EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Because paintings and cars are objects, Qayak. Women are not. Men are not. Men and women have feelings, and histories, and individual personalities.

Again, because cars and works of art aren't people. They are objects. They are not sexual beings, but things. To reduce a woman or a man to the level of an object in exactly the way you describe has a label.

It's "sexual objectification," which I suppose falls under the aegis of "sexism." It's a subset of sexism, if you will, or perhaps a piece of the puzzle that is sexism.

Across the board, universally, 100% of the time, for all people in all circumstances? No, of course not. But there are times when it is exactly that. The when would be when the person being objectified feels that's what's happening. The jogging woman, not being aware of your momentary thoughts as you drove past, can't feel objectified by you, because she's not at all aware of you.

But in a face-to-face situation, she very well might. Or she might not.

This is exactly why no one can come up with a universal "code of behavior" for this.
There is no such thing; every incident must be taken as an individual incident, and weighed on its own merits each and every time, with all of the variables taken into consideration at the time.

And above all, the feelings of the other person need to be considered. What you meant to do isn't at all as important to me as how what you did made me feel. And if your actions or words make me feel objectified, I want to be able to tell you that without being belittled, or condescended to, or told to stop whining about it. Because that is sexism.
Not to diminish your point which can be applied to many situations, but are you saying anytime one has a purely physical attraction to someone they are automatically sexist?


You illustrate one of the problems here and that is perception of what is sexist. I understand there has been discussion in the forum where dismissing our physical attraction to each other as 'biology' was unsatisfactory to some, and I haven't yet read those threads (linked to above). But surely we can't just deny our biology completely.


There has to be a better way to define sexism. I think it depends on the context and the manner said physical attraction is expressed, not the fact it merely exists.
 
Not to diminish your point which can be applied to many situations, but are you saying anytime one has a purely physical attraction to someone they are automatically sexist?

No. I am not saying that. I am specifically addressing Qayak's use of "work of art or car." Please read my post again; I was quite specific.


You illustrate one of the problems here and that is perception of what is sexist. I understand there has been discussion in the forum where dismissing our physical attraction to each other as 'biology' was unsatisfactory to some, and I haven't yet read those threads (linked to above). But surely we can't just deny our biology completely.

Who suggested that we do? Not I.


There has to be a better way to define sexism. I think it depends on the context and the manner said physical attraction is expressed, not the fact it merely exists.

Which is exactly what I said:

Across the board, universally, 100% of the time, for all people in all circumstances? No, of course not. But there are times when it is exactly that. The when would be when the person being objectified feels that's what's happening. The jogging woman, not being aware of your momentary thoughts as you drove past, can't feel objectified by you, because she's not at all aware of you.

But in a face-to-face situation, she very well might. Or she might not.

This is exactly why no one can come up with a universal "code of behavior" for this.
There is no such thing; every incident must be taken as an individual incident, and weighed on its own merits each and every time, with all of the variables taken into consideration at the time.

I also apologize if my comments on Qayak's comments are derailing. I don't intend that, but I felt it was important to address what he'd said.
 
Last edited:
....
I also apologize if my comments on Qayak's comments are derailing. I don't intend that, but I felt it was important to address what he'd said.
You are not derailing. We can't collect data on sexism within the community if we have different definitions of what we are looking for.

slingblade said:
Because paintings and cars are objects, Qayak. Women are not.
I did read your post, so let me ask a different way. Are there any circumstances where someone could enjoy a person's physical beauty like a painting without being sexist?

I totally agree if one tried to write up the rules it would be problematic because there are so many different circumstances to consider.
 
I did read your post, so let me ask a different way. Are there any circumstances where someone could enjoy a person's physical beauty like a painting without being sexist?

I'm not Slingblade, but of course there are. I enjoy the physical beauty of the guy who does the Old Spice adverts.
for those who it hasn't reached

And Jessica Ennis in the Powerade adverts

The problem comes when the Old Spice guy gives a lecture on quantum physics, and I go up to him afterwards and tell him the lecture was great, and ask could he take his clothes off and sit on this horse for a minute.
 
You are not derailing. We can't collect data on sexism within the community if we have different definitions of what we are looking for.

Okay, thank you. I take your thread rules seriously, and didn't want to be seen as disregarding them. I think they're needed, and you're right to have them.


I did read your post, so let me ask a different way. Are there any circumstances where someone could enjoy a person's physical beauty like a painting without being sexist?

I'm not sure, but I think the difference lies, at least somewhat, between thinking it, and saying and/or acting like it's the primary concern. You can't really control what you think, as much as you can control how you act or what you say. It's fine to think a woman or a man is really attractive. But it's wrong to stop there. The term, "whole package" comes most readily to mind.

We all know that physical attraction matters a lot to most people as sexual beings. That's not to say that everyone must be a knock-out, but if your looks repel instead of attract, that kind of defeats the whole thing, right?

I'm with SgtBaker: no one sees me as a sexual being anymore, except my husband. I'm no longer youthful and attractive. And yeah, I do miss it. I miss being the girl that turned heads and got flirted with. Mostly. Part of me is rather glad that's done with. It was tiring.

However, now that I'm no longer considered sexy, I'm starting to notice that I'm pretty much invisible. It isn't "well, now that they're not all thinking of how best to get me into bed, they'll respect my mind more." Pfft. They don't even notice I'm in the room. At least I used to be able to "hook them with my looks," and then show them my brains, and a lot of them noticed. I used to have a shirt that said, right across my ample cleavage, "All this, and brains, too." And I used to know guys who eagerly agreed with that. Except, it used to be, "Yeah, she's pretty, but damn, she's smart, too."

It was the "but" that really hurt. It would have been better if "but" had been "and." Just like, "He's handsome, but he's smart." "And" is better in that sentence, as well. As if being both is an amazing combination, rarely seen in the wild.

It's not amazing. It's how many of us really are, and it is how many of us want to be seen.

I totally agree if one tried to write up the rules it would be problematic because there are so many different circumstances to consider.

I guess the only "rule" we could really have is a revamping of "try not to be a dick."
"Try not to be a penis on legs." "Try not to be a walking vagina."

Try to appreciate and value the person as a whole. Not as a hole.
 
Last edited:
Scene: Skeptic Female Number 1 paints the words "Do me now" in chocolate onto the bare stomach of Skeptic Female Number 2 at Skeptic gathering.

Evidence is in picture form. A picture of an innocent time.

Many words have been written about sexism and women in the skeptic movement. An individual's words may be futile at this point. At least, my words may be.

But I am looking at a picture of two happy women, engaging in innocent fun. Fun that might not be had in this present time. People change. Randy young ladies become thoughtful and studious women. And social pressures weigh heavily upon those who pause and think long enough.

Things are blowing up, it seems. I would like my contribution to critical thinking to be more of just that: thinking. Especially as a woman. Chocolate not included.
 
Scene: Skeptic Female Number 1 paints the words "Do me now" in chocolate onto the bare stomach of Skeptic Female Number 2 at Skeptic gathering.

Evidence is in picture form. A picture of an innocent time.

Many words have been written about sexism and women in the skeptic movement. An individual's words may be futile at this point. At least, my words may be.

But I am looking at a picture of two happy women, engaging in innocent fun. Fun that might not be had in this present time. People change. Randy young ladies become thoughtful and studious women. And social pressures weigh heavily upon those who pause and think long enough.

Things are blowing up, it seems. I would like my contribution to critical thinking to be more of just that: thinking. Especially as a woman. Chocolate not included.

Not to derail, but maybe this is a burden that is finally catching up to the digital generation.

My sins of youth are only found in the fading memories of my colleagues, but my kids will have their histories searchable for all time. For good or for bad.
 
Not to derail, but maybe this is a burden that is finally catching up to the digital generation.

My sins of youth are only found in the fading memories of my colleagues, but my kids will have their histories searchable for all time. For good or for bad.

I think that this might be a good thing, it might make people relax a bit.
 
OK, back to the evidence collecting. :)

I looked through this linked thread, I’m in need of a new word. Library Lady gave a synopsis of 'we've come a long way baby' and opined that using the name, skepchick was perhaps regressive.

Words matter and hopefully we are passed dismissing the importance of changing the language to include more gender neutral vocabulary. Yes Virginia, it does matter.

I started out as "beskeptical". Someone suggested "beskeptigal" when I was mistaken for a guy a tad too often in the BAUT forum which at the time was still the BA forum. At the time, 'gal', didn't fit my image of myself. Just my personal impression of the term. I debated using "skeptigirl" because "girl" was along the same line as "chick", maybe even worse. "Girl" did not and still doesn't bother me. However, I am well aware of the problem using girl for a grown woman and it can be sexist in the wrong context.


But I digress, ... there are two issues here. One, why did people often assume I was a guy on the BAUT forum? No surprise, if you sound intelligent discussing science and no one knows your gender people default to 'male'. That's more benign sexism as far as being offensive goes, but important to change as far as the image goes of skeptical community women.

So, how many women have experienced an assumption they were male in the forum? And how many times have any of us made the wrong assumption about the gender of a fellow forum poster? I know because of my own experience I often use gender neutral language with people whose gender I don't know because I can't tell from their conversation which gender they are.


The second issue is simply to ask, are there other examples of sexist language on the forum? I don't find 'chick' or 'girl' demeaning because I'm comfortable with my self esteem. But I side with Library Lady that the name 'skepchick' perhaps does not convey the message that group is trying to convey, (their business, of course). You can imagine if they called themselves the "little skeptic girls" the message that name would include. I'm not really interested in forum names, but are there examples of potentially sexist but perhaps unintended event titles, discussion titles, or thread titles? Have there been any particularly sexist speakers at any events anyone recalls?
 
Last edited:
So, how many women have experienced an assumption they were male in the forum?

Me. But I admit, I was trying not to be seen as female when I first got here, because I thought it might get me taken more seriously until I got established. And yeah, it worked.



And how many times have any of us made the wrong assumption about the gender of a fellow forum poster? I know because of my own experience I often use gender neutral language with people whose gender I don't know because I can't tell from their conversation which gender they are.

(somehow, this part dropped out of my reply, sorry.) I have not known if a poster was male or female sometimes, because of a masculine or gender-neutral forum name, or avatar. I've had to go the "he/she" route a few times.


The second issue is simply to ask, are there other examples of sexist language on the forum? I don't find 'chick' or 'girl' demeaning because I'm comfortable with my self esteem. But I side with Library Lady that the name 'skepchick' perhaps does not convey the message that group is trying to convey, (their business, of course). You can imagine if they called themselves the "little skeptic girls" the message that name would include. I'm not really interested in forum names, but are there examples of potentially sexist but perhaps unintended event titles, discussion titles, or thread titles? Have there been any particularly sexist speakers at any events anyone recalls?

Well...I'd have to give this some thought as to the forum.

My only claim to skeptic fame is the time Penn called me a "cantankerous bitch" at TAM, which I took as a compliment, actually, given the circumstances. If I'd been a man, however, he'd probably have called me a "cantankerous bastard," so I can't say I judged it as sexist, myself. Other's mileage may vary.
 
Last edited:
However, now that I'm no longer considered sexy, I'm starting to notice that I'm pretty much invisible. It isn't "well, now that they're not all thinking of how best to get me into bed, they'll respect my mind more." Pfft. They don't even notice I'm in the room.

At the danger of a slight de-rail, welcome to the world of the vast majority of men. We never had the option to 'hook them with our looks', mind you.
 
At the danger of a slight de-rail, welcome to the world of the vast majority of men. We never had the option to 'hook them with our looks', mind you.

Sorry, I simply don't find that completely true. When I was young and shallow, you had to be at least "cute" to get my sexual attention. You only had to be male to get my attention in general.
 
As for a larger scale epidemic, the skepicism movement is tied closely to the academic world, specifically science and philosophy departments (The major figures in the movement are almost all philosophers--Harris, Dennett--or scientists--Dawkins, Myers...etc). Thus, it may be worthwhile to study the incidents of harrassment in those settings:

http://www.insidehighered.com/news/...s_consider_what_to_do_about_sexual_harassment

Here's another blog on the issue:
http://www.newappsblog.com/2011/03/...rassment-in-the-philosophy-profession.html#tp

Here's a blog that collects individual examples of harrassment:
http://beingawomaninphilosophy.wordpress.com/about-2/

Here's a movement of philosophers trying to involve more women in journals and conferences:
http://feministphilosophers.wordpress.com/gendered-conference-campaign/

Obviously philosophy departments aren't the exact same thing as the "skeptical movement," but just like men, the female philosophers are a natural fit as speakers at these conferences. If they put up with all the nonsense described at those various links in their professional lives, I can't imagine many of them would be excited to run off and deal with similar crap at less formal events.

I think it's an unjustifiable leap to go from "X is a problem in the academic philosophical community" to "X is a problem in the skeptical community", simply because academic philosophers are very, very far from the majority of card-carrying skeptics. You might as well argue that since Ian Plimer is a geologist that any problem in the geological community is probably a problem in the atheist community.

I also think you need to be careful to avoid the base rate fallacy. If we cherry-pick every anecdote of sexism from every community we can somehow associate with organised skepticism no doubt we can assemble a big basket of cherries, but that doesn't get us any closer to answering the question of whether sexism is more or less of a problem in the organised skeptical community than anywhere else. It could still very well be that despite the big bowl of cherries organised skepticism is still less sexist than most other communities, not more sexist.

While the OP did call for anecdotes pertaining to the organised skeptical community, I think we should be cautious about throwing our net wider than the organised skeptical community.
 
I think it's an unjustifiable leap to go from "X is a problem in the academic philosophical community" to "X is a problem in the skeptical community", simply because academic philosophers are very, very far from the majority of card-carrying skeptics. You might as well argue that since Ian Plimer is a geologist that any problem in the geological community is probably a problem in the atheist community.

I also think you need to be careful to avoid the base rate fallacy. If we cherry-pick every anecdote of sexism from every community we can somehow associate with organised skepticism no doubt we can assemble a big basket of cherries, but that doesn't get us any closer to answering the question of whether sexism is more or less of a problem in the organised skeptical community than anywhere else. It could still very well be that despite the big bowl of cherries organised skepticism is still less sexist than most other communities, not more sexist.

While the OP did call for anecdotes pertaining to the organised skeptical community, I think we should be cautious about throwing our net wider than the organised skeptical community.

Right, that's why I acknowledged the distinction in my post. It's not a 1:1 matchup, but as a philosophy graduate, I know that world better than the "skeptical community," or at least the series of conferences being mentioned.

The reason why philosophy is uniquely relevant to this topic is that a sizeable chunk of people in the skeptical community arrived there via philosophy (and certainly other disciplines). It's highly likely that someone will end up speaking at an atheist or skeptical conference because of work they did via a philosophy department.

Additionally, a lot of this sexism in the philosophy world really exploded recently. It therefore provides a great deal of the data requested in the OP.

You're certainly welcome to distinguish between the environments, but since "skepticism" is a topic that supervenes over a range of academic disciplines, and just about everyone who speaks at these conferences went through many years of school, it's a good place to start. The journals in the parent disciplines are more established, the populations are larger, the history is greater, similarities and distinctions will be instructive.

The thread title describes most North American philosophy departments pretty well.
 
I'm with SgtBaker: no one sees me as a sexual being anymore, except my husband. I'm no longer youthful and attractive. And yeah, I do miss it. I miss being the girl that turned heads and got flirted with. Mostly. Part of me is rather glad that's done with. It was tiring.

However, now that I'm no longer considered sexy, I'm starting to notice that I'm pretty much invisible. It isn't "well, now that they're not all thinking of how best to get me into bed, they'll respect my mind more." Pfft. They don't even notice I'm in the room. At least I used to be able to "hook them with my looks," and then show them my brains, and a lot of them noticed. I used to have a shirt that said, right across my ample cleavage, "All this, and brains, too." And I used to know guys who eagerly agreed with that. Except, it used to be, "Yeah, she's pretty, but damn, she's smart, too."

First off, you nailed that perfectly. I imagine that people (because I do think men experience it to) just prefer the package deal. They want their eyes and their brain stimulated. OTOH, I've noticed the inverse effect, as well,; the hotter the person is, the less they need to qualify as being intelligent; She's really smart because she used a three syllable word, completely out of context? I just explained quantum field theory!
 
At the danger of a slight de-rail, welcome to the world of the vast majority of men. We never had the option to 'hook them with our looks', mind you.
I think that is an ingrained sexist belief. I need another word here, myself, one for 'sexist' when there is no malice perceived in it. So this wouldn't be the kind of sexist comment I'd hold against you, rather that makes me want to point out that your stereotype is mistaken.

Not my type but Brad Pitt's looks, for example, surely contributes to his income and success. I think looks in a guy can go a long way.
 
Sorry, I simply don't find that completely true. When I was young and shallow, you had to be at least "cute" to get my sexual attention. You only had to be male to get my attention in general.
My tendency to pick bad partners was in part because I liked a certain 'look' in a guy. Not that all my partners were bad guys, mind you.

When it comes to the complaint too many men hit on the women at our events, one can't help but wonder if a guy that the woman perceived was quite attractive was making the pass how that would be perceived.
 
I think it's an unjustifiable leap to go from "X is a problem in the academic philosophical community" to "X is a problem in the skeptical community", simply because academic philosophers are very, very far from the majority of card-carrying skeptics. You might as well argue that since Ian Plimer is a geologist that any problem in the geological community is probably a problem in the atheist community.

I also think you need to be careful to avoid the base rate fallacy. If we cherry-pick every anecdote of sexism from every community we can somehow associate with organised skepticism no doubt we can assemble a big basket of cherries, but that doesn't get us any closer to answering the question of whether sexism is more or less of a problem in the organised skeptical community than anywhere else. It could still very well be that despite the big bowl of cherries organised skepticism is still less sexist than most other communities, not more sexist.

While the OP did call for anecdotes pertaining to the organised skeptical community, I think we should be cautious about throwing our net wider than the organised skeptical community.
The reason I stayed away from these was that there are plenty of places we can find sexism and bias against women. Certainly many scientific and academic fields only recently became the realm of equality among genders. There's a lot of leftover sexism. I'm 100% certain you can find it in these fields and in academia.

Skeptics/atheists/freethinkers are unique in that critical thinking and recognizing dogma and throwing it off are the focus of these groups. We need direct evidence, not indirect evidence.
 
Right, that's why I acknowledged the distinction in my post. It's not a 1:1 matchup, but as a philosophy graduate, I know that world better than the "skeptical community," or at least the series of conferences being mentioned.

I'd say it's nothing like a 1:1 matchup. What percentage of philosophy conference attendees are career philosophers with higher degrees in philosophy? What percentage of skeptical conference attendees are career philosophers with higher degrees in philosophy? Unless my ideas about organised skepticism in the USA are way off base I'd guess that you were looking at between a 1:10 and 1:1000 matchup in membership, and that's before you take into account the fact that sexual politics and behaviour in the career academy might differ from sexual politics and behaviour in primarily social groups like organised skeptical conferences.

The reason why philosophy is uniquely relevant to this topic is that a sizeable chunk of people in the skeptical community arrived there via philosophy (and certainly other disciplines). It's highly likely that someone will end up speaking at an atheist or skeptical conference because of work they did via a philosophy department.

What percentage is a "sizeable chunk", and what is your evidence for this percentage?

Additionally, a lot of this sexism in the philosophy world really exploded recently. It therefore provides a great deal of the data requested in the OP.

Wanting something to be relevant doesn't make it relevant. If it's not relevant it's not data.

You're certainly welcome to distinguish between the environments, but since "skepticism" is a topic that supervenes over a range of academic disciplines, and just about everyone who speaks at these conferences went through many years of school, it's a good place to start. The journals in the parent disciplines are more established, the populations are larger, the history is greater, similarities and distinctions will be instructive.

You are equivocating here between skepticism as a very broad intellectual field and organised skepticism as a social phenomenon. I think the availability heuristic is fooling you into thinking that the data you already have is more relevant than it really is. You should be searching for data which is actually directly relevant to the subject at hand, not trying to stretch for reasons to justify using irrelevant data that you had in hand already.
 
OK, I finished the 10 page bordello thread. On the one hand the thread devolved into nonsense with a smattering of sexist comments. There were a few rude remarks aimed at Skeptifem who actually had made some reasonable points and some of the reactions were definitely sexist, demeaning her opinions and points with sexist stereotyped descriptions of her and her comments. And the initial point of the thread was quickly lost with the argument following a straw man that Noblecaboose's concern was the bordello theme alone. NC really said the theme was not a good choice for TAM.

But on the other hand, having been on this forum a long time, not being afraid to get involved in controversy, and not having the most passive posting style, I have seen a large percentage of threads devolve the same way. The insults may have had a different flavor, but they were otherwise essentially the same. One need merely peruse the AAH threads to see how awful we can be toward each other.

There are a couple of forum members whose comments are very frequently sexist. And a thread like the bordello thread seemed to bring a bit of sexism out in otherwise not so inclined members. We have men in the community. Sexist comments are not that hard to find in the forum, some as jokes, some as insulting to women the guys might use other insults for if the person they were insulting was male.


We are back to the question, is the sexism on the forum particularly pronounced. I'd say it's there, but hard to quantify if it causes many women to stay away from the forum. It appears to have played a role in NC leaving the forum.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom