EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Are women who throw themselves at male celebrities from the film and music industries being rude when those celebrities are famous more for their looks and behaviour than their acting or musical abilities?
Yes. It doesn't matter why they are famous.
The social contract isn't crafted by any single person.

You are entitled to an opinion but understand that we can't force everyone to conform to our expectations. We have the right to try and persuade. That is what the dialectic is for. That is why this discussion important. It's not to uncover some absolute objective moral truth about seduction. Such an animal simply doesn't exist in a complex and dynamic world.
 
Last edited:
which is cool so long as you don't expect others to agree.
I'm not sure what you mean by this. I wouldn't expect others to necessarily have the same reaction. I do expect rational people to agree that such a reaction is reasonable under the circumstances and my opinion of those that don't has dimished considerably.
I don't think either are per se rude. And this goest to the heart of this. No one speaks for all women. Life simply does not work like that. There are things I find rude that others don't. I don't think the world must change to accomodate me. That said. There is a reason euphamisms exist. They are far less likely to offend, And, sometimes coffee is just coffee.
Yes. I agree. I'm not sure what your point is though. I don't expect the world to change to accomodate me. I do think it's appropriate to make my opinion on the matter clear because many people were apparently unaware how such propositions are likely to be perceived and that it will be considered rude and inappropriate behavior by many, if not most, women.

And that is your perogative. So long as you don't have an expectation that everyone should agree with you.
Again, I'm not sure what your point is. I don't expect everyone to agree with me. I do expect that any time I'm interacting with strangers, most will be polite but some will be rude either out of ignorance or thoughtlessness or simply because they are uncaring about their effect on others. Those that are rude due to ignorance or thoughtlessness will often correct their behavior once they realize it offends others.
Many men and women have hook ups with strangers. A troubling aspect I have with all of this is that this incident shoud define what is inapropriate behavior and dictate how all women should act.
Excuse me, but who is dictating how all women should act? And how is it they are saying women should act? And why should this incident not be used to define inappropriate behavior? It goes well over the line for me and many other people living in mainstream society and occasionally staying in hotels. I think it's best to make it known how such propositions are perceived (creepy) so that others can avoid being that guy.
It is solipsistic for me to reason a behavior rude and declare that everyone else should likewise find it so. It's not solipsistic to voice an opinion in the hopes of changing attitudes.
Yes. What attitude are you hoping to change?
Perhaps the vast majority of women agree with you. Regardless, lots of women, a few women, if a segment of the population find that rude then we ought to know about it so we can make informed decisions.
EXACTLY! Now that the skeptic/atheist community has been informed that many women feel that way, what has the response been?

Given the question regarding what kind of treatment can women expect to receive at skeptic/athiest events and does it negatively impact on their desire to attend such events, I think the elevator saga and it's monstrous aftermath has illustrated the group norms and what women can expect. IMO, it does not make the skeptic/atheist community look attractive.
 
The social contract isn't crafted by any single person.

You are entitled to an opinion but understand that we can't force everyone to conform to our expectations. We have the right to try and persuade. That is what the dialectic is for. That is why this discussion important. It's not to uncover some absolute objective moral truth about seduction. Such an animal simply doesn't exist in a complex and dynamic world.

Yes. I was giving my opinion, not revealing some objective truth. Was that not clear?
 
Last edited:
Skeptics generally value reason and logic over emotions and gut feelings. That this is generally a good thing I surely don't need to argue to anyone reading.

But there is an important exception: why is it that we naturally consider gut feelings and emotions reliable when they obviously are not in the first place? Because in close relationships between family members, friends, etc., our emotions and gut feelings often ARE more reliable than logic and science -- because we are evolutionarily evolved to be very good at "feeling" subtle behavior clues about what the other people who are family / potential mates / potential enemies want, while it is notoriously difficult to get enough information to reliably predict this using explicit data. Humans are complicated systems, not easy to analyze explicitly. This is the grain of truth in the eternal you-can't-prove-God-doesn't-exist argument: "can you PROVE love exists"? Well, perhaps today with neuroscience we can. But we had gut feeling to "sense" it (or lack of it) in the other person for thousands of years before that.

Many skeptics dismiss emotion and feeling in these areas as well, and thus act in a way that is perhaps perfectly logical on its face, in this case, telling Rebecca what he feels and waiting for an answer. It is this among other reasons that make me think "elevator guy" probably never imagined raping Rebecca if she said "no"; he knows that is wrong -- logic and ethics explicitly tells him so. But he didn't see why his asking is inappropriate (as opposed to ethically wrong).
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure what you mean by this. I wouldn't expect others to necessarily have the same reaction. I do expect rational people to agree that such a reaction is reasonable under the circumstances...
I don't care about the circumstances. It's reasonable under any circumstance FOR YOU AND OTHERS. Not everyone.

Yes. I agree.
I wish you would keep that in mind as you respond. Your position changes as you go on.

I'm not sure what your point is though. I don't expect the world to change to accomodate me.
It sure looks like you do later in this post.

I do think it's appropriate to make my opinion on the matter clear because many people were apparently unaware how such propositions are likely to be perceived and that it will be considered rude and inappropriate behavior by many, if not most, women.
Here is when you begin to slide from agreeing that your opinion doesn't define what is appropriate for everyone, to declare that "many, if not most women" would find the behavior inappropriate. How is it that you go from speaking for yourself to speaking for "many if not most"?

Those that are rude due to ignorance or thoughtlessness will often correct their behavior once they realize it offends others.
Wait. You've gone off of the tracks here. I agree with the proposition but we can only asses it as to YOUR opinion.

  • Is the behavior of EG rude per se or not?
You are not being consistent. If it's just your opinion then we can't state that this behavior must change for everyone.

Excuse me, but who is dictating how all women should act?
NOT ME. Sheesh Beth. What was that all about?

And why should this incident not be used to define inappropriate behavior?
Wow. Just WOW! Because your solipsism isn't everyone else's reality.


EXACTLY! Now that the skeptic/atheist community has been informed that many women feel that way, what has the response been?
Yes, but "many" isn't everyone. We have no way to know the ratio.

Given the question regarding what kind of treatment can women expect to receive at skeptic/athiest events and does it negatively impact on their desire to attend such events, I think the elevator saga and it's monstrous aftermath has illustrated the group norms and what women can expect. IMO, it does not make the skeptic/atheist community look attractive.
???
 
Last edited:
Yes. I was giving my opinion, not revealing some objective truth. Was that not clear?
No. Not even close. See your previous post. You are all over the board. From simply stating an opinion to wondering when people will get it that your opinion is many if not most women's opinion and therefore we should do something about it.

No, not clear in the least.
 
Fascinating that you should gripe about how someone else has depicted an imaginary women as "tarted up, busty", when your own depiction of a real person is in exactly the same way.

You explained the difference, yet you still don't get it. I am lampooning RW for using sexuality to advance her career and then complaining about the sexuality in the community she helped create.
 
I don't care about the circumstances. It's reasonable under any circumstance FOR YOU AND OTHERS. Not everyone.
Yes. Did you think I would disagree with that statement?
I wish you would keep that in mind as you respond. Your position changes as you go on.

It sure looks like you do later in this post.
I think you are misinterpreting me.
Here is when you begin to slide from agreeing that your opinion doesn't define what is appropriate for everyone, to declare that "many, if not most women" would find the behavior inappropriate. How is it that you go from speaking for yourself to speaking for "many if not most"?
Because I've read thousands of blog posts and comments on this matter. The majority of women are quite clear on that. Would you like me to link a few blogs on the matter that indicate that women are generally not cool with what EG did?
Wait. You've gone off of the tracks here. I agree with the proposition but we can only asses it as to YOUR opinion.
And yours too since you agree with the proposition. Doesn't that imply that we've gone off the tracks together. :)
  • Is the behavior of EG rude per se or not?
You are not being consistent. If it's just your opinion then we can't state that this behavior must change for everyone.
Um, what are you talking about here? Yes, in my opinion his behavior was rude. That I think something is rude does not imply that everyone must change. All I can do is state my opinion on the matter and state my opinion that many, if not most, other women feel similarly. Others can and will behave however they wish. Why do you interpret expressing my opinion that something is rude with insistance that others must conform to my expectations?
NOT ME. Sheesh Beth. What was that all about?

You had said:
A troubling aspect I have with all of this is that this incident shoud define what is inapropriate behavior and dictate how all women should act.

So I asked who was dictating how all women should act. Who were you referring to with that sentence?
Wow. Just WOW! Because your solipsism isn't everyone else's reality.
What in the world are you talking about here? I'm not a solipsist and thought you were of the opinion that we all shared the same reality. Why shouldn't this incident be used to define inappropriate behavior? It seems to me that it already is being used in that manner and I don't understand why you object to that.

Yes, but "many" isn't everyone. We have no way to know the ratio.
That is correct. We can only make a guess based on the way the majority of women have responsed to the incident. My guess is that it would between 60% and 80%, but I don't know for certain. What would you estimate the ratio to be? Close to even or skewed to one side or the other? Which side?

No. Not even close. See your previous post. You are all over the board. From simply stating an opinion to wondering when people will get it that your opinion is many if not most women's opinion and therefore we should do something about it.

Yes, my opinion on the appropriateness of the EG's behavior is shared by many, if not most, women. Whether or not something should be done about it depends what you want the skeptic/atheist community to be.

Do you think such behavior should be tolerated or should it be made clear that it isn't acceptable? What results do you think might be expected with the different courses of action?

No, not clear in the least.

Sorry. In the future, please be advised you can generally interpret all my statements as my opinion rather than dictates about how other people should or do behave.
 
It's not one or the other, it's a compilation. You can share an elevator with a stranger and not even notice them.
In which case a guy on an elevator when a woman is alone on it at 4am in a nice hotel is not a relevant part of RW's complaint.


You can share an elevator with a stranger and strike up a polite conversation (which I suspect was EG's intention). Sharing an elevator with a stranger, who you suspect follows you into the elevator (according to the version she spoke of at the event where she called out McGraw), and then makes a request of you, that you find unusual, at the very least will stick in your memory for a while. Where you take it after that all depends on your previous experieces and prejudices.
Unless you are looking at this from a skeptical view point in which case you should be able to rationalize that the guy on the elevator without talking should make one no less comfortable than a guy on the elevator who is talking.

It boils down to RW reacting to EG's comments, but adding the elevator detail should not have added anything. Otherwise it's like saying you are adding zero points and then claiming it increased the total.
 
Because I've read thousands of blog posts and comments on this matter. The majority of women are quite clear on that. Would you like me to link a few blogs on the matter that indicate that women are generally not cool with what EG did?
And how did you control for confirmation bias? Did you go to blogs that were likely to attract women who thought it was not cool?

And yours too since you agree with the proposition. Doesn't that imply that we've gone off the tracks together.
No. I don't don't know how many people will think it is inappropriate. That is the difference. I don't assume there will be much if any change. If there is I will gladly accept it. I don't claim to know what is appropriate.

All I can do is state my opinion on the matter and state my opinion that many, if not most, other women feel similarly.
That's fine if you add the caveat or make it clear that it is your opinion.

Others can and will behave however they wish. Why do you interpret expressing my opinion that something is rude with insistance that others must conform to my expectations?
Because you leave no room for any other interpretation when you state categorically "many if not most women". You don't say, "IMO many if not most women".

You had said:
A troubling aspect I have with all of this is that this incident sho[l]ud define what is inapropriate behavior and dictate how all women should act.
(See bolded text). I DON'T think it necessarily should define anything.

  • I don't declare it should.
  • I don't declare it shouldn't.
  • I haven't predetermined an outcome.
  • It appears You have.
So I asked who was dictating how all women should act. Who were you referring to with that sentence?
You are asking the wrong question. It's not the "who" it's the "what". I have no predetermined outcome.

What in the world are you talking about here? I'm not a solipsist and thought you were of the opinion that we all shared the same reality.
Then don't predetermine what should be the end result and don't presume to speak for "many if not most" women.

Why shouldn't this incident be used to define inappropriate behavior?
Really?

It seems to me that it already is being used in that manner and I don't understand why you object to that.
What do you mean?

That is correct. We can only make a guess based on the way the majority of women have responsed to the incident. My guess is that it would between 60% and 80%, but I don't know for certain. What would you estimate the ratio to be? Close to even or skewed to one side or the other? Which side?
A.) I honestly don't know. B.) I doubt we will know. C.) I think it irrelevant. Social mores should never be based on any single controversial or polemical issues. Sometimes they are but it's a really bad basis that often turns out bad. This issues are complex and subject to demagoguery. Our best bet is an open dialog and honest appraisals of risks using skepticism and critical thinking.

Yes, my opinion on the appropriateness of the EG's behavior is shared by many, if not most, women.
You know this how? You apply no skepticism to your view? You do not take into account your own bias? No critical thinking?

Do you think such behavior should be tolerated or should it be made clear that it isn't acceptable?
You are asking the wrong questions. You are viewing this the wrong way. I'm not so solipsistic (and I don't mean that in the sense you think I am) as to think my opinion as to whether or not the behavior is appropriate applies to everyone. Humans are far too varied and there are simply too many other variables. I think it perfectly appropriate for women to think it inappropriate for them and others while acknowledging that their opinions don't represent the totality of the thought and opinion.

What results do you think might be expected with the different courses of action?
I think if we all stayed home and didn't interact with each other no one would be offended. The world isn't that black and white.

Sorry. In the future, please be advised you can generally interpret all my statements as my opinion rather than dictates about how other people should or do behave.
I can't do that. If you mean something then say it.
 
Last edited:
...
Because I've read thousands of blog posts and comments on this matter. The majority of women are quite clear on that. ....
I still need a longer block of time to get back to some of your's and Meg's comments, but I want to address this. You are looking at a very select sample of women on those blogs.

In addition, in the blogosphere on this matter, RW has a lot of fans.

I agree that there are less people with my point of view commenting, but there are people who take the position I do, that it was not a very big deal and as a proclaimed feminist, RW's reaction was inconsistent with a liberated woman. But there is no way the sample you are looking at represents the actual sentiment of the majority of women. It might, but your evidence is not convincing.
 
In which case a guy on an elevator when a woman is alone on it at 4am in a nice hotel is not a relevant part of RW's complaint.


Unless you are looking at this from a skeptical view point in which case you should be able to rationalize that the guy on the elevator without talking should make one no less comfortable than a guy on the elevator who is talking.

It boils down to RW reacting to EG's comments, but adding the elevator detail should not have added anything. Otherwise it's like saying you are adding zero points and then claiming it increased the total.

I don't know how else to explain that it's not a matter of any one single detail but the compilation of details that makes the incident memorable, to RW. What makes the elevator a notable addition to the story has been said, already, there's no immediate escape, should the situation take a turn for the worst. All of this occurs without EG ever needing to have any bad intentions. Sometimes it just happens, wires get crossed. Perhaps in Ireland, it is perfectly normal to go back to a stranger's room. In America, it's called risky behavior. That's why I've said, your experiences and prejudices will define where you take it.
 
And how did you control for confirmation bias? Did you go to blogs that were likely to attract women who thought it was not cool?
I lowered my overall estimate under the assumption that a larger percentage of women who thought it was not cool would respond than those who didn't care. I went to blogs written by people who thought it was not cool and blogs written by people who thought it was not a problem. I went to blogs written by feminist women and blogs written by skeptic men. In other words, I read a lot of different opinions by a lot of different people with varying viewpoints.
That's fine if you add the caveat or make it clear that it is your opinion.
I'll try to remember to do that more often. Can you try to remember that I'm just someone posting on a forum without the ability to force others to behave according to my personal standards and therefore, I am not dictating to others what they should do?
(See bolded text). I DON'T think it necessarily should define anything.

  • I don't declare it should.
  • I don't declare it shouldn't.
  • I haven't predetermined an outcome.
  • It appears You have.
I don't even know what you are talking about here. I thought you were stating that it should not as you indicated you found that aspect troubling. And I have no idea what outcome you are talking about, predetermined or otherwise.
You are asking the wrong question. It's not the "who" it's the "what". I have no predetermined outcome.

So what did you mean when you wrote
A troubling aspect I have with all of this is that this incident shoud define what is inapropriate behavior and dictate how all women should act.
Who or what do you think is dictating how all women should act and what behavior is being dictated?

Then don't predetermine what should be the end result and don't presume to speak for "many if not most" women.
What end result do you think I've determined? Because I'm not aware of having done so. If I do get to determine it, I'd like to know what it is I've determined.
Yes, really. Would you care to answer the question now?
What do you mean?
I mean that IMO the incident is being discussed in many places and IMO people are using to define the boundary of what they think should be considered acceptable behavior.
I think it irrelevant. Social mores should never be based on any single controversial or polemical issues. Sometimes they are but it's a really bad basis that often turns out bad. This issues are complex and subject to demagoguery. Our best bet is an open dialog and honest appraisals of risks using skepticism and critical thinking.
Yes. Isn't that we are attempting here?
You know this how? You apply no skepticism to your view? You do not take into account your own bias? No critical thinking?
I know this because I've been reading and listening to women talk about this. Many is a certainty. Would you like a list of names? Whether or not it's a majority I'm not certain of, which is why I phrased it the way I did.
Do you think such behavior should be tolerated or should it be made clear that it isn't acceptable?
You are asking the wrong questions. You are viewing this the wrong way.
I was asking your opinion. That's why I'm participating in this thread. To understand what other people's opinions are and why they hold the opinions they do. Why do you consider that 'wrong questions' and viewing it the 'wrong way'? And, if you wouldn't mind, I'd still like to hear your opinion regarding the answer to those questions.
I'm not so solipsistic (and I don't mean that in the sense you think I am) as to think my opinion as to whether or not the behavior is appropriate applies to everyone. Humans are far too varied and there are simply too many other variables. I think it perfectly appropriate for women to think it inappropriate for them and others while acknowledging that their opinions don't represent the totality of the thought and opinion.
I feel the same way, but for this incident we are basically discussing the culture of our society and the culture of the skeptic/atheist community. If it wasn't already clear, my opinion is in regard to those cultures, not afganistan tribal society or Hell's Angels.

What results do you think might be expected with the different courses of action?
I think if we all stayed home and didn't interact with each other no one would be offended. The world isn't that black and white.
That doesn't answer my question. I am actually interested in hearing your opinion if you would care to share it.
 
I still need a longer block of time to get back to some of your's and Meg's comments,
I look forward to it.
But there is no way the sample you are looking at represents the actual sentiment of the majority of women. It might, but your evidence is not convincing.

My apologies. I though it was clear from the context that I meant the majority of women posting had indicated that. I agree that it is only supporting, not convincing evidence that the majority of women would feel the same.
 
Perhaps in Ireland, it is perfectly normal to go back to a stranger's room. In America, it's called risky behavior. That's why I've said, your experiences and prejudices will define where you take it.

At conferences I've been in the US, and I've been to many, it's considered normal, between men. Perhaps some consider it risky, but I've never met one.
 
At conferences I've been in the US, and I've been to many, it's considered normal, between men. Perhaps some consider it risky, but I've never met one.

I don't think it would be near as risky for men as the probability they will sexually assaulted is much lower. But I don't understand. Why would you agree to go to the hotel room of someone you had never spoken with prior to being invited to their room?
 
At conferences I've been in the US, and I've been to many, it's considered normal, between men. Perhaps some consider it risky, but I've never met one.

I'm not sexist or anything, it's just that men are promiscuous sluts...j/k

Actually, I was speaking more about women, though. I'm not trying to perpetuate the idea that women shouldn't, I'm just saying, women going off with strange men tends to be considered risky. For the record, in the 11 year old gang raped, thread, I was one of the ones arguing against the idea that women are supposed to take special precautions.
 
I lowered my overall estimate under the assumption that a larger percentage of women who thought it was not cool would respond than those who didn't care. I went to blogs written by people who thought it was not cool and blogs written by people who thought it was not a problem. I went to blogs written by feminist women and blogs written by skeptic men. In other words, I read a lot of different opinions by a lot of different people with varying viewpoints.
Cool. How did you control for confirmation bias?

I'll try to remember to do that more often. Can you try to remember that I'm just someone posting on a forum without the ability to force others to behave according to my personal standards and therefore, I am not dictating to others what they should do?
I think you will have more success if you make it clear that you are not being presumptive.

I don't even know what you are talking about here.
I'm not sure how to be more clear. I used the world "should". I DON'T think it NECESSARILY SHOULD define anything. It might. Can you see a difference between "necessarily should" and "might"?

I thought you were stating that it should not as you indicated you found that aspect troubling.
I find any predetermined outcome troubling.

Outcome = The behavior of EG is determined to be inappropriate.

So what did you mean when you wrote Who or what do you think is dictating how all women should act and what behavior is being dictated?
I'm going to apologize here as I see that I was wrong in my understanding of what you are saying. Please forgive me and I'll try again.

A troubling aspect I have with all of this is that this incident should define what is inappropriate behavior and dictate how all women should act.
So I asked who was dictating how all women should act. Who were you referring to with that sentence?
You.

I think it's best to make it known how such propositions are perceived (creepy) so that others can avoid being that guy.
How is this not defining the behavior as inappropriate (creepy)?

What end result do you think I've determined?
That the behavior of EG is creepy.

Yes, really. Would you care to answer the question now?
I'm truly at a loss as to how you could ask that question. YOU DON'T KNOW? Seriously, do you even know my position? Does it escape you so quickly? Really? I'm sorry but that is very frustrating. Can you infer my position from the previous paragraph? Okay. Okay. Let's go back.

Why shouldn't this incident be used to define inappropriate behavior?
  • Because not all people perceive of this incident as inappropriate.
  • There is no objective basis for all people to perceive of this incident as inappropriate.
Beth, I've been beating that drum from the moment I stepped foot in this discussion. How is it that you don't know it? Seriously? Would you stop, take a deep breath and give it a moment to sink in? No single incident such as this one should ever define the thoughts and feelings of all people. Now, is there anything that you don't get about that?

I mean that IMO the incident is being discussed in many places and IMO people are using to define the boundary of what they think should be considered acceptable behavior.
YES! YES! YES! But that doesn't mean that at the end of the day we have to all agree and codify a law or rule that men cannot ever ask a stranger for coffee while in an elevator at 4:00am

Defense Atty: Can you give this person fair consideration?
Beth: Of course I can. We should give HIM a fair trial and THEN hang him.

Yes. Isn't that we are attempting here?
Some of us. Yes.

I know this because I've been reading and listening to women talk about this.
You didn't answer my question. Do you even know what it means to say "control for confirmation bias"?

I was asking your opinion.
You gave me a false choice.

Why do you consider that 'wrong questions' and viewing it the 'wrong way'?
Because there is no definitive, objective absolute way to find the answer. Social mores are not rooted in absolutes. Some will tolerate it. Some will find it inappropriate. Some will think the word "tolerate" an inappropriate word to use. The way you ask the question reveals that you think the only choice is to find the behavior inappropriate and tolerate it or unacceptable. I reject your questions.

And, if you wouldn't mind, I'd still like to hear your opinion regarding the answer to those questions.
Let me set aside your fallacious questioning and get to the spirit of what I think you were asking.


  1. I DON'T KNOW. My mind is open. I have no predetermined position. I've acknowledged when Meg and others have made good arguments.
  2. I care very deeply about the well being and concern that women have in this regard.
  3. I'm a man and though I tend to be skeptical of my views I'm doubly so when it comes to the opinions of women.
  4. This isn't a jury trial. I likely will hold contradictory positions and continue to analyze as I receive more information.

I feel the same way, but for this incident we are basically discussing the culture of our society and the culture of the skeptic/atheist community. If it wasn't already clear, my opinion is in regard to those cultures, not afganistan tribal society or Hell's Angels.
I've no clue what this means.

That doesn't answer my question.
Yes it does. I could ask you if the outcome would be different if instead of RW there was a woman in the elevator who was hoping some guy would ask her to his room for coffee?

I am actually interested in hearing your opinion if you would care to share it.
I gave you my honest opinion. Why don't you think about it.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it would be near as risky for men as the probability they will sexually assaulted is much lower. But I don't understand. Why would you agree to go to the hotel room of someone you had never spoken with prior to being invited to their room?

If one has presented a paper, then it's usually to talk about the paper. Whenever, it's what people call "networking." You discuss things, such as details of the various things you've seen at the conference. It leads to contacts and sometimes employment opportunities.

Events during the day are so packed, and there's so much information, and people are everywhere. The only practical way to get one-on-one discussions is in hotel rooms in the middle of the night.

In any event, it's pretty common.
 
Cool. How did you control for confirmation bias?
I'm sorry, I thought I made it clear I wasn't conducting a formal study. I did not control for any sort of bias. You may accept or reject my summarization as you choose. It was not meant to be scientific. You asked how I knew something. I told you. I never made any claim that my opinion was other than my opinion.
I find any predetermined outcome troubling.

Outcome = The behavior of EG is determined to be inappropriate.

Why? If RW had blogged about the guy who farted in the elevator, would you abstain from finding that to be inappropriate? How about if he had pissed there? Would you consider my opinion that such behavior is inappropriate to be a troubling predetermined outcome?

I'm going to apologize here as I see that I was wrong in my understanding of what you are saying. Please forgive me and I'll try again.
You are forgiven. I appreciate the acknowledgment that you did not understand what I was saying.
Interesting. Could you quote me the phrase where you perceived that I was dictating to all women how they should behave? I don't even know what behavior you think I am dictating to them.

I think it's best to make it known how such propositions are perceived (creepy) so that others can avoid being that guy.
How is this not defining the behavior as inappropriate (creepy)?
Okay. I don't see that as being an end result, but a starting point, kind of like I would also consider farting or pissing in the elevator as inappropriate. But if that's what you meant by 'end result', then you are correct.
  • Because not all people perceive of this incident as inappropriate.
  • There is no objective basis for all people to perceive of this incident as inappropriate.
Is there any behavior that all people would perceive as inappropriate? Is there an objective basis for the way we classify other behaviors as appropriate or inappropriate? I would answer both of those questions with no, so I don't think this implies that we should not use incidents like this to help us define community standards.

While I don't see your concerns as being any more applicable to this incident and discussion that any other, I do appreciate your taking the time to explain your concerns to me.

No single incident such as this one should ever define the thoughts and feelings of all people. Now, is there anything that you don't get about that?
Yes. Why do you feel that defining what is and isn't appropriate within our culture is equivalent to defining the thoughts and feelings of all people? I think the first is typically done without the second.
YES! YES! YES! But that doesn't mean that at the end of the day we have to all agree and codify a law or rule that men cannot ever ask a stranger for coffee while in an elevator at 4:00am
Of course not. Has anyone proposed a law? Or even a formal rule? Why argue against something no one (at least on this thread) has been arguing for? IMO, it's not even implied by the discussion we've had so far.
Defense Atty: Can you give this person fair consideration?
Beth: Of course I can. We should give HIM a fair trial and THEN hang him.
Unfair on your part. Just for the record, the only time I ever sat on a jury, I hung the jury because the prosecutor didn't make his case IMO. I refused to convict without sufficient evidence.
Do you think such behavior should be tolerated or should it be made clear that it isn't acceptable?
You gave me a false choice.
There's a third option between tolerating something and considering it unacceptable? What would that be? There are, of course, options like enthusiastically embracing the behavior or calling for a law against it. Is that what you meant? If so, that's fine. I can interpret such responses as tolerating or considering unacceptable respectively.
Let me set aside your fallacious questioning and get to the spirit of what I think you were asking.
  1. I DON'T KNOW. My mind is open. I have no predetermined position. I've acknowledged when Meg and others have made good arguments.
  2. I care very deeply about the well being and concern that women have in this regard.
  3. I'm a man and though I tend to be skeptical of my views I'm doubly so when it comes to the opinions of women.
  4. This isn't a jury trial. I likely will hold contradictory positions and continue to analyze as I receive more information.
Do those answers indicate that you think that such behavior should be tolerated or should be considered unacceptable? I simply don't know how to interpret them with regard to what I asked. I don't have any idea what you think was the spirit of what I was asking. Perhaps you could add the questions you are actually answering next time.

What results do you think might be expected with the different courses of action?
I think if we all stayed home and didn't interact with each other no one would be offended. The world isn't that black and white.
That doesn't answer my question. I am actually interested in hearing your opinion if you would care to share it.
Yes it does.
IMO, the question remains unanswered. You responded with a non-sequitor. I still have no idea of what you think would be expected for either of those two courses of action.
I could ask you if the outcome would be different if instead of RW there was a woman in the elevator who was hoping some guy would ask her to his room for coffee?
Yes, you can ask. My response is that I think the outcome would have been different. I also think the probability that such a woman would have been in the elevator at 4am to be extremely small, right up there with the probability that the man just wanted coffee and not sex. What is your opinion regarding the probabilities of those events? How likely do you think the possibility that EG just wanted coffee? How likely do you think the possibility that a random woman in a hotel elevator at 4am is hoping that the guy with her will ask her to his room for coffee?
I gave you my honest opinion. Why don't you think about it.
Because you haven't actually expressed an opinion in the areas I am interested in. You keep not answering the questions I ask and instead either answer completely different questions without telling me what they are or respond with non-sequitors that leave me clueless regarding what your opinion is on the question I asked.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom