I was applying your analogy to the specific point you were responding to. It had been assumed that there was some small element of danger to Rebecca since she was in a hotel elevator during this incident. This assumption was so prevalent that anyone suggesting she wasn't in danger was ridiculed and derided, prolonging the ****-storm. Skeptic Ginger was wondering whether this derision was warranted. She discovered that the application of rationality to the question leads one to discover that it isn't dangerous. When you brought up the tutu, in order to make it analogous, it would have to be the case that a man should realize that a woman wearing a tutu will be especially anxious because of the inherent danger (albeit small) of being murdered because one is wearing a tutu.
I just...
No, the tutu had nothing to do with anxiety. The tutu analogy went simply to the point that a broad statistical truth is fairly useless when facts modify the situation.
Being murdered in a tutu is extremely, extremely rare. Wearing a tutu, however, doesn't protect you from bullets. If someone points a gun at you, thinking, "Hey, I'm in a tutu. People never get shot in tutus, I'm safe," is bad reasoning.
It's an issue of opportunity, and we don't have any statistics that explain how frequent sexual assaults on elevators are when the necessary elements for the opportunity are in place combined with the type of behavior that occurred.
But yes, you've made a powerful argument that the analogy does not, in fact, apply to things it wasn't designed to apply to.
Right. Because it was the kind of enclosed space where a woman might expect some small chance of rape. (You're not talking claustrophobia, for example.) Those who pointed out that it wasn't a very good spot to expect a rape were denigrated, even though it turns out that they were probably right.
No, they really weren't. There are literally hundreds of examples of rapes on elevators. I linked a bunch of them in the other thread. Just google the relevant terms. You will see page after page of women being assaulted and raped on elevators.
These happen during the day, in office buildings, in apartment buildings, with serial rapists, with people making small talk--there's no real pattern. What Skeptic Ginger and her source did was limit the sample by modifying it to "hotel elevator." That doesn't yield anything useful, it just limits the data set while offering no insight into the opportunity issue. It's based on the flawed premise that the "hotel elevator" was the most important causal factor when it wasn't.
There were a number of folks who specialized in elevator rape:
Police are looking for a man suspected in a string of seven rapes in four months, three of them in Chelsea, where he caught his victims in elevators.
The latest incident was on Fri. May 2 when a 23-year-old model was raped in the building at 153 W. 27 St. where she was taking an acting class. A surveillance camera caught an image of the suspect walking through the lobby.
On Jan. 15, a woman in the Chelsea Elliot Houses was raped in an elevator. On Jan. 29, two women were robbed and one was sexually assaulted in a Robert Fulton Houses elevator. Women were raped in Bronx elevators in incidents on Jan. 19 and on April 13; another woman became a victim in the E. 20s, police said. The suspect is described as a black man in his early 20s, about 5 ft. 9 in. slim build and in the latest incident he was wearing his hair in cornrows. Police said the suspect ingratiates himself with small talk to his intended victims and can convince them that he belongs in the building.
http://www.thevillager.com/villager_2/chelseaelevator.html
It's a place of vulnerability, IF someone attempts to use it as such. The point is not that elevators are uniquely dangerous, simply that it's a place where sexual assault can occur. If the only issue were that Watson was on an elevator with a man, this never would have become a story in the first place.
That's not analogous, though. That would be like stepping onto an elevator which contains a man with his erect penis exposed and a knife in his hand, leering at you.
...I'm illustrating a statistical concept with analogy. I'm not trying to make a 1:1 comparison to the elevator situation.
This is more like wondering why the car in front of you keeps braking and you eventually find out that they do so whenever they see a big rock on the side of the road.
Great, I guess we have to do this.
No, it's more like driving through the mountains and seeing a series of smaller rocks bounce down the slope in front of you. It could be nothing, or it could be the start of a landslide, there's really no way to know from your perspective. Some people might play the odds and try to speed through, others would pull up and wait. If the rocks are small enough, both groups are probably justified.
But the simple raw data concerning your odds of being hit by a boulder on a highway in Colorado are not very useful. Those odds don't tell you much when you're in the position of seeing a potential landslide.
And if you want to take it a step further, the point is simply: "Avoid causing rocks to go tumbling down the hill and force people to try and figure out whether it's nothing or a *********** landslide."