EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

No, I don't think she's lying. If I thought so I would have said so.

Then why the weasel words?

If he'd said 'whatever floats your boat' it wouldn't have been misogynist, would it?

Correct. The lack of a gender-specific aspect means that the saying by itself would no longer count as mysogynistic.

So it's only because he mentioned skirts? I don't think the use of a single word or phrase taken out of context like that tells us enough about anything to say it's misogynist unless you are looking for it. And frankly if you are looking for anything hard enough you'll find it. So I'm going for 'not proven' on that one.

Do you see the difference between these two phrases?

1. He tried to cheat me out of a dollar.
2. He tried to jew me out of a dollar.

Just one word is different, and both are common enough things to hear. Do I have to be "looking for it" to be offended by the second one? It's about the choice of words. It's about calling out a specific characteristic that has nothing to do with the actual point, thereby falsely linking the two. I can be condescending or accusing without being mysogynist, racist, homophobic, whatever - but once I needlessly include emphasis on one of those characteristics the connotations change.
 
Then why the weasel words?

What weasel words? I have no idea if her account is true or false, but I have no reason to think she's lying. If it's true, action should have been taken.


Correct. The lack of a gender-specific aspect means that the saying by itself would no longer count as mysogynistic

Do you see the difference between these two phrases?

1. He tried to cheat me out of a dollar.
2. He tried to jew me out of a dollar.

Just one word is different, and both are common enough things to hear. Do I have to be "looking for it" to be offended by the second one? It's about the choice of words. It's about calling out a specific characteristic that has nothing to do with the actual point, thereby falsely linking the two. I can be condescending or accusing without being mysogynist, racist, homophobic, whatever - but once I needlessly include emphasis on one of those characteristics the connotations change.

Yep, using the word Jew as a verb in a derogatory manner is probably enough context to judge. Using the word skirt as a noun.......well I'm going to need a bit more info.

Counter Example:

Person 1: Do you know if the bathroom is free?

Person 2a: No, some [N-word] is in there

Person 2b: No, there's a black dude in there

Person 2c: No, there's some guy in there

Person 2d: No, someone's in there.

I think we can safely say that 2a is being derogatory, and 2d is in the clear. Is 2b racist for unnecessarily pointing out the guy is black? Dunno...context. Is 2c sexist for pointing out the gender of the individual? Dunno...context.

On its own I'm not willing to convict someone for the single phrase highlighted. If it was a pattern of behaviour then fair enough.
 
I think we can safely say that 2a is being derogatory, and 2d is in the clear. Is 2b racist for unnecessarily pointing out the guy is black? Dunno...context. Is 2c sexist for pointing out the gender of the individual? Dunno...context.

Your counter-example is too neutral for it to apply, in my opinion. As I said before, the combination of the condescention and the superflous gender reference is what does it.

I could weigh in on your counter-example, but it wouldn't be the same thing.
 
*sigh*

The comment is now removed, because a moderator agreed with me that it was inappropriate - but there is a poster who has made a point, several times, of responding to my opinions by either threatening to **** me (since I wouldn't touch said person with a ten foot barge pole, that is in effect a threat of rape - this was the comment that was removed) or by pointing out how my, to him, perceived lack of sexual attractiveness (yes, consistency is not this person's forte) somehow renders my opinions moot. Before I put him on ignore he also insisted that I not try to pursue him, despite a complete lack of me ever doing that. Other posters' reactions to this behaviour has mainly been either back slapping or complete disinterest. This behaviour did not address my points, was clearly directed solely at what I, as a woman, in the mind of this psycho should be concerned about. I have never seen this poster threaten to **** male posters he doesn't agree with. The moderator response was only removal of the offending lines. The poster did not receive an infraction.
<snip>
It's too bad you had that experience on the JREF forum. I'm surprised that the poster didn't receive an infraction. Did you request or receive any explanation for that omission from the moderator who agreed that the comment was inappropriate? Did they believe the threat was only for effect, and not seriously meant (because if it was serious, not only should the poster be banned, he should be reported to the authorities)? How long ago was this? Maybe you should bring it up in FM.
 
It was within the context of feminism and skepticism. It was a fairly bold statement even within that context and may have been a misstep.

Like all of the extra workshops, the curriculum including crafts time was announced before TAM.

It was also presented by Watson, on a panel on Feminism and Skepticism (or was it Atheism?) as part of the regular program. See https://skepticalteacher.wordpress.com/tag/rebecca-watson/

I don't know if that was such a big deal, though I'm pretty sure that a workshop where participants constructed Angry Penes would cause a ruckus. (I think you'd have to have some of those styrofoam rods or cotton batting or something, because it's kind of hard to make a 3-D sculpture with felt and glue without it's collapsing.)

Might make some interesting elevator encounters, though.
 
Exhibit 47a
In which a male makes inappropriate sexual remarks to a female:

"Nice Cans!? FFS, Really?




Exhibit 47b
In which a male shows understanding toward the above mentioned male and explains how the woman is wrong. Inferences made that she sent mixed messages, it didn't really bother her, because if it did, she wouldn't have done it the "wrong way":


It's a mixed message to say that you don't appreciate having your bosom being referenced because it's inappropriate and then turning around and commenting on the length of the guy's penis as well as its turgidity. Furthermore, she promised to make future comments about his penis, thus continuing the banter, not stopping. Had she stopped with the blue part, her message would have been less ambiguous but still ambiguous. Larry in Three's Company was a lovable if perverted character who was a long-time friend of Janet, Chrissy, Cindy, and Terri as well as Jack's best friend . The red part sends the meta-message that the topic of sexual body parts is acceptable.

If I'm the "nice cans" guy reading that exchange and not her blog, I would not get the message that she didn't want me making comments like that again because her response seems to confirm my initial impression that she was up for it.

ETA: I want to be clear that I have no problems with her finding it inappropriate or not really being bothered by it. That's her call, and she's not putting out a "Guys, don't do that" message. My issue is that if she was truly bothered by it and if she wanted to make sure the guy knew it and if she didn't want him to do it again, she went about it the wrong way.

You can almost hear the implied, "Gals, don't do this."

Exhibit 47c

In which, after a female expresses that the above female incident was handled just fine, in her opinion, the male advises her what her problem is. She, too, apparently, just doesn't understand guys.


Ah, I see your problem. You are assuming that a guy who wants to talk about a woman's breasts would not want her to talk about his penis. I suppose that maybe there are one or two guys like that, but I can't think of any guy I know who would consider her shifting the discussion to his penis as anything other than encouragement. That's what happened in this case as evidenced by the guy talking about using a yardstick to measure his penis.



Because, you know, the problem just couldn't be as simple as "this guy behaved badly". The problem is women just don't understand. :rolleyes:
 
How many are now on this list, Skeptic Ginger? Has every example brought up in this thread been recorded? If not, why not?
Clearly they are "recorded". The examples are here for everyone to see. The request for examples to be PMed to me if one couldn't post them hasn't resulted in any additional examples.

As you chided Bookitty earlier in the thread for not understanding the scientific method, I hope you will take this opportunity to explain how you are using it in this thread.

In particular, I would like to know:
What methods, formulas, or criteria are you using to evaluate these anecdotes?
What methods are you employing to control for bias?
I have addressed this a couple times.

The criteria is, the examples need to be specific, not a general feeling. And the examples need to be specific to the skeptic/atheist communities, not just examples of sexism in the academic or scientific communities where sexism has already been established. That's it.

We started with a number of people stating they experienced sexism at formal skeptic/atheist events and the sexism was bad enough to account for some of the discrepancy in the gender imbalance in the attendance at these events.

But the initiating incident that started the conversation was not universally judged to be sexist. So it puts into question (besides other problems like selective memory) the reliability of undefined complaints of personally experiencing sexism at skeptic/atheist events.

In addition, if indeed sexism is a problem within our community, it really needs to be better defined if we are to address it. Just telling guys not to do that, or insisting an ill-defined problem must be addressed isn't likely to result in the best use of resources or the best outcome. For example, some people welcome and participate in flirting at our events and others don't. To simply declare, flirting is out, is not a satisfactory solution, nor is putting the onus on males to to needlessly limit their behavior or on females to advertise they are available. Again, there is not universal agreement here and it is presumptuous for any of us to speak for everyone.


So, at this point, I am not out to determine if there is a causal relationship between sexism and the gender imbalance at formal events. We must first define the sexism. I think we can do that here. And despite the fact this is a less than perfect method for quantifying the sexism, I think the results are still worth looking at.

So far four kinds of complaints have emerged.
  • 1) expressing legitimate sexual interest (it is not universally acceptable)
  • 2) individuals with obnoxious behavior
  • 3) sexist comments to speakers and in emails to speakers and other community members
  • 4) sexism possibly expressed by a person in a position of authority

I haven't totaled the numbers yet and when I do I will list the complaints with some details for people to judge for themselves. The first 2 seem to compose the bulk of the complaints. There were a couple instances of #3 and only one complaint of #4 (IIRC).


Of course, you are welcome to go through the thread and report your own totals.
 
....
Because, you know, the problem just couldn't be as simple as "this guy behaved badly". The problem is women just don't understand. :rolleyes:
And yet here you are with this straw man and your tunnel vision view of what I must be up to in this thread.


BTW, what do you mean by the number 47?
 
Your counter-example is too neutral for it to apply, in my opinion. As I said before, the combination of the condescention and the superflous gender reference is what does it.

I could weigh in on your counter-example, but it wouldn't be the same thing.

Well, I don't know. That's why I said a bit more context would help. On its own its inconclusive.
 
Meg, since you are once again making assertions without supporting arguments and since when called on it in the past you ignored counterarguments, I will simply ask you some questions. Please respond or stop calling me sexist.

So, first of all, on what basis are you claiming that expressing my opinion is somehow sexist? Are you saying that I must either agree with her or keep my mouth lest I be accused of having sexist opinions? That's what it sounds like.

Exhibit 47a

In which a male makes inappropriate sexual remarks to a female:

"Nice Cans!? FFS, Really?

Where is your evidence that it was inappropriate? I read the blog several times. She did not post what was in her e-mail to him. She did not explain what their relationship was outside of and before this one exchange. I could give you a diaper load of scenarios showing a range of "nothing wrong with his comment" to "what a total jerk!"

There are two sides to a story, and all we have is an incomplete version of one side. Sorry, but I'm not going to make a judgment call as to whether *I* think what he wrote was out of line. Why are you making the judgment that it was inappropriate?


Exhibit 47b

In which a male shows understanding toward the above mentioned male and explains how the woman is wrong. Inferences made that she sent mixed messages, it didn't really bother her, because if it did, she wouldn't have done it the "wrong way":

Wrong about what? I didn't pass judgment on the appropriateness of the comment. I said that I believe that if her intention was to get him to stop his behavior, she did it the wrong way. There's evidence I'm right because his response to her comments about his penis was to continue the bawdy discussion.

I explained why I believe she sent mixed messages. Please address those arguments and tell me why you disagree. Then explain how those arguments are sexist.


You can almost hear the implied, "Gals, don't do this."

I didn't imply anything. I stated outright that if somebody initiates a sexually oriented dialogue with you that makes you uncomfortable, it's a bad idea to continue/escalate the dialogue because that's what the person was after in the first place. Please explain how that's sexist. After all, it applies to all permutations of gender and sexual orientation.



In which, after a female expresses that the above female incident was handled just fine, in her opinion, the male advises her what her problem is. She, too, apparently, just doesn't understand guys.

What does the gender of the person whom I corrected have anything to do with it?

Skeptic Ginger seems to be under the impression that if the receiver feels uncomfortable having its body discussed, then the sender will feel uncomfortable having its body discussed. Therefore, by reversing the roles, the receiver is sending a meta-message to the sender to stop.

I am saying that the sender most likely enjoys discussing its body. Therefore, the meta-message is not "stop" but "hey, this is fun." If someone gets an obscene phone call from someone describing what they'd like to do to it, do you think saying the same types of crude remarks back would discourage the person? If some man in a trench coat whipped out his thingy in front of some woman he didn't know, do you think he would be discouraged if she in turn flashed her breasts at him? At Mardis Gras do you think that women would stop flashing their breasts if men responded by whipping out their thingies?

Please explain how my disagreement with Skeptic Ginger is any way sexist.

Please explain why it is permissible for you to proclaim sexism on Skeptic Ginger's behalf but I'm not allowed to proclaim "not sexism" on someone else's behalf.

Please explain how it's sexist to say if you want to send a clear message, state your message clearly rather than implying it. After all, that advice is universal across all permutations of gender and sexual orientation.

Because, you know, the problem just couldn't be as simple as "this guy behaved badly". The problem is women just don't understand. :rolleyes:

I didn't extrapolate this incident to all men and women. I did my best to keep it tightly focused on the two parties. I don't know if he behaved badly or not for the reasons I gave at the very start. What information do you have to come to a firm conclusion that it was inappropriate? Do you need me to provide real-life scenarios where it would have been just fine? Just say so, and I will.
 
*sigh*

The comment is now removed, because a moderator agreed with me that it was inappropriate - but there is a poster who has made a point, several times, of responding to my opinions by either threatening to **** me (since I wouldn't touch said person with a ten foot barge pole, that is in effect a threat of rape - this was the comment that was removed) or by pointing out how my, to him, perceived lack of sexual attractiveness (yes, consistency is not this person's forte) somehow renders my opinions moot. Before I put him on ignore he also insisted that I not try to pursue him, despite a complete lack of me ever doing that. Other posters' reactions to this behaviour has mainly been either back slapping or complete disinterest. This behaviour did not address my points, was clearly directed solely at what I, as a woman, in the mind of this psycho should be concerned about. I have never seen this poster threaten to **** male posters he doesn't agree with. The moderator response was only removal of the offending lines. The poster did not receive an infraction.


This has made me lose interest in FC completely and has made me consider leaving the forum completely. One psycho on ignore might be one thing, but the apparent acceptance of that behaviour is more of a systemic issue.
Can you provide some links? I went searching around for what you're describing, and I found quite the little soap opera in Forum Community. Is that what you're talking about?


We have another poster responding to a measured, but critical, post by another female poster with "whatever floats your skirts" despite the issue having nothing to do with gender, nor skirts. This is insiduous because it manages to be extremely condescending, misogynist and at the same time non actionable.
It took some time to find this because your quote was wrong. The actual quote is " whatever blows your skirt up." AA Alfie wrote that, and he wrote it more than once in that thread.

To Pup: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=6144042#post6144042

To Slingblade: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7282658#post7282658

It's actually a common phrase:
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=whatever blows your skirt up&defid=4951582

If you're going to call that sexist, then I am going to call your usage of the word douchebag sexist. Fair enough?

And then there is of course the woman-on-woman bashing of anyone who doesn't respond to different situations, regardless of background, as the self proclaimed shining beacons of womanhood.
Are you referring to something like the comment below in the aforementioned soap opera in FC where Professor Yaffle (a woman) condescendingly called you "dear" when she accused you of having "hissy" fits:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7224420#post7224420
Not everything is about you dear. Sometimes other people are just having a laugh with eachother in your general vicinity.

But since you insist - all I saw in this thread was someone making a joke and you pouncing on them like a rabid dog. And then childishly calling them chicken because they didn't want to be part of one of your hissyfits.

Get over it.

I'm not trying to pick on you here, but Skeptic Ginger asked for evidence rather than conclusions. You have provided little evidence and lots of opinion. I'm simply not going to take your word for it, nor would I expect you to take my word for it. Just point to the exchanges so we can see for ourselves what transpired and reach our own conclusions. We're very fortunate that it's written down, so there's no issues with faulty/selective memory.
 
If you're going to call that sexist, then I am going to call your usage of the word douchebag sexist. Fair enough?

"Douchebag" isn't a sexist insult. It's not actually gender-specific. If anything it's insulting to actual douche bags, but if 'douching' was a person rather than a concept it would be both sexist and a douchebag, so that's okay. (Nope. Not joking. It's insulting and potentially harmful to women.)
 
"Douchebag" isn't a sexist insult. It's not actually gender-specific. If anything it's insulting to actual douche bags, but if 'douching' was a person rather than a concept it would be both sexist and a douchebag, so that's okay. (Nope. Not joking. It's insulting and potentially harmful to women.)
Way to miss the point.

While a douche technically refers to irrigating any orifice, there are only two orifices routines irrigated. An enema goes in the rectum and a douche goes in the vagina. Wiki can be a pretty good source of the general usage of terms, so check it out yourself.

If you read that article, it gets into what a douche bag is. It reads, "The term usually refers to a person, usually male, with a variety of negative qualities..."

But, hey, I'll play along. Skirts are not only worn by women. Some men wear kilts, and if you want to equate an enema bag to a douche bag, I'll be happy to equate a kilt to a skirt. Then, of course, we have cross-dressers and drag queens. And just because I can be just as pedantic as the next person, skirts are also found on saddles, rockets, cars and furniture.

But the point is that I consider neither term sexist simply because there are some general associations with gender. The term "whatever blows up your skirt" is simply a colorful way of saying that something doesn't really matter. A douchebag is a colorful term for a jerk.

I'm not going to get my panties in a bunch about either term. ;)
 
Who is this poster? Name him.

If someone is making threats to physically assault another poster on the forum, then they should be banned.

There's a huge difference between trying to persuade someone to have sex with you and threatening someone with physical assault. Let's not conflate the two.

As Forum Liaison:

I do not know what the referenced post was or who it was however if anyone threatened to rape someone they would be banned and (as I have done in the past when such serious matters arise) I would endeavour to contact the relevant police authorities, such behaviour is not tolerated.
 
This has made me lose interest in FC completely and has made me consider leaving the forum completely. One psycho on ignore might be one thing, but the apparent acceptance of that behavior is more of a systemic issue.
There are individuals on the forum that really do act like dicks in some discussions. And one person in particular I'm aware of gets away with a lot of awful treatment of certain individuals he decides to harass. I am one of those targets. Believe me, I agree that hurtful insults whether sexist or not, sometimes wrongly go unnoticed, IMO. My point above about the politics forum is that there are insults that are more hurtful than other insults.
Why does 'sexist' or 'misogynist' spark so much more controversy than insults like 'attention whore' or 'hypocrite' do? It seems to me that the latter are much more hurtful, but a great deal of the 'elevatorgate' phenomenon has been arguments over such terminology.

I think that WTBS has a valid concern in that the apparent acceptance of that behavior is a systemic problem within our community. I'm not sure what, if anything, should be changed. In general, I feel the membership agreement covers such behavior, but as you mentioned, moderation is not an easy job. My personal solution has been to place anyone who I find annoying in that way on ignore and to stay out of the politics subforum, but that isn't an optimum solution by any means.

But I wouldn't blame another person for leaving rather than coming to the forum and being subjected to hurtful comments.
I don't either. But then, I don't blame women who say they don't attend atheist/skeptical conferences because they don't appreciate the treatment they receive. Whether the objectionable behavior should be considered sexist or not seems a minor quibble to me but is apparently the major point of contention for you and many others.
And then there is of course the woman-on-woman bashing of anyone who doesn't respond to different situations, regardless of background, as the self proclaimed shining beacons of womanhood.
That goes both ways and in this debate, clearly the RW side are out in force insulting everyone who doesn't go along with their view.
Yes, men do not have a monopoly on bad behavior. I agree that the bashing of women who disagree with the feminist position has been quite ridiculous on some sites.

Seriously, the comments on Skepchick and a couple other blogs are full of nothing but immature comments about those who happen to disagree. Maybe there is an equal amount of RW bashing, (I know there is some), but I don't see it as equal on both sides. That could be my bias because of how legit or not I see the comments.
Have you read the 'there was a woman speaker on an elevator' thread here? Plenty of RW bashing going on there. A great deal of it would be reported and actionable if RW was still a member. Whether or not the bashing is equal on both sides, I can't say. Different sites have majorities going to different groups.
But let me give you my example. I think it hurts the cause of feminism to portray women as vulnerable and so easily offended. Yet many women are calling that misogynistic. Seriously? Is it really anti-women to be telling women they have the power to travel the world, stay in hotels alone, and not be afraid, and, telling women they have a choice to be offended by EG or not, it is not EG's choice, nor in EG's control?
Has that actually been called misogynistic? I suspect that it has more to do with the way the sentiment was expressed rather than the sentiment itself being considered misogynistic. To be honest, if that's what you have been trying to communicate, it hasn't come across.
It's a different point of view but equally pro-woman as far as I'm concerned. To say my view is supporting sexist men or that I'm only saying women should "take it" is an unfair criticism of my view.
I'm sorry, but that is how your view is coming across to me as well. It may be an unfair criticism, but you have failed to distinguish between how your view differs from telling women to 'take it' without complaint.

And then there's the double punishment, when reacting with discomfort to one situation is wrong, but not being wary of same situation - had it led to unfortunate events - would also have been wrong.
What example are you referring to here?
I think WTBS's point is that Rebecca is 'punished' for having made her statement by being called names like 'attention whore', told that she shouldn't be uncomfortable in that situation, told she should consider it a compliment, told that such encounters are to be expected when leaving a hotel bar at 4 am, etc. OTOH, if she hadn't been wary in that situation (i.e. uncomfortable because of the vulnerability of the situation), if she had been attacked in the elevator or worse, accepted the invitation believing he was sincere about 'coffee' and been attacked there, she would have been similarly 'punished' - i.e. told that such encounters are to be expected when leaving a hotel bar at 4 am., told she was naive to think that he just wanted to talk when he invited her to his room, etc.
If this is not what WTBS meant, hopefully she will explain further.
Clearly they are "recorded". The examples are here for everyone to see. The request for examples to be PMed to me if one couldn't post them hasn't resulted in any additional examples.
Now that you have several examples, what is your opinion? Do you think sexism is a problem in the skeptical/atheist community? Do you think that the behavior that has been described is an influential factor in women deciding where or not to be active in that community?
So, at this point, I am not out to determine if there is a causal relationship between sexism and the gender imbalance at formal events. We must first define the sexism. I think we can do that here. And despite the fact this is a less than perfect method for quantifying the sexism, I think the results are still worth looking at.

So far four kinds of complaints have emerged.
  • 1) expressing legitimate sexual interest (it is not universally acceptable)
  • 2) individuals with obnoxious behavior
  • 3) sexist comments to speakers and in emails to speakers and other community members
  • 4) sexism possibly expressed by a person in a position of authority

I haven't totaled the numbers yet and when I do I will list the complaints with some details for people to judge for themselves. The first 2 seem to compose the bulk of the complaints. There were a couple instances of #3 and only one complaint of #4 (IIRC).
I would like to point out that your #4 is a more serious issue since the behavior of leaders and those in positions of authority set the standards of acceptable behavior. RD's comment that aroused such ire was, IMO, due as much to his status in the community as his words. Many others have written equally egregious comments or worse (though few have his talent with words) but that did not cause the same furor.
 
The criteria is, the examples need to be specific, not a general feeling. And the examples need to be specific to the skeptic/atheist communities, not just examples of sexism in the academic or scientific communities where sexism has already been established. That's it.

That sounds pretty simple and to the point. However, when you respond..

When it comes to the complaint too many men hit on the women at our events, one can't help but wonder if a guy that the woman perceived was quite attractive was making the pass how that would be perceived.

or

There were a few rude remarks aimed at Skeptifem who actually had made some reasonable points and some of the reactions were definitely sexist, demeaning her opinions and points with sexist stereotyped descriptions of her and her comments.

or

The point of this thread is to collect valid evidence as opposed to selective memory conclusions.

or
Do we know if Henneberg's experience at CERN was due to her not being a physicist, or due to her being a woman? I would conclude it was a combination.

or
I gave my reasons for accepting or rejecting anecdotal reports.


..for example, one might wonder if you have more criteria than what you stated above. It appears you are attempting to validate or invalidate examples based on some standard or definition of "sexist" which you have not defined or declared up front, or on some standard or definition of "what constitutes good evidence of sexism" which you have not defined or declared up front.

This thread is more than a simple request for data.


We started with a number of people stating they experienced sexism at formal skeptic/atheist events and the sexism was bad enough to account for some of the discrepancy in the gender imbalance in the attendance at these events.

Yes. And if you stuck entirely to your "request for data" line of questioning, that would be one thing.

But you've also stated you have your own hypothesis.

I only hypothesize there should be less sexism in our community, but I have not tested the hypothesis

How am I supposed to support the absence of evidence hypothesis? I'm trying to give the claimers that there is evidence the benefit of the doubt.

In my experience in the skeptic and atheist communities (which is quite a bit) I've not seen the sexism that is being described. And, I've hypothesized for the reasons I said. If I was convinced my hypothesis was true, I wouldn't be looking for evidence to support or refute it. I don't see evidence of the sexism-in-our-community charges Skepchick and their supporters are making. But I accept that I could be wrong and am trying to look at this with an open mind. But I'm not going to accept the charges without evidence.

So let's recap, you are not JUST looking for examples of sexism in the community that might explain the gender imbalace. You've hypothesized that there is less sexism in this community than in society at large.

Do you not see that there is an obvious conflict here? You are trying to do two different and conflicting things. While stating you want to accumulate data about sexism in the community, while at the same time expecting there to be less than average sexism in the community, you risk self-fulfilling your own expectations.



But the initiating incident that started the conversation was not universally judged to be sexist. So it puts into question (besides other problems like selective memory) the reliability of undefined complaints of personally experiencing sexism at skeptic/atheist events.

Since when has "universally judged to be sexist" been a criteria for what is or isn't sexist?

And why would it be logical or rational to assume that since there is debate regarding the "sexisminess", (for lack of a better word), of a singular incident by an single individual that one should question reliability of other people's accounts?

You said yourself,
The whole point of this thread is to find evidence that what PZ is saying is true.
Why should the debate surrounding RW's statements make PZ's statements any more or less reliable?




In addition, if indeed sexism is a problem within our community, it really needs to be better defined if we are to address it. Just telling guys not to do that, or insisting an ill-defined problem must be addressed isn't likely to result in the best use of resources or the best outcome. For example, some people welcome and participate in flirting at our events and others don't. To simply declare, flirting is out, is not a satisfactory solution, nor is putting the onus on males to to needlessly limit their behavior or on females to advertise they are available. Again, there is not universal agreement here and it is presumptuous for any of us to speak for everyone.

So, at this point, I am not out to determine if there is a causal relationship between sexism and the gender imbalance at formal events. We must first define the sexism. I think we can do that here. And despite the fact this is a less than perfect method for quantifying the sexism, I think the results are still worth looking at.


You've already stated that this thread IS out to determine if there is a causal relationship between sexism and gender imbalance, so it's really hard to backtrack and get your method right now. I think it's great that you've realized that before you can analyze something you have to figure out how to define it and then how to measure it. I think this thread is pretty much a lost cause though. You've got a whole lot of people measuring a whole lot of different things based on their own interpretations of someone else's one sided stories. And by having that whole lot of people analyzing whatever the hell they want to analyze and declaring whatever the hell they want to declare about it, you've inadvertantly created a situation where people that do have evidence might be unwilling to put it forth, because they don't want this same treatment. In other words, you've unintentionally skewed the investigation in order to "prove" your hypothesis.

What's really screwy is that by doing so you might also have unintentionally influenced the thing you are trying to study so as to add numbers to the "how many women have seen examples of sexism within the community and choose not to attend events because of it" group. Is it possible that just reading this thread might lead a woman to choose not to go to TAM? I don't know, but I think it is possible.



As far as the quantifying and defining go, I personally think that if sexism is a problem in society at large, and/or if sexism is a problem within the science, academic, or philosophical communities, (the circles from which many of our members come), then it is no big stretch to think that sexism is probably a problem in our own community, too, and probably at about the same rate. How one scientifically quantifies it, I do not know. Though I think anonymous well worded polls sent to all women within given communities, then comparing the answers might be some kind of a start. Whether one is able to quantify it by asking questions on one open internet forum? I doubt very much that anyone would take those results very seriously as some kind of actual research.


Since sexism is a social issue of treatment of an individual based on a social construct of gender stereotypes, I doubt anyone can define it into some kind of short, pithy statement that everyone can understand, let alone agree upon. Every individual is different, obviously, and every individual has absorbed the teachings and attitudes of a myriad of people in the making up of the gender and social stereotypes they hold in their own head.

Sexism can be as subtle and insidious that even a well respected and renowned feminist might unconciously harbor for example, the sexist notion that women don't know how to fix cars, so without even thinking about it, she automatically asks her coworker Tom to help her diagnose her problem, when in reality Mary, who enjoys working on cars and has been doing it her whole life, would be a much better choice.

Or it can be as blatant and obvious and repugnant as a man who thinks that if a woman is walking alone at night that she must be a whore, and he therefore has the right to assault her.

In one example there is essentially no "harm" done, especially if Mary doesn't even know that she asked Tom for help with her car rather than herself. No harm, no foul, as they say. But it's still sexist. In the other example grievous bodily harm and legal charges might result.

So good luck trying to define it. I really mean that.



So far four kinds of complaints have emerged.
  • 1) expressing legitimate sexual interest (it is not universally acceptable)
  • 2) individuals with obnoxious behavior
  • 3) sexist comments to speakers and in emails to speakers and other community members
  • 4) sexism possibly expressed by a person in a position of authority

I haven't totaled the numbers yet and when I do I will list the complaints with some details for people to judge for themselves. The first 2 seem to compose the bulk of the complaints. There were a couple instances of #3 and only one complaint of #4 (IIRC).

Of course, you are welcome to go through the thread and report your own totals.

I think that's a great start at attempting to classify this. I do question the use of the word "legitimate". And I'm really not just trying to be difficult here. What's the difference between "expressing legitimate sexual interest" and "expressing sexual interest"?
 
Why does 'sexist' or 'misogynist' spark so much more controversy than insults like 'attention whore' or 'hypocrite' do?
It's a Rorschach test. What we see of each other's views are often a reverse mirror view of our own deep seated emotions.

If an RW contraian observes that RW's response lacks nuance, is presumptive and contains fallacy her defendors hear all the hateful and vial crap the loonies spew.

If an RW defender says that sex, intimacy and seduction are all cool but we need to raise the awareness of men that women are often made uncomfortable by thoughtless and/or unnecassary vulgarity or assumptions about women then the contrarians hear fascist calls for prohibitons against intimacy and seduction by a fringe element of the left.

There are serious logical errors and hateful rhetoric on both sides. There is moderate and reasoned argument and points on both sides. Many want to focus more on the fringe and ignore the more moderate and reasoned views and argument.

At least that's the way I see it.
 
I think that's a great start at attempting to classify this. I do question the use of the word "legitimate". And I'm really not just trying to be difficult here. What's the difference between "expressing legitimate sexual interest" and "expressing sexual interest"?
I can't speak for SG but I would say that their is a difference between "appropriate expressions" of sexual interest and "inappropriate expressions". The problem is that there is a lot of gray area and often due to significant differences of view point the twain very often do meet. While I find the actions of EG
sketchy I don't finf them per se innapropriate.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom