EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

I can give one data point :)

I asked my wife about this yesterday over dinner. She was baffled as to why it was even an issue. I tried very hard to relay the problem...confined space...4am...she said she did not want to be propositioned etc. She still said. So what? He didn't do anything to her physically did he? Apparently my wife has also been hit on a lot (even in elevators late at night) as she was a journalist covering tech conferences in Las Vegas. Apparently she never saw it as an issue.

After this I called her a misogynistic and paid for dinner :D

P.S. Sorry if it doesn't fit with spirit of the thread.
 
I can give one data point :)

I asked my wife about this yesterday over dinner. She was baffled as to why it was even an issue. I tried very hard to relay the problem...confined space...4am...she said she did not want to be propositioned etc. She still said. So what? He didn't do anything to her physically did he? Apparently my wife has also been hit on a lot (even in elevators late at night) as she was a journalist covering tech conferences in Las Vegas. Apparently she never saw it as an issue.

After this I called her a misogynistic and paid for dinner :D

P.S. Sorry if it doesn't fit with spirit of the thread.
:D
 
Personally, I think being propositioned by a complete stranger is rude behavior, whether he/she uses subtle euphemism or crude vulgarity to express his/her desire.
Personally, I would not have 'propositioned' quite in that way (if it was a proposition--I'd easily have asked Dawkins the exact same question in the same situation, and I'm not gay).

If I'd gotten interested in a woman in such circumstances--intellectually and/or romantically--I would have made sure to introduce myself in a public situation, such as at the bar. I would also have attempted to figure out whether there was any mutual interest by establishing eye contact and possibly other cues. However, such signals don't always work.

However, as long as I've introduced myself previously--however briefly--I could basically have behaved exactly like EG has been described. I'm not sure if that would be ok by you, or qualified as 'creepy'.

I do think that women need to be aware that guys don't constantly get romantic proposals from women, at least not most of us. Giving a girl a smile and a wink typically will not make her approach me, even if she's in fact madly in love with me. If I want to make anything happen, I typically need to make it happen. And although I try very hard to be polite, and subtle, and responsive to hints, and not pushy at all--I have gotten it wrong. Many times.

It's uncomfortable. It does not feel nice to be refused. It may hurt my relation with someone I still want to be friends with. And although I hope I've never 'creeped anyone out', I can't be sure.

I'm not a sex freak, and I don't think I'm inappropriately objectifying women. But I do have a sexual interest in women, and I do feel that some women are expecting men to be so exceptionally 'respectful' that they can't very well make any sexual advances at all, at least not towards someone they don't already know quite well.
 
That's true. You have to find the paper, but the link gives enough information to find it in a good university library. I've read the full paper, and there was no correlation with political attitudes, MMPI scores, intelligence tests, or several other factors. The strongest correlation was with the stated sex of the child, and there were much smaller correlations with the sex of the respondent and their experience with children.
Which still leaves the second point I made, and the question of how representative the sample was of the political attitudes. Conservatives have quite the range of beliefs among the members.
 
More data

I decided to do a little data more collection on the question of how common RW's reaction to EG's proposition was. This time I went to Phil Plaits blog:
http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/b.../richard-dawkins-and-male-privilege/#comments

This blog had 1942 comments at 3pm on Friday. I went through the first 1000 of them doing the same thing as what I posted in 510. The results are quite similar to the other site.

Again, I limited my data collection to posters that had female names, female avatars, or indicated in their posts that they were female. I skimmed over posters who had obviously male name or male avatars. I may have missed some on either side, so feel free to go there, check out the comments, and suggest additions to either list.

I identified 21 female posters who felt that that EG's behavior was just fine. I identified 36 female posters that felt that EG's behavior was inappropriate. With 36 out of 57 women feeling that EG behavior inappropriately, that's 63.15%. Again, I don’t think this is conclusive proof that the majority of women would find it inappropriate, but it is certainly consistent with that hypothesis and it adds support to that assumption. Regardless of whether or not it is the majority viewpoint, I think it confirms that such a reaction is quite common for women in our society.

Here is the list of poster names and how I categorized them. While you might not agree with my results, you can at least go to the site and verify them for yourself. The number given behind the name is the comment is when I decided to add that name to my list, which was not necessarily the first post by that individual.

Female posters who support RD/EG:

  • Stephanie 3
    JeDii Watkins 41
    Jane 45
    Sarah 151
    Amanda (agrees uncomfortable, but okay with it) 194
    K 300
    Kitty 348
    Clara Bunford 364
    Charm City Girl 404
    JCW 415
    Miranda Celeste Hale 491
    Connie Dobbs 530
    Sylveria 607
    mithrien 616
    Anna Johnstone 636
    KYD 685
    Andreas H 797
    Isobel_A 798
    Adrian Johnson 809
    Danai 894
    Sarah Lynne 905
Female posters who think EG's behavior was inappropriate:

  • Ruth 8
    Kim 17
    quarksparrow 20
    Kaylen 21
    Robyn 29
    Steph 37
    Maria 56
    Mrs. BA 72
    elaine! 81
    Jenn 82
    Srahhh 86
    VAB 109
    Blue 155
    Kate 176
    Yikes! 232
    Kathleen 323
    Calli Arcale 332
    twirlgrl 448
    nnaylime 486
    Kath R 553
    De 566
    REA 622
    Jo 628
    Lucide 650
    flibbertigibbet 675
    Julie 745
    Cap 763
    Sarah B 764
    Eleanor 800
    Karen 801
    Karin 855
    Silvia Possas 858
    Jennifer 859
    lolly 884
    Katie 906
    Illuminata 940
 
I identified 21 female posters who felt that that EG's behavior was just fine. I identified 36 female posters that felt that EG's behavior was inappropriate.
Thanks. While I don't find your findings improbable, and it's roughly in line with my own feelings (2/3 over the line and 1/3 fine is about how I feel), I think it's important to remember that we are not really talking about what happened in that elevator. As far as I know, we only have RW's version of what happened. And she obviously disapproved. So really, no matter what actually happened, I would expect most people to mostly agree with RW.

If there's one thing where I disagree with RW, it's that she claims it was obviously wrong. If she had struck a more reasonable tone, not asserting that everyone who disagrees with her must be some kind of creep unable to interact with the opposite sex, then probably more people would have been willing to listen and improve.
 
Thanks. While I don't find your findings improbable, and it's roughly in line with my own feelings (2/3 over the line and 1/3 fine is about how I feel), I think it's important to remember that we are not really talking about what happened in that elevator. As far as I know, we only have RW's version of what happened. And she obviously disapproved. So really, no matter what actually happened, I would expect most people to mostly agree with RW.

If there's one thing where I disagree with RW, it's that she claims it was obviously wrong. If she had struck a more reasonable tone, not asserting that everyone who disagrees with her must be some kind of creep unable to interact with the opposite sex, then probably more people would have been willing to listen and improve.
:) Yes. This has been my point from day 1. Saying, look guys, many if not most women probably would not like that. I know I wouldn't. So my advice to you is don't do that. We WOULDN'T be here.

Had she said, Richard (Dick), I understand your point but you are engaging in false consolation. My point must rise and fall on it's own merits. But I do agree that being propositioned on an elevator, saying no and having that respected is a far cry from genital mutilation.

I could go on. Dawkins helped escalate it and RW never did herself any favors.
 
If I'd gotten interested in a woman in such circumstances--intellectually and/or romantically--I would have made sure to introduce myself in a public situation, such as at the bar. I would also have attempted to figure out whether there was any mutual interest by establishing eye contact and possibly other cues. However, such signals don't always work.

However, as long as I've introduced myself previously--however briefly--I could basically have behaved exactly like EG has been described. I'm not sure if that would be ok by you, or qualified as 'creepy'.
Depending on the non-verbal cues, it might be fine. If you're not sure, it would be best to wait until the elevator doors are open.

It's uncomfortable. It does not feel nice to be refused. It may hurt my relation with someone I still want to be friends with.
This is understandable.
I do feel that some women are expecting men to be so exceptionally 'respectful' that they can't very well make any sexual advances at all, at least not towards someone they don't already know quite well.
No, that's not the case. Just don't try to isolate the object of your interest from others before making your move. That's what the predators do.

Thanks. While I don't find your findings improbable, and it's roughly in line with my own feelings (2/3 over the line and 1/3 fine is about how I feel), I think it's important to remember that we are not really talking about what happened in that elevator.
Yes, it's probably best to think of it as a hypothetical scenario at this point.
 
Depending on the non-verbal cues, it might be fine. If you're not sure, it would be best to wait until the elevator doors are open.
This I don't get. Sure, it might be better to do it in a place where there are other people around. But why would a hotel corridor be better than a hotel elevator? An elevator might be just about the worst place for a predator to attack someone.

And there are practical considerations. Let's say I try to make a proposition at the bar, but other people are listening in on the conversation, and for my sake and hers I don't want to make my proposition so that others can hear it. I'd say most people would like to keep any spontaneous liaisons secret, so I would not really expect a woman to say yes if anyone, except possibly her best friend, is around to hear it.

So, let's say I've flirted with this woman, and I think she has flirted back. But I'm not sure--she appears to be a bit shy, I can't quite establish eye contact for long, and I might be wrong. I've exchanged some small talk with her and she does not dismiss me. Do I follow her to the elevator and make a polite proposition? Sure I do.
 
Last edited:
This I don't get. Sure, it might be better to do it in a place where there are other people around. But why would a hotel corridor be better than a hotel elevator?
It isn't a confined space. She can say no and immediately walk away. A predator could of course try to prevent her from doing so, but a confined space like an elevator gives him a better chance of subduing her before she can escape.
An elevator might be just about the worst place for a predator to attack someone.
Apparently not. Elevators are one of the places that women are given instructions about in 'how to avoid sexual assault' classes. Plenty of attacks have happened in elevators.
 
.... Plenty of attacks have happened in elevators.
Where is your evidence that elevators are to be feared? What constitutes "plenty"? The other day an elevator in Seattle slipped 4 floors injuring a woman. Should we now start fearing that elevators we are on are going to fall?
 
Last edited:
A predator could of course try to prevent her from doing so, but a confined space like an elevator gives him a better chance of subduing her before she can escape.
Then again, a guy with a gun could walk into a public place and start shooting everyone. At some point we need to realize there is inherent risk in the world and decide if we want to mitigate the risk by just staying home.

I understand what you are saying. I really do. There are somethings we can do to be prudent and protect ourselves and to avoid causing distress in others (I don't wear trench coats and a hockey mask as I walk my bull dog late at night). But the truth is we can't plan ahead for every possible risk and the notion that people need to think through ever possible scenario before they ask someone to coffee is absurd. I'm married but if I were single I wouldn't rule out asking a woman out while on an elevator. I'd first try to make eye contact, see if she smiled and if her gaze lingered. If not I probably wouldn't do it.

It's not the specifics that are important. That's one of the things that is really bogging this all down. What we need is understanding of various views and positions from different people of different genders. We also need tools that can be adapted for different situations rather than a check list for every possible situation.
 
Last edited:
Elevators are one of the places that women are given instructions about in 'how to avoid sexual assault' classes. Plenty of attacks have happened in elevators.
That is no evidence that attacks would be more common in elevators than anywhere else. I mean, plenty of attacks have happened in, let's say, a crowded bar.

Maybe there's a fear of attacks in elevators for some irrational reason, like claustrophobia. Now--I can understand that if someone is making physical advances in a confined space, that's extra unpleasant. That actually happened to me with a very big and very drunk girl who wouldn't take no for an answer, and I'm sure the same thing has happened to most women more than once. But that's very different in my opinion from someone talking politely.

But for assault, I'm willing to bet that the crucial moment is entering your room, not the elevator. That's the logical time for a predator to strike. Heck, if a big unknown guy followed me along the corridor to my room, I'd be worried about getting raped.
 
Where is your evidence that elevators are to be feared? What constitutes "plenty"? The other day an elevator in Seattle slipped 4 floors injuring a woman. Should we now start fearing that elevators we are on are going to fall?
I'm not going to argue with you in support of something I haven't said and don't believe to be true. As near as I can tell, no one has said that elevators are to be feared. That's a straw man of your own devising. As far as what constitutes 'plenty', when classes offered to women on how to avoid sexual assault include instructions on how to minimize the risk in elevators, IMO that's plenty.

That is no evidence that attacks would be more common in elevators than anywhere else.
You originally asked "But why would a hotel corridor be better than a hotel elevator [for propositioning a woman you don't know]?" In my response to that, I never said that attacks would be more common in elevators than anywhere else, nor do I know if that's the case. In fact, in all the 1,000's of comments on this incident that I've perused, I've yet to read one that made the claim that attacks in elevators are more common than elsewhere. That simply isn't the issue or the reason for concern.
I mean, plenty of attacks have happened in, let's say, a crowded bar.
Yes, attacks can happen anywhere. But in a crowded bar, if a woman is assaulted she can call for help and someone can respond. That's not going to be the case in an elevator which is why men can come across as creepy by asking for sex in that space.
Maybe there's a fear of attacks in elevators for some irrational reason, like claustrophobia.
An irrational cause like claustrophobia that affects approximately 60% of women? I don't buy that. It seems to me like they are concerned because sexual assault happens frequently (something like 1 in 4 women experience it) and a confined space you cannot exit with no one else around to witness what is happening is a vulnerable place to be.
But for assault, I'm willing to bet that the crucial moment is entering your room, not the elevator. That's the logical time for a predator to strike. Heck, if a big unknown guy followed me along the corridor to my room, I'd be worried about getting raped.

Yes, another point to keep in mind when asking for sex. After you make your offer politely, if the woman declines, following her to her room is also likely to come across as creepy.
 
Last edited:
I'm not going to argue with you in support of something I haven't said and don't believe to be true. As near as I can tell, no one has said that elevators are to be feared. That's a straw man of your own devising. As far as what constitutes 'plenty', when classes offered to women on how to avoid sexual assault include instructions on how to minimize the risk in elevators, IMO that's plenty.
....
Where is your evidence that, "plenty of attacks have happened in elevators"? Please define "plenty" as you meant it here.

Clearly the implication is 'elevators are places women should fear attack'. Perhaps you'd like to clarify how "plenty of attacks" does not imply "should fear". I'm not trying to create any straw men.


If it is irrational for women to believe assaults are a particular problem in elevators, shouldn't we be concerned with dispelling the myth, not encouraging acceptance of an irrational fear?
 
Last edited:
Where is your evidence that, "plenty of attacks have happened in elevators"? Please define "plenty" as you meant it here.
I just did. Enough that it warrents specific instructions in classes provided to women on how to avoid sexual assault.
Clearly the implication is 'elevators are places women should fear attack'. Perhaps you'd like to clarify how "plenty of attacks" does not imply "should fear". I'm not trying to create any straw men.

If it is irrational for women to believe assaults are a particular problem in elevators, shouldn't we be concerned with dispelling the myth, not encouraging acceptance of an irrational fear?
I don't think it is irrational for women to believe that assaults are a particular problem in elevators. That does not translate to the idea that women should fear elevators. IMO, it has to do with the vulnerability of a person in an elevator. We've discussed this before.

Another place that gets special instructions on how to prevent sexual assaults are parking lots. Do you interpret that as implying that women should fear parking lots? I don't. I think it just means that there are certain vulnerabilities to being in that particular kind of space and there are things women can do to reduce the probability that they will suffer a sexual assault there.
 
So the argument is:

P: Some humans fear attack from other humans in an elevator.

The question posed against that is:

Q: Is that fear rational?

We have two answers.

1. Yes, it is rational and here is the data that proves the risk.

Q1: Is the risk reduced when politely propositioned (applying to our incident)?

a. Yes the risk is reduced...here is the data.

Conclusion then is that we should always talk to people in elevators to put them at ease and reduce the risk.

b. No the risk is not reduced

Conclusion is that we should have to develop some social cues to help people through this

c. No the risk is increased

Do not proposition others in elevators.

2. The fear is not rational.

Conclusion is that those humans have to deal with their irrational fear.


Is this breakdown fair? If it is then the contention here is basically the rationality of that fear. If the rationality has been proven(haven't seen it yet) then the next step is to find out if propositions actually increase the risk or leave it the same to warrant a look at the problem.
 
I just did. Enough that it warrents specific instructions in classes provided to women on how to avoid sexual assault.
That's only evidence people who teach the class believe X. It's not evidence of anything else.

I don't think it is irrational for women to believe that assaults are a particular problem in elevators. That does not translate to the idea that women should fear elevators. IMO, it has to do with the vulnerability of a person in an elevator. We've discussed this before.

Another place that gets special instructions on how to prevent sexual assaults are parking lots. Do you interpret that as implying that women should fear parking lots? I don't. I think it just means that there are certain vulnerabilities to being in that particular kind of space and there are things women can do to reduce the probability that they will suffer a sexual assault there.
Actually, when I am in a parking lot alone after dark, I have my key out and I'm conscious of people around me. When I'm in an elevator I certainly am NOT taking special precautions if a man gets on the elevator with me. I'm pretty sure there is evidence women are attacked in parking lots.
 
That's only evidence people who teach the class believe X. It's not evidence of anything else.
Okay, you have a point. I happen to think that the people who teach a class are generally better informed about the subject than people who don't, but I don't have evidence to support that assumption. BTW I don't presume it is always the case, that's just the way I would bet.
Actually, when I am in a parking lot alone after dark, I have my key out and I'm conscious of people around me. When I'm in an elevator I certainly am NOT taking special precautions if a man gets on the elevator with me. I'm pretty sure there is evidence women are attacked in parking lots.

Yes, there is evidence that women are attacked in parking lots as well as in elevators, alleys, and all sorts of other places including their own homes. Different precautions are advised for different situations. For example, having your keys out is a common one for parking lots, but not for elevators. What is your point here?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom