Beth, I see a number of flaws with your arguments. I'll do my best to explain, but it's going to be VERY long. I don't feel bad considering how long this thread has already become. Please do me the courtesy of reading it all the way through before responding. The points build on each other.
Thank for taking the time to write such a well developed response. Since it is so long, I'm only going to respond to a few points. If there is something in particular you would like me to respond to, please ask.
Beth says EG should have waited the few seconds for the elevator doors to open. I reverse that argument to say that if the elevator doors were to open within a few seconds, there's not much reason for concern. It goes both ways.
Sadly, it does not. Until the doors open, it is possible for the man to prevent that from happening and prolong the time in the elevator until he is willing to let her out. That is why the elevator contributes heavily to the feeling of discomfort some woman feel in that situation. The minor inconvenience that the man may experience by waiting for the elevator doors to open is trivial in comparison and renders the situation unequal. It does not go both ways.
First, a little hypocrisy revelation is in order. Bookitty, while disputing my contention that people should not let other people be responsible for their drinking (the serial male seducer story), said that these women made the mistake of trusting their "fellow skeptic." It strikes me as hypocritical to make that argument on one hand and on the other call EG a "complete stranger" to RW.
He wasn't. They were attending the same conference, which forms a bond of camaraderie. It's one reason why people keep their badges on after hours. You'll chat with "strangers" wearing the same kind of badge while you ignore the other people there. It doesn't mean your best buds, but it makes the "complete stranger" claim a bit tenuous, especially when you figure his name was on his badge.
I am not Bookitty. I have not made that argument nor even discussed that particular incident. IMO, attending the same conference does not negate the other person being a 'total stranger', particularly in regard to an invitation to his hotel room when the woman has never spoken with him previously. I don't think your accusation of hypocrisy is valid.
If you're going to condemn someone as being "inappropriate" for making a proposition, the amount of indignation to which you're entitled is commensurate with the things you've done to indicate your reaction...
I'm not calling RW a slut. What I'm saying is that when people treat us a certain way, we need to be aware of what we've done to give that person an indication that their behavior might be appropriate.
I think this is a valid point, but it does not work in favor of your argument. Despite earlier escapades in her life, RW had made it quite clear that she would not be receptive to such an invitation at that time.
I can see how it might have been a proposition. I see it as more likely that EG meant what he said. I find the unyielding, unsupported assertion that it was a proposition to be sexist towards men.
I agree there is some probability that he was not interested in sex when he asked her to come to his hotel room. However, even if that was the case, women are not entitled to make that assumption. If they do, and they are wrong, they will be blamed as hopelessly naive and deserving of whatever happened to them. You may see the assumption as unyielding, unsupported and sexist towards men. I see it as the only reasonable assumption a for woman in that situation to make. I also consider the probability that he was not hoping for sex if she said yes to be quite small.
I find epepke's assertion that such invitations are frequently issued and accepted at conferences between men to be a revelation. I've never had such an invitation given to me at a conference, even those I have presented papers at. I have only received requests to meet in the hotel lobby, restaurant, or other public locations. IMO most men are aware that such an invitation issued to a woman has entirely different connotations than one issued to another man.
Looking at the totality of circumstances and the actions taken (and not taken) by RW, I find the implication of the Fear Factor to be either disingenuous or unreasonable. I don't believe as a society we should be obligated to base our behaviors on irrational reactions, regardless of gender.
I find her discomfort (she never said she was afraid) quite understandable. I would likely feel the same. Whether rational or not, I think that it is very common reaction. Given that it can reasonably be expected to cause a large percentage of women discomfort and the alternative is not much of an imposition on men (waiting until the elevator doors are open to make the invitation), and given the current socially accepted standards of elevator etiquette (
http://www.elevatorrules.com/), it seems quite reasonable to me to let men know that many women find that behavior unacceptable.
If a man doesn't don't mind making women uncomfortable, he can certainly make such propositions in elevators. If he does, many women will find them creepy, boorish, and not want to have coffee with them anywhere as a result. All in all, I don't know why a man, regardless of whether he wants sex or just coffee and conversation, would want to creep out the woman he's inviting. OTOH, certain types of predators enjoy making women uncomfortable. All-in-all, it's just not a smart move for a sincere guy because, as one commentator put it, it's behavior that is indistinguishable from creepy.
Those people (by "those people" I mean "we" since we all have our sore spots) need to accept that their behavior is a few standard deviations from the norm.
IMO RW's reaction was NOT far from the norm. There are women who apparently will never take an elevator with a strange man and no one else in it. They get off and with for the next one. That's reasonable because they are farther from the norm and I don't think men should be obligated to wait and take the next elevator. Why do you think that RW's reaction was a few standard deviations from the norm?
The most important thing of all is that this is not an issue or sexism of feminism. I tried to use gender neutral language when appropriate. I would apply the same reasoning to all permutations of gender and sexual orientation. It is simply an issue of manners. To make it a feminist issue trivializes feminism, as Richard Dawkins made quite clear. It's also extremely divisive, and it makes men such as myself who not only believe in equality but practice it daily less reluctant to involve ourselves with feminist groups and causes.
I don't know if this is legitimately an issue of sexism or feminism. I agree that EG was not necessarily being sexist or sexualizing or objectifying RW. I think RW was wrong to class those who disagreed with her assessment as misogyist.
OTOH, I don't think an invitation to a man's hotel room can be treated without regard to the sex of the invitee. A woman should not assume that the man issuing the invitation is desiring only coffee and conversation and should not go to the hotel room of any man that she is not prepared to have sex with.