Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Skeptic Ginger - here's a very short (30 seconds) blog about sexism in the skeptical community. I think it's good evidence.
You are funny.
Skeptic Ginger - here's a very short (30 seconds) blog about sexism in the skeptical community. I think it's good evidence.
Not if she didn't see the behavior as some horrid travesty of feminism. If she felt the need to point it out to the guy, but beyond that she wasn't moved, there's no mixed message there.
I believe in choosing my battles. Some guy commenting I look hot is not one of them. Some creep telling me I need a man to fix my liberated attitude, that requires a different response.
Inappropriate, yes. But to what degree? To the degree you point it out, problem solved? Or to some degree that requires one act affronted and miffed?I got the impression that she felt that his comment about her bosom was inappropriate given her view of their relationship. I don't think she accurately conveyed that message to him by commenting on his penis since that's a tacit invitation for more such sexual banter, which was evidenced by his response about the yardstick. If she was just mildly annoyed and didn't care all that much, I think her response was fine. I think you and I are on the same page.
Inappropriate, yes. But to what degree? To the degree you point it out, problem solved? Or to some degree that requires one act affronted and miffed?
If you said, nice cans, and you were called on it, even jokingly, most guys would be a tad embarrassed regardless if the woman was polite enough to point it out with a joke taking the edge off the criticism.
My point is, it is not necessarily giving mixed messages. It really depends on non-verbal cues in the interaction. I could flirt back using the same words and a different intonation, or I could use those same words and remind you with my example how inappropriate your comments were. I don't need to make a federal case of it. I have a choice to let this minor sexism bother me or not. I choose a higher threshold to be more seriously offended.
I did not say she didn't find it inappropriate. I'm saying what is the level of outrage?....
It's a mixed message to say that you don't appreciate having your bosom being referenced because it's inappropriate and then turning around and commenting on the length of the guy's penis as well as its turgidity. Furthermore, she promised to make future comments about his penis, thus continuing the banter, not stopping. Had she stopped with the blue part, her message would have been less ambiguous but still ambiguous. ....
If I'm the "nice cans" guy reading that exchange and not her blog, I would not get the message that she didn't want me making comments like that again because her response seems to confirm my initial impression that she was up for it.
ETA: I want to be clear that I have no problems with her finding it inappropriate or not really being bothered by it. That's her call, and she's not putting out a "Guys, don't do that" message. My issue is that if she was truly bothered by it and if she wanted to make sure the guy knew it and if she didn't want him to do it again, she went about it the wrong way.
By contrast, I believe it was Rebecca Watson who had the workshop at TAM where people made angry vaginas. I could see how people could take offense at such blatant sexuality. Granted, it was an optional session, but I'm sure some were made uncomfortable riding an elevator alone with somebody carrying a two-foot replica of a vagina.
People have asked that buzzo not be invited back to TAM. Nothing came of it and his blog has been featured on the front page of the JREF site.
<snip>
ETA: And I'd love to discuss this further but I need to go boil some pectin. Because there are men who treat women as fellow travelers on this weird road we call life. They don't think of them as sperm-dumps, ego-boosts, pussy-guardians, status symbols and decoration, but truly equals.
And those men don't just get sex whenever they want it. They get jam. Homemade strawberry jam that is so good you want to lick the bowl. In every possible metaphoric and literal sense.
*sigh*
The comment is now removed, because a moderator agreed with me that it was inappropriate - but there is a poster who has made a point, several times, of responding to my opinions by either threatening to **** me (since I wouldn't touch said person with a ten foot barge pole, that is in effect a threat of rape - this was the comment that was removed) or by pointing out how my, to him, perceived lack of sexual attractiveness (yes, consistency is not this person's forte) somehow renders my opinions moot. Before I put him on ignore he also insisted that I not try to pursue him, despite a complete lack of me ever doing that. Other posters' reactions to this behaviour has mainly been either back slapping or complete disinterest. This behaviour did not address my points, was clearly directed solely at what I, as a woman, in the mind of this psycho should be concerned about. I have never seen this poster threaten to **** male posters he doesn't agree with. The moderator response was only removal of the offending lines. The poster did not receive an infraction.
This has made me lose interest in FC completely and has made me consider leaving the forum completely. One psycho on ignore might be one thing, but the apparent acceptance of that behaviour is more of a systemic issue.
<snip>
*sigh*
The comment is now removed, because a moderator agreed with me that it was inappropriate - but there is a poster who has made a point, several times, of responding to my opinions by either threatening to **** me (since I wouldn't touch said person with a ten foot barge pole, that is in effect a threat of rape - this was the comment that was removed) or by pointing out how my, to him, perceived lack of sexual attractiveness (yes, consistency is not this person's forte) somehow renders my opinions moot. Before I put him on ignore he also insisted that I not try to pursue him, despite a complete lack of me ever doing that. Other posters' reactions to this behaviour has mainly been either back slapping or complete disinterest. This behaviour did not address my points, was clearly directed solely at what I, as a woman, in the mind of this psycho should be concerned about. I have never seen this poster threaten to **** male posters he doesn't agree with. The moderator response was only removal of the offending lines. The poster did not receive an infraction.
We have another poster responding to a measured, but critical, post by another female poster with "whatever floats your skirts" despite the issue having nothing to do with gender, nor skirts. This is insiduous because it manages to be extremely condescending, misogynist and at the same time non actionable.
*sigh*
The comment is now removed, because a moderator agreed with me that it was inappropriate - but there is a poster who has made a point, several times, of responding to my opinions by either threatening to **** me (since I wouldn't touch said person with a ten foot barge pole, that is in effect a threat of rape - this was the comment that was removed) or by pointing out how my, to him, perceived lack of sexual attractiveness (yes, consistency is not this person's forte) somehow renders my opinions moot. Before I put him on ignore he also insisted that I not try to pursue him, despite a complete lack of me ever doing that. Other posters' reactions to this behaviour has mainly been either back slapping or complete disinterest. This behaviour did not address my points, was clearly directed solely at what I, as a woman, in the mind of this psycho should be concerned about. I have never seen this poster threaten to **** male posters he doesn't agree with. The moderator response was only removal of the offending lines. The poster did not receive an infraction.
I think she was saying he should consider the open invitation to register and attend not to apply to him.Curious about this - why is he invited to TAM by the JREF?
I did not say she didn't find it inappropriate. I'm saying what is the level of outrage?
I just don't see the problem.
"Nice cans."
"How would you like it if we talked about your dick?"
Seems straightforward and to the point.
I believe Dr. Buzzo had a camera on his shoe and Dr Adequate was giving out unsolicited tonsillectomies with his tongue (are they really doctors?). I stated unequivocally that this was unacceptable and that they should have been tossed from TAM and banned for life. I don't think anyone has "dismissed" those incidents nor do I think anyone has disagreed with my suggested actions by the JREF.
What Dr. Adequate did was a crime - sexual assault. Somebody should have notified the JREF. RemieV said she was too upset to pass it on. I think if I had been there and witnessed it, I would have put him on the ground before anyone had a chance to stop me. I would have definitely pitched a fit with the JREF until they did something about it.
What Dr. Buzzo did is a crime in just about every state, and in those few states where it's not explicitly a crime, it could be prosecuted under other statutes. You have the legal right to take pictures of people in public, but you don't have a right to take pictures of them when there's a reasonable expectation of privacy. Thus taking a picture of a woman in her skirt is legal even if unwanted, but it's illegal to take a picture up her skirt.
I'm not sure what exactly it is we are supposed to do with your argument? My intuition is a middle of the road approach where you don't suggest that people stop being social creatures or prohibit social interaction with the possibility of intimacy, but then...I mean - how about all those people who _aren't_ constantly hit on, but really wish they were? If hitting on people - or telling them you plan to **** them - is a gawd given right under any conceivable circumstances, then surely it is also a gawd given right for everyone to get hit on?
See, I'm not sure you are actually suggesting what it seems you are in fact suggesting. It's seems to me that you want to hug the middle of the road and then you veer to the extreme. I hesitate to ask if you are really suggesting no one ever ask another person to coffee but I suspect that you will accuse me of a straw man but I could be wrong. Could you clarify?Should we draw up a rota? Because apparently, that is all this is about. Just leaving people the **** alone is apparently too tall an order, so let's just make sure you can prepare.
Yeah, okay, see, not everyone who disagrees with you falls into a neat tidy box. It might be convenient for rhetorical purposes but it's not conducive to discussion.*awaits abuse, self aggrandizing fantasies....
I am assuming the guy recognized the analogy, understood his mistake, and realized Michelle was not flirting back. I'm not saying that is the only possible option.Ah, I see your problem. You are assuming that a guy who wants to talk about a woman's breasts would not want her to talk about his penis. I suppose that maybe there are one or two guys like that, but I can't think of any guy I know who would consider her shifting the discussion to his penis as anything other than encouragement. That's what happened in this case as evidenced by the guy talking about using a yardstick to measure his penis.
I certainly don't remember ever seeing behaviour like this but if it happened as you describe it, then something should have been done about it.
Unless I'm missing something that's just a turn of phrase and doesn't suggest misogyny in the slightest. Of course, I don't have the context to make a clearer judgement.
There are individuals who display bad behavior. I shall add this one to the list. I'm not sure how it reflects on the community at large, that depends on the frequency. But failing to recognize how the targeted member feels, or accepting the behavior, is a valid issue in this context.*sigh*
The comment is now removed, because a moderator agreed with me that it was inappropriate - but there is a poster who has made a point, several times, of responding to my opinions by either threatening to **** me (since I wouldn't touch said person with a ten foot barge pole, that is in effect a threat of rape - this was the comment that was removed) or by pointing out how my, to him, perceived lack of sexual attractiveness (yes, consistency is not this person's forte) somehow renders my opinions moot. Before I put him on ignore he also insisted that I not try to pursue him, despite a complete lack of me ever doing that. Other posters' reactions to this behaviour has mainly been either back slapping or complete disinterest. This behaviour did not address my points, was clearly directed solely at what I, as a woman, in the mind of this psycho should be concerned about. I have never seen this poster threaten to **** male posters he doesn't agree with. The moderator response was only removal of the offending lines. The poster did not receive an infraction.
There are individuals on the forum that really do act like dicks in some discussions. And one person in particular I'm aware of gets away with a lot of awful treatment of certain individuals he decides to harass. I am one of those targets. Believe me, I agree that hurtful insults whether sexist or not, sometimes wrongly go unnoticed, IMO. My point above about the politics forum is that there are insults that are more hurtful than other insults. Ridicule is the key factor so 'panties in a bunch' comments can be more hurtful than just saying, don't get upset. I'm not sure it is sexism that is the main issue more than simply obnoxious forum members. Some of those obnoxious forum members are indeed sexist and it shows in their comments. They tack gender ad homs on to whatever else they are trying to address with ad homs. I don't know that gender ad homs in those circumstances are any worse than other forms of ridicule.This has made me lose interest in FC completely and has made me consider leaving the forum completely. One psycho on ignore might be one thing, but the apparent acceptance of that behaviour is more of a systemic issue.
We have another poster responding to a measured, but critical, post by another female poster with "whatever floats your skirts" despite the issue having nothing to do with gender, nor skirts. This is insiduous because it manages to be extremely condescending, misogynist and at the same time non actionable.
That goes both ways and in this debate, clearly the RW side are out in force insulting everyone who doesn't go along with their view. Seriously, the comments on Skepchick and a couple other blogs are full of nothing but immature comments about those who happen to disagree. Maybe there is an equal amount of RW bashing, (I know there is some), but I don't see it as equal on both sides. That could be my bias because of how legit or not I see the comments.And then there is of course the woman-on-woman bashing of anyone who doesn't respond to different situations, regardless of background, as the self proclaimed shining beacons of womanhood.
What example are you referring to here?And then there's the double punishment, when reacting with discomfort to one situation is wrong, but not being wary of same situation - had it led to unfortunate events - would also have been wrong.
You have to distinguish between belittling and discounting one's view using sexist insults and simply disagreeing with the view. That can be a very gray area. We are not all going to agree on subjects like the one you note here. People do not have to concede to another's viewpoint in this forum. Respecting the other person's point of view is a different matter from agreeing with that point of view. I understand your view but I think this issue as you are presenting it here goes beyond what this thread is about.And then there's the issue of almost all discussions regarding sensitive areas like age of consent or childhood abuse always assuming it only happens to girls and that if boys are brought into the discussion, it only seems to be heinous to a certain demographic if it was man on boy, while grown woman on boy seems to be OK to some people. Boys are either invisible in abuse discussions or even ridiculed, or minimized, if they "didn't appreciate cougar class".
It goes in all directions and it goes on and to my mind a huge problem is that so many of us seem to have failed to develop theory of mind. It seems simply unfathomable to some people that another person's reaction can be equally as valid as theirs and might be based on a completely different background.
A decently intelligent human being should at least be aware of the phenomena of "other people being not the same as you" as an intellectual concept, even if they can't understand it on an emotional level.
You are drifting into straw man territory here.I mean - how about all those people who _aren't_ constantly hit on, but really wish they were? If hitting on people - or telling them you plan to **** them - is a gawd given right under any conceivable circumstances, then surely it is also a gawd given right for everyone to get hit on? Should we draw up a rota? Because apparently, that is all this is about. Just leaving people the **** alone is apparently too tall an order, so let's just make sure you can prepare.
*awaits abuse, self aggrandizing fantasies about how a REAL woman/feminist/true Scotsman would have handled said psycho and minimizing of the behaviour that was uncomfortable to me and a plethora of self congratulatory big grins from the poster who now is likely very pleased to see that his behaviour did have the wished for result: shutting me up and making me lose interest in the forum. Oh, and complete dismissal of experiences as "single instance" or even disbelief that they happend, or dismissal of reacting to it. Or, you know - despite the context being very much about being threatening, writing rape threats off as "a clumsy come-on"...*
You sound skeptical. Do you think she's lying?
I can't imagine why you would need more context to see that that's a misogynistic phrase. Unnecessarily gendered? Check. Condescending? Check. Put those two together...
I shall add this one to the list. I'm not sure how it reflects on the community at large, that depends on the frequency. But failing to recognize how the targeted member feels, or accepting the behavior, is a valid issue in this context.