The criteria is, the examples need to be specific, not a general feeling. And the examples need to be specific to the skeptic/atheist communities, not just examples of sexism in the academic or scientific communities where sexism has already been established. That's it.
That sounds pretty simple and to the point. However, when you respond..
When it comes to the complaint too many men hit on the women at our events, one can't help but wonder if a guy that the woman perceived was quite attractive was making the pass how that would be perceived.
or
There were a few rude remarks aimed at Skeptifem who actually had made some reasonable points and some of the reactions were definitely sexist, demeaning her opinions and points with sexist stereotyped descriptions of her and her comments.
or
The point of this thread is to collect valid evidence as opposed to selective memory conclusions.
or
Do we know if Henneberg's experience at CERN was due to her not being a physicist, or due to her being a woman? I would conclude it was a combination.
or
I gave my reasons for accepting or rejecting anecdotal reports.
..for example, one might wonder if you have more criteria than what you stated above. It appears you are attempting to
validate or
invalidate examples based on some standard or definition of "sexist" which you have not defined or declared up front, or on some standard or definition of "what constitutes good evidence of sexism" which you have not defined or declared up front.
This thread is more than a simple request for data.
We started with a number of people stating they experienced sexism at formal skeptic/atheist events and the sexism was bad enough to account for some of the discrepancy in the gender imbalance in the attendance at these events.
Yes. And if you stuck entirely to your "request for data" line of questioning, that would be one thing.
But you've also stated you have your own hypothesis.
I only hypothesize there should be less sexism in our community, but I have not tested the hypothesis
How am I supposed to support the absence of evidence hypothesis? I'm trying to give the claimers that there is evidence the benefit of the doubt.
In my experience in the skeptic and atheist communities (which is quite a bit) I've not seen the sexism that is being described. And, I've hypothesized for the reasons I said. If I was convinced my hypothesis was true, I wouldn't be looking for evidence to support or refute it. I don't see evidence of the sexism-in-our-community charges Skepchick and their supporters are making. But I accept that I could be wrong and am trying to look at this with an open mind. But I'm not going to accept the charges without evidence.
So let's recap, you are not JUST looking for examples of sexism in the community that might explain the gender imbalace. You've hypothesized that there is less sexism in this community than in society at large.
Do you not see that there is an obvious conflict here? You are trying to do two different and conflicting things. While stating you want to accumulate data about sexism in the community, while at the same time expecting there to be less than average sexism in the community, you risk self-fulfilling your own expectations.
But the initiating incident that started the conversation was not universally judged to be sexist. So it puts into question (besides other problems like selective memory) the reliability of undefined complaints of personally experiencing sexism at skeptic/atheist events.
Since when has "universally judged to be sexist" been a criteria for what is or isn't sexist?
And why would it be logical or rational to assume that since there is debate regarding the "sexisminess", (for lack of a better word), of a singular incident by an single individual that one should question reliability of other people's accounts?
You said yourself,
The whole point of this thread is to find evidence that what PZ is saying is true.
Why should the debate surrounding RW's statements make PZ's statements any more or less reliable?
In addition, if indeed sexism is a problem within our community, it really needs to be better defined if we are to address it. Just telling guys not to do that, or insisting an ill-defined problem must be addressed isn't likely to result in the best use of resources or the best outcome. For example, some people welcome and participate in flirting at our events and others don't. To simply declare, flirting is out, is not a satisfactory solution, nor is putting the onus on males to to needlessly limit their behavior or on females to advertise they are available. Again, there is not universal agreement here and it is presumptuous for any of us to speak for everyone.
So, at this point, I am not out to determine if there is a causal relationship between sexism and the gender imbalance at formal events. We must first define the sexism. I think we can do that here. And despite the fact this is a less than perfect method for quantifying the sexism, I think the results are still worth looking at.
You've already stated that this thread IS out to determine if there is a causal relationship between sexism and gender imbalance, so it's really hard to backtrack and get your method right now. I think it's great that you've realized that before you can analyze something you have to figure out how to define it and then how to measure it. I think this thread is pretty much a lost cause though. You've got a whole lot of people measuring a whole lot of different things based on their own interpretations of someone else's one sided stories. And by having that whole lot of people analyzing whatever the hell they want to analyze and declaring whatever the hell they want to declare about it, you've inadvertantly created a situation where people that do have evidence might be unwilling to put it forth, because they don't want this same treatment. In other words, you've unintentionally skewed the investigation in order to "prove" your hypothesis.
What's really screwy is that by doing so you might also have unintentionally influenced the thing you are trying to study so as to add numbers to the "how many women have seen examples of sexism within the community and choose not to attend events because of it" group. Is it possible that just reading this thread might lead a woman to choose not to go to TAM? I don't know, but I think it is possible.
As far as the quantifying and defining go, I personally think that if sexism is a problem in society at large, and/or if sexism is a problem within the science, academic, or philosophical communities, (the circles from which many of our members come), then it is no big stretch to think that sexism is probably a problem in our own community, too, and probably at about the same rate. How one scientifically quantifies it, I do not know. Though I think anonymous well worded polls sent to all women within given communities, then comparing the answers might be some kind of a start. Whether one is able to quantify it by asking questions on one open internet forum? I doubt very much that anyone would take those results very seriously as some kind of actual research.
Since sexism is a social issue of treatment of an individual based on a social construct of gender stereotypes, I doubt anyone can define it into some kind of short, pithy statement that everyone can understand, let alone agree upon. Every individual is different, obviously, and every individual has absorbed the teachings and attitudes of a myriad of people in the making up of the gender and social stereotypes they hold in their own head.
Sexism can be as subtle and insidious that even a well respected and renowned feminist might unconciously harbor for example, the sexist notion that women don't know how to fix cars, so without even thinking about it, she automatically asks her coworker Tom to help her diagnose her problem, when in reality Mary, who enjoys working on cars and has been doing it her whole life, would be a much better choice.
Or it can be as blatant and obvious and repugnant as a man who thinks that if a woman is walking alone at night that she must be a whore, and he therefore has the right to assault her.
In one example there is essentially no "harm" done, especially if Mary doesn't even know that she asked Tom for help with her car rather than herself. No harm, no foul, as they say. But it's still sexist. In the other example grievous bodily harm and legal charges might result.
So good luck trying to define it. I really mean that.
So far four kinds of complaints have emerged.
- 1) expressing legitimate sexual interest (it is not universally acceptable)
- 2) individuals with obnoxious behavior
- 3) sexist comments to speakers and in emails to speakers and other community members
- 4) sexism possibly expressed by a person in a position of authority
I haven't totaled the numbers yet and when I do I will list the complaints with some details for people to judge for themselves. The first 2 seem to compose the bulk of the complaints. There were a couple instances of #3 and only one complaint of #4 (IIRC).
Of course, you are welcome to go through the thread and report your own totals.
I think that's a great start at attempting to classify this. I do question the use of the word "legitimate". And I'm really not just trying to be difficult here. What's the difference between "expressing legitimate sexual interest" and "expressing sexual interest"?