EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Did you look at the following which has been linked to several times in this thread?
Not previously
“Hotel Elevator Rape” Is Less Common Than “Man Bites Dog”

It appears to draw a reasonable conclusion based on a fair amount of evidence and to my knowledge no one has provided an evidence based rebuttal.

I have a problem with his methodology. For starters, he limited his data collection to rape only, while I have been specifically avoiding the term rape and talking about sexual assaults, a broader term than rape. Far more troublesome was the limitation on his data collection to rapes occurring in hotel elevators while not similarly limiting his man bites dog search. How many times have dogs been bitten by a human in hotel elevators? I would expect that a man raping a woman is a more common crime than a man biting a dog in just about any specific situation you want to collect data on.

Limiting one type of incident to very specific circumstances while not similarly limiting the other doesn't make for a reasonable comparison. Of course, I don't get the impression that a reasonable comparison was his intention.
 
So the argument is:

P: Some humans fear attack from other humans in an elevator.

The question posed against that is:

Q: Is that fear rational?

We have two answers.

1. Yes, it is rational and here is the data that proves the risk.

Q1: Is the risk reduced when politely propositioned (applying to our incident)?

a. Yes the risk is reduced...here is the data.

Conclusion then is that we should always talk to people in elevators to put them at ease and reduce the risk.

b. No the risk is not reduced

Conclusion is that we should have to develop some social cues to help people through this

c. No the risk is increased

Do not proposition others in elevators.

2. The fear is not rational.

Conclusion is that those humans have to deal with their irrational fear.


Is this breakdown fair? If it is then the contention here is basically the rationality of that fear. If the rationality has been proven(haven't seen it yet) then the next step is to find out if propositions actually increase the risk or leave it the same to warrant a look at the problem.
:) :) :)

One problem. It requires critical thinking.
 
Enough that it warrents specific instructions in classes provided to women on how to avoid sexual assault.
I disagree that this can be used for drawing any conclusion at all about the realism of the threat. It will be treated in classes if women attending such classes request that it be treated. And they will request if if they have this fear, whether or not the fear is rational.

Even if the instructors know perfectly well that elevator assaults are next to non-existent, they wouldn't really have a good reason not to teach it. First, this type of instruction is, in my opinion at least, as much about making women feel secure, as it is about providing them with knowledge that is actually useful. Second, just about any technique that can be taught to defend oneself against assault in an elevator, can also be used in more realistic situations

Anyway, I don't know what this really has to do with the topic of this thread, other than that I agree it that if this is an irrational fear, as I'm inclined to believe, then it would be good to get that information out so that women can be more relaxed in elevators, regardless of whether anyone is talking about coffee or not.
 
Not previously


I have a problem with his methodology. For starters, he limited his data collection to rape only, while I have been specifically avoiding the term rape and talking about sexual assaults, a broader term than rape. Far more troublesome was the limitation on his data collection to rapes occurring in hotel elevators while not similarly limiting his man bites dog search. How many times have dogs been bitten by a human in hotel elevators? I would expect that a man raping a woman is a more common crime than a man biting a dog in just about any specific situation you want to collect data on.

Limiting one type of incident to very specific circumstances while not similarly limiting the other doesn't make for a reasonable comparison. Of course, I don't get the impression that a reasonable comparison was his intention.
The whole premise in elevatorgate includes, 4am, foreign country, and "come to my room", so Dr B had a reason to look specifically at hotel elevators. As for rape vs assault, I'm not quite sure what you expect the data might show that it doesn't. Robbery in elevators? Groping?

As for the control, man bites dog, I think that was tongue in cheek. It should be obvious to anyone who believes 1 in 4 women has been sexually assaulted (even 1 in 6) combined with the number of elevator hours women must accumulate over a decade that one should see more assaults in those elevators than the data collected showed.

As it stands, I've not seen anyone make an evidence based case supporting the claim, elevators are places one should particularly be concerned. You cited safety training, but that is no more than evidence of the belief.

The whole premise that this elevator was somehow a 'confined space' is extremely weak. Stand by the door, don't stand against the back wall if it suits your world view of risk.
 
The whole premise in elevatorgate includes, 4am, foreign country, and "come to my room", so Dr B had a reason to look specifically at hotel elevators. As for rape vs assault, I'm not quite sure what you expect the data might show that it doesn't. Robbery in elevators? Groping?
Robbery is not a sexual assault. Personally, I wouldn't consider groping to be either, although I'm not certain of the legal definition. I think of sexual assault as an attempted rape. Sometimes the man doesn't manage to accomplish intercourse for some reason, like being interrupted or premature ejaculation.
As for the control, man bites dog, I think that was tongue in cheek. It should be obvious to anyone who believes 1 in 4 women has been sexually assaulted (even 1 in 6) combined with the number of elevator hours women must accumulate over a decade that one should see more assaults in those elevators than the data collected showed.
No, IMO not at all obvious. Can you provide some evidence to back up the claim that we would expect to see more assaults in elevators (or hotel elevators) than the collected data show? Or give the assumptions you are making when doing the calculation that allowed you to make that determination?
As it stands, I've not seen anyone make an evidence based case supporting the claim, elevators are places one should particularly be concerned. You cited safety training, but that is no more than evidence of the belief.
Yes. Evidence of that belief by people who assess such risks professionally.
The whole premise that this elevator was somehow a 'confined space' is extremely weak. Stand by the door, don't stand against the back wall if it suits your world view of risk.
Standing by the door is one of the pieces of advice those professionals give.
 
I disagree that this can be used for drawing any conclusion at all about the realism of the threat. It will be treated in classes if women attending such classes request that it be treated. And they will request if if they have this fear, whether or not the fear is rational.
Do you have any reason to suspect that a) women have requested such instruction or b) the content of such classes are based on requests of that nature?
Even if the instructors know perfectly well that elevator assaults are next to non-existent, they wouldn't really have a good reason not to teach it.
Actually they do. Such classes are typically quite short, so there is a limited amount of time to cover all the information they wish to import. There's no reason to spend class time on situations that don't require it.
First, this type of instruction is, in my opinion at least, as much about making women feel secure, as it is about providing them with knowledge that is actually useful. Second, just about any technique that can be taught to defend oneself against assault in an elevator, can also be used in more realistic situations.
I have no reason to think that they are more interested in making women feel secure rather than helping them to be more secure, which will also help them feel secure.
Anyway, I don't know what this really has to do with the topic of this thread, other than that I agree it that if this is an irrational fear, as I'm inclined to believe, then it would be good to get that information out so that women can be more relaxed in elevators, regardless of whether anyone is talking about coffee or not.
I don't think women are particularly afraid of being raped in elevators. What it is, IMO, is that they are discomfited by sexual invitations from strangers in elevators. That isn't quite the same thing.
 
Robbery is not a sexual assault. Personally, I wouldn't consider groping to be either, although I'm not certain of the legal definition. I think of sexual assault as an attempted rape. Sometimes the man doesn't manage to accomplish intercourse for some reason, like being interrupted or premature ejaculation.
No, IMO not at all obvious. Can you provide some evidence to back up the claim that we would expect to see more assaults in elevators (or hotel elevators) than the collected data show? Or give the assumptions you are making when doing the calculation that allowed you to make that determination?
Yes. Evidence of that belief by people who assess such risks professionally.

Standing by the door is one of the pieces of advice those professionals give.
Beth, you continue to ask the side that actually has presented evidence to provide more, all the while the side that has presented no evidence still has presented no evidence.
 
Can you provide some evidence to back up the claim that we would expect to see more assaults in elevators (or hotel elevators) than the collected data show?
Someone has obviously spent quite a bit of effort to find such cases. It's now open for peer review--anyone who knows about additional cases are free to report them. I can't recall ever hearing about a hotel elevator rape here in Sweden, and I believe I would remember. I remember hearing about rapes in railway station elevators and this I can also confirm by googling. Admittedly I have not spent 3 days searching but I can find no incident of a rape in a hotel elevator in Sweden. Assault rapes are typically reported nationally.

I'm not saying these are the only hotel elevator rapes that have occurred. Probably, it's just a fraction. However, if there had been thousands of hotel elevator rapes, we should expect to be able to find more cases easily. Therefore, we can reasonably conclude that it is rare.
 
I don't think women are particularly afraid of being raped in elevators. What it is, IMO, is that they are discomfited by sexual invitations from strangers in elevators. That isn't quite the same thing.
So what is it that discomfits them, then? If it's not the worry of getting attacked, what is it? Because, frankly, if it's not based on a worry of some serious kind, the proper solution is for these women to grow a bit thicker skin. They can and should expect men to treat them with respect and dignity, but if they are going to go around being discomfited for no reason, then they can not blame anyone else for that.

Just to be clear, I'm not mocking people with irrational fears. A lot of people have such issues and it should be taken seriousĺy. But we should not pretend that this can be fixed externally. That doesn't help anyone.
 
So what is it that discomfits them, then?
IMO, it is the awareness of being in a vulnerable space with a stranger whom they cannot predict his next actions.

If it's not the worry of getting attacked, what is it?
Yes, the discomfiture is most probably rooted in the worry of getting attacked. But discomfiture after being propositioned in an elevator is not the same as an irrational fear of being raped in elevators.
 
Beth, you continue to ask the side that actually has presented evidence to provide more, all the while the side that has presented no evidence still has presented no evidence.

I've presented evidence that was requested when I could - i.e. accounts of women who attended skeptic/atheist conferences and their assessment of their treatment. Most of which you dismissed as not meeting your standards.

I also reviewed thousands of comments to obtain a count of women who had posted on this incident in order to substantiate my assessment that many, if not most, women would be uncomfortable in the situation RW described. While you may not find the evidence convincing, I find it insulting for it to be dismissed as 'no evidence'.

The evidence that was presented for your claim does not imply the conclusion you have drawn. I asked for the additional evidence and/or assumptions required to make that conclusion. IMO, that's not an unreasonable request.
 
I've presented evidence that was requested when I could - i.e. accounts of women who attended skeptic/atheist conferences and their assessment of their treatment.
Sure. I appreciate that and based on your evidence I agree that many if not most women agree that the situation described by RW would have been uncomfortable. In my mind, that issue is settled. However, the question over whether rapes in hotel elevators are common or extremely rare is something completely different. On that issue, I have seen compelling evidence that it is extremely rare, and no evidence to the contrary.
 
Sure. I appreciate that and based on your evidence I agree that many if not most women agree that the situation described by RW would have been uncomfortable. In my mind, that issue is settled. However, the question over whether rapes in hotel elevators are common or extremely rare is something completely different. On that issue, I have seen compelling evidence that it is extremely rare, and no evidence to the contrary.
Thanks for that acknowledgement. However, who has claimed that it is common? I didn't think that was a point of contention.
 
I've presented evidence that was requested when I could - i.e. accounts of women who attended skeptic/atheist conferences and their assessment of their treatment. Most of which you dismissed as not meeting your standards.
I'm talking specifically about the elevator. The accounts you speak of are not related to your specific comments about the elevator.

The evidence that was presented for your claim does not imply the conclusion you have drawn. I asked for the additional evidence and/or assumptions required to make that conclusion. IMO, that's not an unreasonable request.
Which conclusion? You've lost me here.
 
Sure. I appreciate that and based on your evidence I agree that many if not most women agree that the situation described by RW would have been uncomfortable. In my mind, that issue is settled. However, the question over whether rapes in hotel elevators are common or extremely rare is something completely different. On that issue, I have seen compelling evidence that it is extremely rare, and no evidence to the contrary.
OK, if this is where Beth is going, then her and I are talking about two different things, and you are talking about what I am.


Women's perceptions about elevator risk is a different question from the actual risk.

As far as "many if not most", it seems to me that Beth's count showed about a 50:50 ratio of agreement:disagreement re the level of elevator 'discomfort' warranted in the incident in question.
 
Last edited:
I've been lurking the last day or so. Choosing to listen instead of talking. I've gone back over some posts. I've not seen anything to warrant an opinion that the perceptions of danger from elevators are significant such that changes are warranted. I think problems will likely work themselves out with open dialog. JMHO.
 
IMO, it is the awareness of being in a vulnerable space with a stranger whom they cannot predict his next actions.
We are back to the same problem. The "awareness" you speak of is based on false assumptions. If the risk is falsely perceived, that is the definition of irrational thinking.



Yes, the discomfiture is most probably rooted in the worry of getting attacked. But discomfiture after being propositioned in an elevator is not the same as an irrational fear of being raped in elevators.
And this comes back to philosophy, mostly. Is it EG's responsibility to not make RW uncomfortable, in which case the question has been asked repeatedly, how was he supposed to know his proposition was prohibited in this specific interaction? While RW is certain he should have known, the fact women themselves viewed EG's actions differently is evidence EG would have had to read RW's mind, or, seriously curtail his approaches women in order to never make any of them uncomfortable. Remember, some women in this discussion have said they 'never' want to be approached by men they don't know.

The claim EG's mandatory deference to women's discomfort is somehow consistent with feminist goals is also questionable. Not letting EG make one uncomfortable is more consistent with my and other women's view of feminist goals.
 
Last edited:
We are back to the same problem. The "awareness" you speak of is based on false assumptions. If the risk is falsely perceived, that is the definition of irrational thinking.

So where do you draw the line? Please tell me the precise location where a woman can be assured of zero risk when encountering a stranger.
 
So where do you draw the line? Please tell me the precise location where a woman can be assured of zero risk when encountering a stranger.
Is this a realistic question? Zero risk is your standard?

How do you leave the house each day? :rolleyes:


Now, had you asked about reasonable or relative risk when encountering a stranger, I suggest you base your decisions/actions on real risk, and try to avoid perceived risk when the perception is inconsistent with real risk.

My philosophy is based on the fact that there is no such thing as zero risk, and avoiding risk comes at a cost. The easy things are a no brainer. Make sure you have a working smoke alarm in your house, and that you check the batteries a couple times a year. Wear a seatbelt in any vehicle. Look both ways when you cross the street.

Some things are more costly. A Volvo has excellent crash safety, but it is very expensive. There is evidence some diets are healthier than others but it takes a lot of effort for some people to stick to a healthy diet. Beyond the easy no brainer risk avoidance measures we need to make decisions that we find acceptable. If that Volvo is important to you, you spend the money. If you can't, then you buy the safest vehicle you can afford. If an unsafe sports car is something you really want, then base the decision on real data about the safety, not on impressions of safety or lack of it. If you love bacon and are willing to trade your indulgence for the cardiac risk, same thing, base the decision on real data, not on perceived risk.

The bottom line is we make risk avoidance decisions all the time. But most people make those decisions based on perceived risk rather than real risk. And studies of perceived risk vs real risk reveal there are a number of things which distort perceived risk for most humans. False beliefs about the risk to women at 4am in an elevator in a 5 star hotel in a 'foreign country' for example, is not surprising given what we know about how people perceive risk. Rational thinkers would try to match those perceptions with the actual data (real risk) as much as possible.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom