EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

I'm not conjecturing anything. This is an educational forum, and I am attempting to add some information that all people might not know. If there are men around that think getting a woman snockered or high is a good way to get her into your room in order to have sex with her, they might want to rethink that plan. Depending on the circumstances, which only a court of law will decide, it could just land you a Category A Felony conviction and a life sentence.

More info here:
http://www.shouselaw.com/nevada/sexual-assault.html
http://www.crisiscallcenter.org/sexualassault_nl.html

"Sounds to me like this person just might be way more than an ass" is conjecture, plain and simple. How can we have a discussion when you refuse to support your assertions, refuse to answer direct questions, and now claim that saying somebody "just might be" something is not conjecture?

I highly doubt that people are unaware that having sex with a limp body is most likely rape. Educating people about Nevada rape laws is way off topic for a discussion of evidence of sexism in the skeptical "movement."

There are plenty of unanswered questions directed your way. Please answer them. If you're simply going to ignore responses to your posts, start a blog.
 
Oh for pete's sake..

Just about every post in this thread is conjecture based on hearsay evidence. Your own opinions about the examples in this thread are conjectures based on hearsay evidence. The whole elevatorgate kerfuffle is from people making conjectures based on hearsay evidence.

con·jec·ture/kənˈjekCHər/
Noun: An opinion or conclusion formed on the basis of incomplete information.
Verb: Form an opinion or supposition about (something) on the basis of incomplete information

hear·say/ˈhi(ə)rˌsā/Noun
1. Information received from other people that cannot be adequately substantiated; rumor.
2. The report of another person's words by a witness, usually disallowed as evidence in a court of law.

The Thrasher doth protest too much, methinks.
 
....In my mind skeptics aren't special. I would expect a similar distribution of negative and positive characteristics at skeptic events as I would at any other event.
There are more liberals and more atheists among us than many groups. I shouldn't have to defend my belief that there are more sexists among conservative Christians and far right wingers. We have less of those. Perhaps it is counteracted by the greater number of science types among us. Women were excluded from scientific circles until the last half century and there is bound to be leftover sexism in that group.

I believe these effects are probably small. We aren't that homogeneous of a group. And I see no reason to expect an absence of sexism. I'm sure I've stated that clearly more than once in this discussion, whether it's been heard or not.


...Well, I take that back. I think the Skepchicks emphasis on sex makes it more appealing for people into that kind of stuff or viewing it as a more sexually free event. It's not like ScrapBookerChicks sells "Would I be creating a memory if I **** in your face?" buttons.....
I think the atmosphere, at TAM in particular, has been one of inviting relationships, be they just friendly or more. To hear people complain about being approached needs to be carefully examined before conclusions can be drawn about the 'problem'.
 
I haven't gotten past the first page of the thread, but I wanted to point out that collecting anecdotes as data points inherently introduces confirmation bias. You may easily hear from many who were indecently propositioned in an elevator but few of those who pushed the button and got off without incident.
And going by people's conclusions without knowing the anecdotes behind it is even less objective.

Sigh.... Why is it people keep missing the point about the thread's goals?

I'm asking people to describe what has led them to conclude they've "experienced/seen sexism" so that we can eliminate some of their bias and draw better conclusions about the claims.
 
Last edited:
A good example of sexism in the skeptical community - We had a member here who was a classic male chauvinist pig, Uncayimmy, once he knew a member was female his posting style would become even more aggressive and condescending; so when he knew it was a female poster that had him on the ropes when he couldn't (as often happened) support his ludicrous claims he would try to patronize them, intimidate them and so on. Now granted he tried to bully anyone who dared to disagree with him but when it was a female he just totally lost it.
Is that was he was so hard to talk to? ;) I just put him on ignore, problem solved for me. And he got himself banned, problem solved for everyone else.

This points to an interesting side note. We are the ones who identify ourselves as skeptics. But not everyone here is even close to being a skeptic. Some people are here to challenge scientific evidence based conclusions. Others are here to proselytize. And still others fancy themselves as skeptics but the facts say otherwise.
 
I'm not conjecturing anything. This is an educational forum, and I am attempting to add some information that all people might not know. If there are men around that think getting a woman snockered or high is a good way to get her into your room in order to have sex with her, they might want to rethink that plan. Depending on the circumstances, which only a court of law will decide, it could just land you a Category A Felony conviction and a life sentence.
...
Do you really think a knowledge deficit is the problem here?
 
Oh for pete's sake..

Just about every post in this thread is conjecture based on hearsay evidence. Your own opinions about the examples in this thread are conjectures based on hearsay evidence. The whole elevatorgate kerfuffle is from people making conjectures based on hearsay evidence.

con·jec·ture/kənˈjekCHər/
Noun: An opinion or conclusion formed on the basis of incomplete information.
Verb: Form an opinion or supposition about (something) on the basis of incomplete information

hear·say/ˈhi(ə)rˌsā/Noun
1. Information received from other people that cannot be adequately substantiated; rumor.
2. The report of another person's words by a witness, usually disallowed as evidence in a court of law.

The Thrasher doth protest too much, methinks.

So which is it, Meg? First you say it's not conjecture, then you come back and claim it is. The simple fact of the matter is that you have no basis on which to say this ass "just might have" raped these women. It's, as I said, not only baseless (a key adjective) but in contradiction to what evidence we do have.

Please stop making unfounded assertions and then ignoring requests to defend them. On what basis are you claiming that this guy might be a rapist? It's a very serious claim that goes way beyond being a manipulative horn dog. Defend your position. Is that really too much too ask?
 
I state again, for the reading impaired.

In response to Thrasher's conclusion formed on the basis of incomplete information:
The guy sounds like an ass, no doubt about it. I'm just not seeing how this is sexism.
I wrote: Sounds to me like this person just might be way more than an ass. I have not declared an opinion or made a conclusion about that person. I have only expressed the opinion that that behavior *might* be considered more serious than "an ass".

I am not asserting that this person is a rapist, nor do I feel the need to defend assertions that I have not made.

Since you seem to need to have things spelled out for you, here is my opinion.

My opinion is the RemieV is a very intelligent person.
My opinion is that if a very intelligent person is nervous about or hesitant to discuss a certain matter, it might be because the very intelligent person has a good reason to feel that way. Perhaps this certain matter is more serious than other examples of behavior that have come up in this thread.
My congecture is that this might be more serious because of who the person is, or this might be more serious because of what the person did.


I have no intentions of attempting to guess who the person is, nor do I care to pretend there is enough evidence presented to discern exactly what he did, whether it was consensual, what he might or might not have lied about, what was discussed between the two people, or whether this is an example of sexism.

There are enough people doing that already.
 
I state again, for the reading impaired.
Leave out the personal attacks, please.

In response to Thrasher's conclusion formed on the basis of incomplete information:
Please don't refer to me in the third person and then proceed to address me in the second person (see below). It makes me uncomfortable and creeps me out.

Since you [second person] seem to need to have things spelled out for you, here is my opinion.

I wrote: Sounds to me like this person just might be way more than an ass. I have not declared an opinion or made a conclusion about that person. I have only expressed the opinion that that behavior *might* be considered more serious than "an ass".
You then went on to say that he "just might be" more than just an ass because he might have done something that not only was NOT indicated to have happened but was likely to NOT have happened based on the story as presented.

He also just might be a terrorist! Here, let me quote the terrorism statutes for those who may not know that terrorism is illegal.

My opinion is the RemieV is a very intelligent person.

My opinion is that if a very intelligent person is nervous about or hesitant to discuss a certain matter, it might be because the very intelligent person has a good reason to feel that way. Perhaps this certain matter is more serious than other examples of behavior that have come up in this thread.
So now you're trying to imply that maybe you are right to say this man "just might be" a rapist because of what RemieV didn't say. Here's a different take. If RemieV is "very intelligent" then why wouldn't she and the victims report a serial rapist? That's what intelligent people do. She doesn't need to tell us, but she needs to tell the authorities, which can be done anonymously.

My congecture is that this might be more serious because of who the person is, or this might be more serious because of what the person did.
What happened to "I'm not conjecturing anything??" You're building up a house of cards. For what purpose, I don't know.
 
Good lord - the essence of the problem for me here is anonymity. Having worked for the JREF, I can't exactly hide behind my pseudonym (heck, I don't even try to because it would be pointless).

I just thought of a perfectly comparable story that has nothing to do with sexism and doesn't technically involve anything that happened while I was employed by the JREF, but does illustrate rank-closing in the skeptical community and I can't even bring myself to type THAT because once you know my name, figuring out the name of the person I'm talking about is incredibly easy - and I'd really prefer not to turn around and see an article about myself posted somewhere where I can't stop it. I do have a life outside of this forum, after all.

So while it might be exceedingly important to me to warn women who plan to attend events "Hey, this community is not any safer than any other just because they're skeptics," it just ain't THIS important. Sorry.

Instead of continuing to participate in a thread that is asking for specific examples, perhaps I should just make a new one for women about keeping safe at conferences and ask the mods to sticky it in the Skeptical Events subsection. That ultimately makes more sense, and doesn't require the finger-pointing.
 
... I should just make a new one for women about keeping safe at conferences and ask the mods to sticky it in the Skeptical Events subsection. That ultimately makes more sense, and doesn't require the finger-pointing.
I see nothing wrong with providing useful advice for a safe TAM. Could you do it in such a way as to not make it look like this is a pervasive problem and could you include other security issues? Would you consider discussing the difference between rational and irrational fear? Perhaps you could recommend the following book. I would hate to think that a skeptics organization is fostering irrational fear.

The Culture of Fear: Why Americans Are Afraid of the Wrong Things
 
And going by people's conclusions without knowing the anecdotes behind it is even less objective.

Sigh.... Why is it people keep missing the point about the thread's goals?

I'm asking people to describe what has led them to conclude they've "experienced/seen sexism" so that we can eliminate some of their bias and draw better conclusions about the claims.

I get your point. I don't like the person who started this whole controversy, but if women are being bombarded with come on's and comments on their appearance, it's a valid issue. The occasional polite approach in a bar where people are drinking and, I assume, joking and flirting, is something different though.

I think its unfortunate that Rebecca Watson is the one to bring it up, especially the way she did. If there's anyone who's done more to sexualize women in this scene, I can't think of one. She's done the same at skeptical events from what I've read, throwing sexually themed parties, encouraging women to hit on guys in blog posts, etc. If women being treated as sex objects is a problem, she's more to blame then anyone.

Some so called feminists (I say some because I've come across quite a few women making sensible comments in these blogs and threads) will make an accusation of sexism the moment someone asks for more evidence or questions this lady's story. Not any way for a skeptic to behave, if you ask me.

So yeah, this thread is not a bad place to start, imo. Let's hear your grievances ladies. Is walking through a skeptics convention like passing by a construction site these days? Did some drunk male speaker grab your chest? How bad is it out there really?

I'm certainly not taking Watson's word for it.
 
I see nothing wrong with providing useful advice for a safe TAM. Could you do it in such a way as to not make it look like this is a pervasive problem and could you include other security issues? Would you consider discussing the difference between rational and irrational fear? Perhaps you could recommend the following book. I would hate to think that a skeptics organization is fostering irrational fear.

The Culture of Fear: Why Americans Are Afraid of the Wrong Things

I'm not sure why I would include other security issues since that wouldn't be the topic, and I don't have any knowledge about any others. I also don't see how it fosters irrational fear. Would it foster irrational fear to watch your drink closely; to not accept one from anyone, even if you have met them on the forum a bamillion times, if you didn't see it poured?
 
I'm not sure why I would include other security issues since that wouldn't be the topic...
Singling out this one incident could make it appear that it is particularly worse than any other security issue. But why not? Are those other issues unimportant to attendees?

...and I don't have any knowledge about any others. I also don't see how it fosters irrational fear. Would it foster irrational fear to watch your drink closely; to not accept one from anyone, even if you have met them on the forum a bamillion times, if you didn't see it poured?
It could be, sure. Especially if sexual assault were singled out. Somebody is likely to ask "why this and not other concerns"? "What else are they not telling me?" That's a reasonable inference. If you refuse to make the suggestions more comprehensive, would you be willing to add a caveat about relative risks and how those suggestions are not due to any empirical evidence that TAM is particularly more risky than any other event?
 
So Remie, can you just tell us if you are talking about 1 person, 2 people or what?

It still sounds to me like an individual rather than a community issue.
 
Good lord - the essence of the problem for me here is anonymity. Having worked for the JREF, I can't exactly hide behind my pseudonym (heck, I don't even try to because it would be pointless).
I don't see anyone complaining about the degree to which you've gone. I think everyone understands your position. Do you believe otherwise?

So while it might be exceedingly important to me to warn women who plan to attend events "Hey, this community is not any safer than any other just because they're skeptics," it just ain't THIS important. Sorry.

Instead of continuing to participate in a thread that is asking for specific examples, perhaps I should just make a new one for women about keeping safe at conferences and ask the mods to sticky it in the Skeptical Events subsection. That ultimately makes more sense, and doesn't require the finger-pointing.
If this community is not any safer or more dangerous than any other, why do we need a sticky thread at all? And why gear it to women only? That's the very question Skeptic Ginger is trying to address.
 
If this community is not any safer or more dangerous than any other, why do we need a sticky thread at all? And why gear it to women only?
And what advice would it give and how will it be verified as the right advice?
 
Meh, I'm stepping out of the discussion. When I first started participating, I was under the impression that the thread was asking for examples - not asking for debate. I gave the examples. Think of them what you will. I'm not in a position to go further into it.

As for the advice thread, essentially, it would be, "I know you feel like you know a lot of the people at skeptical conferences because you've met them on forums or seen their talks. But really, you don't know them at all. Treat it like a club full of strangers, and navigate accordingly."
 
Meh, I'm stepping out of the discussion. When I first started participating, I was under the impression that the thread was asking for examples - not asking for debate. I gave the examples. Think of them what you will. I'm not in a position to go further into it.

As for the advice thread, essentially, it would be, "I know you feel like you know a lot of the people at skeptical conferences because you've met them on forums or seen their talks. But really, you don't know them at all. Treat it like a club full of strangers, and navigate accordingly."
It sounds like advice one would give to children.

I do hope you see fit to tell us the number of people you are talking about before you bow out. It will give us better information to go on.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom