EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

I wish to offer my two cents...

A) A famous man's name is tagged to this and other threads and he hasn't been proven to have done anything wrong and I think we can discuss this as hypothetical without dragging what may be an innocent person's name through whatever. Drop his name from the tag.

B) Equating rape to inappropriate language is wrong. Rape ruins people. Inappropriate verbal flirting can be very wrong but it doesn't usually ruin lives.

C) I don't see skeptic men as different than other men. My mom was a nurse and she said some doctors/surgeons were people nurses avoided getting in an elevator with alone even during daylight. These men were men people looked up to, not drunks on vacation in Las Vegas.

I've been to Las Vegas for trade shows and I know some men drink too much and get more aggressive than they usually are at home. Not an excuse for men, but an excuse for not singling out skeptics over plumbers in Las Vegas. I doubt a scientific study would find men on this site are more sexist than the population at large, and I bet they would be found to be less sexist. (No proof, just my gut feeling).
 
I wish to offer my two cents...

A) A famous man's name is tagged to this and other threads and he hasn't been proven to have done anything wrong and I think we can discuss this as hypothetical without dragging what may be an innocent person's name through whatever. Drop his name from the tag.

B) Equating rape to inappropriate language is wrong. Rape ruins people. Inappropriate verbal flirting can be very wrong but it doesn't usually ruin lives.

C) I don't see skeptic men as different than other men. My mom was a nurse and she said some doctors/surgeons were people nurses avoided getting in an elevator with alone even during daylight. These men were men people looked up to, not drunks on vacation in Las Vegas.

I've been to Las Vegas for trade shows and I know some men drink too much and get more aggressive than they usually are at home. Not an excuse for men, but an excuse for not singling out skeptics over plumbers in Las Vegas. I doubt a scientific study would find men on this site are more sexist than the population at large, and I bet they would be found to be less sexist. (No proof, just my gut feeling).
I approve of this meesage. :)
 
I wish to offer my two cents...

A) A famous man's name is tagged to this and other threads and he hasn't been proven to have done anything wrong and I think we can discuss this as hypothetical without dragging what may be an innocent person's name through whatever. Drop his name from the tag.

B) Equating rape to inappropriate language is wrong. Rape ruins people. Inappropriate verbal flirting can be very wrong but it doesn't usually ruin lives.

C) I don't see skeptic men as different than other men. My mom was a nurse and she said some doctors/surgeons were people nurses avoided getting in an elevator with alone even during daylight. These men were men people looked up to, not drunks on vacation in Las Vegas.

I've been to Las Vegas for trade shows and I know some men drink too much and get more aggressive than they usually are at home. Not an excuse for men, but an excuse for not singling out skeptics over plumbers in Las Vegas. I doubt a scientific study would find men on this site are more sexist than the population at large, and I bet they would be found to be less sexist. (No proof, just my gut feeling).
While I generally agree, I have a question. Are liberals less likely to be sexist than conservatives or not? Are Christians whose religion has some sexist tenets, more likely to be sexist than atheists?
 
I approve of this meesage. :)
You are a fan of the truth I bet.

While I generally agree, I have a question. Are liberals less likely to be sexist than conservatives or not?
This is a "what is your definition of the terms question." My gut says liberals are less sexist but Sarah Palin may disagree.
Are Christians whose religion has some sexist tenets, more likely to be sexist than atheists?
You only asked for one question as I recall. I'll answer a second but you owe me ;)

Yes, sexist tenet Christians are more likely to be sexist than atheists.

It required effort that needs to be repayed to discover this truth. How can you ever repay me? (My point is I'm a guy and we are sexist by nature and you ladies wouldn't have it any other way ;) )
 
How does skepchick compare to richarddawkins.net?
If you feel it's relevant for some reason, explain why. If you need help doing it, just ask. I compared the Skepchick site to StopSylvia and the JREF to demonstrate that your claim of it being a "very small blog" is unsupported.

Who do you think has a higher profile in the atheism/skeptical community, Dawkins or Watson?
Skeptic Ginger answered this quite well.

I assume that you're implying that the JREF is such a board, and that the arguments are "going" against RW. That certainly hasn't been my impression, unless you measure it by number of posts.
Yes, I was implying the JREF is such a board. No, I was not implying that I had made a conclusion about which way the wind blows here. Have you attempted to verify your impression by counting members posting?


In any event, this is an odd sort of distinction you're trying to draw here. The JREF is "neutral" because it's a "discussion board," but say, Pharyngula isn't because it's a "blog"?
Who decides what topics get started on Pharyngula?

Who decides here?

Blogs, even the JREF's SWIFT, will remove or not approve comments for whatever reason they choose. On discussion boards like this, very few posts are removed and pretty much never for their position.

People are attracted to blogs for the opinions, generally to nod their heads in agreement. People are attracted to discussion forums like the JREF for the debate.
 
This is a "what is your definition of the terms question." My gut says liberals are less sexist but Sarah Palin may disagree.
Someone who calls Obama a socialist is not a good source for definitions. OTOH, Palin is a liberated woman in many ways, religious right winger or not. I am talking about the aggregate here, not the individuals.

You only asked for one question as I recall. I'll answer a second but you owe me ;)...
It required effort that needs to be repayed to discover this truth. How can you ever repay me? (My point is I'm a guy and we are sexist by nature and you ladies wouldn't have it any other way ;) )
I am one of those women who has no issues with the biological differences between men and women. I wouldn't even be bothered if a man wanted to 'take care of me' as long as he respected me as a partner when it came to decisions that affect me or us.
 
Beth, I see a number of flaws with your arguments. I'll do my best to explain, but it's going to be VERY long. I don't feel bad considering how long this thread has already become. Please do me the courtesy of reading it all the way through before responding. The points build on each other.
Thank for taking the time to write such a well developed response. Since it is so long, I'm only going to respond to a few points. If there is something in particular you would like me to respond to, please ask.
Beth says EG should have waited the few seconds for the elevator doors to open. I reverse that argument to say that if the elevator doors were to open within a few seconds, there's not much reason for concern. It goes both ways.
Sadly, it does not. Until the doors open, it is possible for the man to prevent that from happening and prolong the time in the elevator until he is willing to let her out. That is why the elevator contributes heavily to the feeling of discomfort some woman feel in that situation. The minor inconvenience that the man may experience by waiting for the elevator doors to open is trivial in comparison and renders the situation unequal. It does not go both ways.
First, a little hypocrisy revelation is in order. Bookitty, while disputing my contention that people should not let other people be responsible for their drinking (the serial male seducer story), said that these women made the mistake of trusting their "fellow skeptic." It strikes me as hypocritical to make that argument on one hand and on the other call EG a "complete stranger" to RW.
He wasn't. They were attending the same conference, which forms a bond of camaraderie. It's one reason why people keep their badges on after hours. You'll chat with "strangers" wearing the same kind of badge while you ignore the other people there. It doesn't mean your best buds, but it makes the "complete stranger" claim a bit tenuous, especially when you figure his name was on his badge.
I am not Bookitty. I have not made that argument nor even discussed that particular incident. IMO, attending the same conference does not negate the other person being a 'total stranger', particularly in regard to an invitation to his hotel room when the woman has never spoken with him previously. I don't think your accusation of hypocrisy is valid.
If you're going to condemn someone as being "inappropriate" for making a proposition, the amount of indignation to which you're entitled is commensurate with the things you've done to indicate your reaction...
I'm not calling RW a slut. What I'm saying is that when people treat us a certain way, we need to be aware of what we've done to give that person an indication that their behavior might be appropriate.
I think this is a valid point, but it does not work in favor of your argument. Despite earlier escapades in her life, RW had made it quite clear that she would not be receptive to such an invitation at that time.
I can see how it might have been a proposition. I see it as more likely that EG meant what he said. I find the unyielding, unsupported assertion that it was a proposition to be sexist towards men.
I agree there is some probability that he was not interested in sex when he asked her to come to his hotel room. However, even if that was the case, women are not entitled to make that assumption. If they do, and they are wrong, they will be blamed as hopelessly naive and deserving of whatever happened to them. You may see the assumption as unyielding, unsupported and sexist towards men. I see it as the only reasonable assumption a for woman in that situation to make. I also consider the probability that he was not hoping for sex if she said yes to be quite small.

I find epepke's assertion that such invitations are frequently issued and accepted at conferences between men to be a revelation. I've never had such an invitation given to me at a conference, even those I have presented papers at. I have only received requests to meet in the hotel lobby, restaurant, or other public locations. IMO most men are aware that such an invitation issued to a woman has entirely different connotations than one issued to another man.

Looking at the totality of circumstances and the actions taken (and not taken) by RW, I find the implication of the Fear Factor to be either disingenuous or unreasonable. I don't believe as a society we should be obligated to base our behaviors on irrational reactions, regardless of gender.
I find her discomfort (she never said she was afraid) quite understandable. I would likely feel the same. Whether rational or not, I think that it is very common reaction. Given that it can reasonably be expected to cause a large percentage of women discomfort and the alternative is not much of an imposition on men (waiting until the elevator doors are open to make the invitation), and given the current socially accepted standards of elevator etiquette (http://www.elevatorrules.com/), it seems quite reasonable to me to let men know that many women find that behavior unacceptable.

If a man doesn't don't mind making women uncomfortable, he can certainly make such propositions in elevators. If he does, many women will find them creepy, boorish, and not want to have coffee with them anywhere as a result. All in all, I don't know why a man, regardless of whether he wants sex or just coffee and conversation, would want to creep out the woman he's inviting. OTOH, certain types of predators enjoy making women uncomfortable. All-in-all, it's just not a smart move for a sincere guy because, as one commentator put it, it's behavior that is indistinguishable from creepy.

Those people (by "those people" I mean "we" since we all have our sore spots) need to accept that their behavior is a few standard deviations from the norm.
IMO RW's reaction was NOT far from the norm. There are women who apparently will never take an elevator with a strange man and no one else in it. They get off and with for the next one. That's reasonable because they are farther from the norm and I don't think men should be obligated to wait and take the next elevator. Why do you think that RW's reaction was a few standard deviations from the norm?
The most important thing of all is that this is not an issue or sexism of feminism. I tried to use gender neutral language when appropriate. I would apply the same reasoning to all permutations of gender and sexual orientation. It is simply an issue of manners. To make it a feminist issue trivializes feminism, as Richard Dawkins made quite clear. It's also extremely divisive, and it makes men such as myself who not only believe in equality but practice it daily less reluctant to involve ourselves with feminist groups and causes.
I don't know if this is legitimately an issue of sexism or feminism. I agree that EG was not necessarily being sexist or sexualizing or objectifying RW. I think RW was wrong to class those who disagreed with her assessment as misogyist.

OTOH, I don't think an invitation to a man's hotel room can be treated without regard to the sex of the invitee. A woman should not assume that the man issuing the invitation is desiring only coffee and conversation and should not go to the hotel room of any man that she is not prepared to have sex with.
 
If you feel it's relevant for some reason, explain why. If you need help doing it, just ask. I compared the Skepchick site to StopSylvia and the JREF to demonstrate that your claim of it being a "very small blog" is unsupported.

The point is that the premise that "bloggers are taking Watson's side because they she's got a popular blog and they like her" is rather dubious given that those same bloggers have taken "Watson's side" over "Dawkins' side," and Dawkins has a much bigger net presence and many of these bloggers are at least as "close" to Dawkins as to Watson.

Skeptic Ginger answered this quite well.

No, she really didn't. She, like you, has decided that it's more fun to imply that people who disagree with her are just biased. That's ok, two can play that game. I've decided to repeat in every post that SG only disagrees with Watson because she's jealous of her success.

Yes, I was implying the JREF is such a board. No, I was not implying that I had made a conclusion about which way the wind blows here.

Liar. You were implying just that.

Have you attempted to verify your impression by counting members posting?

No, because I'm not the one making these ad populum arguments, or claiming a difference between blog commenters and forum posters. It's your claim, you gather the damn evidence.

Who decides what topics get started on Pharyngula?

Who decides here?

Blogs, even the JREF's SWIFT, will remove or not approve comments for whatever reason they choose. On discussion boards like this, very few posts are removed and pretty much never for their position.

People are attracted to blogs for the opinions, generally to nod their heads in agreement. People are attracted to discussion forums like the JREF for the debate.

All of which is just dependent on your flawed original claim that the blog owners are "biased."
 
....
No, she really didn't. She, like you, has decided that it's more fun to imply that people who disagree with her are just biased. That's ok, two can play that game. I've decided to repeat in every post that SG only disagrees with Watson because she's jealous of her success.

Your question: "Who do you think has a higher profile in the atheism/skeptical community, Dawkins or Watson?"

My answer: "Dawkins has a larger presence among the public. He actually is an accomplished biologist and writer. RW has a large presence in the skeptical community which is the community that is discussing this topic. I imagine most of Dawkins' fans don't think RW's comments about him were more than a drop in the bucket of the gazillion other people who criticize Dawkins all the time. It got a little notice but not the explosion of interest that was more localized within the skeptic and atheist community familiar with RW.

What you are missing is that most of the people in this discussion are in the friends of RW category. Dawkins has had enemies since he first attacked god beliefs. The two worlds are not the same."


Could you please support your charge that my answer reflects only bias against people who disagree with me rather than fact.

As for being jealous, no. I have no interest in being in her shoes, she is nothing like me and I like who I am. Bothered that skeptics find such interest in someone who doesn't have a lot of substance, yes. Bothered that skeptics are repeating the unsupported claims of RW, also, yes. It's unfortunate. But it is not an insurmountable barrier to promoting critical thinking. Rather, I think many people are learning from the example.


....All of which is just dependent on your flawed original claim that the blog owners are "biased."
How could they possibly not be biased? Your definition of what is meant by bias may be the problem here. One can be biased toward the valid evidence based conclusion just as one can be biased against it. Bias merely means point of view. One has to address what one is biased against or toward in order to define bias as bigoted or causing one to not see the facts.
 
Last edited:
Some data on women's reactions to EG's behavior

I decided to do a little data collection on the question of how common RW's reaction to EG's proposition was. I went to an article published at the Atlantic Wire and examine the 1060 comments on that site. Here is the link.
http://www.theatlanticwire.com/nati...-wrath-over-sexual-harassment-comments/39637/

Since this is not a skeptic site, I felt the comments there would be more representative of women in general. I did not notice fans of RW commenting on that site, so I don't think that it should be biased for that reason.

I limited my data collection to posters that had female names, female avatars, or indicated in their posts that they were female. I skimmed over posters who had obviously male name or male avatars. I may have missed some on either side, so feel free to go there, check out the comments, and suggest additions to either list.

I identified 9 female posters who felt that that EG's behavior was just fine and an additional three that I suspect are female but was unable to ascertain for sure. I identified 15 female posters that felt that EG's behavior was inappropriate and an additional two that I suspect are female but was unable to ascertain for sure. With 15 out of 24 women feeling that EG behavior inappropriately, that's 62.6%. While I cannot still state with certainty that a majority of women would find it inappropriate, I think it adds support to that conclusion. I also think that it shows that RW's reaction is not very far from the norm for women.

Here is the list of poster names and how I categorized them. While you might not agree with my results, you can at least go to the site and verify them for yourself.

Female posters who support EG:
  • Pamala Clift
    heysuze
    skepticgal2
    audreyafaber
    shahan
    MomsUnite
    annademo
    Alyson Conyers
    SciFi_Chick
Possibly female posters who support EG:
  • evil_spock
    llilly
    amenhammer
Female posters who think EG's behavior was inappropriate:
  • Kristine Collins
    molly cruz
    Rebecca
    Mary Parker
    Carrie Patrick
    A is for Atheist
    ankhorite
    Labyrinthia
    marilynsue
    Dawn Sed
    Nahida Nisa
    eclecticeccentric
    LadyAtheist
    Solutreantoolkit
    tinfoil hattie
Possibly female Female posters who think EG's behavior was inappropriate:
  • drst
    the_procter
 
I decided to do a little data collection on the question of how common RW's reaction to EG's proposition was. I went to an article published at the Atlantic Wire and examine the 1060 comments on that site. Here is the link.
http://www.theatlanticwire.com/nati...-wrath-over-sexual-harassment-comments/39637/

Since this is not a skeptic site, I felt the comments there would be more representative of women in general. I did not notice fans of RW commenting on that site, so I don't think that it should be biased for that reason.

I limited my data collection to posters that had female names, female avatars, or indicated in their posts that they were female. I skimmed over posters who had obviously male name or male avatars. I may have missed some on either side, so feel free to go there, check out the comments, and suggest additions to either list.

I identified 9 female posters who felt that that EG's behavior was just fine and an additional three that I suspect are female but was unable to ascertain for sure. I identified 15 female posters that felt that EG's behavior was inappropriate and an additional two that I suspect are female but was unable to ascertain for sure. With 15 out of 24 women feeling that EG behavior inappropriately, that's 62.6%. While I cannot still state with certainty that a majority of women would find it inappropriate, I think it adds support to that conclusion. I also think that it shows that RW's reaction is not very far from the norm for women.

Here is the list of poster names and how I categorized them. While you might not agree with my results, you can at least go to the site and verify them for yourself.

Female posters who support EG:
  • Pamala Clift
    heysuze
    skepticgal2
    audreyafaber
    shahan
    MomsUnite
    annademo
    Alyson Conyers
    SciFi_Chick
Possibly female posters who support EG:
  • evil_spock
    llilly
    amenhammer
Female posters who think EG's behavior was inappropriate:
  • Kristine Collins
    molly cruz
    Rebecca
    Mary Parker
    Carrie Patrick
    A is for Atheist
    ankhorite
    Labyrinthia
    marilynsue
    Dawn Sed
    Nahida Nisa
    eclecticeccentric
    LadyAtheist
    Solutreantoolkit
    tinfoil hattie
Possibly female Female posters who think EG's behavior was inappropriate:
  • drst
    the_procter

Given the small, possibly not representative sample, and the fact that the numbers aren't overwhelmingly supporting one stance, I'd suggest that we can't say that's significantly different to an even split on the subject..
 
Given the small, possibly not representative sample, and the fact that the numbers aren't overwhelmingly supporting one stance, I'd suggest that we can't say that's significantly different to an even split on the subject..

We can practically guarantee that people who feel strongly enough to post a comment or write a blog entry about the EG "issue" are not a representative sample of the vast majority of people who consider it trivial and/or don't care what Ms. Watson says or thinks about it.
 
I decided to do a little data collection on the question of how common RW's reaction to EG's proposition was. I went to an article published at the Atlantic Wire and examine the 1060 comments on that site. Here is the link.
http://www.theatlanticwire.com/nati...-wrath-over-sexual-harassment-comments/39637/

Since this is not a skeptic site, I felt the comments there would be more representative of women in general. I did not notice fans of RW commenting on that site, so I don't think that it should be biased for that reason.

I limited my data collection to posters that had female names, female avatars, or indicated in their posts that they were female. I skimmed over posters who had obviously male name or male avatars. I may have missed some on either side, so feel free to go there, check out the comments, and suggest additions to either list.

I identified 9 female posters who felt that that EG's behavior was just fine and an additional three that I suspect are female but was unable to ascertain for sure. I identified 15 female posters that felt that EG's behavior was inappropriate and an additional two that I suspect are female but was unable to ascertain for sure. With 15 out of 24 women feeling that EG behavior inappropriately, that's 62.6%. While I cannot still state with certainty that a majority of women would find it inappropriate, I think it adds support to that conclusion. I also think that it shows that RW's reaction is not very far from the norm for women.

Here is the list of poster names and how I categorized them. While you might not agree with my results, you can at least go to the site and verify them for yourself.

Female posters who support EG:
  • Pamala Clift
    heysuze
    skepticgal2
    audreyafaber
    shahan
    MomsUnite
    annademo
    Alyson Conyers
    SciFi_Chick
Possibly female posters who support EG:
  • evil_spock
    llilly
    amenhammer
Female posters who think EG's behavior was inappropriate:
  • Kristine Collins
    molly cruz
    Rebecca
    Mary Parker
    Carrie Patrick
    A is for Atheist
    ankhorite
    Labyrinthia
    marilynsue
    Dawn Sed
    Nahida Nisa
    eclecticeccentric
    LadyAtheist
    Solutreantoolkit
    tinfoil hattie
Possibly female Female posters who think EG's behavior was inappropriate:
  • drst
    the_procter
Thank you for doing that. It is very useful information, even if just to test the hypothesis that the trend we estimate we are reading is a blog really is borne out when the observation is more systematic.

It would be well worth the effort to compare certain blogs. PZ has a later one he closed after ~1,000 replies I might try to count up later. And I wonder if there are any on this subject over at RD's site?
 
Last edited:
We can practically guarantee that people who feel strongly enough to post a comment or write a blog entry about the EG "issue" are not a representative sample of the vast majority of people who consider it trivial and/or don't care what Ms. Watson says or thinks about it.
So we are measuring the tails of the bell curve. The information is still useful.
 
Given the small, possibly not representative sample, and the fact that the numbers aren't overwhelmingly supporting one stance, I'd suggest that we can't say that's significantly different to an even split on the subject..

You are correct. The p-value for a 9/15 split from a 50/50 population is 0.1537, which would not be considered significantly different. On the other hand, a 50/50 split indicates that such reactions are very common.

We can practically guarantee that people who feel strongly enough to post a comment or write a blog entry about the EG "issue" are not a representative sample of the vast majority of people who consider it trivial and/or don't care what Ms. Watson says or thinks about it.

I don't know that people posting particularly cared about Ms. Watson since it was not a skeptic site. While we can't know that it is representative, there is no reason to assume bias one way or the other.

Thank you for doing that. It is very useful information, even if just to test the hypothesis that the trend we estimate we are reading is a blog really is borne out when the observation is more systematic.
Yes, that's basically why I decided to do so. It indicated to me that my observations were not terribly biased, but a reasonably close assessment of what I had read.
It would be well worth the effort to compare certain blogs. PZ has a later one he closed after ~1,000 replies I might try to count up later. And I wonder if there are any on this subject over at RD's site?

I read a few hundred comments from PZ's blog, mostly in the comments on the post about RD's 'letter to muslima'. That's really about all I can stomach from his readers. While PZ is entertaining, I find his commenters to be unpleasant reading and don't usually bother, so I won't be attempting that. I don't know if RD's site has anything on it as I don't peruse that. But anyone who wants to do more could do so for either site, or any other, and post their results here.
 
I don't know that people posting particularly cared about Ms. Watson since it was not a skeptic site. While we can't know that it is representative, there is no reason to assume bias one way or the other.
There IS reason. People don't live in a vacuum. Opinions about sex-positivism, gender equality, polemical rhetoric, boorish male attitudes, etc., influence damn near everyone. If we don't at least consider that there could be bias, and therefore skeptical of the data, then we are neither skeptics nor are we critical thinkers.
 
I see no mention of political attitudes in the abstract and the paper has a fee for access.

That's true. You have to find the paper, but the link gives enough information to find it in a good university library. I've read the full paper, and there was no correlation with political attitudes, MMPI scores, intelligence tests, or several other factors. The strongest correlation was with the stated sex of the child, and there were much smaller correlations with the sex of the respondent and their experience with children.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom