EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

And yet Bookitty referred to the women who were "plied with drinks" as those who "trusted a fellow skeptic enough to let their guard down while drinking." Apparently the message does need to get out to some people that "fellow skeptic" doesn't mean squat.
I'm not saying there aren't dumb people in the world. I'm questioning the idea one needs to advise skeptics about their trust in strangers. It seems to me to be something one needs to advise dumb people.

Perhaps I shouldn't venture off into this topic. I can already see how difficult it might be to explain my gut reaction to Remie's perceived need to warn. It might take another 10 pages to explain.
 
I think we are getting closer to what I see this whole problem as being. The question is not (or shouldn't be) "how many specific acts of sexism have occured?" The real question is "Is sexism perceived to be a problem in our community?"

Please understand that I am not using the word "perceived" to indicate that I don't take any of these examples seriously. I do take them seriously. I do acknowledge, though, that organizations can suffer from the "one bad apple" syndrome, meaning a small amount of events can affect the opinions of a large amount of people, and how that organization is perceived by people.

As an example, let's say a liquor store in your neighborhood gets robbed twice in one week. People in the neighborhood might have a tendency to think, "That store is not safe, I will shop elsewhere." Very few people would try to analyze statistics on liquor store robberies in order to realize that since this particular store has not been robbed in 10 years prior to these incidences, that statistically, this store is no more or less safe than any other liquor store.* Likewise, that liquor store, seeing the drop off in sales, would not be addressing the real problem by assembling statistics about liquor store robberies and taking out an ad in the newspaper explaining why people's fears were wrong. A better choice would be to take actions that would lead people to believe they are more safe shopping here, like perhaps installing security cameras, hiring a guard, or installing better lighting in the parking lot.

Likewise, an organization suffering from the perception of sexism would do better to take actions that directly counter those perceptions, like perhaps, being more diligent in their own hiring practises, hiring an equal amount of women and men speakers, holding meetings or panels especially on diversity in the community, and taking the suggestions made seriously. That sort of thing.



*[Note, I made those numbers up. I do not have any actual statistics on liquor store robberies]
 
I think we are getting closer to what I see this whole problem as being. The question is not (or shouldn't be) "how many specific acts of sexism have occured?" The real question is "Is sexism perceived to be a problem in our community?"
The best cure for false beliefs should be the truth when it comes to skeptics.

Likewise, that liquor store, seeing the drop off in sales, would not be addressing the real problem by assembling statistics about liquor store robberies and taking out an ad in the newspaper explaining why people's fears were wrong. A better choice would be to take actions that would lead people to believe they are more safe shopping here, like perhaps installing security cameras, hiring a guard, or installing better lighting in the parking lot.
You don't tell us why one action isn't adressing the problem and the other is. If the problem is false belief then facts can counter false beliefs. All of the other stuff is security theater and does nothing to correct the false beliefs but in fact renforces the false beliefs.

The statistics are truth and expose irrational fear. The added security is simply an attempt to molify the fear with a show. Crime and insurance experts would care more about the facts.

I suspect that what you mean is that humans are not usually persuaded by truth but instead by psychological manipulation (perception IS reality). If so I agree. Sad that evenskeptics are subject to irrational fears and are not persuaded by facts but more likely to be motivated by emotion and slight of hand.

Likewise, an organization suffering from the perception of sexism would do better to take actions that directly counter those perceptions, like perhaps, being more diligent in their own hiring practises, hiring an equal amount of women and men speakers, holding meetings or panels especially on diversity in the community, and taking the suggestions made seriously. That sort of thing.
I actually think you should have skipped the analogy. This strikes me far less as style over substance. It seems to me substantive and personally I don't have a problem with it.

Thing is, I don't share your cynicsm that facts cannot correct spurios and irrational beliefs among skeptics, still, given this debate, you may well be right.
 
Last edited:
Thing is, I don't share your cynicsm that facts cannot correct spurios and irrational beliefs among skeptics, still, given this debate, you may well be right.
If it's true, then there is no skeptical movement in the first place.
 
I think we are getting closer to what I see this whole problem as being. The question is not (or shouldn't be) "how many specific acts of sexism have occured?" The real question is "Is sexism perceived to be a problem in our community?"....
There's no question it is perceived to be a problem.

The two unanswered questions are, by how many people is it perceived that way, and how accurate is that perception?

It would also appear that the complaints are being amplified by a few vocal 'perception leaders', resulting in more people being convinced the perception is correct. All the more reason to remind people to look at the evidence, not to just listen to people claiming it is true.
 
...
Likewise, an organization suffering from the perception of sexism would do better to take actions that directly counter those perceptions, like perhaps, being more diligent in their own hiring practises, hiring an equal amount of women and men speakers, holding meetings or panels especially on diversity in the community, and taking the suggestions made seriously. That sort of thing....
Addressing Problems 101: Don't suggest solutions until you define the problem.

We know there is a gender and diversity imbalance. So an effort to hire and recruit more women and minorities is a solution for a defined problem.

Beyond that, the "diversity panels" might be useful to collect more data upon which to base other solutions, but if you are referring to panels of people with unsubstantiated 'perceptions' who are going to discuss their views, I don't think that is the most useful approach.
 
Thing is, I don't share your cynicsm that facts cannot correct spurios and irrational beliefs among skeptics, still, given this debate, you may well be right.

I'm not really that cynical. I think it's important to acknowledge that some facts can never be proven, and are not under your control to take actions on, while other facts can be considered real information and hard data and are under your own control. Hearsay about past events are not facts, no matter how much they are debated. Actual statistics about your organization are facts, and are completely under your control. Taking concrete actions in your staffing creates a fact that cannot be disputed. This is not sleight of hand or smoke and mirrors. It IMO is a realistic approach to dealing with perceptions of sexism. It creates the ability, in the future, to argue: "FACT, our staffing ratio of women to men is 50/50. FACT, approximately 50% of our management is women. FACT, approximately 50% of our speakers are women. FACT, we hosted ___ sessions on diversity which resulted in our implementing X number of suggestions. Based on these FACTS, our organization is not sexist."
 
I'm not really that cynical. I think it's important to acknowledge that some facts can never be proven, and are not under your control to take actions on, while other facts can be considered real information and hard data and are under your own control. Hearsay about past events are not facts, no matter how much they are debated. Actual statistics about your organization are facts, and are completely under your control. Taking concrete actions in your staffing creates a fact that cannot be disputed. This is not sleight of hand or smoke and mirrors. It IMO is a realistic approach to dealing with perceptions of sexism. It creates the ability, in the future, to argue: "FACT, our staffing ratio of women to men is 50/50. FACT, approximately 50% of our management is women. FACT, approximately 50% of our speakers are women. FACT, we hosted ___ sessions on diversity which resulted in our implementing X number of suggestions. Based on these FACTS, our organization is not sexist."
On its face I've no problem with your post. Two points.

  1. It has very little if anything to do with your liquor store example
  2. I said that your suggestions for TAM were substantive. The point is conceded.
The stats for the liquor are not, "facts that can never be proven". Insurance companies live and die on actuarial data and analysis. I think your use of the analogy only muddies up the water.
 
I concede that point to you, RandFan. My liquor store analogy perhaps muddied the water more than it cleared it. I appreciate your willingness to look past that to see what I am really trying to say.
 
I also addressed this here in the other thread.

If the woman has the ability to control the outcome (I have the ability to control my response, for example), then it is empowering to exercise that ability, and un-empowering to rely on the male to change the outcome by changing his behavior.

I'm going to respond here because I'm staying out of the conversation in the other thread.

Skeptic Ginger said:
More than one person is perceiving the suggestion the woman is the one who needs to change as telling women to "suck it up". And I've been thinking about why that perception is bothering me so much. Even more than wanting the aggressor to 'figure out' they should change the behavior, sometimes it is even just the expectation that it is up to the aggressor to do the changing. That perpetuates the powerless woman role.
What exactly is it that you think women should change about their behavior? That they shouldn't be uncomfortable and wary in a situation where a stranger has propositioned them in an small space with no available exit and no observers? Or that they shouldn't make it clear that such behavior is unacceptably rude in their opinion?

I perceive the solutions much as you do, empowering women rather than trying to un-empower men. In addition, I see it as something women have control over, as opposed to the un-empowered position of asking/wanting/expecting someone else to act differently to meet women's needs.
Why do you think that expecting women to tolerate such situations without complaint is 'empowering'? Why do you perceive that telling men that propositioning a stranger in an elevator is acting like a creep as 'unempowering' men?
The difference is in the power to affect the outcome. It may sound cliche' but it is still true, you can choose not to be bothered by unwanted sexual interest that has no other effects.
If you have the power to control the outcome (and you do have the power to control your response) then it is much more liberating to use that power and IMO, to view the solution as being up to men to change, contributes to lessening the status of women.
I'm not entirely sure that all women can 'choose' not to be bothered by unwanted sexual interest. Their reaction is going to be based on their inherent attitudes about sex developed over their lifetimes. I think that telling women not to be bothered by 'unwanted sexual interest' is akin to telling a fat person they should eat less. It may be true, but that message doesn't make the fat person feel empowered. In order to effect such a change, a tremendous amount of effort is required and the probability of long term success remains low.

I also think you have to consider realistically the expected outcome of making that advice the standard for dealing with such complaints. If you tell women "learn to live with unwanted sexual attention at skeptic/atheist events" (which does come across as 'suck it up' to me), the message that comes across is that women shouldn't complain about behavior that they feel is over the line. If they do, the best reaction they can expect is to be informed that their expectations of acceptable behavior is what is out of line.

It also sends the message that the culture at such events is one in which men may proposition any woman anywhere at any time at such an event without it is being considered inappropriate behavior. A reasonable expectation of sending that message is that women who are bothered by the behavior will either accept it and deal with it without complaint or they will not attend events or participate in organizations that have a culture of tolerating behavior they find unpleasant and bothersome. What any particular woman decides depends on the value she places on belonging to the organization, how much unwanted sexual attention she personally receives, and how much it bothers her. Perhaps few enough women are bothered by such behavior that it won't make any difference.

OTOH, I'll quote Jennifer Oulette once again:
Ouelette said:
Here is the message being sent to the women skeptics and atheists say they want to join their ranks: “If an atheist/skeptic man behaves boorishly toward you, or refuses to respect your boundaries, whether social or sexual, and you have the gall to state firmly that this is not okay, you will be publicly pilloried, ridiculed for being hysterical, called a man-hating feminazi (or worse), and have your concerns belittled and dismissed.”
That's definitely that message that is coming through to this woman after reading hundreds of posts on this subject.
 
I concede that point to you, RandFan. My liquor store analogy perhaps muddied the water more than it cleared it. I appreciate your willingness to look past that to see what I am really trying to say.
Cool. I sincerely want a dialog and I concede that I'm not always as as open to that as I think I am. I'm trying. :)
 
For the same reason the 'N' word does. Insults that are based on a class of people are seen that way. Individualized insults are describing an action the person may have displayed. Sexism and misogyny are never deserved. Sometimes people are hypocrites and attention whores. Maybe attention whore isn't the nicest way to put it, and clearly sometimes the insults are intended to be hurtful and/or not deserved. Upon rereading this, my answer is confusing and inaccurate.

Let me try again. In this specific case, the reaction to the insults is most likely based on whether the person commenting perceives the insult to be true or false.
Actually, I think your first answer was more illuminating for me.

I also agree that whether it is perceived true or false makes a difference. My general impression is that insults that are considered false are easy to ignore while people get outraged about the ones they suspect are true. Is what you meant to imply?

It has to do with underlying premises. I do not perceive EG was doing anything more than telling RW he was interested in getting to know her better, and I don't perceive an elevator in a 5 star hotel in "a foreign country" at 4am as less safe than the same elevator at 2pm, or the bar at 4am. If I say so, I'm not "incredibly dismissive of my [RW's] experience and that of other women in this community, and so uneducated about the fundamentals of feminist thought."
I think you're wrong about it being less safe. At 2 pm, there are likely to be people in the foyer at any floor it stops on and the bar at 4 am has other people in it. Having other people around makes for a safer situation. In addition, being in a foreign country means that the each person is less likely to be able to pick up on cultural cues, both verbal and non-verbal, the other person is sending out and correctly interpret them, which may lead to problems.
Just as you aren't likely hearing the message, "There's no evidence that elevator is unsafe as is being portrayed. It hurts women to echo this false belief. It makes women fear things they need not fear." You hear, "I'm dismissing women's feelings (or whatever)."
I don't think I've accused you of dismissing women's feelings. I simply disagree with you regarding the elevator being as safe as you seem to think it is. I've listed the reasons above.
And you don't hear, "EG's behavior was not different from any other sexual interest comment." You hear, "I'm telling women to suck it up." I would not be telling a woman to suck it up if the behavior of EG was rude or really was what RW claimed it was.
While there are different standards of acceptable behavior, assuming that EG had done something you considered incredibly rude, how do you think a woman should respond?

It's a tricky conundrum here. Can one truly disagree with how a person perceives a situation and say so without dismissing their experience? You are a practicing nice guy, you tell me, how can one say there is no evidence here supporting RW's beliefs without RW hearing something else?
Thanks for the compliment. I try hard to be nice on the internet. I try hard to focus on understand other people's arguments. I try not to tell people they are wrong, but to tell them I disagree. I can explain why I disagree with their conclusion, for example, I might say that I don't consider EG's proposition to be sexist behavior. I would ask why they feel that it was.

Sometimes people will still get upset, but far fewer get upset by my telling them my opinion and why I feel that way than get upset by my telling them they are wrong and I am right even if the explanations are essentially the same. I also find that I have to discontinue some conversations because I am unable to respond without falling into non-nice behavior. It's one reason I'm no longer posting in the other thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom