This. You specifically said "mothering is a woman's greatest instinct" (not true) and then followed up with the lamentation "What happened to us?" So OBVIOUSLY you are implying that you think it is a bad thing when women do not have a maternal instinct. Also, saying that mothering is a woman's greatest instict would mean that ALL women should not only want to be mothers, but want to be mothers more than they want to do anything else in the world, more even than they want to breathe. We should just be baby machines that think baby baby baby all day long, after all, if that's our GREATEST instinct, which would mean it surpasses our instincts even when it comes to our basic bodily needs like eating, sleeping, breathing, etc.
I don't argue that it isn't AN instinct, but certainly far from our greatest, and not a compelling instinct in the way our survival instincts are (jerking your hand away when you touch something hot, throwing your hands up or ducking when something is thrown at you, etc). And again...even if it is an instinct, so what? Humans aren't slaves to instinct, we're complex creatures who have emotions and reason and what not that means our instincts are not the end all be all determining factor of our behavior, nor should they be, or else all men would just be uncontrollable sex fiends.
What does that fifty million number have to do with my post? I said specifically my post was not meant to be debating abortion, because when it comes to abortion, I just don't have a strong opinion on it one way or the other.
I was addressing your specific point that motherhood is a woman's greatest instinct and your lamenting "what happened to us?" as if abortion is some new invention that goes against traditional human societies.
Will you conceed that motherhood is not a woman's greatest instinct, and that your question of "what happened to us?" doesn't make any sense because humans have been have been killing their children for as long as humans have existed, and have been having abortions for as long as they have known how to do so? And that these practices have been both widespread and socially acceptable in various societies. Historically, abortion has been more socially acceptable than it is today in much more conservative and religious time periods, which again means that your "what happened to us?" makes no sense.
But hey, if you can't actually counter my argument, and you aren't mature enough to admit you were wrong, just scream FIFTY MILLION again and pretend like in your mind that's a valid response to someone who isn't even arguing whether or not abortion is immoral.
And here's the thing about the fifty million argument...it means nothing if the person you're arguing against doesn't consider abortion murder. I'm a vegetarian, for instance. If I am trying to argue the merits of vegetarianism, I'm not going to use emotional pleading about the number of animals killed. Here let's try your debating tactic on yourself. Do you know how many animals are slaughtered in the United States every year?
9,000,0000,000
9 Billion
9 BILLION
There, did that work? Are you a vegetarian now (assuming you weren't before I made this argument)? I'm assuming you're not (though if you have, indeed, now decided to become a vegetarian simply because I said 9 BILLION please correct me), because you don't consider killing animals for meat to be immoral, so me throwing out numbers of how many animals are killed has no effect on you. In the same way, someone who does not think abortion is immoral is not going to be swayed by you throwing out a number of how many abortions there have been. This is a debating tactic that simply isn't going to convince anyone who doesn't already agree with you.