EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Question regarding quantifying sexist behavior.

If a guy shouts out a "great boobs!" comment during a speaker's presentation, and 500 women hear it, of which x percentage think it is sexist, and y percentage think "OMFSM! If this is the kind of sexist crap that goes on at these things, I am not going to attend another!" Does that count as 1 example of sexist behavior, X examples of sexist behavior, or Y examples of sexist behavior?

Even if you think because of "boobquake" that the comment might not be sexist, if some percentage of people in the audience are new to the movement, or this particular conference, or have just never heard of this speaker before, and are therefore unaware of "boobquake", if this percentage of people conclude the comment is just blatantly sexist, are they wrong?


Similarly, if BuzzCam accosts 5 women at a conference, and those instances are witnessed by X people and the stories about these events are recounted to Y people, and of all those people Z amount say "OMFSM! If this is the kind of sexist crap that goes on at these things, I am not going to attend another!" does this count as 1, 5, X, Y or Z counts of sexist behavior?

When Kennedy was shot, was that 200,000,000 counts of murder?
 
When Kennedy was shot, was that 200,000,000 counts of murder?

Obviously no.

However, if your intention is not to gather assasination statistics, but to find out whether there are potential candidates for president that don't run because they fear being assasinated, you might find that the same 4 assasinations affect the decisions of many many more people.
 
Last edited:
Obviously no.

However, if your intention is not to gather assasination statistics, but to find out whether there are potential candidates for president that don't run because they fear being assasinated, you might find that the same 4 assasinations affect the decisions of many many more people.

You asked if one event becomes N number of examples based on various conditions. I'm telling you that it's just one event. You are welcome to argue how much effect it might have. I laid out the evidence, so rather than argue in generalities, express your opinion on the evidence itself.

I see at least three factors to consider:

1) The severity of the event.
2) The number of people aware of the event.
3) The probability that any given event is a one-off event or an indication of something that happens more often but was not reported.

For example, take the tongue guy.

1) Very severe event that could easily result in the victim not returning.

2) News of it was apparently spread by word of mouth (pardon the pun), but clearly some attendees didn't know about it. Those who heard about it may choose not to take the risk depending on #3.

3) This was very likely a one-off event by a single person. I doubt that if there were multiple tongue guys we wouldn't hear about them. Most people wouldn't appreciate it, but I think most would not stay away because just one person was a total *******. Unless, of course, word got out that the JREF was notified and didn't act. In that case, I could see people boycotting TAM because of the lack of response.

I encourage you to evaluate the other evidence in the same way rather than ask vague questions.
 
You asked if one event becomes N number of examples based on various conditions. I'm telling you that it's just one event. You are welcome to argue how much effect it might have. I laid out the evidence, so rather than argue in generalities, express your opinion on the evidence itself.

I see at least three factors to consider:

1) The severity of the event.
2) The number of people aware of the event.
3) The probability that any given event is a one-off event or an indication of something that happens more often but was not reported.

For example, take the tongue guy.

1) Very severe event that could easily result in the victim not returning.

2) News of it was apparently spread by word of mouth (pardon the pun), but clearly some attendees didn't know about it. Those who heard about it may choose not to take the risk depending on #3.

3) This was very likely a one-off event by a single person. I doubt that if there were multiple tongue guys we wouldn't hear about them. Most people wouldn't appreciate it, but I think most would not stay away because just one person was a total *******. Unless, of course, word got out that the JREF was notified and didn't act. In that case, I could see people boycotting TAM because of the lack of response.

I encourage you to evaluate the other evidence in the same way rather than ask vague questions.

Derek Bartholomaus recently made an interesting post wherein he said that, by his observations, the skeptical world has a tendency to close ranks and hide bad things that happen because our public image is already rather negative. I think this is, to some extent, true.

For instance, apparently the least believable thing I've mentioned in regards to sexism is the skeptical leader who refused to hire women, and yet I've given pretty equal amounts of evidence for all the incidents I've pointed out. Why is that?

As for the guy with the getting women drunk thing - a couple of things are being ignored there as well. In addition to the alcohol issue, what I said was that the guy lies about extremely important things. I can't say what those are without coughing up the identity.

It's not just issues of sexism, either. There are plenty of things about plenty of people in the skeptical movement that would totally blow minds. I just don't see why that's surprising. If we aren't surprised when politicians are caught in the sack with underage prostitutes, why are we surprised at the same sorts of things here?

I've been attempting to stay out of the thread because I really don't want to get in trouble somehow for talking about these things, but I'm still reading. And what I'm reading is driving me a little bit crazy.
 
Derek Bartholomaus recently made an interesting post wherein he said that, by his observations, the skeptical world has a tendency to close ranks and hide bad things that happen because our public image is already rather negative. I think this is, to some extent, true.
Interesting. The only problem I have is that I'm not certain which I'm skeptical of more, his observations and confirmation bias or mine?

It's not just issues of sexism, either. There are plenty of things about plenty of people in the skeptical movement that would totally blow minds.
It's called the human conditions. Some people see the bad. Some the good. Some are skeptical of their own bias.

If we aren't surprised when politicians are caught in the sack with underage prostitutes, why are we surprised at the same sorts of things here?
I'm not sure who is surprised.

I've been attempting to stay out of the thread because I really don't want to get in trouble somehow for talking about these things, but I'm still reading. And what I'm reading is driving me a little bit crazy.
Perhaps the issues are too upsetting. I'm NOT patronizing you. I avoid a lot of things that bother me. This doesn't. Not in the least.

My niece was raped and the authorities decide for various reasons that the case was problematic and decided not to prosecute. It devastated my niece, my sister and her family. I was outraged for a long time. If for one moment I thought any of this was about condoning or covering up sexual assault of any kind I'd go balistic.

I take women's rights seriously and I think this is a great opportunity to vet the various opinions about these kinds of incidents. What bothers me is when people only see this in a narrow POV on either side.
 
Interesting. The only problem I have is that I'm not certain which I'm skeptical of more, his observations and confirmation bias or mine?

It's called the human conditions. Some people see the bad. Some the good. Some are skeptical of their own bias.

I'm not sure who is surprised.

Perhaps the issues are too upsetting. I'm NOT patronizing you. I avoid a lot of things that bother me. This doesn't. Not in the least.

My niece was raped and the authorities decide for various reasons that the case was problematic and decided not to prosecute. It devastated my niece, my sister and her family. I was outraged for a long time. If for one moment I thought any of this was about condoning or covering up sexual assault of any kind I'd go balistic.

I take women's rights seriously and I think this is a great opportunity to vet the various opinions about these kinds of incidents. What bothers me is when people only see this in a narrow POV on either side.

I'm a bit confused. I don't really find the discussion upsetting. I don't know where you got that. Or maybe I'm reading you wrong?
 
Derek Bartholomaus recently made an interesting post wherein he said that, by his observations, the skeptical world has a tendency to close ranks and hide bad things that happen because our public image is already rather negative. I think this is, to some extent, true.

For instance, apparently the least believable thing I've mentioned in regards to sexism is the skeptical leader who refused to hire women, and yet I've given pretty equal amounts of evidence for all the incidents I've pointed out. Why is that?

As for the guy with the getting women drunk thing - a couple of things are being ignored there as well. In addition to the alcohol issue, what I said was that the guy lies about extremely important things. I can't say what those are without coughing up the identity.

It's not just issues of sexism, either. There are plenty of things about plenty of people in the skeptical movement that would totally blow minds. I just don't see why that's surprising. If we aren't surprised when politicians are caught in the sack with underage prostitutes, why are we surprised at the same sorts of things here?

I've been attempting to stay out of the thread because I really don't want to get in trouble somehow for talking about these things, but I'm still reading. And what I'm reading is driving me a little bit crazy.
So you are saying someone acted outrageously and you can't comment lest they be exposed?

If things are so bad, why would anyone be protecting secrets?
 
So you are saying someone acted outrageously and you can't comment lest they be exposed?

If things are so bad, why would anyone be protecting secrets?

I don't mean to paint it as an Everyone's Evil And There Is A Conspiracy type of thing. Everyone isn't evil. There isn't a conspiracy that I'm aware of. There are, simply, people who do bad things and then try to cover their asses. Much the same as anywhere.

My original point was that the skeptical world is no less sexist than any other world.
 
Derek Bartholomaus recently made an interesting post wherein he said that, by his observations, the skeptical world has a tendency to close ranks and hide bad things that happen because our public image is already rather negative. I think this is, to some extent, true.
I agree that they close ranks. I'm not sure if it's because of image or just the natural tendency of groups to close ranks.

For instance, apparently the least believable thing I've mentioned in regards to sexism is the skeptical leader who refused to hire women, and yet I've given pretty equal amounts of evidence for all the incidents I've pointed out. Why is that?
I speak for nobody but myself:

* I find at hard to imagine people who would follow such a leader these days, especially since it's clearly illegal. I personally wouldn't want to be involved in testifying in a lawsuit, so I'd try to steer clear.

* I find it hard to imagine a leader would be so stupid as to utter those words in front of you.

* If such hiring practices are actually carried out (you didn't mention if they were), it should be obvious to spot. I would expect skeptics to notice and somebody to blog about it since it's a hot button.

I don't know you from Eve, so I mean nothing personal when I say that this is the least believable statement. As a skeptic I can only give it so much weight, especially considering the lack of details. I don't dismiss it, and if it's as you say, I would have very serious issues with it.

Meanwhile, I''d fully expect in a convention of 1,000+ people that there would be an ******* who would do something like the tongue or camera things. I've seen those done. For me personally, that falls under the, "I'd expect one such person every year" category.

Does that help?

As for the guy with the getting women drunk thing - a couple of things are being ignored there as well. In addition to the alcohol issue, what I said was that the guy lies about extremely important things. I can't say what those are without coughing up the identity.
Why is that important? I expect it. People lie all the time when trying to hook up with other people. It's a meme on dating sites. It's a cliche on TV sitcoms. Why do you think this adds more to the story?

It's not just issues of sexism, either. There are plenty of things about plenty of people in the skeptical movement that would totally blow minds. I just don't see why that's surprising. If we aren't surprised when politicians are caught in the sack with underage prostitutes, why are we surprised at the same sorts of things here?
That's what I'm interested in finding out. In my mind skeptics aren't special. I would expect a similar distribution of negative and positive characteristics at skeptic events as I would at any other event. Well, I take that back. I think the Skepchicks emphasis on sex makes it more appealing for people into that kind of stuff or viewing it as a more sexually free event. It's not like ScrapBookerChicks sells "Would I be creating a memory if I **** in your face?" buttons.

I've been attempting to stay out of the thread because I really don't want to get in trouble somehow for talking about these things, but I'm still reading. And what I'm reading is driving me a little bit crazy.
That's fair.
 
I haven't gotten past the first page of the thread, but I wanted to point out that collecting anecdotes as data points inherently introduces confirmation bias. You may easily hear from many who were indecently propositioned in an elevator but few of those who pushed the button and got off without incident.
 
I agree that they close ranks. I'm not sure if it's because of image or just the natural tendency of groups to close ranks.


I speak for nobody but myself:

* I find at hard to imagine people who would follow such a leader these days, especially since it's clearly illegal. I personally wouldn't want to be involved in testifying in a lawsuit, so I'd try to steer clear.

* I find it hard to imagine a leader would be so stupid as to utter those words in front of you.

* If such hiring practices are actually carried out (you didn't mention if they were), it should be obvious to spot. I would expect skeptics to notice and somebody to blog about it since it's a hot button.

I don't know you from Eve, so I mean nothing personal when I say that this is the least believable statement. As a skeptic I can only give it so much weight, especially considering the lack of details. I don't dismiss it, and if it's as you say, I would have very serious issues with it.

Meanwhile, I''d fully expect in a convention of 1,000+ people that there would be an ******* who would do something like the tongue or camera things. I've seen those done. For me personally, that falls under the, "I'd expect one such person every year" category.

Does that help?


Why is that important? I expect it. People lie all the time when trying to hook up with other people. It's a meme on dating sites. It's a cliche on TV sitcoms. Why do you think this adds more to the story?


That's what I'm interested in finding out. In my mind skeptics aren't special. I would expect a similar distribution of negative and positive characteristics at skeptic events as I would at any other event. Well, I take that back. I think the Skepchicks emphasis on sex makes it more appealing for people into that kind of stuff or viewing it as a more sexually free event. It's not like ScrapBookerChicks sells "Would I be creating a memory if I **** in your face?" buttons.


That's fair.

I honestly cannot speak any more on the hiring one. Sorry.

And in the other case, I'm not talking about lies like, "I can bench press hundreds of pounds!" I'm talking about lies like, "No, I don't have gonorrhea."

Please note the word 'like'.
 
I honestly cannot speak any more on the hiring one. Sorry.
No need to apologize. You shared what you felt comfortable sharing. It hasn't been dismissed (at least by me).

And in the other case, I'm not talking about lies like, "I can bench press hundreds of pounds!" I'm talking about lies like, "No, I don't have gonorrhea."

Please note the word 'like'.
Honestly, I'm getting a bit confused about this story. The "like" seems to be implying that he had relations with the woman. My initial impression was that he attempted to steer them to his room but nothing happened. Can you please clarify?
 
No need to apologize. You shared what you felt comfortable sharing. It hasn't been dismissed (at least by me).


Honestly, I'm getting a bit confused about this story. The "like" seems to be implying that he had relations with the woman. My initial impression was that he attempted to steer them to his room but nothing happened. Can you please clarify?

I thought I'd mentioned that he has done this dozens of times, and mentioned that it culminated in sex.

I'm once again heading into territory I shouldn't.
 
I don't mean to paint it as an Everyone's Evil And There Is A Conspiracy type of thing. Everyone isn't evil. There isn't a conspiracy that I'm aware of. There are, simply, people who do bad things and then try to cover their asses. Much the same as anywhere.

My original point was that the skeptical world is no less sexist than any other world.

Just as a wild guess, I would guess that it's probably less sexist than the worlds of professional sports, FLDS, or radical feminism. It might be more sexist than the worlds of real estate sales, or the Quakers. But maybe not.

Still, to me the question is whether the world is sexist enough, beyond a certain threshold, to warrant the things that have been said about what the sexism does, let alone the use of the idea that it is responsible for keeping women away. I think that this thread was an attempt to gather some pilot evidence to see if that was plausible, and I don't see that it has.
 
I thought I'd mentioned that he has done this dozens of times, and mentioned that it culminated in sex.

I'm once again heading into territory I shouldn't.

The guy sounds like an ass, no doubt about it. I'm just not seeing how this is sexism.
 
Sounds to me like this person just might be way more than an ass.

The legal definition of sexual assault ("rape") in Las Vegas, Nevada under NRS 200.366 is when a person "subjects another person to sexual penetration, or who forces another person to make a sexual penetration on himself or herself or another, or on a beast, against the will of the victim or under conditions in which the perpetrator knows or should know that the victim is mentally or physically incapable of resisting or understanding the nature of his or her conduct."

"Mentally or physically incapable of resisting" includes being really drunk, or passed out from drinking.
 
Sounds to me like this person just might be way more than an ass.

The legal definition of sexual assault ("rape") in Las Vegas, Nevada under NRS 200.366 is when a person "subjects another person to sexual penetration, or who forces another person to make a sexual penetration on himself or herself or another, or on a beast, against the will of the victim or under conditions in which the perpetrator knows or should know that the victim is mentally or physically incapable of resisting or understanding the nature of his or her conduct."

"Mentally or physically incapable of resisting" includes being really drunk, or passed out from drinking.

You're adding conjecture to hearsay. Baseless conjecture, I should note, since the women were apparently capable of getting back to the room and the implication about the "significant lies" is that sex was being discussed.
 
A good example of sexism in the skeptical community - We had a member here who was a classic male chauvinist pig, Uncayimmy, once he knew a member was female his posting style would become even more aggressive and condescending; so when he knew it was a female poster that had him on the ropes when he couldn't (as often happened) support his ludicrous claims he would try to patronize them, intimidate them and so on. Now granted he tried to bully anyone who dared to disagree with him but when it was a female he just totally lost it.
 
I'm not conjecturing anything. This is an educational forum, and I am attempting to add some information that all people might not know. If there are men around that think getting a woman snockered or high is a good way to get her into your room in order to have sex with her, they might want to rethink that plan. Depending on the circumstances, which only a court of law will decide, it could just land you a Category A Felony conviction and a life sentence.

More info here:
http://www.shouselaw.com/nevada/sexual-assault.html
http://www.crisiscallcenter.org/sexualassault_nl.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom