For the same reason the 'N' word does. Insults that are based on a class of people are seen that way. Individualized insults are describing an action the person may have displayed. Sexism and misogyny are never deserved. Sometimes people are hypocrites and attention whores. Maybe attention whore isn't the nicest way to put it, and clearly sometimes the insults are intended to be hurtful and/or not deserved. Upon rereading this, my answer is confusing and inaccurate.
Let me try again. In this specific case, the reaction to the insults is most likely based on whether the person commenting perceives the insult to be true or false.
Actually, I think your first answer was more illuminating for me.
I also agree that whether it is perceived true or false makes a difference. My general impression is that insults that are considered false are easy to ignore while people get outraged about the ones they suspect are true. Is what you meant to imply?
It has to do with underlying premises. I do not perceive EG was doing anything more than telling RW he was interested in getting to know her better, and I don't perceive an elevator in a 5 star hotel in "a foreign country" at 4am as less safe than the same elevator at 2pm, or the bar at 4am. If I say so, I'm not "incredibly dismissive of my [RW's] experience and that of other women in this community, and so uneducated about the fundamentals of feminist thought."
I think you're wrong about it being less safe. At 2 pm, there are likely to be people in the foyer at any floor it stops on and the bar at 4 am has other people in it. Having other people around makes for a safer situation. In addition, being in a foreign country means that the each person is less likely to be able to pick up on cultural cues, both verbal and non-verbal, the other person is sending out and correctly interpret them, which may lead to problems.
Just as you aren't likely hearing the message, "There's no evidence that elevator is unsafe as is being portrayed. It hurts women to echo this false belief. It makes women fear things they need not fear." You hear, "I'm dismissing women's feelings (or whatever)."
I don't think I've accused you of dismissing women's feelings. I simply disagree with you regarding the elevator being as safe as you seem to think it is. I've listed the reasons above.
And you don't hear, "EG's behavior was not different from any other sexual interest comment." You hear, "I'm telling women to suck it up." I would not be telling a woman to suck it up if the behavior of EG was rude or really was what RW claimed it was.
While there are different standards of acceptable behavior, assuming that EG had done something you considered incredibly rude, how do you think a woman should respond?
It's a tricky conundrum here. Can one truly disagree with how a person perceives a situation and say so without dismissing their experience? You are a practicing nice guy, you tell me, how can one say there is no evidence here supporting RW's beliefs without RW hearing something else?
Thanks for the compliment. I try hard to be nice on the internet. I try hard to focus on understand other people's arguments. I try not to tell people they are wrong, but to tell them I disagree. I can explain why I disagree with their conclusion, for example, I might say that I don't consider EG's proposition to be sexist behavior. I would ask why they feel that it was.
Sometimes people will still get upset, but far fewer get upset by my telling them my opinion and why I feel that way than get upset by my telling them they are wrong and I am right even if the explanations are essentially the same. I also find that I have to discontinue some conversations because I am unable to respond without falling into non-nice behavior. It's one reason I'm no longer posting in the other thread.