EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

That doesn't wash. People are objects too. Much of our society is based on the looks of people and the fashions they wear. Our society spends a lot of time on this, and not just for sexual purposes. "The clothes make the man," "Dressed for success," etc., all show that appearance is important and going to be noticed.

Okay, let me try it again. Because men and women are sentient beings with minds and feelings. They are not inanimate things that can't feel or think, consent or refuse.



Why is it "sexual" objectification? I am not interested in having sex with this person and I notice when a man is dressed well and in good shape.

I don't see how admiring, or commenting, on people's looks, or asking one to have sex with you is sexist, or sexism.

I've already said it isn't always sexism, or always sexist. That it depends on a number of things, and that each incident has to be weighed on its own merits.



Objectified by me? I just found her attractive. I didn't make her that way.

But what you felt or meant or intended isn't the determining factor. It's how it makes her feel, and that's going to, again, depend on a lot of variables. Myself, I like a little mild attention in that way, especially now that I rarely get such attention. I don't mind a simple wolf-whistle or appreciative look most of the time. If it goes beyond that, depending on how far and in what direction, I might mind.


I agree, which is why I think almost all claims of sexism, aren't. There must be some aspect of discrimination for it to be sexism.

I don't think it should be limited to that one word, though. I think there's an inherent aspect of power or dominance to most sexism.

For instance, an anecdote only to illustrate the point: when I arrived at my brother-in-law's house, where I now live, he told me to consider myself "the lady of the house." I had no idea what he meant by that phrase, but not wanting to cause some kind of disagreement, I just nodded.

Later, my husband mentioned something to his brother about the condition of his home: it's filthy, and it was so when we arrived. My husband and I keep our bedroom clean, and we wash our dishes and do our laundry. But the rest of the house is simply nasty. (And the fuel ran out three days after we arrived, so there's been no hot water in the house since May 3.)

His brother said, "I told her she was the lady of the house. Maybe you can make her do what she's supposed to. I guess she's ignoring me. She doesn't even cook for me."

So, being "the lady of the house" meant he had appointed me as the housekeeper/cook/maid of all work for not only my husband and myself, but also for him. You don't find that a sexist assumption? I'm the woman, so the cleaning of his messes is my job, not his own?

My husband and I also noticed that his brother would automatically reject any ideas I suggested for our business. I started filtering everything through my husband, who is now being touted as the source of so many great ideas! :rolleyes: (I need to amend this. He has accepted a few of my ideas, but he accepted almost all of them when my husband presented them as his own.)


I agree that you are free to tell me about how my actions make you feel but just because someone claims it is sexist doesn't make it so. One person is not the decider.

Someone has to be. Whom do you suggest? If I say something hurtful to you, but I didn't mean it to hurt, are your feelings in it of no account?

The issue I find with all this is that sexism is a "BAD" thing but in my mind it no longer means anything because so many people have cried "Wolf" for so long.

Who gets to decide when someone is crying wolf?

When this type of activity happens between people and some want to call it sexism, it completely removes the "bad" from the sexism label. In other words, if this is sexism, sexism is a good thing and I am all for it.
...is in response to:

Slingblade said:
And above all, the feelings of the other person need to be considered. What you meant to do isn't at all as important to me as how what you did made me feel. And if your actions or words make me feel objectified, I want to be able to tell you that without being belittled, or condescended to, or told to stop whining about it. Because that is sexism.

Not being able to object without being belittled, condescended to, or told to stop whining about it is a good thing?

We have very different ideas about that.
 
Last edited:
My point was that even if it turns out that there isn't greater sexism in the skeptical community than in the general public, and even if it isn't keeping women away, we should still try to be accepting and accommodating within reason.

I agree. I disagree however that someone asking if you want to join them for coffee is somehow outside of "within reason"

I also disagree that much (if any) of what rebecca described was sexism
 
Assessing (collecting data) within our group only will not be enough to form well-founded opinions and conclusions. Because we would have to compare the data to something - and this can only happen if we also assess (collect data) the situation in a control group. Which control group? I believe you should think about that before you start assessing us.

I'm not working on my dissertation here, just trying to confirm or refute a claim that was made based on assumptions. Some claim there is evidence, I have not seen it as described. I don't want to say it doesn't exist without looking beyond my personal experience.

So far I've found a couple examples. I don't see a lot of evidence posted by others, just discussion.

I remain open to evidence being presented. Given Kuko4000's post above, however, the person who made the initial claim may have retracted it. I'm going to have to go back to some of the original complaints about sexism keeping women away from events and review them.
 
To continue the derail, about 80% of men are below average in looks, according to women.

http://www.samueljscott.com/2011/07/15/singles-online/

I don't if that means that we're all ugly, or expectations ar eout of touch with reality...
It's time to stop the derail. I'm sorry, I contributed to it as well. But the discussion is drifting and evidence is not being collected. Could we get back to the evidence please?
 
I can't give any evidence, and apologize. I was only ever at one TAM, and I stayed in my room a lot, out of shyness. I didn't get to observe much. I've not been to any other skeptical or crit thinking type of events.
 
Alright, this whole subject is officially completely retarded.

The relationship between the skeptical movement and higher education is EXTREMELY close. Philosophy departments aren't unique in their sexism, it's merely that the women in that subject have chosen to expose the crap they deal with. Women in engineering and biology and physics and mathematics and everything else will have incredibly similar stories to tell.

Now, maybe the "skeptical movement" is wholly composed of only those people who are both in academia and are also not sexist, but since many of the higher profile women in the movement complain of the same behavior, it's a pretty good bet that similar attitudes exist in both arenas.

Obviously the main difference is that TAM and related events are minimally important for an academic's professional career. If you'll notice, I introduced this problem in my first post on the subject. Thus, the sexism is likely to be driven less by professional competition, meaning it's generally of a less malignant variety. That's not much solace for the women who have to deal with it, though.

Look, 50% of my law school class was female. The top handful of students were mostly female. The people who received the most prestigious placements after graduation were female. Every single one of them has endless stories of being harrassed, minimized, sexualized, and worse in the legal academic and professional community. THe stories are EXACTLY the same as what the woman at the blaghag post was discussing.

You're basically waving your hand and trying to argue that even though sexism occurs in academia, all the major disciplines that feed into the "skeptical movement" (psychology, biology, astrophysics, philosophy...), every level of the professional world from the most prestigious to the least impressive, and it all occurs in basically the same way (the stories are identical), somehow there is this universe of Skeptopia that is immune from the dynamic that exists everywhere else, even though the women involved report the same sort of treatment.

Thus, the reason that philosophy issue is relevant to this discussion is that the sort of person (man or woman) who will be interested in attending TAM or related conferences as a leisure activity are likely to be drawn from that academic environment. If they're dealing with that BS in their professional life then notice the same dynamic when they engage with whatever this "skeptical movement" is, it doesn't take a massive leap to conclude that sexism may have a part in keeping women away.

Now, to be fair, I would bet the low attendance of women has more to do with ambivalence than any actual sexism-based repulsion. Obvioulsy some women feel that way and have expressed such, but the biggest culprit in keeping women away from these events is likely the fact that they've never heard of them or have no idea what goes on.
TraneW, please, if you don't have evidence that is specific to the skeptic/atheist/freethinking communities, your evidence IS NOT RELEVANT TO THIS THREAD. No one is refuting that the sexism you are documenting exists. You are preaching to the choir.

How has the stuff you are citing specifically sent skeptical/atheist/freethinking women fleeing from our formal events?
 
TraneW, please, if you don't have evidence that is specific to the skeptic/atheist/freethinking communities, your evidence IS NOT RELEVANT TO THIS THREAD. No one is refuting that the sexism you are documenting exists. You are preaching to the choir.

Then what makes "skepticism" different. The major players are all the same as those that exist in the fields where the sexism is obvious.

When they're in academia, sexism is obvious, when they attend TAM, all that sexism goes away. Only the non-sexist members of academia attend.

How has the stuff you are citing specifically sent skeptical/atheist/freethinking women fleeing from our formal events?

You're trying to narrow the acceptable data set to the point that you'll never find anything. The only "evidence" that will satisfy your request is a woman who turned from skepticism because of sexism then decided to blog about it.

When you stack the deck, you're going to find what you want, which is a lack of data.

But again, since "Skepticism" is almost entirely made up of people from higher education (both in terms of the leaders/speakers and attendees), that's a good place to look. Why would women who fight their way through endless BS in their professional academic lives go spend their leisure time with the very same people that are giving them ******

If your interest is trying to figure out why the male-female ratio is as it is, or even more broadly, how sexism is affecting women in the skeptical movement, this is not a good approach. If you want to try to infer from a lack of specific stories from women to a conclusion that therefore sexism isn't turning women off, you're on the right track.

Look, if you really take this issue seriously, start a webpage like the one I linked from women in philosophy. THis might take some effort, but I bet if you involve blaghag or Greta Christina or even Skepchick, I bet you'll get hundreds of stories in a relatively short time. You linked the website with the abuse victims, shoot that blogger an e-mail, tell her what you're looking for, and I bet she'll get her readers involved.
 
Last edited:
Skeptic Ginger, just in case, this is what Rebecca said in the latest SGU episode:

Rebecca Watson said:
...I think I've been pretty clear from day one that there's nothing especially misogynist about men and women in the the atheist / skeptical communities…


53 mins 19 secs -> @ http://www.theskepticsguide.org/archive/podcastinfo.aspx?mid=1&pid=312
RW has made a point a couple times now that she didn't mean everyone or the majority and even said the majority was just peachy keen. I suppose that means this thread to collect evidence that sexism is worse, the same or less within the skeptic/atheist/free thinking communities is moot.


But let's go back to the initial events here and see if that reiteration changes things. It's hard to read this blog again. :( It's worse after all the discussion we've had.

Watson on naming names at the CFI conference
I hear a lot of misogyny from skeptics and atheists, but when ancient anti-woman rhetoric like the above is repeated verbatim by a young woman online, it validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another....
It's important to stop here and read what the comment was RW was referring to:

Stef McGraf's supposed dismissive comment as quoted by RW:
My concern is that she takes issue with a man showing interest in her. What’s wrong with that? How on earth does that justify him as creepy? Are we not sexual beings? Let’s review, it’s not as if he touched her or made an unsolicited sexual comment; he merely asked if she’d like to come back to his room. She easily could have said (and I’m assuming did say), “No thanks, I’m tired and would like to go to my room to sleep.”
That is "ancient anti-woman rhetoric" that "validates ... misogyny"? (The rest of McGraf's comments are here if anyone is interested. )


If RW is seeing boogymen under the bad as it appears to some of us, then her claims of evidence are suspect. I'll continue with my attempt at verification.


RW went on to cite a single anecdote we should add to the data collection here:
After my talk, I met a ton of amazing young men and women who came to talk to me about their own experiences. Some were considering not attending the conference due to the anti-woman sentiments they were reading. Some told me that the previous year, they watched in horror as Heidi Anderson was shouted down while on the stage discussing feminist issues. I think that the intelligent, thoughtful, caring people I met at the conference were very much in the majority, but are often out-shouted by an angry minority.

I'll look into this incident. If someone already has links, feel free to beat me to it.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, I simply don't find that completely true. When I was young and shallow, you had to be at least "cute" to get my sexual attention. You only had to be male to get my attention in general.

Yeah, but the ones with the power and the ability to get us places are predominantly straight white males remember.

My broader point is that I think sometimes women forget that a) their gender can be as much an advantage as it can be a disadvantage on occasions and b) the average white male doesn't walk through life having rose petals thrown at his feet by fawning admirers.

I think that is an ingrained sexist belief. I need another word here, myself, one for 'sexist' when there is no malice perceived in it. So this wouldn't be the kind of sexist comment I'd hold against you, rather that makes me want to point out that your stereotype is mistaken.

Not my type but Brad Pitt's looks, for example, surely contributes to his income and success. I think looks in a guy can go a long way.

Well of course they can, but your average guy doesn't look like Brad Pitt. Your average guy isn't going to get very far in life flirting with the boss. Your average guy doesn't get to play the 'I'm different, and therefore interesting, everyone sit and listen to my unique perspective' card.

Yes the vast majority of people in positions of privilege are white straight middle aged men, that doesn't mean that all white straight men have the same privilege and I think sometimes people forget that.

To hear some women speak you would think being a man is like winning the lottery every day because we never have to worry about anything at all. I wish it were so.
 
Then what makes "skepticism" different. The major players are all the same as those that exist in the fields where the sexism is obvious....
You're trying to narrow the acceptable data set to the point that you'll never find anything. The only "evidence" that will satisfy your request is a woman who turned from skepticism because of sexism then decided to blog about it.

When you stack the deck, you're going to find what you want, which is a lack of data.[snip].
TW, feel free to start your own thread with your own goal. I told you, you are preaching to the choir. I can't imagine a single skeptic who isn't aware of the gender discrimination within the academic and scientific fields. We all grew up with it, some more so than others. For Pete's sake, I'm in one of the most affected professional fields there is, nursing. Our whole profession has been affected by sexism and still is. Have you seen my thread complaining about the current J&J ads promoting nurses as buying into superstition along with science?


I have a very narrow goal here, yes. I'm not trying to test the hypothesis sexism exists. I am trying to validate or invalidate a very specific charge RW made, clearly defined in my last post above: "Some were considering not attending the conference due to the anti-woman sentiments they were reading."

IMO, RW is seeing monsters where there are none. I'm looking for specific incidents because people are doing what you are doing, making assumptions without evidence. Your argument is, it must be there, not, I have evidence confirming that. What's wrong with looking for the direct evidence rather than making assumptions using indirect evidence?
 
Last edited:
....

Yes the vast majority of people in positions of privilege are white straight middle aged men, that doesn't mean that all white straight men have the same privilege and I think sometimes people forget that.

To hear some women speak you would think being a man is like winning the lottery every day because we never have to worry about anything at all. I wish it were so.
:id:

Think about it:
White straight men get special treatment.
Beautiful women get special treatment.

You are missing the obvious, beauty is simply being judged by different standards in each gender. :)
 
Last edited:
TW, feel free to start your own thread with your own goal. I told you, you are preaching to the choir. I can't imagine a single skeptic who isn't aware of the gender discrimination within the academic and scientific fields. We all grew up with it, some more so than others. For Pete's sake, I'm in one of the most affected professional fields there is, nursing. Our whole profession has been affected by sexism and still is. Have you seen my thread complaining about the current J&J ads promoting nurses as buying into superstition along with science?


I have a very narrow goal here, yes. I'm not trying to test the hypothesis sexism exists. I am trying to validate or invalidate a very specific charge RW made, clearly defined in my last post above: "Some were considering not attending the conference due to the anti-woman sentiments they were reading."

IMO, RW is seeing monsters where there are none. I'm looking for specific incidents because people are doing what you are doing, making assumptions without evidence. Your argument is, it must be there, not, I have evidence confirming that. What's wrong with looking for the direct evidence rather than making assumptions using indirect evidence?

Alright, it's your thread. You won't get any such evidence this way. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
 
:id:

Think about it:
White straight men get special treatment.
Beautiful women get special treatment.

You are missing the obvious, beauty is simply being judged by different standards in each gender. :)

I'm probably going to regret asking this, but what special treatment do I supposedly get?

For example, are the majority of electronics engineers men because of special treatment?
 
The claim was made sexism among community members was keeping women from attending community events. I ask people to post the evidence. Support the claim.
What sort of evidence are you looking for? Are you looking for sociological studies? Or just anecdotes?

How are you defining sexism for the purpose of collecting evidence? Are you looking for examples of women who don't attend because they felt they weren't listened to or taken seriously because they were female? What about evidence of 'creepiness' or excess sexual attention leading women to decide against attending, does that count as evidence of sexism?

There is no need to document sexism in the society at large. No one refutes that it exists.
If you are wanting to compare sexism in the skeptical/atheist community to determine if it is better or worse, then the average level of sexism in society needs to be documented for comparison purposes. How do researchers measure sexism in a society?

What's wrong with looking for the direct evidence rather than making assumptions using indirect evidence?
There nothing wrong with looking for direct evidence. But in the absence of direct evidence, which is your current state, it is a reasonable assumption that the skeptical/atheist community will be similar unless you have reason to assume otherwise.

Personally, I don't find the 'skeptics are less sexist than the rest of the population" idea. I see no reason to assume that they are better (or worse) given their gender proportions than any other group/organization. But I've noticed that sexism seems to increase with the proportion of the gender in the organization and this seems to be true for both genders.

I'm probably going to regret asking this, but what special treatment do I supposedly get?

For example, are the majority of electronics engineers men because of special treatment?

I don't think so. This is an interesting question. The majority of engineers (all types) are white males and asian males. Women, in my estimation, are better represented in the engineering community than either blacks or hispanics. Does that mean the profession is both sexist and racist?

I don't think so. But it doesn't seem possible to speculate on why that discrepancy exists without it being perceived as racism or sexism. If you aren't willing to tolerate those accusations, you can't seem to have much of conversation about it on the internet.
 
Last edited:
Okay, let me try it again. Because men and women are sentient beings with minds and feelings. They are not inanimate things that can't feel or think, consent or refuse.

You haven't show how this distinction makes one iota of difference. In my view it doesn't. Looking at/commenting on an attractive woman is no different than looking at/commenting on a piece of art one likes. If I see a woman and say, "She's very beautiful" how is that any more sexist than looking at a painting and saying "That's really beautiful."

I've already said it isn't always sexism, or always sexist. That it depends on a number of things, and that each incident has to be weighed on its own merits.

Okay but I haven't seen where the incident that started all these threads has any aspect of sexism.

But what you felt or meant or intended isn't the determining factor. It's how it makes her feel, and that's going to, again, depend on a lot of variables.

I completely disagree. Just because someone takes offence at something doesn't make it sexism. People do not read minds and do not know if someone is having a bad day. The only reasonable criteria is how I feel and what I intend, not what she feels or thinks.

Myself, I like a little mild attention in that way, especially now that I rarely get such attention. I don't mind a simple wolf-whistle or appreciative look most of the time. If it goes beyond that, depending on how far and in what direction, I might mind.

But how is anyone to know that? They, in fact, can't know and can only use their own feelings and intentions to gauge. That's why I don't see anything wrong with what happened in the elevator. The guy asked, was rejected, and went on with his life. Nothing sexist in that.

I don't think it should be limited to that one word, though. I think there's an inherent aspect of power or dominance to most sexism.

I might agree with that upon consideration (give me awhile) but where is that in the incidents that have so far been discussed?

For instance, an anecdote only to illustrate the point: when I arrived at my brother-in-law's house, where I now live, he told me to consider myself "the lady of the house." I had no idea what he meant by that phrase, but not wanting to cause some kind of disagreement, I just nodded.

Later, my husband mentioned something to his brother about the condition of his home: it's filthy, and it was so when we arrived. My husband and I keep our bedroom clean, and we wash our dishes and do our laundry. But the rest of the house is simply nasty. (And the fuel ran out three days after we arrived, so there's been no hot water in the house since May 3.)

His brother said, "I told her she was the lady of the house. Maybe you can make her do what she's supposed to. I guess she's ignoring me. She doesn't even cook for me."

So, being "the lady of the house" meant he had appointed me as the housekeeper/cook/maid of all work for not only my husband and myself, but also for him. You don't find that a sexist assumption? I'm the woman, so the cleaning of his messes is my job, not his own?

My husband and I also noticed that his brother would automatically reject any ideas I suggested for our business. I started filtering everything through my husband, who is now being touted as the source of so many great ideas! :rolleyes: (I need to amend this. He has accepted a few of my ideas, but he accepted almost all of them when my husband presented them as his own.)

Okay, so I agree this is sexism but where is that in the incidents under discussion? And why is the claim being made about sexism in the skeptic community? Was RW's claim about sexism being rejected because she was a woman or because it wasn't sexism in the opinion of those rejecting it?

How was she being dominated? How was she being controlled?

Someone has to be. Whom do you suggest? If I say something hurtful to you, but I didn't mean it to hurt, are your feelings in it of no account?

But sexism isn't hurt feelings. That's the issue I am having. Racism isn't hurt feelings either. They may hurt the person's feelings but there is an actual discriminatory aspect that must be present. Saying that someone asking you to join them for coffee is sexism because you didn't want to be asked and your feelings are hurt is absurd.

Who gets to decide when someone is crying wolf?

It's easy to tell. When someone is claiming sexism when the act doesn't fit the bill is crying wolf.

Not being able to object without being belittled, condescended to, or told to stop whining about it is a good thing?

We have very different ideas about that.

That is a completely different issue and goes to the character/mood of the person you are disagreeing with. We often see the same thing happen on these forums, in fact, you and I have been involved in a few. :D

Is Dawkins' response to RW sexist? Well, does he have a habit of responding to males in the same manner? I think he does when I watch some of the responses he has made to others who disagree with him. So, that is just Dawkins' way of responding and not sexism at all. That in this case his abruptness is directed at a woman doesn't make it sexist.
 
I'm probably going to regret asking this, but what special treatment do I supposedly get?

For example, are the majority of electronics engineers men because of special treatment?
This is getting off topic. I am beginning to give up that I'll get any more evidence than I dig up myself so I'm going to answer. But I'd like to get back to the thread topic soon, if you don't mind.

You get higher wages and easier access to being hired if you take the employment field as a whole. I'm hoping the academic gender bias is decreasing but I don't know.
 
What sort of evidence are you looking for? Are you looking for sociological studies? Or just anecdotes?

How are you defining sexism for the purpose of collecting evidence? Are you looking for examples of women who don't attend because they felt they weren't listened to or taken seriously because they were female? What about evidence of 'creepiness' or excess sexual attention leading women to decide against attending, does that count as evidence of sexism?


If you are wanting to compare sexism in the skeptical/atheist community to determine if it is better or worse, then the average level of sexism in society needs to be documented for comparison purposes. How do researchers measure sexism in a society?


There nothing wrong with looking for direct evidence. But in the absence of direct evidence, which is your current state, it is a reasonable assumption that the skeptical/atheist community will be similar unless you have reason to assume otherwise.

Personally, I don't find the 'skeptics are less sexist than the rest of the population" idea. I see no reason to assume that they are better (or worse) given their gender proportions than any other group/organization. But I've noticed that sexism seems to increase with the proportion of the gender in the organization and this seems to be true for both genders.

Our Seattle Skeptics group is just not sexist as is being described by people with other experiences. And I've had less contact with the atheist group but the experiences I did have did not have any overt sexism.

I only hypothesize there should be less sexism in our community, but I have not tested the hypothesis. I base it on the more common that not awareness of religious sexism issues and the rejection of those. And on the community's emphasis on critical thinking rather than accepting traditional beliefs without question.

Does that mean there is no sexism? Of course not. But just as I'd expect to see more sexism at a right wing war rally and less at a liberal war protest, I think we have a much greater % of social liberal thinkers among us.



As for evidence, I'm looking for very specific incidents. So far the incidents I've found were a charge that guys couldn't get past "Boobquake" when Jen McCreight was talking about something else at another event, (not Jen's complaint, BTW), the response to Noblecaboose's concerns about the bordello themed Skepchic Party at TAM8, and I'm looking into the incident I just came across with Heidi Anderson being "shouted down" when she brought up feminist concerns.
 
We often see the same thing happen on these forums, in fact, you and I have been involved in a few. :D

We have, indeed, and as an aside, thank you for this conversation, and thanks to both of us for being able to have it without it denigrating into something...not good.

However, I suppose I have to let it go now, as it is rather a derail, and I seem unable to make my points clear. Not your fault, but mine. But thanks all the same. :)
 
Well I'm having trouble getting the details of the Heidi Anderson kerfuffle. I managed to track down that she presented in the 2010 CFI Student Leadership Conference, "I Seriously Doubt It - Moving Skepticism from Snark to Substance", a talk that was similar in theme to Plait's "Don't Be a Dick". Then she participated on a panel with Chris Mooney ("The Republican War on Science"). From the conference syllabus:
7:00 Heidi Anderson: "I Seriously Doubt That: Moving Skepticism from Snark to Substance"
8:00 Panel: Chris Mooney, Robert Price, Heidi Anderson – Ronald A. Lindsay, Moderator

There's nothing much in Anderson's post event blog entry: The Ethics of Conversation - Thoughts on Confrontation vs. Accommodation

It was/is a controversial topic. I fail to see that comments would have been about feminism and I can't find anything about what those might have been. If people weren't polite during the panel discussion, it would not surprise me. I found a brief mention on a skeptic deist's blog that implied Anderson's weight was brought up in a comment but he was so vague about it, who knows. He referred to a picture of a skeptic hippo and said there were no words to go with the picture. I can only guess what he was referring to.


Does anyone else know what happened at this conference panel discussion?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom