EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

We have something called social etiquette. Now let me hasten to state that I lean nihilist and don't think there is any ultimate moral right and wrong about touching a woman's bottom in such a manner. But I accept social etiquette. I don't expect that just because I don't find something rude (I think touching a woman's bottom to be rude unless it's my wife in private) means that I can do that thing.

That's the point you are missing. I've said over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over that we should discuss the issue to move the zeitgeist. If this should become a rule of social etiquette I could live with that. But neither you nor I are the arbiters of what is social etiquette. It's not something that people get together and vote on. It's something we discuss, debate, attempt to persuade, just as we do most ethics, morals etc.

Not propositioning women in an elevator might become a rule of social etiquette. Then again, it my never achieve such a status the way, oh say not farting in an elevator is considered rude by most if not all Western rules of social graces. On the other hand, it might just be that more men think more carefully and considerately before propositioning women in the first place. And you and I would both think that a good thing.

No. Given that the social contract does not preclude propositions for coffee then the act of doing so isn't per se rude. Declaring it rude because of particular circumstances won't make it per se rude.

A small quibble - physical autonomy is hardly a grey area. Don't bother to go into the argument, I know it by heart. Suffice to say that imo, nihilism is a philosophy best saved for those who think humans would be better off as sociopaths. With that you can probably see how the entire thing will play out and hopefully don't have the energy for it either.
 
I liked BionicDance's response


Yes and no. Her initial premise is wrong. Watson wasn't frightened.

Also, all the tasers and pepper spray in the world doesn't help against a boor. You can't shock someone for being an ass. If there were a guy at TAM who was hovering around the edges of the bar waiting to see which of the younger girls was too drunk, pepper spray is no good. If there's a guy at TAM who is hitting on every.single.woman under the age of 50, martial arts training doesn't work.
 
A small quibble - physical autonomy is hardly a grey area.
In our society? Culturally? Absolutely no gray area.

...nihilism is a philosophy best saved for those who think humans would be better off as sociopaths.
No. The only salient point is that there is no absolute moral truths. And there aren't. That doesn't mean that there are no objective truths based on our subjective preferences. There are. There is such a thing as ethical nihilism. Nihilist don't run around raping and pillaging.
 
Last edited:
Yes and no. Her initial premise is wrong. Watson wasn't frightened.

Also, all the tasers and pepper spray in the world doesn't help against a boor. You can't shock someone for being an ass. If there were a guy at TAM who was hovering around the edges of the bar waiting to see which of the younger girls was too drunk, pepper spray is no good. If there's a guy at TAM who is hitting on every.single.woman under the age of 50, martial arts training doesn't work.
EG was a guy hovering around looking for drunk girls?

Bionic's premise is personal responsibility. When in public perhaps you ought to take precautions. Be with friends. Not get so drunk you lose control of your functions (which BTW is illegal). No. Her premise is dead on. We can work to reduce boorish behavior but we can't guarantee a perfectly safe world so take some personal responsibility.
 
Except the idea of what is "reasonable" is disputed. It seems to be being taken for granted that a single view here is "reasonable" and everyone should agree. Everyone does nto agree. That is being dismissed along with the claim no one is telling anyone what they should think.

Yet, I said nothing of the sort. I said reasonable expectations that not everyone will agree on, yet I also stated that it shouldn't be a law.

I turned the tables around to illustrate there was another view of, another perspective on the event.

So how is my view different? Am I also not claiming others should hold my view? No, but the difference is subtle. Everyone can have their own view of "reasonable" behavior. But when you recognize everyone's view of "reasonable" differs, how then can you expect another to conform to your view of "reasonable" behavior?

You say you do not expect everyone to conform to your view and then finish your post by claiming that women that agree with RW are an embarrassment.

Perception of what is reasonable behavior exists on a continuum. On the extreme ends of the continuum, I think there can be defined reasonableness. Whipping out one's dong in the elevator is not reasonable behavior and though some people have even suggested the man shouldn't get in the elevator at all because some women would be discomforted, I think it is reasonable to say that simply riding in the same elevator was reasonable were RW and EG both going to their rooms.

I must have missed other people, here, stating that EG should have waited for the next elevator but it's utterly pointless when responding to me because I have claimed nothing of the sort. If you are going to address my post, do me a favor and stick to what I have actually stated. By reasonable expectations, all I mean is that there is a social norm, not a law, a norm. Occassionally people cross that norm and are actually successful; for example the friend of mine that successfully picked up a girl by telling her she had a nice set of tits. It worked, would I recommend that route? Probably not.

But when you get to the middle of the continuum, where the perception of reasonable behavior diverges, a simple majority does not define reasonable.

It doesn't have to define reasonable. How many times has there been posts by men discussing their difficulty with meeting women, understanding what women want, how to talk to women; here's a little insight, and that's the best it can be called; given the amount of women that Beth sorted out, stating that it would make them uncomfortable too, approaching them in confined quarters may not be the best approach. Call it a suggestion, call it advice.

Maybe you don't like someone's behavior. Is that reason to suggest they change? Or is it more appropriate to recognize people's perception of the situation is not consistent and therefore one cannot expect others to conform to the perception one doesn't hold? Think what you want. But before you go asking someone else to change their behavior, there should be more reason than some women don't like it.

No, it's not a law that they have to change it but when it comes to light that such an approach might make at least a large fraction of women uncomfortable, you might want to rethink it. Given the amount of excuses offered for the possible reasons that EG chose to make such an approach, it appears that even the people that didn't think RW had much of a platform, found it to be an odd approach.

Each situation needs to be judged on its own merit. If that snail car were driven by an elderly person, I'd be torn between, they shouldn't still have a driver's license and I feel for the person who will suffer if they have to give up the independence of driving.

You could describe dozens of analogies. But let's look at the substance, not the perceived annoyance. Is the driver dangerous? Was the inconvenienced driver really harmed other than annoyed?

No, they are not harmed at all, which was my point. Say you meet a friend for lunch and they bring up a situation where they were driving along and an elderly person pulls out in front of them and does half the speed limit. They've just complained about a relatively harmless situation. Are you going to lecture them about the reasonableness of their complaint or are you going to agree with them, "I know, that is so annoying. Seriously if you are too afraid to drive, get off the street!" or something of that nature. Be honest.

Surely the 'harm' done by potentially discomforting half the women who might have been on the elevator was negligible. It was so negligible in terms of real harm I find it sad that anyone is arguing it is telling women to 'suck it up' by saying they could just say, no thanks. One post even claims the discomfort was akin to saying women shouldn't complain if raped.

Again, I've not made any comparison to rape, so I am not even going to bother with that. You are telling women to suck it up and say no thanks because you've obviously never felt a sense of reluctance, in a situation, because you are now saying it's sad and an embarrassment that women have the nerve to say, "don't do that!"

The word cripple is not an assault, it's what society used to call people with disabilities. Enough disabled people made it clear that it is unacceptable and the word is rarely used anymore. The one and only time I was ever called that was at Sea World, when I was chaperoning a school field trip. I had four second grade girls and there was only four seats available so I gave them to the girls. An elderly man comes up and demands that one of the girls give their seat to the cripple. He had good intentions, he wasn't trying to be offensive but I was offended, none the less. I was a bit shocked that he could make it to 2004 without ever having learned that cripple is a crass term to use. Maybe you think I was being oversensitive by telling him that disabled people tend to not like being called cripples, but I find the word demeaning.

Was EG really displaying misogynistic and/or sexist behavior that requires changing? The more I think about the complaints, the more embarrassed I am that so many women feel their feelings are that delicate.

No I just think he made an odd approach but I think I understand your point, women who don't want that kind of approach need to get over it and comform to your view, lest they be an embarrassment. It's not about being delicate, it's about mutual respect. I will do my best not to offend you, be considerate of how you might take things and I will hope you give me the same respect. That's all.
 
I will do my best not to offend you, be considerate of how you might take things and I will hope you give me the same respect. That's all.
Therein lies the rub. How do we know what is offensive?
 
EG was a guy hovering around looking for drunk girls?

Bionic's premise is personal responsibility. When in public perhaps you ought to take precautions. Be with friends. Not get so drunk you lose control of your functions (which BTW is illegal). No. Her premise is dead on. We can work to reduce boorish behavior but we can't guarantee a perfectly safe world so take some personal responsibility.

Will.not.respond. Must save energy for making banana bread.

Seriously dude, evidence not withstanding, I do have a life. And I can't spend it arguing the finer points of nihilism/responsibility with an Ayn Rand fan. No offense. Over beer, it would be aaaaawesome. On the internet, it's hell.
 
Will.not.respond. Must save energy for making banana bread.

Seriously dude, evidence not withstanding, I do have a life. And I can't spend it arguing the finer points of nihilism/responsibility with an Ayn Rand fan. No offense. Over beer, it would be aaaaawesome. On the internet, it's hell.
That's fine but I'm at a loss as to what there is to even debate. No one has ever demonstrated a priori truth. When they do there is a Pulitzer prize and world accolades awaiting them just as there is for the discovery of mermaids or unicorns. FWIW: Be careful as to your assumptions about my admiration of Rand. I'm not an objectivist and I don't believe Laissez-faire capitalism to be a viable socioeconomic system. But that's fine. :)
 
That's fine but I'm at a loss as to what there is to even debate. No one has ever demonstrated a priori truth. When they do there is a Pulitzer prize and world accolades awaiting them just as there is for the discovery of mermaids or unicorns. FWIW: Be careful as to your assumptions about my admiration of Rand. I'm not an objectivist and I don't believe Laissez-faire capitalism to be a viable socioeconomic system. But that's fine. :)

Oh I know, but the sentence would have looked so bare without it. ;)
 
People who are made uncomfortable when a stranger approaches them unasked need to adjust their behavior? How would they do that? They have no choice in the matter.

Sorry to jump in here with this but I would just point out.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavior_modification
This is how I got over my problems with depression.
It is possible to change your behavior. It is really really hard. You just have to decide to do it. And think about it every second of the day for the next several years.
 
Last edited:
How about photographic evidence? These shocking photos were taken at TAM 2.
 

Attachments

  • Partygoodboy.jpg
    Partygoodboy.jpg
    83.3 KB · Views: 47
  • MoeRickshaw.jpg
    MoeRickshaw.jpg
    96.9 KB · Views: 49
Sorry to jump in here with this but I would just point out.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavior_modification
This is how I got over my problems with depression.
It is possible to change your behavior. It is really really hard. You just have to decide to do it. And think about it every second of the day for the next several years.

Personal growth is a completely different topic (albeit, an interesting one.)

I doubt you're trying to say that women who are interested in skepticism need to invest years of hard work in order to get over their dislike of being bluntly propositioned. That behavior really doesn't need to be modified.
 
So touching is bad but words are ok?
Much too generalizing. You consistently exaggerate which I again can only assume is something you need to do because the facts don't support your position.

Asking someone politely in an elevator if they'd like to come to your room requires no more than a, no thank you, to be done with it.

If the same guy groped your ass, it hardly represents an equivalent thing.

That doesn't mean cheek kissing or hugging, which are two common social greetings in various cultures, are equivalent to ass patting or ass grabbing either. And ass patting seems to be the norm in some sports arenas. You cannot just make a blanket statement that all touching is the same.
 
Much too generalizing. You consistently exaggerate which I again can only assume is something you need to do because the facts don't support your position.

Asking someone politely in an elevator if they'd like to come to your room requires no more than a, no thank you, to be done with it.

If the same guy groped your ass, it hardly represents an equivalent thing.

That doesn't mean cheek kissing or hugging, which are two common social greetings in various cultures, are equivalent to ass patting or ass grabbing either. And ass patting seems to be the norm in some sports arenas. You cannot just make a blanket statement that all touching is the same.

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Removed link to personal attack. Do not repost such links in the future.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Therein lies the rub. How do we know what is offensive?

You don't, societal behaviors change, but when someone comes out and says that a certain behavior is creepy and then something in the range of 40% of the participants in that exchange agree that it is creepy, it's now known that there is a good chance that you are going to come off as creepy. Communication is always a bit of a crapshoot, especially when cultural lines are crossed, but the more information that is available, the more chance you have at successful communication.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom