"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

The greatest instinct in a woman is mothering. What happened to us?


Infanticide is and always has been a firmly embedded human behavior, just as it was for the animals we evolved from and our closest animal relatives today.

This wikipedia article has a good bibliography.
 
so what is a mother supposed to that, when her mother instinct tells her, it isn't the right time for a baby, it will not be good for the baby?
Rip the baby into pieces, of course.

If everyone waited for "the right time," almost no one would have children.

Avoid personal responsibility. Eliminate the evidence.

Heartless.
 
Rip the baby into pieces, of course.

If everyone waited for "the right time," almost no one would have children.

Avoid personal responsibility. Eliminate the evidence.

Heartless.

so motherinstinct only counts when it fits your view?
 
In my state the father is financially responsible for birth and prenatal costs.

Well, none. But that's a very simplistic way of looking at the issue.

True, it was an invitational statement. Ivor seems to think there is something wrong with women having control of the pregnancy. I would like to know his views on other options. I have my opinion on this (Hint: It's nuanced) but if I state it, we will be arguing my position instead of hearing his.
 
But that's not a moral question, it's a political one.

No, LL. It's ALSO a political one. But people's politics are influenced by their morality, and even if you think morality doesn't exist in any objective sense, individual's morality definitely does, even in political questions.

Many people behave in ways they themselves consider immoral all the time.

So what? Unless you think that people's morality never even influence their choices, then morality matters, even if other factors can sometimes overrule it.
 
Do you have anything to back this up? Yes, there are women who get pregnant on purpose to snare a man, just as there are men who don't pay child support of children who were planned. Are either of these extremes the majority?

Probably not.

I am also curious as to exactly which rights you think a man should have over a woman's body simply because he has had sex with her.

None. I think women should be completely responsible for the reproduction of the human race and men (if they want to) should just provide sperm. Once stem cell technology develops even that task can be performed by women and men will be completely superfluous.
 
Probably not.



None. I think women should be completely responsible for the reproduction of the human race and men (if they want to) should just provide sperm. Once stem cell technology develops even that task can be performed by women and men will be completely superfluous.

Neither sex will be superfluous unless we develop some sort of medication against the hormonally-driven irrationality known as attraction. (Hopefully that will never happen.) In the meantime, humans will reproduce with all the messy repercussions of thinking, feeling animals.
 
Personally I perfer to discuss things within the currently established framework rather than therotical maybe.

So a question back to you, when do you believe it is no longer to terminate one's off-spring, and how do you justify that transistion from killable to not killable?

I am asking you what you think the established framework should be.
Why is that so hard to answer?
You have hinted that women should remain pregnant because that is the consequence of failed contraception.
It has been pointed out that abortion can change that consequence, rather like sexual intercourse can lead to pregnancy, but contraception can change that consequence.
Are you resiling from your 'consequence' opposition to abortion and now taking a life-is-sacred position?
That unwillingly pregnant women should be forced to carry the pregnancy to term?
Or that some unwillingly pregnant women should be exempt?
 
Surely you'd have to agree that not having unwanted pregnancies is by far a better solution than on-demand abortion.

Of course it is, just as brushing your teeth is a better solution than major dental surgery.
The question is: do you force the woman who is unwillingly pregnant, that is she does not want to be pregnant whatever caused it, to carry that pregnancy to term?
If she is forced to continue while someone else who makes a 'good case' is allowed an abortion, how else could you desribe the forced continuation other than a punishment for behaviour you do not like?
Your argument falls flat on its face.
 
Last edited:
I believe that life is important, all life. A fetus is genetically unique from its mother, and was brought into being their her actions. I believe that in doing so she adopts the responsiblity to protect that life.
You could say the same about zygotes and embryos. Are you against the Morning After Pill, too? It has the potential to destroy a zygote. Oh noes, the poor life!

And, honestly:

I believe that life is important, all life.
Why?

Also, I take it you never swat mosquitoes. (Oh, oops, did you mean "life with human DNA"? How arbitrary.)

Destroying a life simply because it doesn't fit in with your lifestyle is considered wrong in our society, except it seems when it comes to the most vulnerable of all, the ones who don't have voices.
Wrong. Destroying a person is what is considered wrong. We destroy (animal) lives all the time, and fetuses aren't considered people.

You ask "should a woman with an unwanted pregnancy be forced to continue with that pregnancy?" but to me this is not just a yes or no answer. I believe that women should be forced to take responsiblity to actually not get pregnant in the first place ... If the law was properly enforced and proper education was given then there would be little need to have any woman with an unwanted pregnancy being forced to continue with that pregnancy simply because the number of unwanted pregnancies would drop significantly. But then, hey, responsibility is a dirty word now days...
Even with the best education in the world, there would still be unwanted pregnancies.
When contraception or education fails, do you think women should be forced to carry to term? Yes or no? It IS a simple yes or no question. That you refuse to answer it is very telling, anyway.

By removing abortion on demand, and thus the ability to use it as a form of birth control, it puts the responsibility back on where it should be to take adequate precautions to avoid pregnancy proir to getting it on, not to get rid of it when it happens.
That's idiotic, because most people DO use birth control. They generally use abortions when birth control fail. If you remove the availability of abortion, you won't have less unwanted pregnancies, you'll simply have more unwanted babies.

I'm neither pro-life nor pro-chioce, I'm anti-unwanted pregnancies.
Sorry, but if you want to "remove abortion on demand", you are anti-choice, and pro-life. No other way around that.

Surely you'd have to agree that not having unwanted pregnancies is by far a better solution than on-demand abortion.
No. Not having unwanted pregnancies is good, but abortion should always be available on demand when that fails. It's really that simple.

If you really think people avoid using condoms or the pill and just go "oh well I'll get an abortion if the worst happens", you're out of touch with reality.
 
And if you allow for the children some of those would have had by now, we are fairly at a number at least approximating 70 million or so now.

In the exact same time period, guess about what number the total is for legal and illegal immigration and their children not killed?

Hilarious! You seriously claim that because of abortion all the children that the children who were never born might have had can be counted among the 'dead'.
There is nothing to do but fall about laughing at such stupidity.
 
Wrong. Destroying a person is what is considered wrong. We destroy (animal) lives all the time, and fetuses aren't considered people.

Well, that's rather the whole point: many DO consider fetuses to be people.
 
If everyone waited for "the right time," almost no one would have children.


My wife and I would still have our two.

Are you seriously stating that almost all pregnancies are accidental and unplanned?
 
The lack of logical thinking and rationality here among the self-professed logical and rational really is something.

Hilarious! You seriously claim that because of abortion all the children that the children who were never born might have had can be counted among the 'dead'.
There is nothing to do but fall about laughing at such stupidity.
No, I did not "seriously claim" what you say. However, it is only logical to assume that the 50,000,000 slaughtered would have had some children of their own also. That's reasonably logical, right? Can you follow here? Can you keep up? So, while those additional 20 million were not also so coldly killed, they can be fairly considered among those that otherwise would have been among the living. There are further repercussions to the 50 million dead.
It's not hilarious. It's not stupid. It's clear thinking logic and rationale. Surrender your rigidly held preconceptions and allow for actual thought sometime.

Look at this. Again, another example of such fine cognition:

My wife and I would still have our two.

Are you seriously stating that almost all pregnancies are accidental and unplanned?
I didn't "seriously claim" or "seriously state" any such thing now did I? People have children to have children, regardless of whether their circumstances are ideal or not. That does not mean "almost all pregnancies are accidental and unplanned." That does not logically follow.

How funny. Twin intellects.
 
I've heard some pro-life advocates say that they are against abortion except in cases of rape or incest. Why? Is that baby any less human? Wouldn't it still qualify as killing the unborn?

Just for the record, I'm pro-choice.

Because those children are poisoned with the seed of evil. I know what I'm talking about. CAUSE I'VE WALKED THAT PATH BROTHER!! I WALKED THAT PATH AND I'VE SEEN EVIL WITH THE NAKED EYE!! I'VE TOUCHED THAT EVIL!! I'VE SMELLED THAT EVIL!! AND THAT'S WHY YOU MUST REPENT BROTHER!! FALL ON YOUR KNEES AND REPENT BROTHER!! OOOOOHHHHH!! I'M FEELING THAT MAGNETIC POWER OF GOD! LET ME PUT MY HAND ON YOUR FOREHEAD AND GIVE YOU SOME OF GOD'S POWER! HAAAALLELUJAAAH BROTHER!! HAAALLELUJAAAAAHHH!!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom