irrelevant or non-essential they can certainly help us to understand what is going on. But by the same token if we leave out that which is crucial or relevant then we come to wrong conclusions.

Personally I find the idea of an evolutionary "perspective" foolishly reductionist: and I find the idea of a "strategy" just plain out of line with my experience.

You go on to assert that these different "strategies" for men and women are "successful" and this carries the implication that similar strategies would be less successful. If we assume there are such things as strategies how would you go about demonstrating that? If these "strategies" are indeed built in then we would presumably have nothing to compare them with since everyone would behave in the same way. That being the case then we must define what we mean by "successful". If you take the evolutionary position then "successful" = "survival", I think. That means that every living thing which exists is successful, by definition. So it would appear that one of the most "successful" strategies is to have one fertile female; and a whole lot of folk who are asexual and just work; and a few males. That works really well. Another successful "strategy" is monogamy: lots of animals do really well with that one too. There are species where the best idea is for a male to fertilise eggs already laid and then bugger off, as the female has already done. There are others where the male has a harem of females exclusively for his use. I am sure you can think of others: and of the four I happen to have mentioned three can be seen in human societies. So the idea that human beings have A strategy does not seem to be demonstrable unless we just ignore the instances of monogamy; slave owning societies; polygamy and polyandry. But I think those are relevant and so should not be excluded from your model.

you assert that there is a difference in male and female sex drive. You claim this has been observed time and time again. I do not think you can substantiate that. What I think you really mean is that if it were so it would fit your story, and so you seem to have worked backwards. However this is also mere narrative, influenced by a great many very relevant things. As an example: in those cultures which practice FGM one of the main reasons give is that if they are not mutilated women are sexually insatiable and therefore no man can rely on being able to reproduce. We see the same thing in the phrase "it is a wise man who knows his father", and that comes from our own culture. We have also seen some of the men here lament the figures they claim for infidelity when it comes to child support: so again I think your "seen time and time again" needs a little bit of evidence. Not sure how you are going to get it though: culture cannot be factored out, in any way that is obvious to me. But I am interested in what you can show.


Men are wired to want to have a lot of sex with many different women


So you assert: repeating it does not make it true. I cannot prove that all the monogamous men I have met are honest: perhaps every single one of them is a liar: but I do not believe that. So you need to put up some kind of evidence that there are no monogamous men: or that they are at least vanishingly rare.

and women are wired to be far more picky about who they reproduce with.

Sex and reproduction are not the same thing. We have discussed this on this board before and I have seen absolutely nothing to show that the will to sex is the same thing as the will to children: not in men and not in women. So again I await your evidence for this conflation


Women have to invest a minimum of 9 months and risk a significant chance of death giving birth to a child. Men on the other hand need only invest a few minutes of their time and face virtually no chance of death from reproducing. It is probably the sexual selection by women for men who are more likely to stay around awhile that keeps this male drive in check.

Let us assume for a moment that you are right. Since women are picky about who they have sex with on grounds of reproductive investment they are surely going to be picky about who they have sex with on grounds of reproductive investment; which means they will not choose jack the lad and jack the lad will die out. Strangely, it doesn't work out like that. So now you will cite those studies which purport to show that women prefer jack the lad for sex but kid mr monogamy on that the weans are his the better to have their cake and eat it. Which is mere smear unless you can show some studies which demonstrate that actual behaviour in a majority of women. I don't think you can, but I will be interested to see them if you do
 
Last edited:
Just as a reminder, it wasn't me that took part in the original exchange. That's not to say I'm taking back anything; I simply don't like having other people's words attributed to myself.

It isn't for you to decide what he might find reasonable. And if you think he used his offer as an unjustified attack, then that should have been the response. But it wasn't.

So, you are saying it is for you to decide what another person's response to a particular argument should be?


Of course it wasn't. Everyone and their mother knew that. Because the response to 154 was dishonest, and transparently so.

In my opinion, intentionally transparent dishonesty isn't truly dishonesty at all. If everyone knew the intention, who was deceived?

But you don't know that he wouldn't (hell you don't know that he doesn't already do what you demanded of him). Oh, you could try to claim that if he was flooded with hundreds of babies they he would be unable to, but that's so unrealistic as to be irrelevant. There's no way he would ever get more than a few from this board, if that, and it's entirely possible he COULD do exactly what he said he would for any vaguely realistic numbers.

And it's entirely possible he truly does communicate with the Biblical God and does know that abortion is objectively wrong. But if he cannot or will not provide evidence for either claim, neither should be accepted as a valid argument in a debate.

And that is what this is about. The original argument, perhaps rudely presented, but valid, was that it is no mercy to let a child be born into a life of misery. 154 responded to this by stating he would personally take care of such children. This (rather ridiculous) claim was contested by what you call blatant dishonesty and I call adequate rhetoric.

And more importantly, it shouldn't matter to your position whether or not he would. Does it matter? If not, then you're better off avoiding ad hominems (and claiming that he's not being honest about himself is an ad hominem). And if it does matter, well, your position was probably weak to begin with.

My position isn't really the issue here, though. I haven't taken part in the actual debate, but merely this meta-debate about the kinds of arguments used.

And my position remains. 154 made a poor argument. LL responded with what was essentially a reductio ad absurdum, and my opinion is that this was both effective and acceptably courteous in the context. I've no doubt we'll have to disagree on this. But I do hope you understand that my positions on acceptable debate and abortion legalization are separate, and only one is being discussed here.

If you for some reason or another want to discuss abortions, I would be more than happy to present my view on the subject. But it won't be a continuation of this disagreement.
 
Nope; it's still a dishonest form of argument. In fact, it's essentially an ad hominem argument -- as Ziggurat noted, it's always possible to accuse people on any side of a practical issue of needing to expend more of their own resources to support their position.

You should, then, adddress your concerns to 154, rather than just the people who happen to be arguing against you.
 
You go on to assert that these different "strategies" for men and women are "successful" and this carries the implication that similar strategies would be less successful. If we assume there are such things as strategies how would you go about demonstrating that?


I read recently that the number of men unknowingly raising other men's children was evidence of the female mating strategy, originaly proposed by Sara Hrdy, "Female Plan B."

The female prefers to have children with the strongest and handsomest males. She also desires a male who is loyal and dedicated to supporting the family. As it turns out, our best-looking males tend to like to make the rounds and aren't the settling-down type. This leads females to cheat on their mates and to hide the true parentage of their children.

This behavior is observed in humans, our primate relatives, certain birds and many other animals.

One of many sources.
 
I read recently that the number of men unknowingly raising other men's children was evidence of the female mating strategy, originaly proposed by Sara Hrdy, "Female Plan B."

The female prefers to have children with the strongest and handsomest males. She also desires a male who is loyal and dedicated to supporting the family. As it turns out, our best-looking males tend to like to make the rounds and aren't the settling-down type. This leads females to cheat on their mates and to hide the true parentage of their children.

This behavior is observed in humans, our primate relatives, certain birds and many other animals.

One of many sources.

That source says that 26% - 70% of women cheat. It gives no information about the number of children born to those women or who the parent of the child might be. It then goes on to say that most women are happy with the man they are with.

So basically this is a study that shows that some nearly unidentifiable number of women can cheat. It then offers a single reason for this cheating (acquiring genes) and ignores all other social and personal factors.
 
I like the fact that the negation of the entire argument is included by you in the argument itself. Does it occur to you that babies brought to term by mothers who would have opted for a safe and legal abortion are likely not to be healthy?

I'm going to choose to read this as an affirmative assertion: "Babies brought to term by mothers who would have opted for a safe and legal abortion are likely not to be healthy."
Can you back this assertion up with facts? For instance, the percentage of abortions which are made for reasons involving the health of the fetus?
If you actually do look at the numbers, I think you'll be rather surprised.
 
That source says that 26% - 70% of women cheat. It gives no information about the number of children born to those women or who the parent of the child might be. It then goes on to say that most women are happy with the man they are with.

So basically this is a study that shows that some nearly unidentifiable number of women can cheat. It then offers a single reason for this cheating (acquiring genes) and ignores all other social and personal factors.

Precisely.

ETA: did you read to the end of my post, LL? Those studies are mentioned and they do not tell us what you think they tell us, IMO
 
Last edited:
So basically this is a study that shows that some nearly unidentifiable number of women can cheat. It then offers a single reason for this cheating (acquiring genes) and ignores all other social and personal factors.


Well, the fact that the phenomena is observed across species would help rule out social and personal factors. In any case, it is a theory that I had heard had some wide acceptance among biological anthropologists, and one that I had heard was being confirmed through new observations. But it's not my personal opinion and is not based on any direct knowledge.


Can you back this assertion up with facts?


My knowledge on the subject is almost entirely derived from the excelent examination of abortion in the book Freakonomics.
 
So, you are saying it is for you to decide what another person's response to a particular argument should be?

It's for me to call a dishonest argument dishonest. I'm not sure why anyone should object to me pointing out how to counter an argument honestly.

But I concede the point: I should not demand honesty from others.
(Edit: in the interests of honesty, that last line was sarcasm)

In my opinion, intentionally transparent dishonesty isn't truly dishonesty at all. If everyone knew the intention, who was deceived?

It was transparently dishonest, and it was intentionally dishonest. I do not know or care if it was "intentionally transparent". But given how much effort has been spent on trying to defend the argument as if it were honest, I can only conclude that people wanted it to be treated as if it were honest. Whether or not anyone was deceived becomes somewhat beside the point: we should not participate in a charade.

The original argument, perhaps rudely presented, but valid, was that it is no mercy to let a child be born into a life of misery. 154 responded to this by stating he would personally take care of such children.

No, it wasn't. Was that intentional or unintentional dishonesty on your part? I don't know, I don't care, but it's dishonest. He responded that he would make sure that they were taken care of, he did not promise to raise them himself.

And my position remains. 154 made a poor argument.

That may be. But it's also irrelevant to this meta-debate.

LL responded with what was essentially a reductio ad absurdum

That wasn't a "reductio ad absurdum". And it's strange that you would try to suggest it was, given that much of the defense of the tactic centered around the idea that the requested action was supposedly more reasonable than the offer 154 made. Do you not see a problem when you're offering mutually contradictory defenses?

and my opinion is that this was both effective and acceptably courteous in the context.

This isn't a matter of courtesy. Sometimes, discourtesy is justified. This is a matter of honesty, and the response was intellectually dishonest. And I see no justification for dishonesty in debate.

I've no doubt we'll have to disagree on this. But I do hope you understand that my positions on acceptable debate and abortion legalization are separate, and only one is being discussed here.

I'm very well aware of the distinction. That, in fact, was my entire point of jumping in: not to prove 154 is right about abortion, but to address a rhetorical tactic which is cheap and dishonest. And I wanted to do so because I tire of seeing it wherever it pops up, and it pops up in lots of other debates.
 
The point stands. Those who assume that abortion has prevented a plague of orphans in the U.S. haven't looked at the numbers very closely.

Possibly. But, those who think that making abortion illegal will stop all abortions, or even most, have even less evidence.
 
Well, the fact that the phenomena is observed across species would help rule out social and personal factors. In any case, it is a theory that I had heard had some wide acceptance among biological anthropologists, and one that I had heard was being confirmed through new observations. But it's not my personal opinion and is not based on any direct knowledge.


What phenomenon? This is what I mean about stories......
 
Possibly. But, those who think that making abortion illegal will stop all abortions, or even most, have even less evidence.

I think "even less" is stretching it; at least here, I've seen none presented for either position.
 
It's for me to call a dishonest argument dishonest. I'm not sure why anyone should object to me pointing out how to counter an argument honestly.

But I concede the point: I should not demand honesty from others.
(Edit: in the interests of honesty, that last line was sarcasm)

*Gasp!* :eek: How could you?

You can point out all you like. It doesn't make your opinion the standard, however, and the whole point is that I do not believe the argument was dishonest.

It was transparently dishonest, and it was intentionally dishonest. I do not know or care if it was "intentionally transparent". But given how much effort has been spent on trying to defend the argument as if it were honest, I can only conclude that people wanted it to be treated as if it were honest.

Given that you've been vehemently arguing for honesty, your decision to misrepresent the intentions of others is somewhat puzzling. But I suppose I'll let it slide, if you truly can do nothing else.

Whether or not anyone was deceived becomes somewhat beside the point: we should not participate in a charade.

It is my opinion that human communication is a touch more complex than what you seem to suggest. In my opinion, making a sarcastic remark, or using several related rhetoric tools, is dishonest, if the goal is not deception. In this case, the true goal of LL's suggestion was clearly visible, and I've no reason to think he intended differently. Thus, even though the words spoken were not exactly true, there was no actual deception going on. That is why I don't think your accusations of dishonesty are warranted.

No, it wasn't. Was that intentional or unintentional dishonesty on your part? I don't know, I don't care, but it's dishonest. He responded that he would make sure that they were taken care of, he did not promise to raise them himself.

Perhaps I could have worded myself better. My intention was not to suggest that 154 had promised to take care of the children for the rest of their lives, but merely that he promised to take care of arranging them proper foster parents.


That may be. But it's also irrelevant to this meta-debate.

That wasn't a "reductio ad absurdum". And it's strange that you would try to suggest it was, given that much of the defense of the tactic centered around the idea that the requested action was supposedly more reasonable than the offer 154 made. Do you not see a problem when you're offering mutually contradictory defenses?

I simply have a bad habit of assuming that people can easily follow my lines of thought, which often leads to confusion.

The original claim was essentially that 154 would invest a significant amount of his personal resources to further the well-being of unwanted children. The response was essentially a suggestion he invest a small amount right now. Admittedly, RAA may not be the best description, after all, but in my opinion, it is rather close. Anyway, since what's being reduced here is not the investment, but the time allowed to make it, I do not believe there is a contradiction.

In any case, I admit that part of my post was a little difficult to follow. But I assure you my motives were free of dishonesty.

This isn't a matter of courtesy. Sometimes, discourtesy is justified. This is a matter of honesty, and the response was intellectually dishonest. And I see no justification for dishonesty in debate.

This is what we call begging the question, I believe. I disagree with you about the response being dishonest, so you can't simply slip it in as a premise. If you wish to concentrate on one point, then courteousness is beside it, but so is justification.

I'm very well aware of the distinction. That, in fact, was my entire point of jumping in: not to prove 154 is right about abortion, but to address a rhetorical tactic which is cheap and dishonest. And I wanted to do so because I tire of seeing it wherever it pops up, and it pops up in lots of other debates.

I understand your general argument; in many situations, the argument you describe truly is a dishonest tactic. But in my opinion, here it was fair play.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom