EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Shall we look at this from a different angle? The oft-mentioned buzzo seems to have made finding a girlfriend and/or hooking up at TAM his main objective (possibly life-long ambition.) To that end he has employed every tactic that has been discussed here and quite a few that we haven't gotten around to yet.

He is quite arrogant, confident and rude while pursuing this objective. All those adjectives that get tossed around when the "nice" guys grumble about "bad boys." The "nice cans" email and it's pouty follow up could have easily been written by him.

Has it worked? Not at all. He has struck out to a truly astounding degree and created such a reputation for himself that finding a mate within the skeptical movement now seems unlikely - even if he totally changed his ways.

On the other hand, the people I know who have hooked up within the movement all started as friends. They got to talking about something they both enjoyed, found common ground and later common interest. The time between the initial cerebral connection and the later physical one varies greatly, from minutes to months but that initial conversation is a constant factor.

How does that address the point I was making?

Ms. Watson (and you, apparently) want all men to have the idea "this woman does not want to have sex with me" running through their brains when they interact with women.

Well, here I am. I am that man. Do you want more men to think the way I do?
 
How does that address the point I was making?

Ms. Watson (and you, apparently) want all men to have the idea "this woman does not want to have sex with me" running through their brains when they interact with women.

Well, here I am. I am that man. Do you want more men to think the way I do?

So will you use your psychic skills to try for the million dollars?

I have no idea what Watson wants all men to think and neither do you. Actually, she said nothing about what they think at all. How they act towards her is a completely different subject.

What goes on in your brain is your business. How you treat other people becomes their business.
 
TAM and other conferences are *not* workplaces. They are social occasions.

Thank you for bringing that up, Ivor! I've been waiting for someone to get around to this.

You are right, - mostly. Most of the people at TAM are not there as a condition of their job. (Though some are, like JREF staffers, speakers, and perhaps journalists covering the event for other skeptical publications)

So the rules about workplace harassment do not directly apply, because workplace harassment is against the law, and is a very serious matter. Employers can be sued and experience financial loss, and employees can lose their jobs, their professional licenses, or their entire careers. If a workplace harassment charge is filed, an investigation most definitely would take place, all parties involved would be interviewed, and evidence would be accumulated and examined. By the employer, any agreed upon mediators, and any legal officials involved. All accusations and evidence would be kept as confidential as possible, not only to spare the feelings of all parties involved, which could range from mild discomfort to extreme embarrassment and humiliation, but to also spare their careers from the rumors, inuendos and ill-formed conclusions that well meaning (or not) colleagues leap to when they find out part of the story and fill in the blanks for themselves.


So, again, Ivor, you are right. TAM is *not* a workplace (for most of the attendees). No charges have been filed, no investigation has to be done, no mediators need to be called in.

I don't know that I would agree with you, but for the sake of argument, let's say that TAM is, as you say, a social occasion.

There are LOTS of different kinds of social occasions, and what is considered appropriate behavior for one is not necessarily so for another. A stag party at a strip club, cocktails with a few close friends, bridge club at the senior center, a book club, camping with your best friend, Thanksgiving at your mother's, and a $10,000 a plate political fundraiser dinner are all social occasions. "Social Occasion" does not automatically mean "anything goes".

Encouraging diversity in TAM attendees is an admirable goal. It might mean changing a little, though, if you want everyone to feel welcome.
 
So will you use your psychic skills to try for the million dollars?

I have no idea what Watson wants all men to think and neither do you. Actually, she said nothing about what they think at all. How they act towards her is a completely different subject.

What goes on in your brain is your business. How you treat other people becomes their business.

Still missing the point.

Do you want men to behave as though there is a chance they might have sex with a woman, or do you want them to behave as though there is not?
 
Last edited:
<snip>

Encouraging diversity in TAM attendees is an admirable goal. It might mean changing a little, though, if you want everyone to feel welcome.

Who wants this? It seems a little cabal of women who go to TAM have decided that the primary objective should be to get more women to attend.

Why? Do the majority of people who attend TAM want more women to go enough to start clamping down on other people's behaviour?

If it's a bastion of male chauvinism and misogyny, so what? No one forces or compels you or any other women to attend. No one excludes women from attending either.

If you don't like the people at TAM, have your own sceptics bash somewhere else and specify all who attend must either have a vagina or have had their balls removed.
 
Encouraging diversity in TAM attendees is an admirable goal. It might mean changing a little, though, if you want everyone to feel welcome.

It's an odd word that. It used to mean something to do with different being OK, but now it seems to mean everyone will be homogenized to the point where nobody steps out of line.

In a commercial organisation I guess I can kind of understand the need for it although I'm not sure its as positive a thing as its marketed to be, in social settings... well, I dunno.

I really wouldn't like my stag party, cocktails with friends or seniors bridge club to have to be socially diverse, especially if it meant having to stop doing the things we like doing at them to accommodate the new arrivals.

Events like TAM fall into a sort of quasi-social, commercial organisation so there's arguments to be made for encouraging the modern interpretation of diversity.

Looking at it the other way though and putting my contrary hat on then people who proposition women in lifts are also part of 'diversity' and, while I don't personally feel like going on a crusade to stop the lift propositioners feeling left out there has to be some give and take between 'you need to change to make me feel welcome' and 'i need to change to fit in with this group or just leave them alone to do their own thing'
 
Who wants this? It seems a little cabal of women who go to TAM have decided that the primary objective should be to get more women to attend.

Why? Do the majority of people who attend TAM want more women to go enough to start clamping down on other people's behaviour?

If it's a bastion of male chauvinism and misogyny, so what? No one forces or compels you or any other women to attend. No one excludes women from attending either.

If you don't like the people at TAM, have your own sceptics bash somewhere else and specify all who attend must either have a vagina or have had their balls removed.

See here's the funny thing - skepticism as a movement has a goal. In order to advance towards that goal, the philosophy behind the movement needs to reach as many people as possible. Purposefully excluding large groups of people is contrary to that goal.

Purposefully excluding people from a movement based on science and rationality because they are not open to indiscriminate sexual advance makes the movement look a bit ridiculous. "Woman, you will be hit on by geeks and like it! Or you can go elsewhere!" See, silly.
 
Are those my only options?

Yes. The two options cover all possibilities. Either a man is to be allowed to think and therefore behave as though he might have an opportunity to have sex with a woman in the future, or he is not.

Which is it?
 
See here's the funny thing - skepticism as a movement has a goal. In order to advance towards that goal, the philosophy behind the movement needs to reach as many people as possible. Purposefully excluding large groups of people is contrary to that goal.

Purposefully excluding people from a movement based on science and rationality because they are not open to indiscriminate sexual advance makes the movement look a bit ridiculous. "Woman, you will be hit on by geeks and like it! Or you can go elsewhere!" See, silly.

No one is being excluded from the scepticism movement. TAM is one event. Women and anyone else who finds the people who attend that one event offensive can set up their own sceptical event for like-minded individuals or attend events organised by people they do get on with.

BTW, there are plenty of powerful and influential organisations that have significant amounts prejudice within them at all levels. I don't think sexism is a barrier to a group having power or influence.
 
See here's the funny thing - skepticism as a movement has a goal. In order to advance towards that goal, the philosophy behind the movement needs to reach as many people as possible. Purposefully excluding large groups of people is contrary to that goal.

Purposefully excluding people from a movement based on science and rationality because they are not open to indiscriminate sexual advance makes the movement look a bit ridiculous. "Woman, you will be hit on by geeks and like it! Or you can go elsewhere!" See, silly.

Well said!
 
Attractive? What does that matter? I'm sure that, divorced from his behavior, some women would find buzzo attractive. Eye of the beholder and all that. His looks are not the major contributing factor for failure.

buzzo is a rather unique case in that there is a wealth of evidence available in comparison to the average TAM attendee. He has been repeating the same behavior at the same event for years now and had a consistent result. While it may not live up to your extremely rigid, personal standard of "skepticism," it is interesting enough to mention in the thread that you set up specifically to collect anecdotes.
You have a long way to go here bookitty, to understand the scientific process and rules of logic. Now you are comparing apples to oranges and you've not addressed your prior mistake of calling an association, 'causation'.


I am not drawing a conclusion that X causes Y. I am trying to better define a cause that has already been claimed by others for why there are more men at our events than women. Someone else can establish that the claimed sexism is the cause of the gender imbalance. I am trying to establish whether or not the claimed sexism actually exists and I am trying to better define just what is meant by sexism in this case. (More skepticism 101.)
 
So will you use your psychic skills to try for the million dollars?

I have no idea what Watson wants all men to think and neither do you. Actually, she said nothing about what they think at all. How they act towards her is a completely different subject.

What goes on in your brain is your business. How you treat other people becomes their business.
This is a red herring question dodge.
 
No one is being excluded from the scepticism movement. TAM is one event. Women and anyone else who finds the people who attend that one event offensive can set up their own sceptical event for like-minded individuals or attend events organised by people they do get on with.

BTW, there are plenty of powerful and influential organisations that have significant amounts prejudice within them at all levels. I don't think sexism is a barrier to a group having power or influence.

And how does emulating the Taliban promote critical thinking?
 
Still missing the point.

Do you want men to behave as though there is a chance they might have sex with a woman, or do you want them to behave as though there is not?

In your opinion how different is the behavior is between these choices?

In thinking how I act towards women that I'm sexually attracted to versus women I'm not attracted to, while I certainly would behave differently towards these groups it wouldn't be so much so that my behavior towards someone from one group would be inappropriate towards someone from the other.
 
You have a long way to go here bookitty, to understand the scientific process and rules of logic. Now you are comparing apples to oranges and you've not addressed your prior mistake of calling an association, 'causation'.


I am not drawing a conclusion that X causes Y. I am trying to better define a cause that has already been claimed by others for why there are more men at our events than women. Someone else can establish that the claimed sexism is the cause of the gender imbalance. I am trying to establish whether or not the claimed sexism actually exists and I am trying to better define just what is meant by sexism in this case. (More skepticism 101.)

Oh my gawd. Can you once, just once, actually address what I've said instead showing off your knowledge of terminology. We get it, you have the fallacies page bookmarked.

Here is a direct stand-alone question. What evidence of sexism would fit your personal definition?
 
Oh my gawd. Can you once, just once, actually address what I've said instead showing off your knowledge of terminology. We get it, you have the fallacies page bookmarked.
Bookitty, despite the fact you did not recognize it as so, that was an honestly sincere answer. You are in a skeptics forum, not a social site. We use certain principles to establish facts and you are making the most basic mistakes. How else am I to address your errors in logic?
 
Last edited:
Here is a direct stand-alone question. What evidence of sexism would fit your personal definition?
Commenting on a speaker's sexual attributes or related appearance under most circumstances is sexist, whether done by men or women. There might be a few situations where it was either pertinent or mutually acceptable.

But the come-ons outside of the formal presentations depend totally on the approach. I gave some examples at some point in this discussion. "Hey baby, you look like you need a man" for example, would clearly be sexist. What EG said as reported by RW, it's really hard to picture circumstances where, "don't take this the wrong way" is a sexist come on. And just the fact someone is sexually attracted is not sexist by itself either.
 
Last edited:
Bookitty - Did you miss this post? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7406717#post7406717

There's so much straw being thrown around here every time a crow flies overhead I think it's a monkey.

I believe Dr. Buzzo had a camera on his shoe and Dr Adequate was giving out unsolicited tonsillectomies with his tongue (are they really doctors?). I stated unequivocally that this was unacceptable and that they should have been tossed from TAM and banned for life. I don't think anyone has "dismissed" those incidents nor do I think anyone has disagreed with my suggested actions by the JREF.

What Dr. Adequate did was a crime - sexual assault. Somebody should have notified the JREF. RemieV said she was too upset to pass it on. I think if I had been there and witnessed it, I would have put him on the ground before anyone had a chance to stop me. I would have definitely pitched a fit with the JREF until they did something about it.

What Dr. Buzzo did is a crime in just about every state, and in those few states where it's not explicitly a crime, it could be prosecuted under other statutes. You have the legal right to take pictures of people in public, but you don't have a right to take pictures of them when there's a reasonable expectation of privacy. Thus taking a picture of a woman in her skirt is legal even if unwanted, but it's illegal to take a picture up her skirt.

Meg's wonderful speech and the JREF's announcement about unwanted sexual advances would not work with those kinds of guys. They need eight-knuckle enlightenment.

Do those guys mean there's a problem in the skeptical community? If the JREF was notified and did nothing, then, yes, that's a huge problem. Did people not speak up to the JREF? If yes, then it's a problem, and that's the fault of everyone who witnessed it regardless of gender.

But as I understand it, over 1,000 people attend TAM. Put together any group that size, and you'll have at least a dozen truly messed up individuals walking around. That's par for the course.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom