Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
I think your definition of the word, "fact" is inaccurate, or at least some of the concepts here involving your use of that definition are.I'm not really that cynical. I think it's important to acknowledge that some facts can never be proven, and are not under your control to take actions on, while other facts can be considered real information and hard data and are under your own control. Hearsay about past events are not facts, no matter how much they are debated.
You appear to be claiming we cannot ever establish the degree and kind of sexism that might be a problem within the JREF community. And I assume your conclusion is then, we should act on the unsupported accusations people have made.
This smacks of the commonly cited unskeptical claim that evidence doesn't matter because one believes something is true and the evidence is not confirming the belief. If you don't like the evidence, claim it doesn't reveal anything.
If you are referring to differing subjective conclusions not being resolvable based on evidence, we can at least measure the quantity of incidents that the subjective opinions are being based on.
If your intent in what I quoted is wrong, perhaps you could clarify what you mean by telling us we can't gather the evidence we seek.
Which is why no one is questioning the fact there are more men than women in our community. And it is also why no one is questioning that it is a worthwhile goal to even up the numbers and increase the diversity.Actual statistics about your organization are facts, and are completely under your control. Taking concrete actions in your staffing creates a fact that cannot be disputed. This is not sleight of hand or smoke and mirrors. It IMO is a realistic approach to dealing with perceptions of sexism. It creates the ability, in the future, to argue: "FACT, our staffing ratio of women to men is 50/50. FACT, approximately 50% of our management is women. FACT, approximately 50% of our speakers are women. FACT, we hosted ___ sessions on diversity which resulted in our implementing X number of suggestions. Based on these FACTS, our organization is not sexist."
The question is, what is the best way to do that and if one addresses the wrong cause, we'd be wasting our time and resources. We need to define the cause of the problem before throwing random resources at it.
Last edited: