EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

I'm not really that cynical. I think it's important to acknowledge that some facts can never be proven, and are not under your control to take actions on, while other facts can be considered real information and hard data and are under your own control. Hearsay about past events are not facts, no matter how much they are debated.
I think your definition of the word, "fact" is inaccurate, or at least some of the concepts here involving your use of that definition are.

You appear to be claiming we cannot ever establish the degree and kind of sexism that might be a problem within the JREF community. And I assume your conclusion is then, we should act on the unsupported accusations people have made.

This smacks of the commonly cited unskeptical claim that evidence doesn't matter because one believes something is true and the evidence is not confirming the belief. If you don't like the evidence, claim it doesn't reveal anything.

If you are referring to differing subjective conclusions not being resolvable based on evidence, we can at least measure the quantity of incidents that the subjective opinions are being based on.


If your intent in what I quoted is wrong, perhaps you could clarify what you mean by telling us we can't gather the evidence we seek.



Actual statistics about your organization are facts, and are completely under your control. Taking concrete actions in your staffing creates a fact that cannot be disputed. This is not sleight of hand or smoke and mirrors. It IMO is a realistic approach to dealing with perceptions of sexism. It creates the ability, in the future, to argue: "FACT, our staffing ratio of women to men is 50/50. FACT, approximately 50% of our management is women. FACT, approximately 50% of our speakers are women. FACT, we hosted ___ sessions on diversity which resulted in our implementing X number of suggestions. Based on these FACTS, our organization is not sexist."
Which is why no one is questioning the fact there are more men than women in our community. And it is also why no one is questioning that it is a worthwhile goal to even up the numbers and increase the diversity.

The question is, what is the best way to do that and if one addresses the wrong cause, we'd be wasting our time and resources. We need to define the cause of the problem before throwing random resources at it.
 
Last edited:
What exactly is it that you think women should change about their behavior? That they shouldn't be uncomfortable and wary in a situation where a stranger has propositioned them in an small space with no available exit and no observers? Or that they shouldn't make it clear that such behavior is unacceptably rude in their opinion?

Why do you think that expecting women to tolerate such situations without complaint is 'empowering'? Why do you perceive that telling men that propositioning a stranger in an elevator is acting like a creep as 'unempowering' men?

I'm not entirely sure that all women can 'choose' not to be bothered by unwanted sexual interest. Their reaction is going to be based on their inherent attitudes about sex developed over their lifetimes. I think that telling women not to be bothered by 'unwanted sexual interest' is akin to telling a fat person they should eat less. It may be true, but that message doesn't make the fat person feel empowered. In order to effect such a change, a tremendous amount of effort is required and the probability of long term success remains low.
There is a continuum of how creepy, how discomforting, how offensive various encounters between men and women like the elevator incident could be. And of course there won't be a consensus where to draw the line. But it's really clear to me that EG was not as scary as RW is making him out to be. He was polite. He apparently took no for an answer. Men shouldn't be expected to treat elevators as frightening places for an encounter. There is no evidence they are and no consensus among women that they are.

While a man directly asking a woman to 'do it' in a more clear way would be quite rude.

I expect men to not be rude. I think it is reasonable for them to expect me to be able to handle a polite request by saying no.

If we expect men to go the full distance while we don't move an inch toward the middle, I'd say that actually seemed very sexist of us. It's women putting women on a pedestal. The bottom line, if we expect men to change their behavior, just like a good parent would do, we should pick our battles. Save it for the stuff that actually matters. A harmless come on is not one of those.



I also think you have to consider realistically the expected outcome of making that advice the standard for dealing with such complaints. If you tell women "learn to live with unwanted sexual attention at skeptic/atheist events" (which does come across as 'suck it up' to me), the message that comes across is that women shouldn't complain about behavior that they feel is over the line. If they do, the best reaction they can expect is to be informed that their expectations of acceptable behavior is what is out of line.
Define "unwanted sexual attention".

We've already been down this path. Some people want to meet members of the gender they are sexually attracted to at said events. Some people have voiced the opinion in this discussion that they don't want anyone to express interest in them. How do you propose to balance those competing wants?

It's hard to deny that EG made a polite inquiry. RW's intolerance seems to be the issue here, not EG's inquiry. Why is it so clear to you who was responsible to give way to the other's wants if these two were equals?


It also sends the message that the culture at such events is one in which men may proposition any woman anywhere at any time at such an event without it is being considered inappropriate behavior.
That's a straw man.


A reasonable expectation of sending that message is that women who are bothered by the behavior will either accept it and deal with it without complaint or they will not attend events or participate in organizations that have a culture of tolerating behavior they find unpleasant and bothersome. What any particular woman decides depends on the value she places on belonging to the organization, how much unwanted sexual attention she personally receives, and how much it bothers her. Perhaps few enough women are bothered by such behavior that it won't make any difference.
Accept what? You make it sound like someone is squirting water on women wearing tee shirts.

I challenge you to define unwanted sexual attention so that men and women know exactly what the rules are and that it satisfies most event attendee's expectations equally.


OTOH, I'll quote Jennifer Oulette once again:

That's definitely that message that is coming through to this woman after reading hundreds of posts on this subject.
More straw. Define "behaves boorishly toward you, or refuses to respect your boundaries, whether social or sexual". We probably all agree groping and an unwanted tongue in your mouth are beyond acceptable. And smiling at someone is OK. So let's hear the rest of your definition of exactly where that line should be drawn.
 
Last edited:
Actually, I think your first answer was more illuminating for me.

I also agree that whether it is perceived true or false makes a difference. My general impression is that insults that are considered false are easy to ignore while people get outraged about the ones they suspect are true. Is what you meant to imply?
No, I meant the opposite. If you accuse me of being sexist and I know I'm not, the insult is more outrageous than if you accuse me of being rude and I know I make that mistake sometimes.

People do believe RW seeks attention and they don't believe Stef's comments were misogynist. That's why "attention whore" did not bother some as much as the things RW said about McGraw did.

I think you're wrong about it being less safe. At 2 pm, there are likely to be people in the foyer at any floor it stops on and the bar at 4 am has other people in it. Having other people around makes for a safer situation. In addition, being in a foreign country means that the each person is less likely to be able to pick up on cultural cues, both verbal and non-verbal, the other person is sending out and correctly interpret them, which may lead to problems.
I don't think I've accused you of dismissing women's feelings. I simply disagree with you regarding the elevator being as safe as you seem to think it is. I've listed the reasons above.
While there are different standards of acceptable behavior, assuming that EG had done something you considered incredibly rude, how do you think a woman should respond?
There is no evidence that elevator was a threatening place. If RW perceived it as such that's here prerogative. But to expect EG to anticipate RW's perception is unreasonable.

In addition, as Linda pointed out, there is especially no evidence that EG simply riding in the elevator RW was on, vs riding in it and talking to her did not change the level of risk. When this is noted, some people went so far as to say men should not get on an elevator at night in which a woman is alone on it. Men should politely wait for the next car because getting on the elevator could cause the woman to experience fear.

Do you agree? Isn't that just a wee bit ridiculous? And if you don't agree, do you think it was OK for EG to get on the 'lift'? Why did talking to RW make the fear any greater? It should have made it less.
 
Last edited:
Referring only to the question at 53:30:
While I would say that's certainly an example of sexist thinking, I am sure that some here will argue that since the man did not say "I believe", but instead said "People have told me", that you can't say he said something sexist.
What is with this presumed straw man? I'm sorry but I truly am seeing no relevance here.

It seemed to me that regardless of how the guy worded his question, he was asking because he believed it was true. Yes, it was a sexist comment. A really stupid one. So what? Stupid people attend conferences.

The last formal talk I was at, a 9/11 truther asked questions and the talk was by an author who co-wrote, "Merchants of Doubt" about scientists that support cases against the evidence supported side. Stupid people come to intellectual events.
 
Last edited:
Which is why no one is questioning the fact there are more men than women in our community. And it is also why no one is questioning that it is a worthwhile goal to even up the numbers and increase the diversity.

Watson is. She's working hard to keep women away, especially those who reduce her brand of uniformity.

Anyway, I'm pretty sure that if someone said that Watson was parroting feminist thought, that would be considered sexist. Why isn't her saying that a woman was parroting misogynistic thought considered sexist?

After all, saying that someone is parroting is tantamount to saying that she is unable to think for herself. While I'm sure that there are people for whom such an accusation of a man is unremarkable, most would consider saying that to a woman sexist.

And now we know that it's evidence of sexism that someone said he heard that a woman doesn't want her car fixed but wants a shoulder to cry on. But saying that a woman cannot think for herself is not sexist at all. How exactly does that work?
 
I think your definition of the word, "fact" is inaccurate, or at least some of the concepts here involving your use of that definition are.

From dictionary.com

fact   
[fakt] Show IPA
–noun
1.
something that actually exists; reality; truth: Your fears have no basis in fact.
2.
something known to exist or to have happened: Space travel is now a fact.
3.
a truth known by actual experience or observation; something known to be true: Scientists gather facts about plant growth.


You cannot establish facts by debating and discussing hearsay. We call that gossiping and rumormongering.

You appear to be claiming we cannot ever establish the degree and kind of sexism that might be a problem within the JREF community.
I am claiming that. No matter how much you debate and discuss what might or might not have happened, or whether something is empowering or unempowering, or whether this is a case of someone being rude or not, you can't prove any of it. You can't even prove that some of these events even happened. Please note that I am NOT saying that I don't believe what these women are saying. I do believe them.


And I assume your conclusion is then, we should act on the unsupported accusations people have made.
My conclusion is that debating hearsay does not result in any actionable items at all. My conclusion is that an organization can only act on those things within the organization's control.

This smacks of the commonly cited unskeptical claim that evidence doesn't matter because one believes something is true and the evidence is not confirming the belief. If you don't like the evidence, claim it doesn't reveal anything.

This smacks of a strawman argument. Interestingly, this seems to be something that maybe should be pointed out to the participants in this thread that feel a need to debate the validity of each anecdote.


If you are referring to differing subjective conclusions not being resolvable based on evidence, we can at least measure the quantity of incidents that the subjective opinions are being based on.
Hence my question earlier about how you count the incidents. How do you intend to quantify how many subjective opinions are changed or formed by one perceived incident?

If your intent in what I quoted is wrong, perhaps you could clarify what you mean by telling us we can't gather the evidence we seek.

I did not say you can't gather evidence. You can attempt to gather evidence until the cows come home. Im saying that if your goal is to counter the perception of sexism, a more effective use of resources and time would be to concentrate on those things which are directly under your control which can affect people's perception of the organization.


Which is why no one is questioning the fact there are more men than women in our community. And it is also why no one is questioning that it is a worthwhile goal to even up the numbers and increase the diversity.

The question is, what is the best way to do that and if one addresses the wrong cause, we'd be wasting our time and resources. We need to define the cause of the problem before throwing random resources at it.

I think any action that works toward evening up the numbers and increasing diversity is unlikely to be perceived as a waste of time and resources. On the other hand, spending a whole lot of time debating whether so-and-so called whats-her-name a misogynist or not most probably is.
 
There is a continuum of how creepy, how discomforting, how offensive various encounters between men and women like the elevator incident could be. And of course there won't be a consensus where to draw the line. But it's really clear to me that EG was not as scary as RW is making him out to be.
How scary do you think RW has made him out to be? She's never indicated that she was afraid. She said she was uncomfortable and found his behavior creepy. I would have felt similarly under the same circumstances.
While a man directly asking a woman to 'do it' in a more clear way would be quite rude.
So euphemism is not rude but asking her to 'do it' directly is? Okay. How do you think a woman should respond to a complete stranger asking her to 'do it'?
I expect men to not be rude. I think it is reasonable for them to expect me to be able to handle polite request by saying no.
I think we are in agreement here, we simply differ on what constitutes rude behavior. Personally, I think being propositioned by a complete stranger is rude behavior, whether he/she uses subtle euphemism or crude vulgarity to express his/her desire.
If we expect men to go the full distance while we don't move an inch toward the middle, I'd say that actually seemed very sexist of us. It's women putting women on a pedestal. The bottom line, if we expect men to change their behavior, just like a good parent would do, we should pick our battles. Save it for the stuff that actually matters. A harmless come on is not one of those.
I simply expect men not to be rude. That's the same expectation you have. We simply differ on what we consider rude behavior.

Define "unwanted sexual attention".
Being propositioned by a complete stranger in a hotel elevator. :p
It's hard to deny that EG made a polite inquiry. RW's intolerance seems to be the issue here, not EG's inquiry.
No, it's hard to deny he made a rude request although it's possible that he was polite in the way he made the request. I don't think it is intolerant to expect men to not be rude.

It also sends the message that the culture at such events is one in which men may proposition any woman anywhere at any time at such an event without it being considered inappropriate behavior.
That's a straw man.

Really? It seems to me that if a woman can be propositioned by a complete stranger in an elevator and that is considered acceptable behavior, why should I think there is any place or time at such an event that it would not be considered acceptable behavior? Where is it that you think such an proposition would be considered unacceptable, assuming of course, that the man used a suitable euphemism?
Accept what? You make it sound like someone is squirting water on women wearing tee shirts.
Frankly, squirting water on women wearing tee shirts would be less upsetting than some of the other activities that have been reported on this thread.
More straw. Define "behaves boorishly toward you, or refuses to respect your boundaries, whether social or sexual". We probably all agree groping and an unwanted tongue in your mouth are beyond acceptable. And smiling at someone is OK. So let's hear the rest of your definition of exactly where that line should be drawn.

I'll just stick with the example we're currently working with - propositioning a stranger on an elevator. That's boorish behavior and ignoring fairly common social and sexual boundaries. Doing so after the woman has made it quite clear in her talks that she doesn't like that sort of behavior and has stated in your hearing that she is heading for bed at 4am is ignoring her social and sexual boundaries after she has made you aware of them.

So, not only do I not find Ms. Oulettes statement to be a 'straw man', but I agree with her about the message that is being perceived by many women as a result of the extensive discussion about this incident. That's the message I'm getting.
 
In addition, as Linda pointed out, there is especially no evidence that EG simply riding in the elevator RW was on, vs riding in it and talking to her did not change the level of risk.
He wasn't simply talking to her. He said one thing to her and that was an invitation to come to his hotel room alone at 4am. That was a proposition which breached the social and sexual boundaries that she had previously communicated in his hearing. It makes sense to assess the level of risk much differently after the stranger in the elevator has demonstrated his willingness to overstep those social and sexual boundaries.

When this is noted, some people went so far as to say men should not get on an elevator at night in which a woman is alone on it.

Men should politely wait for the next car because getting on the elevator could cause the woman to experience fear.

Do you agree? Isn't that just a wee bit ridiculous? And if you don't agree, do you think it was OK for EG to get on the 'lift'? Why did talking to RW make the fear any greater? It should have made it less.

No, I don't agree that a man needs to wait for another elevator. If a woman is bothered by it, she can get off and take the next one.
 
...

No, I don't agree that a man needs to wait for another elevator. If a woman is bothered by it, she can get off and take the next one.
I'm coming back to the rest, but tell me how the elevator is relevant if the issue is he talked to her?

It's one or the other, either the elevator contributed to RW's discomfort, in which case just getting on the elevator with her should also be a "guy's don't do that" offense, or it did not contribute to the matter.

How can the elevator have contributed to the discomfort if by itself it is not an issue?
 
He wasn't simply talking to her. He said one thing to her and that was an invitation to come to his hotel room alone at 4am.

This whole thing could have gone down completely differently. In fact, it almost did!! Somebody hacked Rebecca's computer and got the first take of the video blog where she mentions Elevator Guy. She paints quite a different picture.

 
Evidence?

http://www.youtube.com/user/centerforinquiry#p/a/C852E00ABA134E69/0/z-X62CBTv44

Check out the Q&A portion, specifically that which starts around 53:30.

That's not too long after the "hug me, I'm vaccinated" stuff, right? You know, the female organization giving out hugs at an event where the attendees are mostly male (and apparently sexist). The program they promoted with a retro-style drawing of a tarted up, busty nurse.

Your example is immediately after Rebecca says:
"If you are talking to someone and they, you think they haven't understood what you've said and they, uh, she...she falls back on this idea that, well, it's just women's intuition, uh, I, eh... encourage her to think logically. Tell her, tell her in the nicest way you can that she's an intelligent, rational human being who can think logically about things."

Of course, the next guy, the one to whom you are referring, is mocked for asking a sincere question about whether he should offer to help a woman with a car problem or just listen to her.

How come she didn't say in the nicest way possible, "You're an intelligent rational human being who can think logically about things. How do you think you should approach such a situation?"

Hell, why did she say in another interview that socially inept men just need to learn on their own?

So, I thank you for providing more evidence of sexism in the skeptical movement.
 
This whole thing could have gone down completely differently. In fact, it almost did!! Somebody hacked Rebecca's computer and got the first take of the video blog where she mentions Elevator Guy. She paints quite a different picture.

Very clever. I hope it gets some YouTube airtime. :)
 
That's not too long after the "hug me, I'm vaccinated" stuff, right? You know, the female organization giving out hugs at an event where the attendees are mostly male (and apparently sexist). The program they promoted with a retro-style drawing of a tarted up, busty nurse.
Very demeaning to the nursing profession, BTW. And this is not something professional nurses haven't been attempting to bring to peoples' awareness, because we have, for several decades now but it seems people still aren't hearing the message.
 
Last edited:
I'm coming back to the rest, but tell me how the elevator is relevant if the issue is he talked to her?

It's one or the other, either the elevator contributed to RW's discomfort, in which case just getting on the elevator with her should also be a "guy's don't do that" offense, or it did not contribute to the matter.

How can the elevator have contributed to the discomfort if by itself it is not an issue?

Yes, the elevator did contribute to RW's discomfort. I didn't say the issue was just that he talked to her. The point I was making was that talking versus not talking is not the issue, but rather what it was he said. That was, of course, in addition to where and when.
 
<snip>

I think we are in agreement here, we simply differ on what constitutes rude behavior. Personally, I think being propositioned by a complete stranger is rude behavior, whether he/she uses subtle euphemism or crude vulgarity to express his/her desire.

<snip>

Were both parties complete strangers? Ms. Watson has both a reputation for bawdy behaviour and a degree of celebrity.

Are women who throw themselves at male celebrities from the film and music industries being rude when those celebrities are famous more for their looks and behaviour than their acting or musical abilities?
 
That's not too long after the "hug me, I'm vaccinated" stuff, right? You know, the female organization giving out hugs at an event where the attendees are mostly male (and apparently sexist). The program they promoted with a retro-style drawing of a tarted up, busty nurse.

Fascinating that you should gripe about how someone else has depicted an imaginary women as "tarted up, busty", when your own depiction of a real person is in exactly the same way.
 
I'm coming back to the rest, but tell me how the elevator is relevant if the issue is he talked to her?

It's one or the other, either the elevator contributed to RW's discomfort, in which case just getting on the elevator with her should also be a "guy's don't do that" offense, or it did not contribute to the matter.

How can the elevator have contributed to the discomfort if by itself it is not an issue?

It's not one or the other, it's a compilation. You can share an elevator with a stranger and not even notice them. You can share an elevator with a stranger and strike up a polite conversation (which I suspect was EG's intention). Sharing an elevator with a stranger, who you suspect follows you into the elevator (according to the version she spoke of at the event where she called out McGraw), and then makes a request of you, that you find unusual, at the very least will stick in your memory for a while. Where you take it after that all depends on your previous experieces and prejudices.
 
Were both parties complete strangers? Ms. Watson has both a reputation for bawdy behaviour and a degree of celebrity.
Yes. That doesn't even qualify as acquantances.
Are women who throw themselves at male celebrities from the film and music industries being rude when those celebrities are famous more for their looks and behaviour than their acting or musical abilities?
Yes. It doesn't matter why they are famous.
 
Last edited:
How scary do you think RW has made him out to be? She's never indicated that she was afraid. She said she was uncomfortable and found his behavior creepy. I would have felt similarly under the same circumstances.
which is cool so long as you don't expect others to agree.

So euphemism is not rude but asking her to 'do it' directly is? Okay. How do you think a woman should respond to a complete stranger asking her to 'do it'?
I don't think either are per se rude. And this goest to the heart of this. No one speaks for all women. Life simply does not work like that. There are things I find rude that others don't. I don't think the world must change to accomodate me. That said. There is a reason euphamisms exist. They are far less likely to offend, And, sometimes coffee is just coffee.

I think we are in agreement here, we simply differ on what constitutes rude behavior. Personally, I think being propositioned by a complete stranger is rude behavior, whether he/she uses subtle euphemism or crude vulgarity to express his/her desire.
And that is your perogative. So long as you don't have an expectation that everyone should agree with you. Many men and women have hook ups with strangers. A troubling aspect I have with all of this is that this incident shoud define what is inapropriate behavior and dictate how all women should act. It is solipsistic for me to reason a behavior rude and declare that everyone else should likewise find it so. It's not solipsistic to voice an opinion in the hopes of changing attitudes. Perhaps the vast majority of women agree with you. Regardless, lots of women, a few women, if a segment of the population find that rude then we ought to know about it so we can make informed decisions.

I simply expect men not to be rude.
In the movie, Julie and Julia (based on a true story, the hero never meets her hero, Julia Childs. Childs found the behavior of Julie (swearing on Julie's own blog rude). That is Child's perogative. Child's might have the expectation that the world conform to her mores but anyone who has such an expectation can only be disapointed. Humans simply are not monolithic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom