EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

To answer you and the related posts, this thread's narrow focus has a reason. It appears there are more men in our community than women. Some people have claimed one reason for this is women are chased away by sexist men objectifying them or something like that.

Feel free to talk about sexism of women against men if it is related to the discussion. For example, it seems sexist to me to hold a Wild West Bordello hosted by a women’s skepticism group last year at TAM while complaining men verbalizing an interest in a woman is objectifying her. If women in our community are sexualizing guys then complaining when it is reciprocated, that is relevant.

Thank you for your temperate, considered response. I have to say that your clarification of the purpose of the thread was necessary, as it certainly wasn't clear from the OP, but I'm afraid even that stands as evidence of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism. I'll accept the assertion that fewer women than men attend gatherings of skeptics. I do not accept the assertion that that is the fault of men. Casting blame on men and positioning women as victims is a form of sexism perpetuated by both sexes but, I contend, primarily by feminists (female feminists, if the clarification is required - I've known plenty who insist men can't be feminists).

Women in the community do sexualise guys, by the way. Not all of them (and only the hot guys, naturally...), but let's not pretend it doesn't happen. IIRC, the elevator chick was a perp. That's not to say the same women sexualise men and complain about sexualisation of women...oh...IIRC, the elevator chick...

The thread is not about men being sexually assaulted. It's not biased, that problem is just not part of the discussion that men are chasing women away from our events.

Not part of the discussion as to whether men are chasing women away from our events. Did I miss something? Has it been demonstrated that men drive women away, or is that just another example of crass sexism excused because it's perpetrated by the innocent fairer sex?

People are indviduals. Men, and women, all of us, indviduals. A discussion as to whether any individuals are driven away by sexualisation is not sexist. This discussion (apparantly only restricted to women being driven away by men since tyr and I stuck our oars in) is the evidence of sexism in the community you asked for.
 
OK, I finished the 10 page bordello thread.[...]
We are back to the question, is the sexism on the forum particularly pronounced. I'd say it's there, but hard to quantify if it causes many women to stay away from the forum. It appears to have played a role in NC leaving the forum.

I only read as far as NC and her partner leaving the thread. My impression was that NC left not because of 'sexism', but because she didn't get unanimous and unequivocal support for a position she clearly felt strongly about. But we can just call anyone who disagreed with her position 'sexist' and then we're both right...
 
The thread is specific to the instance of men chasing away women via sexism because that was a claim that was made in another thread, that SkepticGinger wanted evidence of and didn't want to derail the other thread by attempting to do an in depth discussion of the matter there.

She's not saying that sexism isn't perpetrated by both sexes. She's not saying that the perpetration of sexism by women against men isn't important. She's saying that she's attempting to see if a particular claim made by someone else is supported by evidence or not, and that other forms and instances of sexism are not relevant to that particular claim.

Wanting to rationally, and logically, examine one particular claim out of any number of possible sets so as to avoid conflating variables uncontrolled for is not sexist. It's a perfectly reasonable way to approach a very complicated subject.
 
First off, you nailed that perfectly. I imagine that people (because I do think men experience it to) just prefer the package deal. They want their eyes and their brain stimulated. OTOH, I've noticed the inverse effect, as well,; the hotter the person is, the less they need to qualify as being intelligent; She's really smart because she used a three syllable word, completely out of context? I just explained quantum field theory!

Heh! I have quite an extensive working vocabulary, as I think a lot of the posters here do. But it's not all that common in the social circles in which I used to run. And not a few men would tell me that it was intimidating, and if I really wanted male attention, I should "dumb it down a bit."

I never thought that was fair to me or to the guys. :(
 
Thank you for your temperate, considered response. I have to say that your clarification of the purpose of the thread was necessary, as it certainly wasn't clear from the OP, but I'm afraid even that stands as evidence of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism. I'll accept the assertion that fewer women than men attend gatherings of skeptics. I do not accept the assertion that that is the fault of men.
Neither do I! But before dismissing the claim made by my fellow female skeptics, I thought it appropriate to first, establish if there even is a problem. Next we would need to look at solutions based on the actual problem, not based on off the cuff assumptions that sexism is chasing women away from our community. I don't want to dismiss the claim without investigating anymore than I want someone to assume the claim without establishing there is evidence.


The rest of your post takes this thread topic the same wrong way. I am not the one making the claim. I am asking for evidence before I challenge it.
 
I only read as far as NC and her partner leaving the thread. My impression was that NC left not because of 'sexism', but because she didn't get unanimous and unequivocal support for a position she clearly felt strongly about. But we can just call anyone who disagreed with her position 'sexist' and then we're both right...
The reason she left was explained by NC on this Skeptopia blog post that Darat shared with us: Why I’ll never return to JREF Forum or The Amaz!ng Meeting
I made the mistake of voicing my opinion regarding the theme of the Skepchick party at this year’s TAM. I found the idea of a Wild West Bordello hosted by a women’s skepticism group a bit distasteful. I tried to make it clear that I am sex positive, that I think women should have a right to be sexy, but just that I thought it was not an appropriate theme for a party at an event where women are already in the minority. By dictating the role of the women (i.e. prostitutes, i.e. sex objects) they basically reduced the women in attendance to their sexuality alone. The suggestion in the fine print of the invitation that other costume ideas are encouraged, still doesn’t change the fact that the THEME ITSELF is necessitating that women sexualise themselves with their very presence at the party.

In no way did "a smattering of sexist comments" equate to calling "anyone who disagreed with her position 'sexist' ". You would do well to reassess the assumptions you brought to this thread and try again, but that's up to you.
 
Last edited:
Skeptic Ginger said:
As many of you know, Rebecca Watson has claimed that sexism is a problem within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities. For the record, she has made a point of saying there was a minority of men within the communities who were guilty of this. But that's a bit contradicted by her additional charge that this sexism has a significant impact on female attendance at conferences and other events.


Skeptic Ginger, just in case, this is what Rebecca said in the latest SGU episode:

Rebecca Watson said:
...I think I've been pretty clear from day one that there's nothing especially misogynist about men and women in the the atheist / skeptical communities…


53 mins 19 secs -> @ http://www.theskepticsguide.org/archive/podcastinfo.aspx?mid=1&pid=312
 
First off, you nailed that perfectly. I imagine that people (because I do think men experience it to) just prefer the package deal. They want their eyes and their brain stimulated. OTOH, I've noticed the inverse effect, as well,; the hotter the person is, the less they need to qualify as being intelligent; She's really smart because she used a three syllable word, completely out of context? I just explained quantum field theory!

I do wonder how this effect(I am uncertain to label it as just sexism as it can benefit some while hurting others of the same sex) has had in various ways on who the prominent young skeptics are.
 
The reason I stayed away from these was that there are plenty of places we can find sexism and bias against women. Certainly many scientific and academic fields only recently became the realm of equality among genders. There's a lot of leftover sexism. I'm 100% certain you can find it in these fields and in academia.

Skeptics/atheists/freethinkers are unique in that critical thinking and recognizing dogma and throwing it off are the focus of these groups. We need direct evidence, not indirect evidence.

The thing is direct evidence requires a certain kind of sexism, while softer unconscious sexism will not necessarily create such discrete evidence.
 
Skeptic Ginger said:
At the danger of a slight de-rail, welcome to the world of the vast majority of men. We never had the option to 'hook them with our looks', mind you.
I think that is an ingrained sexist belief. I need another word here, myself, one for 'sexist' when there is no malice perceived in it. So this wouldn't be the kind of sexist comment I'd hold against you, rather that makes me want to point out that your stereotype is mistaken.

Not my type but Brad Pitt's looks, for example, surely contributes to his income and success. I think looks in a guy can go a long way.

The vast majority of men don't look like Brad Pitt. The vast majority of men aren't as witty as Stephen Fry. The vast majority of men aren't rich.

Anecdote: Four years on dating sites. Only two women ever initiated contact with me. The vast majority of women I contacted didn't even use the semi-automatic "no thanks". Those that did respond for a while just cut off communication without saying "bye".

For all intents and purposes I am practically invisible.
 
The vast majority of men don't look like Brad Pitt. The vast majority of men aren't as witty as Stephen Fry. The vast majority of men aren't rich.

Anecdote: Four years on dating sites. Only two women ever initiated contact with me. The vast majority of women I contacted didn't even use the semi-automatic "no thanks". Those that did respond for a while just cut off communication without saying "bye".

For all intents and purposes I am practically invisible.

This is the dynamics of dating sites. Women get barraged by men, many of them sleazy so they do not have to contact men, they get plenty of men to talk to with out it, and you have to contact them when they are looking for new contacts. Is it fair? not really but it is how it works for what ever reason.
 
I do wonder how this effect(I am uncertain to label it as just sexism as it can benefit some while hurting others of the same sex) has had in various ways on who the prominent young skeptics are.

That was a complete derail and I do apologize. It has it's pros a d cons but I could only stretch it to make it fit sexism and I didn't mean to imply it was sexism.
 
Because paintings and cars are objects, Qayak. Women are not. Men are not. Men and women have feelings, and histories, and individual personalities.

That doesn't wash. People are objects too. Much of our society is based on the looks of people and the fashions they wear. Our society spends a lot of time on this, and not just for sexual purposes. "The clothes make the man," "Dressed for success," etc., all show that appearance is important and going to be noticed.

Again, because cars and works of art aren't people. They are objects. They are not sexual beings, but things. To reduce a woman or a man to the level of an object in exactly the way you describe has a label.

It's "sexual objectification," which I suppose falls under the aegis of "sexism." It's a subset of sexism, if you will, or perhaps a piece of the puzzle that is sexism.

Why is it "sexual" objectification? I am not interested in having sex with this person and I notice when a man is dressed well and in good shape.

I don't see how admiring, or commenting, on people's looks, or asking one to have sex with you is sexist, or sexism.

Across the board, universally, 100% of the time, for all people in all circumstances? No, of course not. But there are times when it is exactly that. The when would be when the person being objectified feels that's what's happening. The jogging woman, not being aware of your momentary thoughts as you drove past, can't feel objectified by you, because she's not at all aware of you.

But in a face-to-face situation, she very well might. Or she might not.

Objectified by me? I just found her attractive. I didn't make her that way.

This is exactly why no one can come up with a universal "code of behavior" for this.
There is no such thing; every incident must be taken as an individual incident, and weighed on its own merits each and every time, with all of the variables taken into consideration at the time.

I agree, which is why I think almost all claims of sexism, aren't. There must be some aspect of discrimination for it to be sexism.

And above all, the feelings of the other person need to be considered. What you meant to do isn't at all as important to me as how what you did made me feel. And if your actions or words make me feel objectified, I want to be able to tell you that without being belittled, or condescended to, or told to stop whining about it. Because that is sexism.

I agree that you are free to tel me about how my actions make you feel but just because someone claims it is sexist doesn't make it so. One person is not the decider.

The issue I find with all this is that sexism is a "BAD" thing but in my mind it no longer means anything because so many people have cried "Wolf" for so long.

When this type of activity happens between people and some want to call it sexism, it completely removes the "bad" from the sexism label. In other words, if this is sexism, sexism is a good thing and I am all for it.
 
This is not a question we can assume as a given. It seems that when one talks of 'sexism' that it is automatically reduced to 'men being sexist against women', which really isn't a fair reduction. Of the sexism I've seen personally (as opposed to seeing on TV or hearing about second hand), more than half were from groups composed primarily of women. Most were from female friends when I was the lone male in the group.

As another example from inside 'the community', the most recent examples were ad homs directed against men for being male. There were ad homs and insults against women for being women too, but came largely from people outside the movement.

So are we talking about only 'men being sexist against women,' or 'sexism in general'?

I have never been to a meeting or organisation of skeptics, so I don't know and said "maybe", but I imagine that these things have male majorities. So I would imagine that sexism by man against women would be what I'd expect. But that doesn't matter so much. Male dominance was just an example of the kind of variable we'd need to control for in this discussion: The general public is pretty near 50:50 men:women, skeptic groups may be dominated by men (or women, or old, or young folks, or rich, or poor...)
 
This is why I hypothesize sexism would be less within our group. And your point is important. But I think we need to start by assessing the problem. Looking for causes and associations would be the next step.

Another good point and it might be interesting to know something about the people who report anecdotes, either witnessed or personally experienced.

I can think of a number of scenarios. But without the data first, it's more speculative than useful.

Assessing (collecting data) within our group only will not be enough to form well-founded opinions and conclusions. Because we would have to compare the data to something - and this can only happen if we also assess (collect data) the situation in a control group. Which control group? I believe you should think about that before you start assessing us.
 
The vast majority of men don't look like Brad Pitt. The vast majority of men aren't as witty as Stephen Fry. The vast majority of men aren't rich.

Anecdote: Four years on dating sites. Only two women ever initiated contact with me. The vast majority of women I contacted didn't even use the semi-automatic "no thanks". Those that did respond for a while just cut off communication without saying "bye".

For all intents and purposes I am practically invisible.

To continue the derail, about 80% of men are below average in looks, according to women.

http://www.samueljscott.com/2011/07/15/singles-online/

I don't if that means that we're all ugly, or expectations ar eout of touch with reality...
 
You are equivocating here between skepticism as a very broad intellectual field and organised skepticism as a social phenomenon. I think the availability heuristic is fooling you into thinking that the data you already have is more relevant than it really is. You should be searching for data which is actually directly relevant to the subject at hand, not trying to stretch for reasons to justify using irrelevant data that you had in hand already.

Alright, this whole subject is officially completely retarded.

The relationship between the skeptical movement and higher education is EXTREMELY close. Philosophy departments aren't unique in their sexism, it's merely that the women in that subject have chosen to expose the crap they deal with. Women in engineering and biology and physics and mathematics and everything else will have incredibly similar stories to tell.

Now, maybe the "skeptical movement" is wholly composed of only those people who are both in academia and are also not sexist, but since many of the higher profile women in the movement complain of the same behavior, it's a pretty good bet that similar attitudes exist in both arenas.

Obviously the main difference is that TAM and related events are minimally important for an academic's professional career. If you'll notice, I introduced this problem in my first post on the subject. Thus, the sexism is likely to be driven less by professional competition, meaning it's generally of a less malignant variety. That's not much solace for the women who have to deal with it, though.

Look, 50% of my law school class was female. The top handful of students were mostly female. The people who received the most prestigious placements after graduation were female. Every single one of them has endless stories of being harrassed, minimized, sexualized, and worse in the legal academic and professional community. THe stories are EXACTLY the same as what the woman at the blaghag post was discussing.

You're basically waving your hand and trying to argue that even though sexism occurs in academia, all the major disciplines that feed into the "skeptical movement" (psychology, biology, astrophysics, philosophy...), every level of the professional world from the most prestigious to the least impressive, and it all occurs in basically the same way (the stories are identical), somehow there is this universe of Skeptopia that is immune from the dynamic that exists everywhere else, even though the women involved report the same sort of treatment.

Thus, the reason that philosophy issue is relevant to this discussion is that the sort of person (man or woman) who will be interested in attending TAM or related conferences as a leisure activity are likely to be drawn from that academic environment. If they're dealing with that BS in their professional life then notice the same dynamic when they engage with whatever this "skeptical movement" is, it doesn't take a massive leap to conclude that sexism may have a part in keeping women away.

Now, to be fair, I would bet the low attendance of women has more to do with ambivalence than any actual sexism-based repulsion. Obvioulsy some women feel that way and have expressed such, but the biggest culprit in keeping women away from these events is likely the fact that they've never heard of them or have no idea what goes on.
 
Last edited:
The thing is direct evidence requires a certain kind of sexism, while softer unconscious sexism will not necessarily create such discrete evidence.

The claim was made sexism among community members was keeping women from attending community events. I ask people to post the evidence. Support the claim.

There is no need to document sexism in the society at large. No one refutes that it exists.
 
The vast majority of men don't look like Brad Pitt. The vast majority of men aren't as witty as Stephen Fry. The vast majority of men aren't rich.

Anecdote: Four years on dating sites. Only two women ever initiated contact with me. The vast majority of women I contacted didn't even use the semi-automatic "no thanks". Those that did respond for a while just cut off communication without saying "bye".

For all intents and purposes I am practically invisible.
Yes, but the vast majority of women who are sexually attracted to men are influenced by the man's physical appearance.

I was just challenging the claim "We never had the option to 'hook them with our looks', mind you".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom