"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Setting aside the issue of abortion, how can you ever separate one from the other? :confused:

Stealing (when it is not a life or death situation- but that's debatable, too) is immoral and something that is against the law.

It is against the law because it is immoral- and an immoral individual act/decision.


Well, let's think this through, because I don't really believe my opinions are altogether very radical.

Is there a single universal morality? If so, what is its source?

If there are moral principles applicable to every human in every society in every situation, then we really don't have to have much of a debate. Whatever those principles are should be law, full stop.

However, I don't think that moral absolutists have had much luck in defining a set of universal rules or in showing that their "universal" rules weren't born of a subjective source - the Bible, etc.

So, then, what relationship does morality have with anything? Your example of stealing is a good one. And let's lay aside stealing medicine for the sick or bread for the starving. Let's just talk about stealing a flat screen TV off the back of a truck.

You say that's immoral. Why? Why does the TV distributor have a greater right to the TV than I do? I think the answer is this: because capitalism only works if ownership is protected by the force of law. Why would I buy and resell flat screen TV's, after all, if not to get really rich so I could buy stuff? Why would I use my money to buy stuff if people are just going to break in and take it?

And we can see many, many societies where there is no such concept of personal property. Those societies are not capitalistic, and are usually subsistance-based tribes.

So, stealing isn't universally immoral. It's just a precondition of our economic system.


It's one and the same.


Well, law and morality are certainly not one and the same. We know this because we all know immoral laws that once existed (slavery, segregation) and that still exist (DOMA, DADT). Except maybe for slavery (for some period of time that has long, long since passed), none of these laws are necessary for the functioning of a capitalist society. Most of them are decidedly anti-capitalist.


This goes for murder, rape, statutory rape, child porn, slavery, sweatshop labor, assault, illegal parking and a million other things that the law prohibits because they are bad.


Does the law prohibit them because they are bad? Or does the law prohibit them out of a combination of economic necessity, inertia, sociological convenience, and government dominance?

Of course, we could do away with all of this if you were to simply lay out a self-consistent universal moral and show how it was arrived at.
 
It's irrelevant what I believe. Infanticide is illegal. Abortion is not.


Gay marriage is illegal in my state. Would it be pushing my morality on others to change that?

(The answer is yes. However, trying to get others to live the way you want them to is not a bad thing. It's what happens in every statehouse, county legislature, town meeting, school board workshop, and home every single day.)
 
The greatest instinct in a woman is mothering. What happened to us?

without getting into the debate as to abortion itself, just want to comment on that...

the greatest instincts of women are basic survival functions, breathing, eating etc.


I very well may change my mind, but as of right now, I don't want a baby. While I want to do foster care once I finish grad school, baby having and long term child rearing is the last thing I want. I have no desire to be a mother.

Last year I had a pregnancy scare. I turned out to not be pregnant, but thought I was (false positive). I personally would not have an abortion unless there was something catastrophically wrong with me or the baby, so that (for me) was not an option. Being married in a stable, loving relationship and financially solvent with excellent family support, I couldn't really justify giving a baby up for adoption. I cried and cried and cried. It was awful, it was one of the worst days of my life.

I know other women who also have no desire to have children, including older women who are middle age and still haven't changed their minds.

Am I not a real woman in your eyes? What about all the other women? I have a real problem with the fact that you think a woman who doesn't want to be a mother has something wrong with her. Yeah, humans have instincts. We also have civilization and reason and interests and emotions and social norms. That's why you don't just see every man raping every young fertile woman he can get his hands on after clubbing rival males over the head with their laptops.

And aside from that, a woman may have maternal instinct, but she also has a keen sense in self preservation. I was reading an anthropology book about problems with foreign aid distribution in Africa. They were talking about how in times of famine, aid groups tend to concentrate on helping the children first, not adults, but this actually isn't practical. When tribes themselves had to deal with famine on their own, the first people they stopped feeding were the youngest children. This is often true all over the world in cases of famine. As the famine gets worse, the younger you are, the quicker your food supply gets cut off. Or maybe you are given much less food or less nutritious food than the others. This is because children can't rebuild the community when the famine ends. The adults can. The younger you are, the less valuable, and the sooner you are in line to die. In some cases, young children have even been cannibalized.


As for the "What happens to us?" Humans have been having abortions for as long as they've had methods with which to perform them. Remember that even in the Puritan days, abortion was legal so long as it happened during the early stages, before the quickening. Infanticide has also been around for as long as humans have been alive. In ancient Rome, it was not uncommon for people to leave their babies to die in the street of exposure, not even bothering to kill them first, if there was the least thing wrong with the baby, or if they simply didn't want to be bothered, either because it was a girl, or because you felt like you had enough kids as it was, etc. The Spartans wanted strong, beautiful babies, and infanticide was common if you weren't the cream of the crop. Human sacrifices amongst the Maya, Inca, and other Latin American tribes were often children. Apparently those parents had a stronger drive to appease their Gods than not kill their children. The Torah praises Abraham for putting the whims of a deity above his son's own life.

So, my point is, continue with your opinion on abortion. But don't make it seem like humans historically are people whose parenting instinct trumps all and who value fetuses and babies above all else, and that progressives invented the idea of abortion and popularized it amongst the masses. In many, many societies throughout the ages, not only abortion but infanticide have been both perfectly legal and common place, along with child abandonment or selling your children into slavery.
 
Last edited:
50,000,000

Fifty million.

FIFTY MILLION.

Fifty million less kids growing up unloved, possibly abused. Fifty million less adults who, raised by an unprepared parent, may have had unwanted children of their own.

Personally, I'd love to see better sex education classes and parenting classes introduced into the public school curriculum. Of course, I'd like high schools to teach kids basic life skills like how to balance a checkbook and what a mortgage is about.

Why is it that those who rail against abortion are often the same people who object to effective sex education?
 
50 000 000 less Kids in Orphanages. Thanks to Abortion.

And, of course, a great many fewer thanks to contraception,non-coital sexual habits, abstinence, luck, menopause and infertility.
All in all, contraception etc are doing a pretty good job, but clearly not good enough.
One unwanted child is one too many.
 
You're doing that to me again.


50,000,000

Fifty million.

FIFTY MILLION.

No. She is not "doing that to you" if you mean attributing things you did not say or mean: not any more than I was doing it when I challenged you on the statement upthread: not any more than I was doing it when I challenged Phantom, either.

I did not elaborate your thought because I thought it was unnecessary: your meaning was plain to see and is plain again in the second part of your post.

The facts do not support your view and in those circumstances most people re-examine their conclusions.

As it stands you have smuggled in unstated premises in support of your position. Perhaps they are unstated because they are unexamined?

When you made the statement that the "greatest instinct in a woman is mothering" you did nothing to support that assertion. You are wrong. It is perfectly obvious that you are wrong, and SC has gone to some trouble to point out why.

But there is more to it than you being wrong:you are wrong in a particular way. You did not say that the "greatest instinct of people is parenting". And it was not an accident, I believe. We can all make mistakes in our use of language and I am not exempt: so if you did mean that the greatest instinct of us all is parentlng then I will be glad to be corrected (though you would still be wrong).

As it stands you implied that women are different from men in this respect. That manufacture of difference is a very familiar tactic: it serves to justify different treatment of the group identified as different: it is a familiar story where one group treats another very badly: so we see things like 'barbarians are intrinsically not interested in freedom so it is is ok to enslave them: not like us greeks': 'black people are intrinsically unfit to run their own affairs, so we must shoulder the white man's burden and rule them *sigh*'; and on and on. This is what you are doing, whether you mean it or not. Those differences do not exist for individuals, and they lead to profoundly immoral consequences. They are also used to justify political decisions which render them to some small extent self fulfilling: and that is very comfortable for those who wish to see themselves as decent, moral, people while abusing and oppressing groups they conveniently characterise as other. They tell themselves they believe in all sorts of good things in terms of human rights and equal opportunity for all: so long as "all" exclludes those they wish to deny those good things to.

Then you do a curious shuffle: because the next thing you do is to say "what has happened to us?" In that phrase you deny what you have just done: and that is why I am prepared to believe you are truly unconscious of the premises and implications of what you are saying: you may honestly believe in the difference you just made up: and that is a very scary thing indeed.

So you say there are 50 million abortions. And I ask again, so what? You have denied the obvious inference and I take you at your word. So what is the point of mentioning it? Is it just an interesting observation with no consequence for policy or law? If that is your view then fair enough. There are 50 million abortions and the birth rate is falling, even while that abortion figure is also falling, if your figures are correct. (and the birth rate has recently risen again in some places so we could debate that too: but it is a separate topic). It would appear that even if we achieved a situation( through education and available contraception, or whatever) that there will be fewer children born: we do not know if that trend will continue or will plateau or will reverse. But what do you propose to do about it if it continues? You can halt the trend by banning abortion for a while maybe? Then what? According to your posts here, then nothing. So fine: if we happen to fall below replacement rate: if we happen to choose not to breed at all you will accept that happily? If that is your position then I have no quarrel with you: we will continue to allow abortion on demand and to make contraception freely available and you will regret the outcome but you will not force women to your will. That is fine with me.

Is that your position? I have the impression that is what you are trying to convey when you clarify: but it is not a natural reading of your words, else why did you introduce the numbers in the first place? Just a lament? "what has happened to us" could be read that way if it stood alone: it did not. It was tied to a mention of instinct: and instinct does not change in 50 years. I am perfectly prepared to believe that you have not thought through what you are saying: or have not conveyed it clearly. I would be interested if you set your view out clearly including the unspoken parts.
 
Last edited:
IIRC, there is research to indicate that, given a choice, young girls generally prefer dolls over toy cars and young boys the opposite. How much of this preference is genetic and how much is influenced by culture is up for debate, but I doubt there are *no* biologically based differences in behaviour between males and females.

From an evolutionary perspective the purpose of life is to get as much of your DNA into the next generation as possible based on an estimate of your current and likely future resources. For men this can generally be best achieved by having sex with lots of women. For women this is generally best achieved by looking after the children they do have.
 
You're doing that to me again.

You did not say that the "greatest instinct of people is parenting". And it was not an accident, I believe. We can all make mistakes in our use of language and I am not exempt: so if you did mean that the greatest instinct of us all is parentlng then I will be glad to be corrected (though you would still be wrong).

As it stands you implied that women are different from men in this respect. That manufacture of difference is a very familiar tactic: it serves to justify different treatment of the group identified as different: it is a familiar story where one group treats another very badly: so we see things like 'barbarians are intrinsically not interested in freedom so it is is ok to enslave them: not like us greeks': 'black people are intrinsically unfit to run their own affairs, so we must shoulder the white man's burden and rule them *sigh*'; and on and on. This is what you are doing, whether you mean it or not. Those differences do not exist for individuals, and they lead to profoundly immoral consequences.

This. You specifically said "mothering is a woman's greatest instinct" (not true) and then followed up with the lamentation "What happened to us?" So OBVIOUSLY you are implying that you think it is a bad thing when women do not have a maternal instinct. Also, saying that mothering is a woman's greatest instict would mean that ALL women should not only want to be mothers, but want to be mothers more than they want to do anything else in the world, more even than they want to breathe. We should just be baby machines that think baby baby baby all day long, after all, if that's our GREATEST instinct, which would mean it surpasses our instincts even when it comes to our basic bodily needs like eating, sleeping, breathing, etc.

I don't argue that it isn't AN instinct, but certainly far from our greatest, and not a compelling instinct in the way our survival instincts are (jerking your hand away when you touch something hot, throwing your hands up or ducking when something is thrown at you, etc). And again...even if it is an instinct, so what? Humans aren't slaves to instinct, we're complex creatures who have emotions and reason and what not that means our instincts are not the end all be all determining factor of our behavior, nor should they be, or else all men would just be uncontrollable sex fiends.



50,000,000

Fifty million.

FIFTY MILLION.

What does that fifty million number have to do with my post? I said specifically my post was not meant to be debating abortion, because when it comes to abortion, I just don't have a strong opinion on it one way or the other.

I was addressing your specific point that motherhood is a woman's greatest instinct and your lamenting "what happened to us?" as if abortion is some new invention that goes against traditional human societies.


Will you conceed that motherhood is not a woman's greatest instinct, and that your question of "what happened to us?" doesn't make any sense because humans have been have been killing their children for as long as humans have existed, and have been having abortions for as long as they have known how to do so? And that these practices have been both widespread and socially acceptable in various societies. Historically, abortion has been more socially acceptable than it is today in much more conservative and religious time periods, which again means that your "what happened to us?" makes no sense.

But hey, if you can't actually counter my argument, and you aren't mature enough to admit you were wrong, just scream FIFTY MILLION again and pretend like in your mind that's a valid response to someone who isn't even arguing whether or not abortion is immoral.

And here's the thing about the fifty million argument...it means nothing if the person you're arguing against doesn't consider abortion murder. I'm a vegetarian, for instance. If I am trying to argue the merits of vegetarianism, I'm not going to use emotional pleading about the number of animals killed. Here let's try your debating tactic on yourself. Do you know how many animals are slaughtered in the United States every year?

9,000,0000,000

9 Billion

9 BILLION

There, did that work? Are you a vegetarian now (assuming you weren't before I made this argument)? I'm assuming you're not (though if you have, indeed, now decided to become a vegetarian simply because I said 9 BILLION please correct me), because you don't consider killing animals for meat to be immoral, so me throwing out numbers of how many animals are killed has no effect on you. In the same way, someone who does not think abortion is immoral is not going to be swayed by you throwing out a number of how many abortions there have been. This is a debating tactic that simply isn't going to convince anyone who doesn't already agree with you.
 
Last edited:
It's irrelevant what I believe. Infanticide is illegal. Abortion is not.

Apparently you're not following the discussion. We're talking about the justification for other legal schemes -- specifically, the OP conversation is about the justification for a legal scheme where abortion is illegel "except for cases of rape or incest".
In response to your question, "why do *you* want to force a woman to carry a baby", I asked you an equivalent question, "why do *you* want to force an adult to be a parent"?
The answer to the two questions is the same -- this isn't about forcing anyone to do anything; it's about disallowing someone from harming someone else. The main difference in opinion on the issue is mainly attributed to whether we should protect the "someone else" from the "someone".
The OP question of "why does it matter how the someone else got there relative to the behavior of the someone?" is far more perceptive and interesting than most of the knee-jerk "I'm going to completely ignore the existence of the someone else" posts that have followed.
It's really not that hard.
 
Setting aside the issue of abortion, how can you ever separate one from the other? :confused:

Stealing (when it is not a life or death situation- but that's debatable, too) is immoral and something that is against the law.

It is against the law because it is immoral- and an immoral individual act/decision.

It's one and the same.

This goes for murder, rape, statutory rape, child porn, slavery, sweatshop labor, assault, illegal parking and a million other things that the law prohibits because they are bad.

Lying, insulting others, and hating others are also immoral. They are, however, not illegal.
Speeding, parking illegally, and not paying taxes are not immoral*. They are, however, illegal.
Legality isn't the same as morality. Legality is about harm to others and compliance with order -- it's about what's good for society. Morality is about something different. Because harming others is often immoral, there's a connection between the two, but the two are not the same.
I am proud to live in a society where the laws and my own moral code are not exactly coincident. Morality is better maintained in the context of freedom to go against it.

*They are at least not inherently immoral actions, although they may become immoral once you understand your obligations.
 
IIRC, there is research to indicate that, given a choice, young girls generally prefer dolls over toy cars and young boys the opposite. How much of this preference is genetic and how much is influenced by culture is up for debate, but I doubt there are *no* biologically based differences in behaviour between males and females.

I'm pretty sure that's all cultural. As a little girl I always wanted to play with toy dragons and other monsters. I found dolls to be dull and pointless even though people who did not know me would give me dolls for birthdays and the like. However, given how wide spread the cultural conditioning is it is almost impossible to do any real study to research this.
 
I'd say 100% of the time this is NONE of MY BUSINESS because I'm a man .. I don't feel a man's input is of any value.
 
IIRC, there is research to indicate that, given a choice, young girls generally prefer dolls over toy cars and young boys the opposite. How much of this preference is genetic and how much is influenced by culture is up for debate, but I doubt there are *no* biologically based differences in behaviour between males and females.

From an evolutionary perspective the purpose of life is to get as much of your DNA into the next generation as possible based on an estimate of your current and likely future resources. For men this can generally be best achieved by having sex with lots of women. For women this is generally best achieved by looking after the children they do have.

Evolution doesn't have a perspective. If you think that is the purpose of life that is your opinion, and you are welcome to it. But in fact there are the things that happen and there are the interpretations we put on those: we make choices about what we consider to be relevant.

As it happens this use of "evolution" to justify moral/political/legal decisions is just as crazy as using the bible to do the same thing. The story you tell is partial at best: it has very little to do with evolution. Species may be monogomous; serially monogamous; promiscuous either way: and any other part of the spectrum of sexual behaviour you care to mention. We see other species' behaviour through the prism of our preconceptions (as I tried to show in discussing the programme about mountain gorillas in another thread): different people see different things. Within the human species (and within other species) there are huge variations. I know a lot of monogamous men: that is just the way they are. We have a word for it: uxorious. It is not a very fashionable word now because the current climate finds it handy to deny the existence of such men. I wonder what those men who have talked eloquently on this board about their commitment to wives/girlfriends and children make of this nonsense I keep seeing spouted. Perhaps you think they sit down and say to themselves "the best way of passing my dna in to the next generation is to take very good care of the children I have": and perhaps you think they just can't count and so are plain wrong when they reach that conclusion. I don't think they do that, though. I think those behaviour patterns are as much a part of our humanity as the ones you prefer to focus on. I also think that the culture can influence those choices: if people are given narratives such as the one you propose then those who are not strongly committed to one position or another may well accept them quite uncritically. Stories do influence behaviour and what is acceptable. So do economics and a whole lot of other things.

But in the end it does not matter one whit. If 99% of men and women behave as you describe (and they certainly don't) that has NO implications at all for the other 1%. You cannot make an "ought" out of an "is", as David Hume famously said. And you cannot make moral/legal/ economic type decisions which affect individuals on the basis of what a majority might choose. That is not the way it works
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom