"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

The lack of logical thinking and rationality here among the self-professed logical and rational really is something.


No, I didn't seriously claim what you say. However, it is only logical to assume that the 50,000,000 slaughtered would have had some children of their own also. That's reasonably logical, right? Can you follow here? Can you keep up? So, while those additional 20 million were not also so coldly killed, they can be fairly considered among those that otherwise would have been among the living. There are further repercussions to the 50 million dead.
It's not hilarious. It's not stupid. It's clear thinking logic and rationale. Surrender your rigidly held preconceptions and allow for actual thought sometime.
Actual thought?
You seem to be suggesting that it is bad that lots of people haven't been born.
Every time a woman fails to have a baby, that is whenever she is not pregnant, we can count her non-existent offspring as a loss,and their non-existent offspring, and theirs, and theirs and theirs...
Talk about following and keeping up. I was actually so far ahead of you, you couldn't see me.

As I said, stupid and hilarious.
 
Again, kerkiwi, in the quote of mine you mocked,

Just the bit about the damned furriners taking over.
I presume not only is abortion the suicide of a culture, but so is any woman who is not pregnant at any given moment.
Mockworthy, definitely mockworthy.
 
154, would you force children to be risen by parents that don't want them?
 
Actual thought?
You seem to be suggesting that it is bad that lots of people haven't been born.
Every time a woman fails to have a baby, that is whenever she is not pregnant, we can count her non-existent offspring as a loss,and their non-existent offspring, and theirs, and theirs and theirs...
I said what I said, and quite plainly. If you wish to make your own leaps of assumption and "suggestion," they are yours alone, not mine. You still make it a habit to attack me for things you say I said even though I never said, suggested or thought them. Why do you need to do that?

Just the bit about the damned furriners taking over.
I presume not only is abortion the suicide of a culture, but so is any woman who is not pregnant at any given moment.
Mockworthy, definitely mockworthy.
"Damned" and "taking over" are your characterizations. I simply made valid observations. Your presumed extrapolations are not mine. I observe. You insult. I understand. Typical.

154, would you force children to be risen by parents that don't want them?
You mean "raised."

Of course not. Ever heard of adoption?
 
Last edited:
Just the bit about the damned furriners taking over.
I presume not only is abortion the suicide of a culture, but so is any woman who is not pregnant at any given moment.
Mockworthy, definitely mockworthy.

I agree that trying to tie immigration with abortion makes little sense. But there really is something to the idea that rampant abortion is a sort of cultural suicide. Russia, for example, had more abortions than births in 2001, and a declining population which wouldn't be declining if those abortions were births. Demographic implosion really can happen, and abortion really can help it happen.
 
But for the fewest of exceptions, abortion is murder for convenience to accommodate hedonistic decadence. Western societies are killing themselves and replacing themselves with foreigners.
Abortion is the suicide of a culture.

only if you consider a fetus is a person
 
I agree that trying to tie immigration with abortion makes little sense. But there really is something to the idea that rampant abortion is a sort of cultural suicide. Russia, for example, had more abortions than births in 2001, and a declining population which wouldn't be declining if those abortions were births. Demographic implosion really can happen, and abortion really can help it happen.
Abortion is no more cultural suicide than is contraception or abstinence.
If an argument is made against abortion on such grounds, exactly the same argument would mean pregnancy was compulsory.
It is not an argument against a woman's right to abort an unwanted pregnancy.
 
I agree that trying to tie immigration with abortion makes little sense. But there really is something to the idea that rampant abortion is a sort of cultural suicide. Russia, for example, had more abortions than births in 2001, and a declining population which wouldn't be declining if those abortions were births. Demographic implosion really can happen, and abortion really can help it happen.
And what then is the only "little sense" way to counter that declining population?
 
I simply made valid observations. Your presumed extrapolations are not mine. I observe. You insult. I understand. Typical.

My extrapolations inevitably follow from the observations you made.
How is pointing out the logical result of your observations an insult?
Your observations are worthy of mockery. That is my observation.
You did not make clear that you understand the logical outcome of your observations. Typical.
 
I said what I said, and quite plainly. If you wish to make your own leaps of assumption and "suggestion," they are yours alone, not mine. You still make it a habit to attack me for things you say I said even though I never said, suggested or thought them. Why do you need to do that?

"Damned" and "taking over" are your characterizations. I simply made valid observations. Your presumed extrapolations are not mine. I observe. You insult. I understand. Typical.

You mean "raised."

Of course not. Ever heard of adoption?

ever seen an orphanage from the inside? a clue how many children around the world are waiting to get a family to life with?
you want just to add 70 000 000 children to orphanages?
 
And what then is the only "little sense" way to counter that declining population?

It makes little sense to tie them together because 1) Russia isn't solving (and probably can't) its demographic decline by importing immigrants, 2) the US wouldn't have a declining population even without immigrants, and 3) there's no reason to think we wouldn't have a large influx of immigrants in the US even without abortion. Both abortion and immigration affect demographics, but they're still very different issues.
 
And Nazis used the exact same rhetorical argument against Jews. It's fine to kill them, they're not really humans. Sieg heil.

Nazis also had a bit of a breeding programme for the master race...
 
Abortion is no more cultural suicide than is contraception or abstinence.

When you've got a declining population, then yes, that's true. You seem to think that invalidates my position, but it doesn't.

If an argument is made against abortion on such grounds, exactly the same argument would mean pregnancy was compulsory.

Plenty of people think suicide is acceptable, or at least should be legal. Concluding that abortion is cultural suicide doesn't require that we outlaw it. Hell, if you're a member of the human extinction movement, that's reason enough to encourage it.

And you're wrong about this logic leading to compulsory pregnancy. There are plenty of reasons that we can consider one measure to prevent some ill acceptable but another measure to prevent the same ill unacceptable. We do it all the time, and with good reason.
 
as long the Vatican doesn't end its anti-condoms propaganda tours in 3rd world countries, there is no decline of population.
 
ever seen an orphanage from the inside? a clue how many children around the world are waiting to get a family to life with?
you want just to add 70 000 000 children to orphanages?
The correct current number of the slaughtered is, again, approximately 50,000,000. If the option was not so easily available, resulting behavior would certainly have been more responsible and the number of "unwanted pregnancies" would have been drastically lower. Also, you assume that every woman that aborted would still have abandoned her baby had she carried it to term. At least very many women would not abandon their baby after birth as casually as they eliminate it early in pregnancy. Everything would be different. And you apparently know almost nothing about current adoption practice. The demand far exceeds the available orphans which is why Americans so-often adopt foreign infants.

Just curious, does any of this register with you?

It makes little sense to tie them together because 1) Russia isn't solving (and probably can't) its demographic decline by importing immigrants, 2) the US wouldn't have a declining population even without immigrants, and 3) there's no reason to think we wouldn't have a large influx of immigrants in the US even without abortion. Both abortion and immigration affect demographics, but they're still very different issues.
We both have our own opinions about the subjects.

Anyone remember 20 years ago when a regular theme with Liberals in America was an opposition to population growth? It was often used tangentially as a supporting argument for "choice." Those same people who were so-opposed to "overpopulation" as long as it meant no more of ourselves no longer seem to ever have or voice the same concern when almost all significant and continuing population growth is from others.

Just another observation. Draw your own conclusions, suggestions and extrapolations.


Nazis also had a bit of a breeding programme for the master race...
Does that in any way invalidate my point?

Ever done it? How many children are you currently, or have you in the past, adopted from an orphanage and raised to adulthood?
Even though this is such a frequently made point in discussions such as this one, it is really irrelevant and dumb.

No, I have never adopted. So what? Many wish to.

Note this. Mark my word. If you or anyone here has a baby that they will kill otherwise, you can deliver that baby to me and I will personally see to it that it find its way to a loving home. And now you say what?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom