EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

I assure you it is a legitimate inquiry. I cited the disclaimer in all honesty about where I thought the evidence stood, and what I thought about women handling benign come-ons.

But as a skeptic, I have no more desire to dismiss a real problem than I have to buy a contrived one based on declarations with little substance. I will look at your links thoroughly before commenting further. I don't suggest I will be without bias looking at the evidence, I have what I consider is a liberated female view. I think it's an oxymoron to be a feminist that wants to be coddled. But I do have a desire to be honest about the evidence.

Right, but you have a rather bizarre notion of what it means to be "coddled." I will give you the benefit of the doubt, but I am guessing we will see a directed effort on your part to minimize and excuse almost every example of sexual harrassment or sexism offered (if anyone cares enough to post in your thread at this point).
 
Last edited:
Well, I'm having a hard time seeing the expression of interest as sexist. So I'm just waiting to see how the thread progresses.

As for my own opinion of sexism, I have some examples. Having people assume weakness and incapableness of me because I am a woman is sexist.

Agreed.

Snide comments that tie criticism to my gender apply.

Agreed.

I was called a skeptic bimbo once on the politics forum. Since I have a master's degree and a successful professional career the ad hom was absurd. That qualified as a sexist comment.

Not sure I agree. I called someone on this forum a bimbo but it wasn't because they were female. I call men bimbos as well. But, I can see how it can be sexist if it is only based on one being female as the older definition of bimbo implies.

If someone ignores everything about you except your body, that can be sexist. This is not the same as simply admiring someone's physical features. It takes more than that. You'd have to never consider anything about women except their bodies.

But that's what I did with that woman. I only considered her body and clothes but the clothes only because of the way they fit her body.

That's the disconnect I see. A man is not sexist because he finds a woman attractive just like a woman who finds men attractive is not sexist. If it were, only people who found men and women equally attractive would not be sexist.

To me, that isn't what sexist means at all. Sexist must carry a component of denying someone something based on their gender. Which is why I don't think the elevator incident, and most others people complain about, are sexist.

And in the culture I exist in, when guys treat women as "them" and the guys as "us" it can be very sexist.

Agreed but it runs both ways. Most men will do more for a woman than they will for a man. Although people don't often hear complaints about it, it is still sexist against men.

Of course, that has to be balanced with the fact that people tend to do more for people they find attractive. So a man finding a woman attractive and doing more for her is not necessarily sexist. Each incident would have to be looked at.

I think if a speaker at one of our conferences was ignored except for comments about her looks, that would be sexist. I really have not seen that occurring though. If I thought a male speaker were good looking, I can't see that would be sexist unless I only considered his looks and not his talk, so just admiring a female speaker's appearance is not enough to be sexist.

I don't think who one is attracted to qualifies as sexism regardless of the circumstances. If one was to dismiss a woman's talk just because she is a woman, that would be sexist but to not be as interested in her talk as you are in her body isn't sexism, it is evidence of a poor/uninteresting topic. The reverse, with a man giving the talk, is also true.

I am just having trouble seeing any of this stuff as sexist. No one is being denied anything they would otherwise be entitled to.
 
So overtures towards lovemaking are insults ?

Even talking to an attractive person is 'hitting on her' , even if the attraction is to her personality ?

Sounds like we ought to make social interaction illegal.
 
If I may chime in, here. What we have is a myriad of diffent personalities coming together with a common link but with varying foundational beliefs. I see a parallel issue within my own little local atheist group, though it doesn't involve sexism. We have one thing in common, we are atheists; that's it. We have our monthly library meeting where we discuss what's going on in the news and the conversation tends to digress into personal experiences, personal points of view, and possible solutions/counters to whatever group of politics we would like to challenge.

In Melbourne, Fl, the second Friday of every month is Friday fest (the road closes and a bunch of local business' advertise). Every so often we put up a table advertising our existence. On these more social events, there is a lot less group discussion and more instances of breaking off into smaller groups, where conversation waxes and waines. Why? Because the only thing we really have in common is our atheism. In the subtext, different things are important to each one of us. One person's "the problem is..." is another person's, "Meh!"

I have never been to a skeptic convention but I imagine that the same happens. Different people go there to see different topics addressed. Some of those people, men and women, might also attend with the hopes of meeting someone with similar views. With so many varying personalities, you are going to also find varying levels of tolerance. So, really, no matter where you go or how careful you are, someone is going to be offended

Now, onto the sexism; I do not see a large sampling of sexism. So far, I've only heard 2 examples of sexism, some of the responses to RW desire to talk about women's issues, even then, they were purely anecdotal. Hitting on someone does not automatically equate to sexism. While their are instances where making sexual advances at say, a woman, because your intent is to reduce the importance of what they are saying to the sexuality of their being; it's sort of reminding a person of their place but that is a bold accusation and requires a little more than the discomfort of being shown attention, to prove it. The other comment RW used as an example of sexism was that the reason there are more men than women is because women aren't as logical/rational/skeptical (I don't remember what word she used), that is a blatently sexist view. "We need more women here so we can **** them," while is may be a little bit dawgist (although kind of one of those funny because of it's shock value), I have a hard time calling that sexist.

I am glad you made this thread Skeptic Ginger because I am intersted in seeing examples of actual sexism, not unwanted advances. I am not deminishing the importance of appropriate advances but that is so subjective, it would be virtually impossible to make a suits all rule about it. The claim is that there is sexism, though, and it's a harsh thing to accuse someone of. What I would like to see are examples of discrimination based on sex or blind stereotyping based on sex.
 
Right, but you have a rather bizarre notion of what it means to be "coddled." I will give you the benefit of the doubt, but I am guessing we will see a directed effort on your part to minimize and excuse almost every example of sexual harrassment or sexism offered (if anyone cares enough to post in your thread at this point).


She seems pretty reasonable so far to me. I'm interested to see how this develops.
 
No evidence to offer, but some thought on interpretation of potential evidence, if any is forthcoming:

1. The skeptic community may have more, or less, of a problem with sexism than the general population, but that would not mean that the common characteristic of being member of the skeptical community is the significant variable. Skeptics are not a random selection of the general population: They are probably more educated, maybe they are predominantly male to start with, etc. So the evidence for occurrence of sexism within our community needs not be compared with that among the general population. Rather, we'd have to define a control group that shares the relevant characteristics other than being skeptic.

[ETA]
2. Some differences between the values of the social statistics of two samples (different groups, or same group at different times) are not due to a real difference of the reported variable, but a difference in reporting. When for example domestic violence is on the rise over the years in statistics, the reason may be not a rise in actual occurrences, but because victims today are more encouraged and informed to report such. Same with different groups in society: IIRC, domestic violence in Germany is reported more often by ethnic Germans than by immigrants, though I suspect in reality it's the other way round, or no difference.
Same then with skeptics: Maybe the women in the skeptic community tend to be more outspoken about sexism than their peers in either the general population, or in an otherwise carefully designed non-skeptical control group.
[/ETA]

3.. Maybe it is true, there is a positive correlation between sexism and skepticism in white men? Could go like this: Equal treatment of both sexes by men is the politically correct norm in our society; a general disposition to question society's norms is the hallmark of a skeptic; at the same time, someone with a general disposition to question society's norms might also question the validity of the norm to treat both sexes equally.

This is not a question we can assume as a given. It seems that when one talks of 'sexism' that it is automatically reduced to 'men being sexist against women', which really isn't a fair reduction. Of the sexism I've seen personally (as opposed to seeing on TV or hearing about second hand), more than half were from groups composed primarily of women. Most were from female friends when I was the lone male in the group.

As another example from inside 'the community', the most recent examples were ad homs directed against men for being male. There were ad homs and insults against women for being women too, but came largely from people outside the movement.

So are we talking about only 'men being sexist against women,' or 'sexism in general'?
 
Having looked for some evidence of sexism specifically within or promoted by members of the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities

Did you look at your own contribution?

This thread is not about men who are sexist, or women who've been sexually assaulted if the anecdote did not occur within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities. No one is arguing sexism and sexual assaults don't exist.

I think this is technically and ironically within the rules of the thread: Is anyone arguing that sexist women and sexual assaults by women don't exist? Even within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities? If not, why did you feel the need to introduce gender into that sentence?

This is not a question we can assume as a given. It seems that when one talks of 'sexism' that it is automatically reduced to 'men being sexist against women', which really isn't a fair reduction. Of the sexism I've seen personally (as opposed to seeing on TV or hearing about second hand), more than half were from groups composed primarily of women. Most were from female friends when I was the lone male in the group.

As another example from inside 'the community', the most recent examples were ad homs directed against men for being male. There were ad homs and insults against women for being women too, but came largely from people outside the movement.

So are we talking about only 'men being sexist against women,' or 'sexism in general'?

Ah, there we are, you've saved me some work tyr.
 
Was it sexist of me? I mean, if it was a work of art, the Mona Lisa say, and I admired it, no one would think it was sexist. Or an even better analogy would be if it were a new Ferrari parked on the street and I stopped to admire it and comment on it. No one would see that as sexist.

Because paintings and cars are objects, Qayak. Women are not. Men are not. Men and women have feelings, and histories, and individual personalities.

Some will say that these aren't good analogies because the woman isn't wearing clothes, or keeping fit, for me to admire and comment on but for her own reasons. I don't think that is true though. First, the owner of the car, or the artwork, didn't buy it and look after it, so that I could admire and comment on it, either. Second, fashion, the clothes the woman was wearing, is indeed meant to be admired and commented on.

So, what would make my admiring and commenting on a woman's appearance sexist but not my admiring or commenting on a car or piece of art?

Again, because cars and works of art aren't people. They are objects. They are not sexual beings, but things. To reduce a woman or a man to the level of an object in exactly the way you describe has a label.

It's "sexual objectification," which I suppose falls under the aegis of "sexism." It's a subset of sexism, if you will, or perhaps a piece of the puzzle that is sexism.

My own personal feelings are that my admiring this woman, the elevator incident, and most of the silliness that gets labelled "sexist behaviour" isn't.

Across the board, universally, 100% of the time, for all people in all circumstances? No, of course not. But there are times when it is exactly that. The when would be when the person being objectified feels that's what's happening. The jogging woman, not being aware of your momentary thoughts as you drove past, can't feel objectified by you, because she's not at all aware of you.

But in a face-to-face situation, she very well might. Or she might not.

This is exactly why no one can come up with a universal "code of behavior" for this.
There is no such thing; every incident must be taken as an individual incident, and weighed on its own merits each and every time, with all of the variables taken into consideration at the time.

And above all, the feelings of the other person need to be considered. What you meant to do isn't at all as important to me as how what you did made me feel. And if your actions or words make me feel objectified, I want to be able to tell you that without being belittled, or condescended to, or told to stop whining about it. Because that is sexism.
 
No evidence to offer, but some thought on interpretation of potential evidence, if any is forthcoming:

1. The skeptic community may have more, or less, of a problem with sexism than the general population, but that would not mean that the common characteristic of being member of the skeptical community is the significant variable. Skeptics are not a random selection of the general population: They are probably more educated, maybe they are predominantly male to start with, etc. So the evidence for occurrence of sexism within our community needs not be compared with that among the general population. Rather, we'd have to define a control group that shares the relevant characteristics other than being skeptic.
This is why I hypothesize sexism would be less within our group. And your point is important. But I think we need to start by assessing the problem. Looking for causes and associations would be the next step.

[ETA]
2. Some differences between the values of the social statistics of two samples (different groups, or same group at different times) are not due to a real difference of the reported variable, but a difference in reporting. When for example domestic violence is on the rise over the years in statistics, the reason may be not a rise in actual occurrences, but because victims today are more encouraged and informed to report such. Same with different groups in society: IIRC, domestic violence in Germany is reported more often by ethnic Germans than by immigrants, though I suspect in reality it's the other way round, or no difference.
Same then with skeptics: Maybe the women in the skeptic community tend to be more outspoken about sexism than their peers in either the general population, or in an otherwise carefully designed non-skeptical control group.
[/ETA]
Another good point and it might be interesting to know something about the people who report anecdotes, either witnessed or personally experienced.

3.. Maybe it is true, there is a positive correlation between sexism and skepticism in white men? Could go like this: Equal treatment of both sexes by men is the politically correct norm in our society; a general disposition to question society's norms is the hallmark of a skeptic; at the same time, someone with a general disposition to question society's norms might also question the validity of the norm to treat both sexes equally.
I can think of a number of scenarios. But without the data first, it's more speculative than useful.
 
Thanks. casebro for breaking the ice. I was about to bump the thread myself, given I'm still searching for evidence that is already on the Net.

There was some kind of brouhaha back in Feb when the Blag Hag Blog posted about a single incident and PZ took it from there.

When Gender Goes Pear-Shaped

Feminist hypersensitivity or masculine obtuseness?

The gist was a panel at an atheist event with a ratio of one female commentator to 5 guys answered a question.Apparently the complaint was dismissed as biology, get over it and the person submitting the question went to pieces in the bathroom.

I can think about something that could be seen as sexism that might not really be. Skeptics groups tend to have a high percentage of people who have asperbergers or are socially awkward for what ever reason. That added to the gender discrepancies could come across as it. A few awkward passes being made socially could give the impressions easily.

And of course the problem is not women being hit on in some fashion it is inappropriate or awkward being hit on. Aside from asexuals people want to be seen as sexually attractive to people they want to have sex with. So there is nothing wrong with women being hit on, provided it is in an appropriate time and in an reasonable manner. The problem is that there are a lot of people at skeptic events who are bad at determining these things. I am certainly one of them, though in my case it would be more of not asking people out when it would be good to do so.
 
...
But that's what I did with that woman. I only considered her body and clothes but the clothes only because of the way they fit her body.
Yes but is that all you consider about all women? Having sexual desires does not mean a person is sexist. There has to be a way to distinguish between the two otherwise the term, sexist, is meaningless.

...That's the disconnect I see. A man is not sexist because he finds a woman attractive just like a woman who finds men attractive is not sexist. If it were, only people who found men and women equally attractive would not be sexist.

To me, that isn't what sexist means at all. Sexist must carry a component of denying someone something based on their gender. Which is why I don't think the elevator incident, and most others people complain about, are sexist.
I agree.

...Agreed but it runs both ways. Most men will do more for a woman than they will for a man. Although people don't often hear complaints about it, it is still sexist against men.

Of course, that has to be balanced with the fact that people tend to do more for people they find attractive. So a man finding a woman attractive and doing more for her is not necessarily sexist. Each incident would have to be looked at.
I suspect it's hard to understand but I find some things which could have a sexist connotation to not be sexist if they are simply part of the culture or a quaint ritual. If a guy wants to buy me dinner, I'm flattered. Opening a door for me can be sweet.

But if these actions are dictated by cultural roles, done out of obligation rather than to please, if I think I'm owed the dinner because I'm female, now the same actions can be sexist. So yes, one can't make blanket statements about everything.

I don't think who one is attracted to qualifies as sexism regardless of the circumstances. If one was to dismiss a woman's talk just because she is a woman, that would be sexist but to not be as interested in her talk as you are in her body isn't sexism, it is evidence of a poor/uninteresting topic. The reverse, with a man giving the talk, is also true.

I am just having trouble seeing any of this stuff as sexist. No one is being denied anything they would otherwise be entitled to.
I also agree.
 
Well, I'm having a hard time seeing the expression of interest as sexist. So I'm just waiting to see how the thread progresses.

As for my own opinion of sexism, I have some examples. Having people assume weakness and incapableness of me because I am a woman is sexist. Snide comments that tie criticism to my gender apply. I was called a skeptic bimbo once on the politics forum. Since I have a master's degree and a successful professional career the ad hom was absurd.

I wouldn't say absurd, there are a lot of over educated idiots in the world, so educational credentials are not a good defense against such a claim. Though there does seem to be a bit of sexism in that comment as it is an gendered term for an idiot so it certainly brings sex into the discussion when it is not needed.
And in the culture I exist in, when guys treat women as "them" and the guys as "us" it can be very sexist. That doesn't mean guys can't do something together without the gals, but when they make too much of it, it crosses into sexism. I'm used to guys and gals all being in the same circle of friends, not two separate groups. But there are guys who don't view the culture that way. It's hard to say one way is right and one way wrong since they just happen to be two different cultures. But I don't personally view the segregated culture positively.

Wouldn't the same apply to women who do the same thing?
 
Did you look at your own contribution?



I think this is technically and ironically within the rules of the thread: Is anyone arguing that sexist women and sexual assaults by women don't exist? Even within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities? If not, why did you feel the need to introduce gender into that sentence?



Ah, there we are, you've saved me some work tyr.
To answer you and the related posts, this thread's narrow focus has a reason. It appears there are more men in our community than women. Some people have claimed one reason for this is women are chased away by sexist men objectifying them or something like that.

Feel free to talk about sexism of women against men if it is related to the discussion. For example, it seems sexist to me to hold a Wild West Bordello hosted by a women’s skepticism group last year at TAM while complaining men verbalizing an interest in a woman is objectifying her. If women in our community are sexualizing guys then complaining when it is reciprocated, that is relevant.


The thread is not about men being sexually assaulted. It's not biased, that problem is just not part of the discussion that men are chasing women away from our events.
 
It's "sexual objectification," which I suppose falls under the aegis of "sexism." It's a subset of sexism, if you will, or perhaps a piece of the puzzle that is sexism.

So everyone is sexist? His example is the kind of thing everyone does. Remember how sexist Buffy the Vampire writers were always trying to get David Boreanas to take his shirt off.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom