EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

It's a Rorschach test. What we see of each other's views are often a reverse mirror view of our own deep seated emotions.

If an RW contraian observes that RW's response lacks nuance, is presumptive and contains fallacy her defendors hear all the hateful and vial crap the loonies spew.
This doesn't seem to be true. Rather, some RW contrarians have made such subtle and accurate observations while others have used name calling like 'attention whore' and exaggeration of her request.
If an RW defender says that sex, intimacy and seduction are all cool but we need to raise the awareness of men that women are often made uncomfortable by thoughtless and/or unnecassary vulgarity or assumptions about women then the contrarians hear fascist calls for prohibitons against intimacy and seduction by a fringe element of the left.
I haven't heard any calls for prohibitions against intimacy or seduction by even the fringiest of the RW supporters on other sites. That people are responding as though they have is interesting and a good point, but isn't an answer to my question. Why does 'sexist' or 'misogynist' spark so much more controversy than insults like 'attention whore' or 'hypocrite' do?
There are serious logical errors and hateful rhetoric on both sides. There is moderate and reasoned argument and points on both sides. Many want to focus more on the fringe and ignore the more moderate and reasoned views and argument.

At least that's the way I see it.

This I can agree with.
 
This doesn't seem to be true. Rather, some RW contrarians have made such subtle and accurate observations while others have used name calling like 'attention whore' and exaggeration of her request.
Sure seems to me that it is true, hmmmm....

I haven't heard any calls for prohibitions against intimacy or seduction by even the fringiest of the RW supporters on other sites.
There is in fact people on this forum calling for the end of all such activity during skeptical events.

That people are responding as though they have is interesting and a good point, but isn't an answer to my question. Why does 'sexist' or 'misogynist' spark so much more controversy than insults like 'attention whore' or 'hypocrite' do?
I can only give you my honest opinion. The choice to accept it, reject it or consider that it is possible is up to you. If you ask for an opinion and one is given, you don't have to accept it. However it is, IMHO, poor form to claim that your question wasn't awnswered.

This I can agree with.
:) Cool, thanks.
 
I can't speak for SG but I would say that their is a difference between "appropriate expressions" of sexual interest and "inappropriate expressions". The problem is that there is a lot of gray area and often due to significant differences of view point the twain very often do meet. While I find the actions of EG sketchy I don't find them per se innapropriate.

What would fall under inappropriate for you? Would it have been 'inappropriate' if EG had not been euphamistic about his proposition? Or would that also have been 'sketchy, but not per se inappropriate'? In other words, where do you draw the line?

I wouldn't have found his request inappropriate had he made it before they got on the elevator or after it had reached the first stop. For me, the fact that he did so in a closed elevator was a big deal and the main reason I found it inappropriate.
 
There is in fact people on this forum calling for the end of all such activity during skeptical events.
That's not exactly the same thing is it?
I can only give you my honest opinion. The choice to accept it, reject it or consider that it is possible is up to you. If you ask for an opinion and one is given, you don't have to accept it. However it is, IMHO, poor form to claim that your question wasn't awnswered.
Poor form or not, I do it all the time. People often don't answer the question that was asked, usually without even realizing it. I don't see how the answer you gave applied to the question I asked. It seemed a non-sequitor to me.
 
What would fall under inappropriate for you?
That's the problem. There is no bright and shinny line. All I can give you are extremes. "Hey sweet ****, want to go back to my room and ****?

Would it have been 'inappropriate' if EG had not been euphamistic about his proposition?
Presumptious and precisely the problem I'm talking about. Apparently you can only view this in a singular light, or I am missreading you. If so I appologize but you will need to clean it up. Though I suspect that whatever your purpose, I've already answered.

Or would that also have been 'sketchy, but not per se inappropriate'? In other words, where do you draw the line?
I think my words in the post you quote clearly indicate a dilleniation. The problem isn't if there are things that are innapropriate but that there are so many view points and variables.

I wouldn't have found his request inappropriate had he made it before they got on the elevator or after it had reached the first stop. For me, the fact that he did so in a closed elevator was a big deal and the main reason I found it inappropriate.
I understand that argument. Other people disagree with you and say anything after RW excused herself would have been inapropriate. I understand those arguments also. I don't dismiss them out of hand. I'm just not sure how compelling they are. Further I don't think my view point ultimately matters. The dialectic will push the zietgeist. Perhaps imperceptably but it will change. Perhaps in ways we can't imagine.
 
That's not exactly the same thing is it?
I find it remarkable and disturbing. But I understand your need to view it in that light. In any event, suggesting that every person in every microcosm is fatuous. I'm more concerned with this paricular call for prohibition.

Poor form or not, I do it all the time. People often don't answer the question that was asked...
I did.

usually without even realizing it.
No misscomprehension on my part.

I don't see how the answer you gave applied to the question I asked.
I do. Abundantly so.

It seemed a non-sequitor to me.
In what way?
 
I understand that argument. Other people disagree with you and say anything after RW excused herself would have been inapropriate. I understand those arguments also. I don't dismiss them out of hand. I'm just not sure how compelling they are. Further I don't think my view point ultimately matters. The dialectic will push the zietgeist. Perhaps imperceptably but it will change. Perhaps in ways we can't imagine.

I understand those arguments as well, they simply don't strike me as nearly as compelling as the place he chose to make his proposition. I agree with you that the dialectic will push the zietgeist and I'm certain it will happen in ways we can't imagine. This isn't a situation that either of us are likely to be in, but expressing our opinions is the way we contribute to the dialectic.
 
I understand those arguments as well, they simply don't strike me as nearly as compelling as the place he chose to make his proposition.
Understood. There is no objective absolute answer here. This is where our understanding of epistimology can help inform our decisions and to be skeptical of our bias.

I agree with you that the dialectic will push the zietgeist and I'm certain it will happen in ways we can't imagine. This isn't a situation that either of us are likely to be in, but expressing our opinions is the way we contribute to the dialectic.
Agreed completely. :)
 
I find it remarkable and disturbing. But I understand your need to view it in that light. In any event, suggesting that every person in every microcosm is fatuous. I'm more concerned with this paricular call for prohibition.
I can understand your concern, but the people involved in any event of that sort have a right to discuss and choose what rules they think are appropriate for that event. I may not agree with such a prohibition, but there are other places where such prohibitions are in effect. That's why I see the call to prohibit such behavior altogether very different than a call to prohibit such behavior in a limited way.
I did.
No misscomprehension on my part.

I do. Abundantly so.

In what way?

I asked:Why does 'sexist' or 'misogynist' spark so much more controversy than insults like 'attention whore' or 'hypocrite' do?

You replied:
It's a Rorschach test. What we see of each other's views are often a reverse mirror view of our own deep seated emotions.

What does a Rorschach test have to do with why there is such a difference in the response to people using those terms?
 
Why does 'sexist' or 'misogynist' spark so much more controversy than insults like 'attention whore' or 'hypocrite' do? It seems to me that the latter are much more hurtful, but a great deal of the 'elevatorgate' phenomenon has been arguments over such terminology.
For the same reason the 'N' word does. Insults that are based on a class of people are seen that way. Individualized insults are describing an action the person may have displayed. Sexism and misogyny are never deserved. Sometimes people are hypocrites and attention whores. Maybe attention whore isn't the nicest way to put it, and clearly sometimes the insults are intended to be hurtful and/or not deserved. Upon rereading this, my answer is confusing and inaccurate.

Let me try again. In this specific case, the reaction to the insults is most likely based on whether the person commenting perceives the insult to be true or false.

I think that WTBS has a valid concern in that the apparent acceptance of that behavior is a systemic problem within our community. I'm not sure what, if anything, should be changed. In general, I feel the membership agreement covers such behavior, but as you mentioned, moderation is not an easy job. My personal solution has been to place anyone who I find annoying in that way on ignore and to stay out of the politics subforum, but that isn't an optimum solution by any means.
Everyone has a different level of tolerance and a different expectation of acceptable behavior. It's not possible to have a perfect forum.

Phil prohibited most discussion of politics and religion on the BA forum when he started it. And when he merged the forum with the UT forum the rule remained. All discord was banned and the discussions are rigidly policed. So the BAUT is always a polite forum to be on. But the drawback is, there are important topics one cannot discuss there. I really wanted to talk about the science of communication, but it was impossible without including political propaganda along with the other areas where people are influenced by how things are purposefully misstated. It was not a topic the mods would allow despite the fact we talked about Creationism and global warming that skirted religion and politics on the forum all the time.

OTOH, there are times when this forum is extremely unpleasant. I've had to make myself not be bothered by certain people here. But now, it's easier. I use ignore sparingly, but I ignore people more often than I use the feature. And I also try to be nicer myself. I think I have made progress in that respect. But I'll never be as nice as you are, Beth, or as nice as people who value being nice more than I do. I value being frank more than being nice. I try for a balance, but I'm not that good at it. I appreciate people like you, however. I'm not trying to say I don't value being nice at all. I'm just saying I'm a tad down the continuum from you.


....I agree that the bashing of women who disagree with the feminist position has been quite ridiculous on some sites.
I believe this is why I've been so interested in this discussion. I feel my position which is very much pro-women's lib is being called anti-feminist. Of course there are aspects of the feminism position being vocalized in this debate that I don't think are pro-women either. ... Oh well.


....Have you read the 'there was a woman speaker on an elevator' thread here? Plenty of RW bashing going on there. A great deal of it would be reported and actionable if RW was still a member. Whether or not the bashing is equal on both sides, I can't say. Different sites have majorities going to different groups.
If some of the comments were a direct reply to someone, they would have a different connotation. It's like the difference between gossiping about a person and insulting them directly. The difference is subtle, but I can see the mods interpreting the posts differently as the circumstances of the comments are different.

Perhaps if that is how you see some of the comments, however, I'll try to be more careful about what I post, though I think I have been for the most part.


Has that actually been called misogynistic? I suspect that it has more to do with the way the sentiment was expressed rather than the sentiment itself being considered misogynistic. To be honest, if that's what you have been trying to communicate, it hasn't come across. I'm sorry, but that is how your view is coming across to me as well. It may be an unfair criticism, but you have failed to distinguish between how your view differs from telling women to 'take it' without complaint.
I understand people don't get what I'm saying. That's not surprising. And I'm pretty sure listening to RW ignore the key issue when she reviews and rationalizes her own comments, that she doesn't get what it is people are complaining about with her comments. I think she sees a different intent than is read in her comments.

It has to do with underlying premises. I do not perceive EG was doing anything more than telling RW he was interested in getting to know her better, and I don't perceive an elevator in a 5 star hotel in "a foreign country" at 4am as less safe than the same elevator at 2pm, or the bar at 4am. If I say so, I'm not "incredibly dismissive of my [RW's] experience and that of other women in this community, and so uneducated about the fundamentals of feminist thought."

But as RW's words indicate, she didn't hear the message, "I don't see things your way". She heard the message, "My experience is being dismissed".

Just as you aren't likely hearing the message, "There's no evidence that elevator is unsafe as is being portrayed. It hurts women to echo this false belief. It makes women fear things they need not fear." You hear, "I'm dismissing women's feelings (or whatever)."

And you don't hear, "EG's behavior was not different from any other sexual interest comment." You hear, "I'm telling women to suck it up." I would not be telling a woman to suck it up if the behavior of EG was rude or really was what RW claimed it was.


It's a tricky conundrum here. Can one truly disagree with how a person perceives a situation and say so without dismissing their experience? You are a practicing nice guy, you tell me, how can one say there is no evidence here supporting RW's beliefs without RW hearing something else? If RW were open to the concept she did make unsupported assumptions about the incident, she wouldn't necessarily hear the different viewpoint as a personal affront. (And BTW, it's been said repeatedly RW's individual reaction is not the issue. It's only the underlying factual assumptions most of us are addressing.)



Here's the message RW gave Rose St Clair and Steph McGraf who after seeing RW's first video commented in the blogosphere that they did not view RW being so vulnerable in the elevator.
RW said:
"I was pretty frustrated, seeing a young woman who I’m sure is intelligent be so incredibly dismissive of my experience and that of other women in this community, and so uneducated about the fundamentals of feminist thought. She ends the video by asking, “What effect do you think it has on men to be constantly told how sexist and destructive they are?”...

When I was discussing the video with friends the next day, I was blown away to be told that there were other student leaders who had expressed similar dismissive attitudes recently on Facebook and on other blogs. An hour or so prior to my talk, someone sent me this link to a post by Stef McGraw on the UNI Freethinkers site. I added a paragraph of that response to a slide for the intro to my talk, in which I hoped to call out the anti-woman rhetoric my audience was engaging in....

I hear a lot of misogyny from skeptics and atheists, but when ancient anti-woman rhetoric like the above is repeated verbatim by a young woman online, it validates that misogyny in a way that goes above and beyond the validation those men get from one another. It also negatively affects the women who are nervous about being in similar situations. Some of them have been raped or otherwise sexually assaulted, and some just don’t want to be put in that position. And they read these posts and watch these videos and they think, “If something were to happen to me and these women won’t stand up for me, who will?”




I think WTBS's point is that Rebecca is 'punished' for having made her statement by being called names like 'attention whore', told that she shouldn't be uncomfortable in that situation, told she should consider it a compliment, told that such encounters are to be expected when leaving a hotel bar at 4 am, etc. OTOH, if she hadn't been wary in that situation (i.e. uncomfortable because of the vulnerability of the situation), if she had been attacked in the elevator or worse, accepted the invitation believing he was sincere about 'coffee' and been attacked there, she would have been similarly 'punished' - i.e. told that such encounters are to be expected when leaving a hotel bar at 4 am., told she was naive to think that he just wanted to talk when he invited her to his room, etc.
Mostly straw men. This is the same way RW portrays herself. But those comments all came after much much more than RW merely making her initial statement and the only comments directly following RW's first video blog addressed only the different perception of the incident as described.

Here's what McGraf said:
It's possible the man actually just wanted to talk and do nothing more, but I'll even give that point to her; I obviously wasn't there, and don't know what sort of vibes he was giving off. Fair enough. My concern is that she takes issue with a man showing interest in her. What's wrong with that? How on earth does that justify him as creepy? Are we not sexual beings? Let's review, it's not as if he touched her or made an unsolicited sexual comment; he merely asked if she'd like to come back to his room. She easily could have said (and I'm assuming did say), "No thanks, I'm tired and would like to go to my room to sleep."

Watson is upset that this man is sexualizing her just after she gave a talk relating to feminism, but my question is this: Since when are respecting women as equals and showing sexual interest mutually exclusive? Is it not possible to view to take interest in a woman AND see her as an intelligent person?

Someone who truly abides by feminist principles would, in my view, have to react in the same manner were the situation reversed; if a woman were to engage a man in the same way, she would probably be creeping him out and making him uncomfortable and unfairly sexualizing him, right? But of course no one ever makes that claim, which is why I see Watson's comment as so hypocritical.
That isn't telling anyone to "suck it up". Neither are McGraf's comments misogynist. Misogyny is a ludicrous conclusion on RW's part about McGraf's comments.



I'm putting the rest in a separate post.
 
Last edited:
When in danger, when in doubt. Run in circles, scream and shout. Ya-hey!
 
Now that you have several examples, what is your opinion? Do you think sexism is a problem in the skeptical/atheist community? Do you think that the behavior that has been described is an influential factor in women deciding where or not to be active in that community?

I would like to point out that your #4 is a more serious issue since the behavior of leaders and those in positions of authority set the standards of acceptable behavior. RD's comment that aroused such ire was, IMO, due as much to his status in the community as his words. Many others have written equally egregious comments or worse (though few have his talent with words) but that did not cause the same furor.
I hesitate to quantify the sexism given the wolves that are lying in wait to pounce the minute I start drawing unsupported conclusions. ;)

So let me say up front, this is merely a descriptive pilot study and should only serve as a direction for further action, not as some definitive data base. But that said, I think this request for evidence has collected a lot of useful information.


Clearly more has been described here that involves individuals' behavior and individuals' reactions than incidents involving the community as a whole. #1 and #2 don't strike me as being as bad as some people feel it is. It would depend on who you were and which events you attended.

A couple of individuals acting like idiots within a large group of people is pretty hard to prevent. I don't think there is any question such individuals should be addressed, nor do I think the organizers of our events typically need to be asked to do so. One merely need draw attention to said behavior problem at said event.

Some people are interested in meeting others, some have complained they don't want anyone expressing interest in them. What do you do with that? I've already said, it is unfair to ask those interested to stop and it is unfair to ask those interested or not interested to wear some kind of advertisement to that effect. I think saying, "Guys, don't do that" was a misplaced gesture. It applied to RW. Clearly the request could not be applied to everyone universally despite some people's expectation that we all believe it was obviously bad behavior on EG's part, or we are misogynists.


There were a couple examples of #3 cited. Can anyone really say the reports were rampant? Were the couple incidents indicative of some widespread problem? At this point I cannot say the conclusion was supported that sexism is a big problem in our community. No one has said it was going to be completely absent. And it should be addressed when it occurs.

It's my suggestion that we address the #3 problem by bringing such incidents to the attention of the community at the time the incidents occur. That would provide a better measure of the frequency, and it would serve to make people more aware of the behavior at the time it occurs. I think most people, with the exception of the few recalcitrant obnoxious individuals any community this size is bound to attract, would be amenable to change their behavior when it is pointed out.


As for #4, yes, of course such a situation is the most harmful. The case reported was a he said she said complaint. If other women working with the same supervisor confirmed the behavior, he should be let go. But the evidence was equivocal, so someone else would have to also have experienced the same sexism by the supervisor.
 
Last edited:
I can understand your concern, but the people involved in any event of that sort have a right to discuss and choose what rules they think are appropriate for that event.
My position is and always has been that everyone involved is entitled to an opinion. I'm not sure who ultimately "chooses" or if such a prohibition is even practical but that's entirely beside the point. As a respecter of the dialectic and lover of free speech I would accept any movement in our shared consciousness. If that included viewing intimate social contact at skeptical meetings as verboten then that would trouble me. However, the social contract is what it is. It's certainly not static and it tends to correct errors. At the end of the day I have my opinion and freedom of speech.

I may not agree with such a prohibition, but there are other places where such prohibitions are in effect. That's why I see the call to prohibit such behavior altogether very different than a call to prohibit such behavior in a limited way.
Not sure how you are delineating.

What does a Rorschach test have to do with why there is such a difference in the response to people using those terms?
I apologize if I'm patronizing but do you know what a Rorschach test is?

It's purpose isn't simply a diagnostic. I suspect that is where you are making your mistake. The test is meant to be evocative, to bring out deep seated emotions and bias (I'm skeptical of the official test but its purported mechanism and purpose serves as a wonderful metaphor).

Okay, so here is why this incident is like a Rorschach test.

If your view is that the boorish behaviors of men (and perhaps some women) are indicative of pernicious and prevailing patriarchy. If your view is that this behavior is just the tip of an iceberg that is doing much to hurt women. That most men are oblivious to these facts because in large part they benefit from the patriarchy. That there needs be some major social change to agitate and shake loose the blinders of men so that we as a society can move on. If any of these views are yours then those views will be magnified by this event bringing the emotion that lies below to the surface.

If your view is anti-authoritarian, stemming from a kind of 1984 dystopic fear, if your view is that any systemic attempt to change behavior through social stigma of behavior or peer pressure will cause far more harm to the cause than it could possibly justify with good (and that view is not without precedent) then this incident will magnify those feelings and you will expose them.

Neither of these two views are wrong. The problem is that they cause us to speak past each other and escalate the rhetoric and invective to get the other side to finally see our point of view (the current discussion throughout the community being exhibit #1). And why not, our POV is correct. Why wouldn't it be? We are the skeptics. We are the critical thinkers. It's the other side that doesn't get it. We just need to get it through their thick skulls.
 
Last edited:
This doesn't seem to be true. Rather, some RW contrarians have made such subtle and accurate observations while others have used name calling like 'attention whore' and exaggeration of her request.
Again, consider the timing of the comments you are referring to, and consider all the things RW said/did in between the first video and the comments.

I haven't heard any calls for prohibitions against intimacy or seduction by even the fringiest of the RW supporters on other sites.
Then you haven't been listening. And, there are also a lot of claims they don't mean that, but then the commenter goes on to say they do mean it.

The bulk of the comments are the latter. Where the problem comes in is when the person tries to describe what is OK and what isn't, in their opinion. There are vague criteria that are not even universally applied by the commenter, let alone universally agreed on.
 
That sounds pretty simple and to the point. However, when you respond..
....
..for example, one might wonder if you have more criteria than what you stated above. It appears you are attempting to validate or invalidate examples based on some standard or definition of "sexist" which you have not defined or declared up front, or on some standard or definition of "what constitutes good evidence of sexism" which you have not defined or declared up front.

This thread is more than a simple request for data.
Your presumptions of me and the thread are wrong, but that's your prerogative. I made it very clear what my perception was of the issue at the beginning. That doesn't mean I can't be objective or wasn't interested in refuting my perception as equally as I was interested in confirming it.


But you've also stated you have your own hypothesis.
That is what you do in research.


So let's recap, you are not JUST looking for examples of sexism in the community that might explain the gender imbalace. You've hypothesized that there is less sexism in this community than in society at large.

Do you not see that there is an obvious conflict here? You are trying to do two different and conflicting things. While stating you want to accumulate data about sexism in the community, while at the same time expecting there to be less than average sexism in the community, you risk self-fulfilling your own expectations.
What I see is your presumption that having an hypothesis one sets out to test means the researcher automatically lacks objectivity. That is a false presumption.

I'd like to point out as well, that I looked for documented incidents in blog comments and posted those in the thread myself.


Since when has "universally judged to be sexist" been a criteria for what is or isn't sexist?

And why would it be logical or rational to assume that since there is debate regarding the "sexisminess", (for lack of a better word), of a singular incident by an single individual that one should question reliability of other people's accounts?

You said yourself, Why should the debate surrounding RW's statements make PZ's statements any more or less reliable?
Some people agree with RW and some people think EG's comments were mere interest, probably sexual, but not sex only or the objectification RW claims she is certain of.

What do you do with that? Call it sexism when there is no agreement it is?


You've already stated that this thread IS out to determine if there is a causal relationship between sexism and gender imbalance, so it's really hard to backtrack and get your method right now.
Really? Are you sure about that?
the OP said:
OK so on to the purpose of the thread. Apparently we have more white males than females or minorities at our conferences and other events. Locally, I'm not sure that's true, but it is at least true for speakers at the larger venues. I see no evidence that a cause for this imbalance has been established by an analysis of the evidence. The claim has been made that sexism at these events contributes to the imbalance. I can only see that is an assumption which has not been established as a fact.

Disclaimer: I'm skeptical and hypothesize other reasons for the imbalance. I think some of our female members have let their other interests in feminism causes bleed over into their views at the skeptic/atheist/freethinker events. This conflating of causes seems to me to be un-skeptically influencing some people's perceptions.

We all have our blind spots and pre-existing tunnels we see the world through. I am no exception. So I'm not looking to fault anyone for their unsupported assumptions. But I do want to look for evidence of the sexism-is-hurting-us hypothesis before I reject it based on my own experiences and underlying assumptions.


This thread is requesting specific anecdotes (yes, anecdotes sometimes are evidence) that support or refute the hypothesis that sexism is a problem within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities beyond a handful of random individual incidents.

Have members witnessed sexist comments about event speakers?
Do members know of sexist incidents at meetings or events where the men's behaviors bothered or could have bothered women there?
Do you have alternative hypotheses for the gender imbalance within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities or evidence there is not much of a gender imbalance in your local group?

Is the sexism real specifically within the skeptic/atheist/freethinker communities or is it an imaginary boogyman created out of unsupported assumptions and misinterpretations of benign incidents? Is this really an issue about our community, or is it just an issue about men in general? Or was this always about men in general and never about our community?
I'm afraid you are confusing the explanatory background information with the stated goal of the thread. You can't get to the causal association without first establishing if the thing you believe is the cause actually exists. It has been established that the gender imbalance exists. If you want to test if sexism is one cause, you first have to establish the fact sexism is present.


I think it's great that you've realized that before you can analyze something you have to figure out how to define it and then how to measure it. I think this thread is pretty much a lost cause though. You've got a whole lot of people measuring a whole lot of different things based on their own interpretations of someone else's one sided stories. And by having that whole lot of people analyzing whatever the hell they want to analyze and declaring whatever the hell they want to declare about it, you've inadvertantly created a situation where people that do have evidence might be unwilling to put it forth, because they don't want this same treatment. In other words, you've unintentionally skewed the investigation in order to "prove" your hypothesis.

What's really screwy is that by doing so you might also have unintentionally influenced the thing you are trying to study so as to add numbers to the "how many women have seen examples of sexism within the community and choose not to attend events because of it" group. Is it possible that just reading this thread might lead a woman to choose not to go to TAM? I don't know, but I think it is possible.
Whatever. :rolleyes:



As far as the quantifying and defining go, I personally think that if sexism is a problem in society at large, and/or if sexism is a problem within the science, academic, or philosophical communities, (the circles from which many of our members come), then it is no big stretch to think that sexism is probably a problem in our own community, too, and probably at about the same rate. How one scientifically quantifies it, I do not know. Though I think anonymous well worded polls sent to all women within given communities, then comparing the answers might be some kind of a start. Whether one is able to quantify it by asking questions on one open internet forum? I doubt very much that anyone would take those results very seriously as some kind of actual research.
If you think there are other ways to collect the data, be my guest, the more data the merrier.


Since sexism is a social issue of treatment of an individual based on a social construct of gender stereotypes, I doubt anyone can define it into some kind of short, pithy statement that everyone can understand, let alone agree upon. Every individual is different, obviously, and every individual has absorbed the teachings and attitudes of a myriad of people in the making up of the gender and social stereotypes they hold in their own head.

Sexism can be as subtle and insidious that even a well respected and renowned feminist might unconciously harbor for example, the sexist notion that women don't know how to fix cars, so without even thinking about it, she automatically asks her coworker Tom to help her diagnose her problem, when in reality Mary, who enjoys working on cars and has been doing it her whole life, would be a much better choice.

Or it can be as blatant and obvious and repugnant as a man who thinks that if a woman is walking alone at night that she must be a whore, and he therefore has the right to assault her.

In one example there is essentially no "harm" done, especially if Mary doesn't even know that she asked Tom for help with her car rather than herself. No harm, no foul, as they say. But it's still sexist. In the other example grievous bodily harm and legal charges might result.

So good luck trying to define it. I really mean that.
So you agree then? One of the problems brought up in the elevator debate has been defining sexism. That's one complaint some of us have with RW insisting we should all agree with her assessment of EG. As for this thread, one reason to describe the perceived sexist incident is for the very thing you are complaining about. If you tell me you experienced sexism at an event, I don't know what that means. If you tell me Dr A stuck his tongue in your mouth, I do know what that means.


I think that's a great start at attempting to classify this. I do question the use of the word "legitimate". And I'm really not just trying to be difficult here. What's the difference between "expressing legitimate sexual interest" and "expressing sexual interest"?
Ask the RW camp. One of the complaints lodged against RW's conclusion about EG was that his actions did not stand out from standard sexual interest.

IMO, it's a continuum and the setting/context matter. "Hey baby, you need some sex" is more obvious to me than, "don't take this the wrong way".
 
Last edited:
R Watson does like attention. Wasn't she banned from this forum for stirring things up? I think this whole episode is more about her vanity then any feminist principles, but anyway.

She has certainly garnered herself some attention here. R Dawkins even weighed in.

The whole thing seems pretty silly. If sexism among atheists were as bad as she claimed, you'd think she'd be able to come up with a better example then that. And The same feminists complaining about this will also tell you that a woman has every right to do what this guy did, and that a woman should be able to go to a mans room even if she hardly knows him without being judged.

In this case a woman was propositioned (she claims) in a fairly polite way, but now she and her friends have decided that this objectified and degraded her. So some feminists are getting worked up over next to nothing, using it as an excuse to talk trash about men. This kind of thing is so insignificant and commonplace, I find it kind of bizarre that its turned into such a controversy. Yes, I know I'm only adding to it with this post, but at this point the @#$ storm is already raging anyway.
 
Since Bookitty twice ignored my request that she support her claim about what evidence has been dismissed by Skeptic Ginger, I figure I'll go through the thread and assemble the evidence. I'll also add my comments.

Blag Hag blog - She lists a bunch of one-line descriptions of things that happened, but most lack context and detail. Some were obnoxious social behaviors (like someone at a party hassling her to drink from his whiskey bottle) while others were more sexism in the skeptical community (commenting on her appearance while introducing her to the audience).
My Opinion: Can't do much evaluation without specifics and context. Some were part of the proceedings while others were clearly in the after-hours events. As a skeptic I'm just not willing to accept conclusions without more detail.

Tranewreck provided several other links to sexism in the ranks of philosophers and concedes "obviously philosophy departments aren't the exact same thing as the "skeptical movement."
My Opinion: Since it would be incorrect to cite a lack of sexism in a parallel/similar field, it is incorrect to include them here. I dismiss them. You can do whatever you want.

The blog and JREF discussion about the Skepchick bordello party[/URL] being off-putting for some women.
My Opinion: Lots of detail, and I can see how some women would find it sexist and be made uncomfortable. It was after-hours, so if you don't like that stuff, don't go. I can't see why an after-hours party would keep you away from the conference.

Skeptic Female Number 1 paints the words "Do me now" in chocolate onto the bare stomach of Skeptic Female Number 2 at Skeptic gathering.
My Opinion: Most likely after hours, so not a big deal to me. I can see how some women would find it degrading while others would find it fun.

Jennifer Ouellette talks about some Facebook friend requests that came post-skeptic conference turning out to be jerks.
My Opinion: Way after hours. It can certainly be off-putting when Facebook "friends" turn out to be creepy, but we don't have specifics on creepy, so it's not really evidence. The simple solution for all permutations of gender and sexual orientation is to be more selective about your Facebook friends. I can see how this person might feel uncomfortable going back to an event where these creeps are, but I can't see why someone would choose not to attend when all you have to do is not accept all comers as Facebook friends.

The sticking the tongue in the mouths of unsuspecting TAM attendees.
My Opinion: Should have been reported to the JREF, and he should have been banned. Extremely out of line and also criminal. I could see how this would keep women away. One guy like that is too many.

Jen McCreight spoke at an event and comments were heard about her "Boobquake" event.
My Opinion: Not enough detail to know for sure what happened. I will say that if you make your boobs the subject of a skeptical lesson, the line between appropriate and inappropriate gets pretty blurry. I wouldn't sweat any first offenses.

Guy who "goes out of his way to get women drunk, offers to walk them back wherever, and then just ushers them to his room."
My Opinion: After hours, so not a big concern. There's a ******* like that at every bar I've ever been to. Grow up and be responsible for how much you drink.

"At least one skeptical leader who "can't work with women" because said person cannot be as frank with women as men. This individual went so far as to inform their staff not to hire women."
My Opinion: No details and not confirmed. If true, a very serious problem. Not sure how much an effect that has on attendance at skeptical events. It could be a lot or none.

Buzzo's upskirt cam.
My Opinion: Should have been reported to the JREF, and he should have been banned. Extremely out of line and also criminal. I could see how this would keep women away. One guy like that is too many.

Australian skeptic Stollznow who is reported as saying "meetings and correspondence were rife with inappropriate and sexist comments about women" but the organization denies it.
My Opinion: Not enough details and no evidence. Since a pay dispute was involved, I don't know what to make of it. Not sure how this would affect attendance at skeptical events.

Nice Cans e-mail.
My Opinion: This e-mail was actually a response to an e-mail from the female skeptic, so obviously the two had some sort of relationship. Without knowing the nature of that relationship or what she wrote to him, I can't say one way or another if it was inappropriate. It's not like it was a comment on her blog.

WhatTheButlerSaw said she was sexually harassed on these forums. She says that she's expressed her lack of attraction to a member here who in turn says he's going to **** her. She equates that to threatening rape.
My Opinion: Need to see the actual exchange. Request has been made for details. The mods saw it and did not give it an infraction, so I'm questioning the connection to rape. I can see how such treatment here would affect attendance at TAM or other skeptical events.

Angry vagina workshop at TAM.
My Opinion: I could see how people would be uncomfortable with such a workshop. Even though it was optional, people would be carrying around two foot vaginas, which can be off-putting. I could see how it could keep people away.

RemieV said she had other stories to share but didn't share them.
My Opinion: I wish she would share them, but I can't express opinions on things I don't know.

I didn't read every post from start to finish, but I did my best. Most of this thread is full of posts that are not evidence at all, which I find sad.
 
Last edited:
Question regarding quantifying sexist behavior.

Question regarding quantifying sexist behavior.

If a guy shouts out a "great boobs!" comment during a speaker's presentation, and 500 women hear it, of which x percentage think it is sexist, and y percentage think "OMFSM! If this is the kind of sexist crap that goes on at these things, I am not going to attend another!" Does that count as 1 example of sexist behavior, X examples of sexist behavior, or Y examples of sexist behavior?

Even if you think because of "boobquake" that the comment might not be sexist, if some percentage of people in the audience are new to the movement, or this particular conference, or have just never heard of this speaker before, and are therefore unaware of "boobquake", if this percentage of people conclude the comment is just blatantly sexist, are they wrong?


Similarly, if BuzzCam accosts 5 women at a conference, and those instances are witnessed by X people and the stories about these events are recounted to Y people, and of all those people Z amount say "OMFSM! If this is the kind of sexist crap that goes on at these things, I am not going to attend another!" does this count as 1, 5, X, Y or Z counts of sexist behavior?
 
I'm sorry, but that is how your view is coming across to me as well. It may be an unfair criticism, but you have failed to distinguish between how your view differs from telling women to 'take it' without complaint. ....
I also addressed this here in the other thread.

If the woman has the ability to control the outcome (I have the ability to control my response, for example), then it is empowering to exercise that ability, and un-empowering to rely on the male to change the outcome by changing his behavior.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom