"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

We both have our own opinions about the subjects.

Anyone remember 20 years ago when a regular theme with Liberals in America was an opposition to population growth? It was often used tangentially as a supporting argument for "choice." Those same people who were so-opposed to "overpopulation" as long as it meant no more of ourselves no longer seem to ever have or voice the same concern when almost all significant and continuing population growth is from others.

Just another observation. Draw your own conclusions, suggestions and extrapolations.

And this all has what to do with forcing a woman who is unwillingly pregnant to go ahead and give birth?
 
We both have our own opinions about the subjects.

Anyone remember 20 years ago when a regular theme with Liberals in America was an opposition to population growth? It was often used tangentially as a supporting argument for "choice." Those same people who were so-opposed to "overpopulation" as long as it meant no more of ourselves no longer seem to ever have or voice the same concern when almost all significant and continuing population growth is from others.

Just another observation. Draw your own conclusions, suggestions and extrapolations.

Why is xenophobia a good argument against abortion?
 
In the United States of America alone; fifty million dead.

50,000,000 killed. Choice.

The greatest instinct in a woman is mothering. What happened to us?

That is ghastly.

Well your own figures prove you wrong, apparently. When your view conflicts with the facts maybe you should reconsider your view?
 
And this all has what to do with forcing a woman who is unwillingly pregnant to go ahead and give birth?

Isn't that the answer to the OP? The exception is only for those women who are unwillingly pregnant. I.e. if a pregnant woman had consensual sex which she knows has the potential to result in her becoming pregnant, then she is not unwillingly pregnant, she's unfortunately pregnant.

ETA: Just to make clear: this is not my point of view on abortion.
 
The correct current number of the slaughtered is, again, approximately 50,000,000. If the option was not so easily available, resulting behavior would certainly have been more responsible and the number of "unwanted pregnancies" would have been drastically lower. Also, you assume that every woman that aborted would still have abandoned her baby had she carried it to term. At least very many women would not abandon their baby after birth as casually as they eliminate it early in pregnancy. Everything would be different. And you apparently know almost nothing about current adoption practice. The demand far exceeds the available orphans which is why Americans so-often adopt foreign infants.

Just curious, does any of this register with you?

you know, it had a reason why i said around the world. Enough kids in 3rd world countries would be happy to grow up in a nice families in a "1." world country.

I am not sure in the US, but here it is not just so easy to get. there are a lot restrictions, which is good. But no further restrictions needed. unless you can show me that a lot woman **** around unprotected and go have slaughtered a fetus several times a year.
 
And this all has what to do with forcing a woman who is unwillingly pregnant to go ahead and give birth?
Did I say it did? Of course not. That's just more of the same from you. Out of the discussion of this thread, I simply made a related tangential point.

154:
Wow ! Your credibility know no bounds...
I'll bite. Please explain.

Why is xenophobia a good argument against abortion?
Why is this standard argumentative tactic acceptable to Leftists?

I have no "irrational fears". I simply reported an observation. It is what it is, regardless of what anyone thinks of it.


Well your own figures prove you wrong, apparently. When your view conflicts with the facts maybe you should reconsider your view?
What view conflicts with what facts?
http://www.nrlc.org/abortion/facts/abortionstats.html
 
Isn't that the answer to the OP? The exception is only for those women who are unwillingly pregnant. I.e. if a pregnant woman had consensual sex which she knows has the potential to result in her becoming pregnant, then she is not unwillingly pregnant, she's unfortunately pregnant.

This becomes simply a semantic game.
If a woman is pregnant and she doesn't want to be, 'unwilling' is a perfectly fine description. I doubt anyone is unable to understand it.
Unwilling, doesn't want to be, thinks it a bad idea, would like to not be pregnant, unhappily, ...
 
Did I say it did? Of course not. That's just more of the same from you. Out of the discussion of this thread, I simply made a related tangential point.

That's where we disagree: I don't think it is related or tangential
 
I have no "irrational fears". I simply reported an observation. It is what it is, regardless of what anyone thinks of it.

The rain has stopped and the sun is shining.
There, another observation reported. I will admit it has nothing to do with whether a woman should be forced to give birth, but it is what it is, regardless of what anyone thinks of it.
Now, let's get down to it:

do you think women should be forced to give birth?
 
<snip>

No, I have never adopted. So what? Many wish to.

Note this. Mark my word. If you or anyone here has a baby that they will kill otherwise, you can deliver that baby to me and I will personally see to it that it find its way to a loving home. And now you say what?

I say that if you want to add millions to orphanages world wide and are not prepared to lessen that number by even one yourself then you have successfully met my definition of a hypocrite.
 
I say that if you want to add millions to orphanages world wide and are not prepared to lessen that number by even one yourself then you have successfully met my definition of a hypocrite.

Also, considering how many children are currently in orphanages, it is difficult to see adoption as an easy or simple solution.
 
I say that if you want to add millions to orphanages world wide and are not prepared to lessen that number by even one yourself then you have successfully met my definition of a hypocrite.
Utter nonsense.

How many abortions are you personally responsible for?

And don't worry boo, I won't ask you...
 
Last edited:
Utter nonsense.

How many abortions are you personally responsible for?

And don't worry boo, I won't ask you...

You're implying that there is something wrong with having a legal medical procedure or knowing someone who has. Why is that?
 
I've heard some pro-life advocates say that they are against abortion except in cases of rape or incest. Why? Is that baby any less human? Wouldn't it still qualify as killing the unborn?

Just for the record, I'm pro-choice.

Maybe those people are smart enough to realize that morality is rarely black and white (and neither is the definition of "human life" or "baby").
 
Note this. Mark my word. If you or anyone here has a baby that they will kill otherwise, you can deliver that baby to me and I will personally see to it that it find its way to a loving home. And now you say what?

Sorry I overlooked this before, but it bears addressing.
I say two things. The first is a question.
How are you in a position to find adoptive homes for multiple babies?

The third is an observation: I suspect that either you are speaking rhetorically, or you are seriously detached from reality. Nobody has suggested that killing babies is an option.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom