"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Because they do it with the fetus in the breach position. Wait till the 39th week and you could do it in the head-down position. You might need to make specialized tools, by what makes you think it can't be done? It sure as hell isn't because they can't get access to the fetus' skull before delivery. Placing electrodes into the fetus' scalp is pretty damn common even before full dilation, and you can dilate without giving birth.
How big around is an electrode, Zigsie?

How big around is the wire attached to an electrode?

Now, how big around is a thirty-nine-week fetus?

How big around is the opening in a woman's cervix before labor starts?

I said, "How the dead fetus is subsequently removed is somewhat beside the point (though removal through the vagina would certainly work): if it's dead, you've performed an abortion". The whole "if it's dead when you remove it" was, I thought, obviously implicit.
Dear child, if you say what you mean, then that saves you the trouble of going back and explaining what you meant.

A procedure that leaves a woman with a dead fetus in her body is not an abortion.
 
How big around is the opening in a woman's cervix before labor starts?

The cervix can be quite dilated (as in >5 cm) well before labor for some women.

Dear child, if you say what you mean, then that saves you the trouble of going back and explaining what you meant.

If you avoid taking a patronizing tone towards someone you know nothing about, then that saves you the trouble of going back and apologizing for sounding like an ass.

A procedure that leaves a woman with a dead fetus in her body is not an abortion.

A procedure which kills the fetus and then removes it is an abortion. Even if the fetus is removed surgically through the uterine wall or through the vagina.
 
Also why don't any pro-lifers here seem to want to answer Kerikiwi's question that's been raised many times - why do *you* want to force a pregnant woman, who doesn't want to be pregnant, to have a baby?

Do you believe infanticide should be legal?
If not, why do *you* want to force a custodial adult, who doesn't want a child, to be a parent?
 
Last edited:
Do you believe infanticide should be legal?
If not, why do *you* want to force a custodial adult, who doesn't want a child, to be a parent?

The problem there is that many different people could look after a baby, while a foetus requires a specific individual.
 
So it's morally acceptable to kill the child only if there's no other viable alternative than me taking care of it?

What is and isn't morally acceptable to a person depends on his or her values. I think individual circumstances have to be considered when trying to decide whether a particular action is defensible or not.

Or to answer your question more directly: It depends.
 
Do you believe infanticide should be legal?
If not, why do *you* want to force a custodial adult, who doesn't want a child, to be a parent?


You imply a contradiction where none exists.

This is because abortion isn't a moral issue, it is a political one. Morality is about answering the question, "What should *I* do?" Politics answers the very different question, "What can I reasonably hope to force others to do?"

And the majority of Americans can be convinced to allow pregnant women to have abortions by appealing to the argument that women should be able to control their own bodies; while simultaneously disalowing mothers to kill their four day-old babies by appealing to the argument that life is sacred.

Sure, at the borders, these two moral concepts conflict. At 36 weeks into a pregnancy, the conflict between the two becomes strong. At 30 weeks (viability with a lot of medical help), the conflict becomes almost unresolvable.

But the vast majority of people spend the vast majority of their time away from borders. They only have to worry about the difference between an 8 week-old fetus and a little, newborn baby.

You cannot find a single moral position that works at the fetus/baby border, or that even defines where exactly that border is.

But abortions will stay safe and legal, and infanticide will stay illegal, for a very, very long time. Because, politically, it's what you can sell.
 
You imply a contradiction where none exists.

This is because abortion isn't a moral issue, it is a political one. Morality is about answering the question, "What should *I* do?" Politics answers the very different question, "What can I reasonably hope to force others to do?"

You've got a very perverse concept of politics if it doesn't include the question, "what should I force others to do?" Sounds a bit along the lines of "There is no good or evil: only power and those too weak to seek it."
 
Has any woman ever said "Put your hand here, you can feel my fetus kick."?

"Fetus" and "choice" are semantic games of deception and justification from those who advocate what even they cannot honestly defend in good conscience.

Fortunately there are those of us who do not have that problem. And my side is not the one that uses pictures that are lies - like showing pictures of miscarried foetuses and calling them abortions - without pointing out they were not wanted abortions but were "natural" abortions due to medical problems of the woman who had wanted the child that foetus would/might have become.
 
So it's morally acceptable to kill the child only if there's no other viable alternative than me taking care of it?
Naughty game playing with the terms here Avalon. It is illegal to kill a child. We call it murder. A foetus is not, until born, a child. It is fun* to falsely name things to confuse issues - FSM knows conservatives pull that crap constantly - but it does not make them so. Facts beat false words/concepts all to heck.





* to some people - I find it pathetic. That's, again, why I am pro-abortion - if it is the woman's choice. No other person's feelings on that matter in the slightest unless the woman chooses for them to matter in her decision.
 
Morality is about answering the question, "What should *I* do?" Politics answers the very different question, "What can I reasonably hope to force others to do?"

You've got a very perverse concept of politics if it doesn't include the question, "what should I force others to do?" Sounds a bit along the lines of "There is no good or evil: only power and those too weak to seek it."


The verb in my sentence was "reasonably hope," not "force." My view of politics isn't perverse, it's inclusive of all political systems.

And the way my sentence "sounds" to you has nothing to do with my actual opinion. I fully agree with Machiavelli that the people are the most powerful political force there is. A republic governed by popular will is stronger than any kingdom.

You, however, have a perverse concept of politics if you think that you can ignore it in favor of thinking about "morality" and ever hope to see anyone ever agree with you at a rate greater than mere chance.
 
This is because abortion isn't a moral issue, it is a political one. Morality is about answering the question, "What should *I* do?" Politics answers the very different question, "What can I reasonably hope to force others to do?"

Setting aside the issue of abortion, how can you ever separate one from the other? :confused:

Stealing (when it is not a life or death situation- but that's debatable, too) is immoral and something that is against the law.

It is against the law because it is immoral- and an immoral individual act/decision.

It's one and the same.

This goes for murder, rape, statutory rape, child porn, slavery, sweatshop labor, assault, illegal parking and a million other things that the law prohibits because they are bad.
 
Last edited:
What is more immoral, letting Woman the possibility to rip apart the baby (like it was called here) before it even realizes that it exists. or forbid woman that option and the kids end up in one of the orphanages where it has to wait until one family wants to adopt it.

I find abortion immoral, but less immoral than forcing woman to give birth to a baby the didn't want in the first place.
 
Last edited:
Well, whether it actually is or isn't immoral is another issue.

What Loss Leader was saying was that it wasn't even a moral question.

Of course it is. If you are against it, it is. If you are for it, it is. If you fall somewhere between those two positions, it is.

And he drew a distinction between a political and moral issue.

That's a distinction that doesn't exist, in the issue of abortion or in many other areas of the law (at least IMHO).

(Nothing personal here, Loss Leader; you are a smart and cool guy. I just find the idea that it wouldn't be a moral issue to be wrong and more than a little nihilistic. If you wanted to argue that abortion wasn't immoral, fine. To say that something like that wouldn't even be a consideration, though, is kind of going too far.)
 
Last edited:
Do you believe infanticide should be legal?
If not, why do *you* want to force a custodial adult, who doesn't want a child, to be a parent?

It's irrelevant what I believe. Infanticide is illegal. Abortion is not. What's the term for creating an argument that is not related to the point and then arguing for/against it? I'm really more interested in why you think you get to decide what a woman does with her own body. Who made you the moral police? By your logic, because I'm a vegetarian, you should be too. Or are you the only one that gets the luxury of making your own decisions?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom