"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Utter nonsense.

How many abortions are you personally responsible for?

And don't worry boo, I won't ask you...

None, you see I don't feel I have the right to tell a woman she must have an abortion rather than give a child up for adoption. What with it not being my body and all.
 
None, you see I don't feel I have the right to tell a woman she must have an abortion rather than give a child up for adoption. What with it not being my body and all.
Hypocrite. You support abortion and haven't contributed to even one?

That's just as logical and reasonable as your point.
 
Hypocrite. You support abortion and haven't contributed to even one?

That's just as logical and reasonable as your point.

Your response is at odds with the post you seem to be responding to.
Fitter didn't say what you think s/he said.
Your logic and reason continue to fail to make the grade.
 
So what you are saying is that it's perfectly acceptable to play russian roulette with getting pregnant because you can always abort it if it all goes wrong?

Do you seriously think that a woman who can't manage to sort out birth control should be responsible for a child?

Even if she is responsible with birth control, it is fallible.

I really don't think there are that many women who use abortion as a form of birth control.
 
A few years ago here there was a newspaper article about students doing exactly this, having unprotected group sex, with the guys all putting money into a pool so they could pay for an abortion if needed. Do you consider that acceptable behaviour?

Great genetics here, great parent material.

I would want this sort of person raising the next generation.
 
Note this. Mark my word. If you or anyone here has a baby that they will kill otherwise, you can deliver that baby to me and I will personally see to it that it find its way to a loving home. And now you say what?


I say this:

The Masonic Home for Children in Oxford, North Carolina provides residential services for orphaned children. They actively seek foster and adoptive parents.

I would never, ever suggest something so radical as you finding a loving home for every single orphan in their care. How about you just make a fifty dollar donation? Here's the form. Send us back MHC-Oxford's acknowledgement of the gift.

What? You promised to care for any child and find a loving permanent home. Did you think you could do it for under fifty bucks?
 
Last edited:
Of course it's not comparable to a third degree burn but pregnancy does make permanent changes to a woman's body. In addition to health issues during pregnancy there are also potential long term affects, including but not limited to scarring, incontinence, wider hips, temporary or permanent injury to the back, potential for future infertility, uterine prolapse, post-partum depression, etc.

That doesn't even take into account the social problems like job performance or promotion. Pregnancy is expensive and time consuming. In a competitive society it can set a woman's career back even if she gives the child up for adoption.

Carrying a child to term isn't a casual event.

Don't forget pre-eclampsia, maternal diabetes (which can have women be insulin dependent diabetics for the rest of their lives), and I also suggest that you google HELLP.

It is only a recent human henomena that we have reduced the number of women who die during childbirth, and that is in the developed world.
 
Last edited:
Don't forget pre-eclampsia, maternal diabetes (which can have women be insulin dependent diabetics for the rest of their lives), and I also suggest that you google HEELP.


Deep vein thrombosis. Don't forget the increased chance that pregnancy will cause you to die of a stroke.
 
Deep vein thrombosis. Don't forget the increased chance that pregnancy will cause you to die of a stroke.

And von willdebrand's disease manifests during pregnancy so the woman bleeds out (it is a form of thrombophaelia as well).

One of my dear friends is currently signed off of work due to devastating sciatica from her pregnancy.

Just past the first trimester and she is suffering massively.

They desperately wanted children, so she is dealing with it fairly well.
 
Well, that's rather the whole point: many DO consider fetuses to be people.
Yeah, I know. It's a free country so they're entitled to be wrong, but fortunately they can't push that view on the rest of us. ;)

And Nazis used the exact same rhetorical argument against Jews. It's fine to kill them, they're not really humans. Sieg heil.

LOL @ Godwin.
 
Go on... explain to me why it's impossible to do a 39th week abortion. What gives a 39-week old fetus powers of invincibility?

How would you go about it?

You could induce labor. That's called "giving birth".

You could perform a hysterotomy. That's called "c-section".

You could go in through the vaginal opening, cut the fetus up and bring it out piece by piece. That's called "severely injuring or killing a pregnant woman".

What other options can you come up with?
 
How would you go about it?

You could induce labor. That's called "giving birth".

You could perform a hysterotomy. That's called "c-section".

You could go in through the vaginal opening, cut the fetus up and bring it out piece by piece. That's called "severely injuring or killing a pregnant woman".

What other options can you come up with?

Pierce the cranium and vacuum out the brain, like they already do for certain forms of abortion. How the dead fetus is subsequently removed is somewhat beside the point (though removal through the vagina would certainly work): if it's dead, you've performed an abortion. I'm sure they could come up with other methods, if there was a demand for it.
 
Do you seriously think that a woman who can't manage to sort out birth control should be responsible for a child?

<snip>

Excellent point. A woman that immature, impulsive or stupid shouldn't be allowed to breed until she becomes more responsible. Perhaps an IUD or other fix and forget type of contraceptive should be installed after she's had the abortion to lower the chances of it happening again.
 
Pierce the cranium and vacuum out the brain, like they already do for certain forms of abortion. How the dead fetus is subsequently removed is somewhat beside the point (though removal through the vagina would certainly work): if it's dead, you've performed an abortion. I'm sure they could come up with other methods, if there was a demand for it.

You've been listening to lies, Ziggie, and should stop. The procedure to which you apparently refer, intact dilation and extraction, is a second-trimester procedure: if it were performed in the third, and certainly if it were performed on a thirty-nine-week fetus, it would result in devastating damage to a woman's body. (Remember her? The woman? She is involved in this, you know.)

As to your utterly bizarre assertion that "if {the fetus} is dead, you've performed an abortion", the procedure to remove a dead fetus from a woman's body is called "abortion".
 
You've been listening to lies, Ziggie, and should stop. The procedure to which you apparently refer, intact dilation and extraction, is a second-trimester procedure: if it were performed in the third, and certainly if it were performed on a thirty-nine-week fetus, it would result in devastating damage to a woman's body.

Because they do it with the fetus in the breach position. Wait till the 39th week and you could do it in the head-down position. You might need to make specialized tools, by what makes you think it can't be done? It sure as hell isn't because they can't get access to the fetus' skull before delivery. Placing electrodes into the fetus' scalp is pretty damn common even before full dilation, and you can dilate without giving birth.

As to your utterly bizarre assertion that "if {the fetus} is dead, you've performed an abortion", the procedure to remove a dead fetus from a woman's body is called "abortion".

I said, "How the dead fetus is subsequently removed is somewhat beside the point (though removal through the vagina would certainly work): if it's dead, you've performed an abortion". The whole "if it's dead when you remove it" was, I thought, obviously implicit.
 
Thankfully this whole discussion is pointless. We live in an age where abortion is available and legal in some countries. Therefore women *do* have a choice regardless of what other people (who seem to want to stick their noses into other people's lives) think. I wonder if pro-lifers ever masturbate - how many millions of potential babies are 'murdered' by that kind of action?
Also why don't any pro-lifers here seem to want to answer Kerikiwi's question that's been raised many times - why do *you* want to force a pregnant woman, who doesn't want to be pregnant, to have a baby?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom