"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Evolution doesn't have a perspective.

<snip>

Yes it does. Evolution weeds out the genes of the members of a species who don't feel inclined or are unable to reproduce and rewards those who are fecund with a better chance at playing for one or more rounds of the game (up to a point). Have fewer than two children (or four nephews/nieces, etc.) and the fraction of the gene pool represented by your genes in the next generation gets smaller.

As for the differences in strategy that are generally most successful for men and women to use to get their genes the best share of the gene pool in the next round, the (observed time and time again) differential in male and female sex drive should be a clue as to why my previous post is correct. Men are wired to want to have a lot of sex with many different women and women are wired to be far more picky about who they reproduce with. Women have to invest a minimum of 9 months and risk a significant chance of death giving birth to a child. Men on the other hand need only invest a few minutes of their time and face virtually no chance of death from reproducing. It is probably the sexual selection by women for men who are more likely to stay around awhile that keeps this male drive in check.
 
Last edited:
Apparently you're not following the discussion. We're talking about the justification for other legal schemes -- specifically, the OP conversation is about the justification for a legal scheme where abortion is illegel "except for cases of rape or incest".
In response to your question, "why do *you* want to force a woman to carry a baby", I asked you an equivalent question, "why do *you* want to force an adult to be a parent"?
The answer to the two questions is the same -- this isn't about forcing anyone to do anything; it's about disallowing someone from harming someone else. The main difference in opinion on the issue is mainly attributed to whether we should protect the "someone else" from the "someone".
The OP question of "why does it matter how the someone else got there relative to the behavior of the someone?" is far more perceptive and interesting than most of the knee-jerk "I'm going to completely ignore the existence of the someone else" posts that have followed.
It's really not that hard.


I think the reason a lot of pro choice people don't believe that pro life people actually care about the life of the fetus rather than just wanting to control the mother is that so many of the most vocal pro lifers are also rabid conservatives who are dead set against universal health care even for children, or any kind of social program that helps children. Some pro life politicians have even come out to vocally be against free or reduced school breakfasts and lunches for impoverished students. They'll make the argument in one breath, "Why should the fetus have to suffer for the mother's actions?" and in the next breath say that a child should have to live with the consquences of being born to impoverished parents. This does not go very far in convincing people that they actually give a rat's patootie about the well being of that child, they just use the "I care about the baby, I don't want it to die!" argument to try and seem morally superior.

That's one thing I did like about being a Catholic pro lifer, at least with my Church and the organizations I was involved with (I fully realize this does not apply to all Catholic pro life groups/churches), they absolutely cared about that child after it was born. They lobied for universal healthcare and other programs which helped children in impoverished families in various ways. They helped support orphanages, encouraged their members to be foster parents and adopt. These were people who weren't interested in standing outside of clinics with pictures of aborted fetuses, or in condemning doctors or politicians or anyone else. These were people who honestly cared about the well being of children and whose efforts were focused on trying to make abortion less necessary rather than simply railing against it with big angry signs. Of course, the big freaking glaring error was that they were also against birth control and sex education, the two best ways to prevent abortion. But that was really more the older generations. Despite the organizations' official positions, most of the young Catholics I knew involved with them were all about the sex ed and birth control as a way to prevent abortion. And I also know other conservatives, not necessarily Catholic ones, who might be against most social programs in general, but don't apply this when it comes to children.


But when you get a pro lifer who does not want to spend one red cent on health care or social programs for impoverished child because "it's not my responsibility"...well, it's certainly their right to think that. But I will never, ever believe them when they then act like they're against abortion because they care about the life of the baby. I will consider their position faux moral outrage for political gain and nothing more.
 
Last edited:
Yes it does. Evolution weeds out the genes of the members of a species who don't feel inclined or are unable to reproduce and rewards those who are fecund with a better chance at playing for one or more rounds of the game (up to a point). Have fewer than two children (or four nephews/nieces, etc.) and the fraction of the gene pool represented by your genes in the next generation gets smaller.

As for the differences in strategy that are generally most successful for men and women to use to get their genes the best share of the gene pool in the next round, the (observed time and time again) differential in male and female sex drive should be a clue as to why my previous post is correct. Men are wired to want to have a lot of sex with many different women and women are wired to be far more picky about who they reproduce with. Women have to invest a minimum of 9 months and risk a significant chance of death giving birth to a child. Men on the other hand need only invest a few minutes of their time and face virtually no chance of death from reproducing. It is probably the sexual selection by women for men who are more likely to stay around awhile that keeps this male drive in check.

Do you see the contradiction in what you have said?
 
Legality isn't the same as morality. Legality is about harm to others and compliance with order -- it's about what's good for society. Morality is about something different. Because harming others is often immoral, there's a connection between the two, but the two are not the same.
I am proud to live in a society where the laws and my own moral code are not exactly coincident. Morality is better maintained in the context of freedom to go against it.

I think we disagree a lot about the topic at hand, and probably other topics as well, but the part quoted above is where this debate should head. The question is not whether abortion is good, but whether it should be legal or illegal.

Abortions are not good. I've never met a woman who was happy to have an abortion. I would never want my family members to have to go through the trauma of having an abortion. But, I think that society is better off where abortions are legal and accessible.

Society is best where the number of legal abortions is reduced through the use of effective contraception and sex ed. Anyone who is vehemently opposed to abortion should focus their attention on reducing unwanted pregnancies. I think everyone but the pope would be happy if abortion clinics were put out of business by contraceptives.
 
Well, law and morality are certainly not one and the same. We know this because we all know immoral laws that once existed (slavery, segregation) and that still exist (DOMA, DADT).
You believe the "Defense of Marriage Act" is "immoral"?!
 
You believe the "Defense of Marriage Act" is "immoral"?!


The answer is, to the extent that I believe that morality exists, yes.

But the real question is how you managed to find time to post in this thread? You should be out working to scrape together that fifty bucks to actually help orphans find loving homes. It's not what you promised, but it's so, so much less that it just shouldn't be a problem for you.
 
But the real question is how you managed to find time to post in this thread? You should be out working to scrape together that fifty bucks to actually help orphans find loving homes.

This is a dishonest form of argument. It's the equivalent of demanding that abortion advocates fund abortions for poor women, or that Iraq war proponents join the military, or war protesters become human shields, or anybody who wants a fire department become a volunteer fire fighter. The logic is garbage. It is, ultimately, nothing more than an appeal to emotion.
 
Save it already, LL. As if your snarky suggestion is my command, regardless of how many times you repeat what you think is so brilliant.
 
You believe the "Defense of Marriage Act" is "immoral"?!

Does this actually surprise you? This is JREF. Religious based bigotry is typically very looked down upon here.

This. You specifically said "mothering is a woman's greatest instinct" (not true) and then followed up with the lamentation "What happened to us?" So OBVIOUSLY you are implying that you think it is a bad thing when women do not have a maternal instinct. Also, saying that mothering is a woman's greatest instict would mean that ALL women should not only want to be mothers, but want to be mothers more than they want to do anything else in the world, more even than they want to breathe. We should just be baby machines that think baby baby baby all day long, after all, if that's our GREATEST instinct, which would mean it surpasses our instincts even when it comes to our basic bodily needs like eating, sleeping, breathing, etc.

I don't argue that it isn't AN instinct, but certainly far from our greatest, and not a compelling instinct in the way our survival instincts are (jerking your hand away when you touch something hot, throwing your hands up or ducking when something is thrown at you, etc). And again...even if it is an instinct, so what? Humans aren't slaves to instinct, we're complex creatures who have emotions and reason and what not that means our instincts are not the end all be all determining factor of our behavior, nor should they be, or else all men would just be uncontrollable sex fiends.





What does that fifty million number have to do with my post? I said specifically my post was not meant to be debating abortion, because when it comes to abortion, I just don't have a strong opinion on it one way or the other.

I was addressing your specific point that motherhood is a woman's greatest instinct and your lamenting "what happened to us?" as if abortion is some new invention that goes against traditional human societies.


Will you conceed that motherhood is not a woman's greatest instinct, and that your question of "what happened to us?" doesn't make any sense because humans have been have been killing their children for as long as humans have existed, and have been having abortions for as long as they have known how to do so? And that these practices have been both widespread and socially acceptable in various societies. Historically, abortion has been more socially acceptable than it is today in much more conservative and religious time periods, which again means that your "what happened to us?" makes no sense.

But hey, if you can't actually counter my argument, and you aren't mature enough to admit you were wrong, just scream FIFTY MILLION again and pretend like in your mind that's a valid response to someone who isn't even arguing whether or not abortion is immoral.

And here's the thing about the fifty million argument...it means nothing if the person you're arguing against doesn't consider abortion murder. I'm a vegetarian, for instance. If I am trying to argue the merits of vegetarianism, I'm not going to use emotional pleading about the number of animals killed. Here let's try your debating tactic on yourself. Do you know how many animals are slaughtered in the United States every year?

9,000,0000,000

9 Billion

9 BILLION

There, did that work? Are you a vegetarian now (assuming you weren't before I made this argument)? I'm assuming you're not (though if you have, indeed, now decided to become a vegetarian simply because I said 9 BILLION please correct me), because you don't consider killing animals for meat to be immoral, so me throwing out numbers of how many animals are killed has no effect on you. In the same way, someone who does not think abortion is immoral is not going to be swayed by you throwing out a number of how many abortions there have been. This is a debating tactic that simply isn't going to convince anyone who doesn't already agree with you.

No response to this, 154?
 
Last edited:
Ziggarut, Loss Leader was referring to this from 154:
Note this. Mark my word. If you or anyone here has a baby that they will kill otherwise, you can deliver that baby to me and I will personally see to it that it find its way to a loving home. And now you say what?
So you are mistaken in saying it is a dishonest form of argument.
 
Last edited:
Nope; it's still a dishonest form of argument. In fact, it's essentially an ad hominem argument -- as Ziggurat noted, it's always possible to accuse people on any side of a practical issue of needing to expend more of their own resources to support their position.
 
I think it's quite appropriate. 154 has offered to take care of any unwanted babies anyone on the forums may have. It seems reasonable that before we start sending little parcels to his doorstep, he should provide some proof of his commitment.

The whole point is off-topic, no doubt, but it was 154 who did the derailing.
 
Ziggarut, Loss Leader was referring to this from 154:

So you are mistaken in saying it is a dishonest form of argument.

I know what he's referring to, but it's still a form of ad hominem. It's an attempt to demonstrate hypocrisy on the part of your opponent, and avoid addressing the actual substance of that position.

Let me give a pretty direct parallel:
A: If I saw someone trapped in a house fire, I would try to rescue them.
B: Then why aren't you a volunteer fireman?

It's cheap rhetoric, flawed logic, and bad faith debate.
 
The whole point is off-topic, no doubt, but it was 154 who did the derailing.

It was 154 who did the derailing by responding to another poster's question as to how many children 154 had adopted?
Sorry, but this issue started with the ad hominems. A process I have seen repeated in most every abortion thread on most every message board, as apparently it is a common attitude among pro-choice folks that all pro-life folks need to be actively adopting babies (ignoring the fact that there are currently far more parents wanting healthy newborns than there are healthy newborns being put up for adoptions).
 
It was 154 who did the derailing by responding to another poster's question as to how many children 154 had adopted?
Sorry, but this issue started with the ad hominems. A process I have seen repeated in most every abortion thread on most every message board, as apparently it is a common attitude among pro-choice folks that all pro-life folks need to be actively adopting babies (ignoring the fact that there are currently far more parents wanting healthy newborns than there are healthy newborns being put up for adoptions).

Which in turn were in response to 154 essentially calling all pro-abortion people murderers. Which, of course, was a response to some or other insult against his beliefs. It would be difficult to point out exactly where the debate turned from an examination of facts to a barrage of appeals to emotion and ad hominems - I'd guess it was some time before the first abortion was performed. Nowadays, any discussion of abortion legislation is simply a parade of logical fallacies on both sides - a tradition you continue with your generalizations and red herrings.

Nevertheless, my original point stands. 154 made the claim that he is willing to personally take care of the well-being of unwanted children. Asking for some show of commitment is a valid response, and 154 should either make a counter-proposal, or admit that his offer was a piece of empty rhetoric.
 
Nevertheless, my original point stands. 154 made the claim that he is willing to personally take care of the well-being of unwanted children. Asking for some show of commitment is a valid response

Only if you're actually considering taking him up on the offer.

The "show of commitment" demanded of him was different than the offer he made, so there isn't any logical requirement that he satisfy the former in order to prove the latter. But more fundamentally, you're trying to impose on him a burden that's simply unreasonable for an internet discussion forum. When someone says what they believe (and that's ultimately what 154 did), we're not in any position to demand that they prove it by performing some action for us. You can either believe him or not, but you can't reasonably demand that he do anything. And it's particularly foolish since believing him wouldn't even undermine your own position, would it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom