EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

I only hypothesize there should be less sexism in our community, but I have not tested the hypothesis. I base it on the more common that not awareness of religious sexism issues and the rejection of those. And on the community's emphasis on critical thinking rather than accepting traditional beliefs without question.
Is there any evidence that such a community emphasis leads to the result you expect?

As a parallel, do you expect Christians to be more charitable than non-Christians because that is one of the important values of their religion? Do you expect Christians to have less extra-marital sex because that is considered a sin by their religion?

If you do have those expectations, you're equating proclaimed values with actual behavior and, according to the survey results I've seen, Christians are not any more charitable or less sexually active outside of marriage than non-Christians.
Does that mean there is no sexism? Of course not. But just as I'd expect to see more sexism at a right wing war rally and less at a liberal war protest, I think we have a much greater % of social liberal thinkers among us.
I don't know that you would see more or less sexism at such events according the liberal/conservative split. The conservative right-wing movement has plenty of women in it and two of their most visible leaders are female (Palin and Bachman).

As for evidence, I'm looking for very specific incidents.

Here's a comment from pharangula:
I also think a lot of people are talking about 'rape,' when the question is about whether a woman can attend a gathering of atheists expecting to interact as an equal, or whether a woman who attends a gathering of atheists should expect being the subject of unwanted sexual attention as the cost of admission.
I have seen enough of these conversations to think that the latter is the case. So I don't go to atheist gatherings. - Harmless Eccentric, Comment #125,
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2011/07/oh_no_not_againonce_more_unto.php#more


Does this qualify as sexism? It certainly qualifies as a woman explaining why she doesn't attend such meetings. It's also exactly the sort of behavior that women were complaining about in the early days of the woman's movement. I suspect that is why many people see such behavior as evidence of sexism, but I'm not sure whether or not you would.
 
Last edited:
This is getting off topic. I am beginning to give up that I'll get any more evidence than I dig up myself so I'm going to answer. But I'd like to get back to the thread topic soon, if you don't mind.

You get higher wages and easier access to being hired if you take the employment field as a whole. I'm hoping the academic gender bias is decreasing but I don't know.

Actually, I'm not sure that is true. Women engineers (at least at one point - I haven't stayed current) could expect slightly higher starting salaries than men in companies that needed to meet certain quota's for hiring minorities. Because there were so few women in the field, financial incentives were available and they would be hired in preference over a similarly qualified male for that reason as well.
 
Actually, I'm not sure that is true. Women engineers (at least at one point - I haven't stayed current) could expect slightly higher starting salaries than men in companies that needed to meet certain quota's for hiring minorities. Because there were so few women in the field, financial incentives were available and they would be hired in preference over a similarly qualified male for that reason as well.

Engineering Pay Gap? Glassdoor Reveals Many Women Engineers Earn Less than Men
 
Is there any evidence that such a community emphasis leads to the result you expect?
Told you it was an hypothesis, what I based it on, and that it had not been tested yet, so no.

As a parallel, do you expect Christians to be more charitable than non-Christians because that is one of the important values of their religion? Do you expect Christians to have less extra-marital sex because that is considered a sin by their religion?
This is going to sound like rationalizing, but it is how I see it. Christians come to their beliefs by indoctrination. Skeptics come to their beliefs by concluding the evidence supports them. I don't think you can compare the two regarding this issue for that reason. We aren't talking about whether one follows indoctrinated beliefs, we are talking about following beliefs you think are true based on convincing evidence.


If you do have those expectations, you're equating proclaimed values with actual behavior and, according to the survey results I've seen, Christians are not any more charitable or less sexually active outside of marriage than non-Christians.
I don't know that you would see more or less sexism at such events according the liberal/conservative split. The conservative right-wing movement has plenty of women in it and two of their most visible leaders are female (Palin and Bachman).
I don't agree with your analogy for the reason I cited above.


Here's a comment from pharangula:
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2011/07/oh_no_not_againonce_more_unto.php#more
PZ said:
I also think a lot of people are talking about 'rape,' when the question is about whether a woman can attend a gathering of atheists expecting to interact as an equal, or whether a woman who attends a gathering of atheists should expect being the subject of unwanted sexual attention as the cost of admission.
I have seen enough of these conversations to think that the latter is the case. So I don't go to atheist gatherings. - Harmless Eccentric, Comment #125,
The whole point of this thread is to find evidence that what PZ is saying is true. So far, not a whole lot of evidence has been forthcoming.


Does this qualify as sexism? It certainly qualifies as a woman explaining why she doesn't attend such meetings. It's also exactly the sort of behavior that women were complaining about in the early days of the woman's movement. I suspect that is why many people see such behavior as evidence of sexism, but I'm not sure whether or not you would.
So far we have a very few number of people claiming this is a concern of many and a frequent occurrence. My question is simply, is this true or overblown based on a couple anecdotes? Does the subject matter or the source of the complaint mean we throw skepticism out the window?
 
Last edited:
:id:

Think about it:
White straight men get special treatment.
Beautiful women get special treatment.

You are missing the obvious, beauty is simply being judged by different standards in each gender. :)

That's not what I said at all, I think we might be discussing different points to be honest. Should I read anything into the fact that your two statements above include all straight white men but only a sub-segment of women? Surely its more accurate to say some straight white men get special treatment and some straight white women get special treatment?

The only reason I posted anything was that when slingblade posted something like 'I feel anonymous now that my looks don't hook them like they used to' (and I'm paraphrasing so I hope she doesn't take offence) I just thought 'I feel anonymous too so how is this a gender/sexism issue? Sounds like she was lucky she had the looks thing for a while now she's just one of the rest of us.'

We all have privilege and lack of privilege in different ways. The fact that we are sitting here on the internet chatting about this stuff probably means we are all ridiculously privileged with respect to the vast majority of people who have ever lived, on the other hand we all have our problems and issues to overcome.

I can't comment on sexism in the skeptic community as I have no experience of these events nor much desire to participate.
 
Yes, we all know about absence of evidence, but it does add to the evidence a few people are exaggerating about the extent of the problem.

This is such a poor method of data collection that you won't be able to conclude even that.

BTW, I await your comments about this post in the other thread.

Oh boy. Why are you having such difficulty with this?

As always, your error involves eliminating relevant facts to distort the statistics.

How many people have been murdered while wearing tutus? The limited number will be of little solace to the tutu-wearing individual with a gun shoved in their face.
 
Last edited:
As always, your error involves eliminating relevant facts to distort the statistics.

How many people have been murdered while wearing tutus? The limited number will be of little solace to the tutu-wearing individual with a gun shoved in their face.

Are you suggesting that an Internet ********* could be sustained for 3 weeks with the supposition that tutu-wearing makes you more prone to murder ("She was wearing a tutu! Do you realize how vulnerable she was in that situation?")? I suppose it's possible.

Linda
 
This is such a poor method of data collection that you won't be able to conclude even that.



Oh boy. Why are you having such difficulty with this?

As always, your error involves eliminating relevant facts to distort the statistics.

How many people have been murdered while wearing tutus? The limited number will be of little solace to the tutu-wearing individual with a gun shoved in their face.

What we have here is a failure to understand the need for an applicable base rate.

You need to know what the general likelihood of being raped in a lift is in order to sensibly assess whether it is reasonable or unreasonable to be frightened by a sexual approach in a lift. Skeptic Ginger is absolutely in the right there in demanding applicable evidence. (Since SG and I have disagreed violently in the past I can assure you that I am no SG cheerleader - in just so happens that in this case she is right).

This is just the same as needing to know what the general likelihood of sexual harassment is in order to know whether one should feel more safe or less safe attending a conference for skeptics.

Pointing to evidence about conferences for professional academics without doing anything but waving your hands to demonstrate that statistics about professional academics are applicable to amateur skepticism gets us nowhere. You need evidence that is actually relevant. Calling people or discussions "officially retarded" is not such a demonstration of relevance.
 
Is there any evidence that such a community emphasis leads to the result you expect?


Told you it was an hypothesis, what I based it on, and that it had not been tested yet, so no.
You seem to be accepting your hypothesis as true in the absence of evidence. Why?
So far we have a very few number of people claiming this is a concern of many and a frequent occurrence. My question is simply, is this true or overblown based on a couple anecdotes?
Good question. How can we make that determination? What evidence is needed?

Do you think the comment I quoted qualifies as evidence of sexism at skeptic/atheist gathers? If not, why not? And if not, can you describe what you are looking for as evidence one way or the other?
 
Are you suggesting that an Internet ********* could be sustained for 3 weeks with the supposition that tutu-wearing makes you more prone to murder ("She was wearing a tutu! Do you realize how vulnerable she was in that situation?")? I suppose it's possible.

What? I'm assuming that's a joke of some sort. You're more than capable of understanding that the analogy was meant to express a specific point, not apply to the situation as a whole.

I'm suggesting that long after this has been explained in excrutiating detail, people cannot seem to comprehend that the elevator was not the source of the angst. It was a factor that increased the apprehension because it was an enclosed space.

It's just infantile to pretend that the issue is the general safety of elevators.

Your odds of being hit by a falling rock on the Colorado highways are low. When you see a landslide, however, it's probably not a good idea to drive through it. The raw statistics are modified by circumstance.
 
Last edited:
You need to know what the general likelihood of being raped in a lift is in order to sensibly assess whether it is reasonable or unreasonable to be frightened by a sexual approach in a lift.

Maybe, but you don't have that evidence. You may have evidence that says being assaulted in a lift is rare, but you have nothing that indicates the frequency of assaults on lifts when a stranger approaches with a random proposition.

Again, what continues to happen, despite having it explained to the point of nausea, is that people treat the "hotel elevator" as though it was the cause of the apprehension. It was not, it was a feature that added to the apprehension once the behavior of EG set it off.

Skeptic Ginger is absolutely in the right there in demanding applicable evidence. (Since SG and I have disagreed violently in the past I can assure you that I am no SG cheerleader - in just so happens that in this case she is right).

This is just the same as needing to know what the general likelihood of sexual harassment is in order to know whether one should feel more safe or less safe attending a conference for skeptics.

But we aren't talking about a broad event. We have specific facts that change the statistical analysis.

On any given night, what are your odds of being held up at gunpoint? Really, really low.

What are your odds of being held up at gunpoint by someone who accosts you while holding their hand inside of their jacket? I have no idea. I would imagine anyone experiencing stress in that situation (most humans) would be justified.

The general stat for your odds of being held up is irrelevant because we have a modifying factor.

Pointing to evidence about conferences for professional academics without doing anything but waving your hands to demonstrate that statistics about professional academics are applicable to amateur skepticism gets us nowhere. You need evidence that is actually relevant. Calling people or discussions "officially retarded" is not such a demonstration of relevance.

No, it's an observation. This new digression will stand as more proof.
 
What? You're more than capable of understanding that the analogy was meant to express a specific point, not apply to the situation as a whole. I don't understand why people have decided to totally suspend their rationality for the purpose of these discussions.

I was applying your analogy to the specific point you were responding to. It had been assumed that there was some small element of danger to Rebecca since she was in a hotel elevator during this incident. This assumption was so prevalent that anyone suggesting she wasn't in danger was ridiculed and derided, prolonging the ****-storm. Skeptic Ginger was wondering whether this derision was warranted. She discovered that the application of rationality to the question leads one to discover that it isn't dangerous. When you brought up the tutu, in order to make it analogous, it would have to be the case that a man should realize that a woman wearing a tutu will be especially anxious because of the inherent danger (albeit small) of being murdered because one is wearing a tutu.

I'm suggesting that long after this has been explained in excrutiating detail...It was a factor that increased the apprehension because it was an enclosed space.

Right. Because it was the kind of enclosed space where a woman might expect some small chance of rape. (You're not talking claustrophobia, for example.) Those who pointed out that it wasn't a very good spot to expect a rape were denigrated, even though it turns out that they were probably right.

It's just infantile to pretend that the issue is the general safety of elevators.

Your odds of being hit by a falling rock on the Colorado highways are low. When you see a landslide, however, it's probably not a good idea to drive through it.

That's not analogous, though. That would be like stepping onto an elevator which contains a man with his erect penis exposed and a knife in his hand, leering at you.

This is more like wondering why the car in front of you keeps braking and you eventually find out that they do so whenever they see a big rock on the side of the road.

Linda
 
I was applying your analogy to the specific point you were responding to. It had been assumed that there was some small element of danger to Rebecca since she was in a hotel elevator during this incident. This assumption was so prevalent that anyone suggesting she wasn't in danger was ridiculed and derided, prolonging the ****-storm. Skeptic Ginger was wondering whether this derision was warranted. She discovered that the application of rationality to the question leads one to discover that it isn't dangerous. When you brought up the tutu, in order to make it analogous, it would have to be the case that a man should realize that a woman wearing a tutu will be especially anxious because of the inherent danger (albeit small) of being murdered because one is wearing a tutu.

I just...

No, the tutu had nothing to do with anxiety. The tutu analogy went simply to the point that a broad statistical truth is fairly useless when facts modify the situation.

Being murdered in a tutu is extremely, extremely rare. Wearing a tutu, however, doesn't protect you from bullets. If someone points a gun at you, thinking, "Hey, I'm in a tutu. People never get shot in tutus, I'm safe," is bad reasoning.

It's an issue of opportunity, and we don't have any statistics that explain how frequent sexual assaults on elevators are when the necessary elements for the opportunity are in place combined with the type of behavior that occurred.

But yes, you've made a powerful argument that the analogy does not, in fact, apply to things it wasn't designed to apply to.


Right. Because it was the kind of enclosed space where a woman might expect some small chance of rape. (You're not talking claustrophobia, for example.) Those who pointed out that it wasn't a very good spot to expect a rape were denigrated, even though it turns out that they were probably right.

No, they really weren't. There are literally hundreds of examples of rapes on elevators. I linked a bunch of them in the other thread. Just google the relevant terms. You will see page after page of women being assaulted and raped on elevators.

These happen during the day, in office buildings, in apartment buildings, with serial rapists, with people making small talk--there's no real pattern. What Skeptic Ginger and her source did was limit the sample by modifying it to "hotel elevator." That doesn't yield anything useful, it just limits the data set while offering no insight into the opportunity issue. It's based on the flawed premise that the "hotel elevator" was the most important causal factor when it wasn't.

There were a number of folks who specialized in elevator rape:

Police are looking for a man suspected in a string of seven rapes in four months, three of them in Chelsea, where he caught his victims in elevators.

The latest incident was on Fri. May 2 when a 23-year-old model was raped in the building at 153 W. 27 St. where she was taking an acting class. A surveillance camera caught an image of the suspect walking through the lobby.

On Jan. 15, a woman in the Chelsea Elliot Houses was raped in an elevator. On Jan. 29, two women were robbed and one was sexually assaulted in a Robert Fulton Houses elevator. Women were raped in Bronx elevators in incidents on Jan. 19 and on April 13; another woman became a victim in the E. 20s, police said. The suspect is described as a black man in his early 20s, about 5 ft. 9 in. slim build and in the latest incident he was wearing his hair in cornrows. Police said the suspect ingratiates himself with small talk to his intended victims and can convince them that he belongs in the building.
http://www.thevillager.com/villager_2/chelseaelevator.html

It's a place of vulnerability, IF someone attempts to use it as such. The point is not that elevators are uniquely dangerous, simply that it's a place where sexual assault can occur. If the only issue were that Watson was on an elevator with a man, this never would have become a story in the first place.

That's not analogous, though. That would be like stepping onto an elevator which contains a man with his erect penis exposed and a knife in his hand, leering at you.

...I'm illustrating a statistical concept with analogy. I'm not trying to make a 1:1 comparison to the elevator situation.

This is more like wondering why the car in front of you keeps braking and you eventually find out that they do so whenever they see a big rock on the side of the road.

Great, I guess we have to do this.

No, it's more like driving through the mountains and seeing a series of smaller rocks bounce down the slope in front of you. It could be nothing, or it could be the start of a landslide, there's really no way to know from your perspective. Some people might play the odds and try to speed through, others would pull up and wait. If the rocks are small enough, both groups are probably justified.

But the simple raw data concerning your odds of being hit by a boulder on a highway in Colorado are not very useful. Those odds don't tell you much when you're in the position of seeing a potential landslide.

And if you want to take it a step further, the point is simply: "Avoid causing rocks to go tumbling down the hill and force people to try and figure out whether it's nothing or a *********** landslide."
 
Last edited:
That's not what I said at all, I think we might be discussing different points to be honest. Should I read anything into the fact that your two statements above include all straight white men but only a sub-segment of women? Surely its more accurate to say some straight white men get special treatment and some straight white women get special treatment?
Funny you can't see it. White men are a subset of all men, beautiful women are a subset of all women and are not confined to only white women.
 
This is such a poor method of data collection that you won't be able to conclude even that.
At the moment it is the only method I have access to. I don't understand your negative reaction to my attempt to be skeptical of my own conclusion.

Because sexism exists an assumption has been made it must be an issue at skeptical events. There are people who believe they have seen evidence of it. My personal experience is the assumption is wrong, it's not the issue it has been claimed to be. It's human nature to develop these assumptions and sometimes they are not consistent with the evidence when one actually looks more closely. I'm looking for defendable evidence that contradicts my experience.



Oh boy. Why are you having such difficulty with this?

As always, your error involves eliminating relevant facts to distort the statistics.

How many people have been murdered while wearing tutus? The limited number will be of little solace to the tutu-wearing individual with a gun shoved in their face.
What relevant facts did Depleted Cranium leave out of their investigation of elevator assaults? (Answering in the other thread instead of here would be appreciated but not demanded.)
 
Last edited:
I just...

No, the tutu had nothing to do with anxiety. The tutu analogy went simply to the point that a broad statistical truth is fairly useless when facts modify the situation.

Being murdered in a tutu is extremely, extremely rare. Wearing a tutu, however, doesn't protect you from bullets. If someone points a gun at you, thinking, "Hey, I'm in a tutu. People never get shot in tutus, I'm safe," is bad reasoning.

Of course, but irrelevant since no one displayed that kind of reasoning.

It's an issue of opportunity, and we don't have any statistics that explain how frequent sexual assaults on elevators are when the necessary elements for the opportunity are in place combined with the type of behavior that occurred.

It's not like we have no idea whatsoever. Hotel elevators are a poor place to attempt a rape. Turning down a polite proposition rarely leads to rape. The combination of the two cannot make rape more likely than either one alone.

No, they really weren't. There are literally hundreds of examples of rapes on elevators.

But that isn't relevant. Hotel elevators are different in several very important ways from elevators in apartment buildings and other places - ways which alter the risk to the rapist considerably.

It's a place of vulnerability, IF someone attempts to use it as such. The point is not that elevators are uniquely dangerous, simply that it's a place where sexual assault can occur. If the only issue were that Watson was on an elevator with a man, this never would have become a story in the first place.

Exactly. And yet, her risk of rape for "on an elevator with a man" was much higher than it would be for "on and elevator with a man and he makes a proposition". It's a classic example of an error made in the name of an availability bias. This perfectly illustrates that the thinking on this issue has been irrational.

Linda
 
You seem to be accepting your hypothesis as true in the absence of evidence. Why?
In my experience in the skeptic and atheist communities (which is quite a bit) I've not seen the sexism that is being described. And, I've hypothesized for the reasons I said. If I was convinced my hypothesis was true, I wouldn't be looking for evidence to support or refute it. I don't see evidence of the sexism-in-our-community charges Skepchick and their supporters are making. But I accept that I could be wrong and am trying to look at this with an open mind. But I'm not going to accept the charges without evidence.

Good question. How can we make that determination? What evidence is needed?
Documented incidents at conferences is one way. The bordello controversy was one. Anything that is a specific event. A charge that '20 old geezers stared at someone's cleavage at a conference' is not evidence on its face. A blog discussion that a particular event had more guys drooling over cleavage than there should have been might be, depending on the number of witnesses who were in agreement it was an issue.

YDo you think the comment I quoted qualifies as evidence of sexism at skeptic/atheist gathers? If not, why not? And if not, can you describe what you are looking for as evidence one way or the other?
Not really. "I have seen enough of these conversations to think that the latter is the case. So I don't go to atheist gatherings" is exactly the kind of opinion testimony I am making. I haven't seen it. A number of people claim they have.

Neither is reliable evidence, just the impressions we have. Like I said, this is the thing I am trying to find evidence to support, or not support. More of the same is not helping. You only have to go on the Skepchick site to find this kind of testimonial. But given the example we have from Rebecca, that demonstrates such impressions of being sexualized might be based on falsely assessing situations.

If people feel their concerns are not being taken seriously, it could be their concerns are being unfairly dismissed, or it could be because their concerns don't warrant being taken seriously.
 
If people feel their concerns are not being taken seriously, it could be their concerns are being unfairly dismissed, or it could be because their concerns don't warrant being taken seriously.

Again, you only get to decide that you don't take it seriously. You don't get to decide it for everyone.

Person A has a concern. You and I both listen to it.

If you decide A's concern doesn't warrant being taken seriously, that's your right, but you don't get to make that decision for me or for anyone else. I demand the right to make that evaluation for myself.

"I don't believe you're taking this seriously!"

I don't believe you're not. Person A is taking it seriously. I respect that.

"Well, here are my rational and logical reasons for my stance. If you are rational and logical, you will agree."

If I don't agree, it doesn't mean I'm not rational or logical. It does mean you've decided I am not.

"But any rational, logical person would agree!"

How do you know? Are you reading their minds? Are you the sole arbiter of rationality or logic? Stop telling me what to think or how to feel. I can do that for myself.

"You're wrong."

So are you.

"Why, because you say so? Who are you to tell me I'm wrong?"

Who are you to do the same to me?

"But I'm right!"

I can see you think you're right. I don't agree. I think I'm right, and these are my reasons.

"Your reasons don't make any sense. You're seeing this wrong."

I'm seeing it through my own lens, my history, my experience, my empathy, my intellect. As you are. My reasons make sense to me. I respect your decision, but I don't agree with it. I want you to accord me the same. Stop trying to force my agreement.

"Fine. You're wrong, but I guess we must agree to disagree."

Yes. Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm going to try to help Person A. If you think she's wrong, then please excuse yourself. You're not helping.
 
Last edited:
Again, you only get to decide that you don't take it seriously. You don't get to decide it for everyone.

No one does. I think some of the point is that evidence is required to know if the fear is rational or not.
 
At this point I'll just wait for the mods to split this thread. It's possibly distinct enough from the other one (and certainly this one) that it could have a life of its own.

Of course, but irrelevant since no one displayed that kind of reasoning.

That's exactly what the reasoning is. From the article Skeptic Ginger linked:

Sure, they have happened. In the history of human race and the billions of hotel stays that have been made, they have happened. But lets get something straight: people have also been struck by meteors on at least two occasions.

"Billions of hotel stays" is that sort of broad statistical claim that is irrelevant because we are in possession of facts that modify the situation.

The entirety of the argument "hotels aren't dangerous" (no ****) is based on that flaw.

It's not like we have no idea whatsoever. Hotel elevators are a poor place to attempt a rape. Turning down a polite proposition rarely leads to rape. The combination of the two cannot make rape more likely than either one alone.

Again, you're modifying the facts to generate the conclusion you want. It's your completely distanced claim that it was "polite." The words give very little indication. Certainly Hannibal Lector delivering the line about coffee would have come off differently.

What are the stats on cold propositions in elevators from strangers (or loose acquaintances for the purposes of the rape and assault stats)? It's a total blackhole. It was more than just two people on the elevator.

But that isn't relevant. Hotel elevators are different in several very important ways from elevators in apartment buildings and other places - ways which alter the risk to the rapist considerably.

You really need to google the subject. I'm not going to link 500 articles. These rapes occur in every possible setting, including businesses in the middle of the day:

Police in the downtown area have intensified patrols and circulated descriptions in an attempt to apprehend an armed robber-rapist who has accosted three women in hotel and office building elevators in the last several days.
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1989-10-12/news/8901210552_1_elevator-raped-palmer-house


Exactly. And yet, her risk of rape for "on an elevator with a man" was much higher than it would be for "on and elevator with a man and he makes a proposition". It's a classic example of an error made in the name of an availability bias. This perfectly illustrates that the thinking on this issue has been irrational.

I'm not sure what foundation lies under that claim. Perhaps I don't understand what you're trying to argue, here.

Obviously "on an elevator with a man" all other factors held equal, probably isn't that dangerous. We don't have a specific statistic, but I think that's a safe bet.

A woman may feel uncomfortable talking to a certain man in any situation. Given the description of EG, I'm sure Watson wouldn't have swooned if he approached her in the bar. She may have had the same sense of apprehension at the guy, or just thought he was weird. In that bar, however, the come-on is just annoying.

Take that same interaction and put it on an elevator and the dynamic changes. It mystifies me that this is a point of contention. The elevator is merely a setting that takes a feeling of annoyance and adds an air of more intense discomfort. It is a reasonable request for women (and A LOT are taking this position even though you disagree, I have no objection to your personal feelings on the matter) to ask men to approach them in situations that are safer.

Hell, that's not even a gender-based request (though the prevailent dynamic of assault in this reality of ours adds a darker edge to the male-female interaction). I've been in situations where weird dudes accosted me. Maybe they were drugged up or something similar. I don't want to be isolated in an elevator with someone when they start getting weird.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom