Loss Leader
I would save the receptionist., Moderator
Setting aside the issue of abortion, how can you ever separate one from the other?
Stealing (when it is not a life or death situation- but that's debatable, too) is immoral and something that is against the law.
It is against the law because it is immoral- and an immoral individual act/decision.
Well, let's think this through, because I don't really believe my opinions are altogether very radical.
Is there a single universal morality? If so, what is its source?
If there are moral principles applicable to every human in every society in every situation, then we really don't have to have much of a debate. Whatever those principles are should be law, full stop.
However, I don't think that moral absolutists have had much luck in defining a set of universal rules or in showing that their "universal" rules weren't born of a subjective source - the Bible, etc.
So, then, what relationship does morality have with anything? Your example of stealing is a good one. And let's lay aside stealing medicine for the sick or bread for the starving. Let's just talk about stealing a flat screen TV off the back of a truck.
You say that's immoral. Why? Why does the TV distributor have a greater right to the TV than I do? I think the answer is this: because capitalism only works if ownership is protected by the force of law. Why would I buy and resell flat screen TV's, after all, if not to get really rich so I could buy stuff? Why would I use my money to buy stuff if people are just going to break in and take it?
And we can see many, many societies where there is no such concept of personal property. Those societies are not capitalistic, and are usually subsistance-based tribes.
So, stealing isn't universally immoral. It's just a precondition of our economic system.
It's one and the same.
Well, law and morality are certainly not one and the same. We know this because we all know immoral laws that once existed (slavery, segregation) and that still exist (DOMA, DADT). Except maybe for slavery (for some period of time that has long, long since passed), none of these laws are necessary for the functioning of a capitalist society. Most of them are decidedly anti-capitalist.
This goes for murder, rape, statutory rape, child porn, slavery, sweatshop labor, assault, illegal parking and a million other things that the law prohibits because they are bad.
Does the law prohibit them because they are bad? Or does the law prohibit them out of a combination of economic necessity, inertia, sociological convenience, and government dominance?
Of course, we could do away with all of this if you were to simply lay out a self-consistent universal moral and show how it was arrived at.