"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Has any woman ever said "Put your hand here, you can feel my fetus kick."?

"Fetus" and "choice" are semantic games of deception and justification from those who advocate what even they cannot honestly defend in good conscience.
 
OK you believe everything you read in the papers. Fair enough. Then you wish to discuss a serious issue on the basis that we should make law or policy or even come to moral conclusions on that kind of anecdote which, even if true, is hardly usual. You want us to believe that this made the papers because it is not news, in other words.

Better yet, he believes -- and apparently expects us to unquestioningly accept -- his memory of an article he read in an unknown paper "a few years ago".

(I believe Jan Harold Brunvand has pointed out that when people read an article debunking, say, stories of poisoned Halloween candy, they tend strongly to recall it as an article about poison in Halloween candy. Just sayin'.)
 
I see what you are saying and where you are coming from but, really, are you serious?


I'm serious insofar as I would like the abortion debate to take place in the proper historical, evolutionary and economic context. I think debating abortion as a moral issue alone misses the point. It's not the way people make decisions and it probably isn't even the way people should make decisions.

Perhaps fidelity to the concept of "morality" is more of an emotional reaction, useful only when people have neither the time nor information to make a more reasoned, economic determination.

I have to say, it's not easy to put aside all questions of morality - as with your toe-cutting-off example. But I'm not convinced that it's wrong to dismiss morality just because it's hard to.


"Well, the death penalty by whipping someone to death over the course of a week or two and then slowly making them bleed to death by cutting off their toes is just inefficient. We should discourage it for that reason alone. Society would function much more smoothly if we just shot them all in prison, you know. Or didn't have the death penalty at all. That would be much less inefficient."

It doesn't even come close to discussing the real pro vs. con arguments of the death penalty.


My opposition to the death penalty is grounded in politics. The "state" is nothing but a collective delusion of the people - it exists only by consent of the governed. The person, on the other hand, is an actual, corporeal being. To my estimation, a consensual hallucination - an imaginary person - should not have the right to murder a real person under any circumstance.

But now we're completely OT.
 
Has any woman ever said "Put your hand here, you can feel my fetus kick."?

Has any woman ever talked about the details of her wedding before she was even engaged?

Did she say "This is the dress I want to wear at my so-far-nonexistent-wedding-that-may-or-may-not-happen-at-some-unknown-date-an-unspecified-period-of-time-in-the-future"?
 
Just as well the Human race doesn't rely on it for survival, we'd have died out centuries ago.

Actually maternal and infant mortality rates have dropped significantly in the last 100 years. At the turn of the century they were aprox 600 deaths per 100,000 live births. (Check out the theme of orphans throughout classic lit.)

Even today abortion may have potential dangers but it is significantly safer than full-term pregnancy. Should a woman be forced to risk her health because birth control isn't infallible?

You also did not address the social and economic concerns.
 
Has any woman ever said "Put your hand here, you can feel my fetus kick."?

"Fetus" and "choice" are semantic games of deception and justification from those who advocate what even they cannot honestly defend in good conscience.

And speeches like this are merely emotional appeals.
 
A few years ago here there was a newspaper article about students doing exactly this, having unprotected group sex, with the guys all putting money into a pool so they could pay for an abortion if needed. Do you consider that acceptable behaviour?

I consider it implausible behavior. You're telling me that teenagers had enough foresight and awareness to put together a pool of money in advance, but not to stop by the drugstore for some condoms? I don't believe it, and I call ********. Either the article was wrong (like the supposed "pregnancy club" at a U.S. high school, which turned out to be nothing of the kind), or your recollection is seriously flawed.

But even if I treat this as a hypothetical, the answer is no, I don't consider it 'acceptable' behavior. But I also don't consider it a reason to force a teenage girl to have a child. Again, it's not about punishment.
 
I don't know why you say that. I'm not even convinced morality exists. And I'm not alone.

But you are in a small minority, and we live in a democracy. So if you want to insist that morality doesn't exist, you're still faced with the fact that the perception of morality does, and that absolutely matters.

Oh, and moral nihilism is repugnant.
 
Possession is 9/10ths of the law.

The great thing about these threads is you come to realise how deluded men are who come out with statements such as "We're having a baby" or "She's carrying our baby" are. No chaps, the reality is that it's 100% her foetus/baby, to do with as she sees fit up until birth, whether you or anyone else likes it or not.

Not that many a woman won't try to fool a man into thinking that the foetus inside her body is somehow partly his responsibility despite him having no rights over it at all.

Do you have anything to back this up? Yes, there are women who get pregnant on purpose to snare a man, just as there are men who don't pay child support of children who were planned. Are either of these extremes the majority?

I am also curious as to exactly which rights you think a man should have over a woman's body simply because he has had sex with her.
 
In the United States of America alone; fifty million dead.

50,000,000 killed. Choice.

The greatest instinct in a woman is mothering. What happened to us?

That is ghastly.
 
And if you allow for the children some of those would have had by now, we are fairly at a number at least approximating 70 million or so now.

In the exact same time period, guess about what number the total is for legal and illegal immigration and their children not killed?
 
In the United States of America alone; fifty million dead.

50,000,000 killed. Choice.

The greatest instinct in a woman is mothering. What happened to us?

That is ghastly.

so what is a mother supposed to that, when her mother instinct tells her, it isn't the right time for a baby, it will not be good for the baby?
 
But you are in a small minority, and we live in a democracy. So if you want to insist that morality doesn't exist, you're still faced with the fact that the perception of morality does, and that absolutely matters.


But that's not a moral question, it's a political one. I doubt you can cite any evidence that people who hold a certain moral opinion necessarily must be swayed to another moral opinion in order to influence their actions. Many people behave in ways they themselves consider immoral all the time.


Oh, and moral nihilism is repugnant.


That's ... ignorant. If moral absolutism doesn't exist, then moral nihilism of one stripe or another would appear necessary. Can you prove that moral absolutes necessarily exist and are discoverable?

Making statements about morality without being able to do so is repugnant.
 
And if you allow for the children some of those would have had by now, we are fairly at a number at least approximating 70 million or so now.

In the exact same time period, guess about what number the total is for legal and illegal immigration and their children not killed?

until what week were those abortions done?
 
Possession is 9/10ths of the law.

The great thing about these threads is you come to realise how deluded men are who come out with statements such as "We're having a baby" or "She's carrying our baby" are. No chaps, the reality is that it's 100% her foetus/baby, to do with as she sees fit up until birth, whether you or anyone else likes it or not.

Not that many a woman won't try to fool a man into thinking that the foetus inside her body is somehow partly his responsibility despite him having no rights over it at all.

In my state the father is financially responsible for birth and prenatal costs.

bookitty said:
I am also curious as to exactly which rights you think a man should have over a woman's body simply because he has had sex with her.

Well, none. But that's a very simplistic way of looking at the issue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom