slingblade
Unregistered
- Joined
- Jul 28, 2005
- Messages
- 23,466
That doesn't wash. People are objects too. Much of our society is based on the looks of people and the fashions they wear. Our society spends a lot of time on this, and not just for sexual purposes. "The clothes make the man," "Dressed for success," etc., all show that appearance is important and going to be noticed.
Okay, let me try it again. Because men and women are sentient beings with minds and feelings. They are not inanimate things that can't feel or think, consent or refuse.
Why is it "sexual" objectification? I am not interested in having sex with this person and I notice when a man is dressed well and in good shape.
I don't see how admiring, or commenting, on people's looks, or asking one to have sex with you is sexist, or sexism.
I've already said it isn't always sexism, or always sexist. That it depends on a number of things, and that each incident has to be weighed on its own merits.
Objectified by me? I just found her attractive. I didn't make her that way.
But what you felt or meant or intended isn't the determining factor. It's how it makes her feel, and that's going to, again, depend on a lot of variables. Myself, I like a little mild attention in that way, especially now that I rarely get such attention. I don't mind a simple wolf-whistle or appreciative look most of the time. If it goes beyond that, depending on how far and in what direction, I might mind.
I agree, which is why I think almost all claims of sexism, aren't. There must be some aspect of discrimination for it to be sexism.
I don't think it should be limited to that one word, though. I think there's an inherent aspect of power or dominance to most sexism.
For instance, an anecdote only to illustrate the point: when I arrived at my brother-in-law's house, where I now live, he told me to consider myself "the lady of the house." I had no idea what he meant by that phrase, but not wanting to cause some kind of disagreement, I just nodded.
Later, my husband mentioned something to his brother about the condition of his home: it's filthy, and it was so when we arrived. My husband and I keep our bedroom clean, and we wash our dishes and do our laundry. But the rest of the house is simply nasty. (And the fuel ran out three days after we arrived, so there's been no hot water in the house since May 3.)
His brother said, "I told her she was the lady of the house. Maybe you can make her do what she's supposed to. I guess she's ignoring me. She doesn't even cook for me."
So, being "the lady of the house" meant he had appointed me as the housekeeper/cook/maid of all work for not only my husband and myself, but also for him. You don't find that a sexist assumption? I'm the woman, so the cleaning of his messes is my job, not his own?
My husband and I also noticed that his brother would automatically reject any ideas I suggested for our business. I started filtering everything through my husband, who is now being touted as the source of so many great ideas!
I agree that you are free to tell me about how my actions make you feel but just because someone claims it is sexist doesn't make it so. One person is not the decider.
Someone has to be. Whom do you suggest? If I say something hurtful to you, but I didn't mean it to hurt, are your feelings in it of no account?
The issue I find with all this is that sexism is a "BAD" thing but in my mind it no longer means anything because so many people have cried "Wolf" for so long.
Who gets to decide when someone is crying wolf?
...is in response to:When this type of activity happens between people and some want to call it sexism, it completely removes the "bad" from the sexism label. In other words, if this is sexism, sexism is a good thing and I am all for it.
Slingblade said:And above all, the feelings of the other person need to be considered. What you meant to do isn't at all as important to me as how what you did made me feel. And if your actions or words make me feel objectified, I want to be able to tell you that without being belittled, or condescended to, or told to stop whining about it. Because that is sexism.
Not being able to object without being belittled, condescended to, or told to stop whining about it is a good thing?
We have very different ideas about that.
Last edited:
