Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually I gave the recommendation that you don't hijack words, as it makes your posts appear (more) nonsensical.

You are correct in saying that physicist do sometimes use existing words to name things. However, they take care to mention that they are using those words to mean something different from the usual definition.

For example, when physicist named the quarks 'up' and 'down', they didn't just give a press release stating: "All atoms consist of up and down! There's also strange! If you don't agree, you're idiots!".

Physicists also take care to choose words that are not intentionally confusing. There's a good reason no quark is called 'grain of sand' or 'a really small ball of cheese' - because those names would be confusing.

You, however, did not take such care. You originally called your blorg an 'environment', and only at a much later time graced us with the knowledge that it was, in fact an 'environment', a word you've defined to mean something contradictory. You also deliberately chose to hijack a word that sounds kind of similar to the idea you are proposing, but is really completely different. You could have explained that as a human error. However, as you've continued to defend your idea, the only possible explanation for this is dishonesty. Well, that and insanity, but the latter should always be implied.

This is exactly what draws me to this forum. More often than not someone else will post my exact sentiments on a given issue in a much more eloquent and coherent way than I ever could. Thank you.
 
Maybe we could just remove the snarking portion from our posts? It would save both of us some time. I won't use ad homs to escape your questions if you won't use ad homs to escape mine?

Again, it was a conditional statement, tied to a question you've again refused to answer. Here it is again:

Do you believe every one, or a substantial percentage of the posters disagreeing with you here are doing so dishonestly, and secretly think you're right?

Well, you asked for it.

One that was contradictory and fairly nonsensical.

Because it's nonsensical.


Rebuttals like "silly" and "nonsense" do not proceed from analytical skill but from intellectual doubt.

Because you keep dodging the issue and hand-waving arguments away.

After you'd already shown your dishonesty in argumentation several times, the insults started appearing. However, they usually don't substitute rebuttals, but merely flavor them. Your apparent inability to notice the difference is a part of the abovementioned dishonesty.

Because your idea is entirely founded on trickery with words. Sure, you can define the words to mean "I am always right", but by doing so, you make them rather meaningless.

I've seen you do it with almost every question you've been asked. Are you expecting praise?

I don't recall seeing any rebuttals to the effect 'it is only a thought experiment'. I've seen many to the effect 'it is a bad thought experiment', 'it isn't a real thought experiment', 'it makes no sense' and 'it's just trickery with words'. On the other hand, your responses have indeed amounted to 'claiming the leeway of a thought experiment'. It's telling that you don't seem to see the problem in that.

Anyway, the part about thought experiments was a side-track. It may be helpful to review your main claim, which I believe to be "This theory is a possible explanation for the beginning of the universe". Now, I disagree, and so do many others, for reasons presented multiple times above. If you're willing to let go of this claim, then I have no problem with calling it a thought experiment, though a failed one.

How does a thought experiment fail?

I must have missed that. Surely you meant to link to them here, and are not being intentionally vague to make it more difficult to follow your ideas?

It's on the this page that you read.
Yes, yes. Zing.
What is wrong with your brain?

I suppose I must agree with the amusingness, or I wouldn't be posting here. But luckily for me, there's not much room for disappointment anymore.

You keep making rebuttals that have no content.

The main rebuttal I have heard is that you don't like that way I have used the word "environment", as if that is any kind of a rebuttal to the ideas, as if I hadn't explained my usage, as if you have been paying attention.

You have made many inane rebuttals, I challenged, and you dropped them. You should consider that a big red flag hand-waving over your skills.
 
A thought experiment is a proposal for testing the truth of some hypothesis.

Here is an example of a thought experiments in the field of science:

Hypothesis: Light has mass.

Test for evidence of the refraction of light as it passes a very massive object: e.g.
The light from the star Vega when it emerges from behind the sun just after a solar eclipse.

Here is a hypothesis in the field of metaphysics:

Hypothesis: An infinite number of angels can dance on the head of a pin.

How does one test for evidence of this metaphysical statement?

Use meta-thoughts.
 
This is exactly what draws me to this forum. More often than not someone else will post my exact sentiments on a given issue in a much more eloquent and coherent way than I ever could. Thank you.

mirrorglass said:
You, however, did not take such care. You originally called your blorg an 'environment', and only at a much later time graced us with the knowledge that it was, in fact an 'environment', a word you've defined to mean something contradictory. You also deliberately chose to hijack a word that sounds kind of similar to the idea you are proposing, but is really completely different. You could have explained that as a human error. However, as you've continued to defend your idea, the only possible explanation for this is dishonesty. Well, that and insanity, but the latter should always be implied.

Suppose someone makes a factually false claim, either by intent or by intentional avoidance of the truth (see bolded comments above).

Now, this is certainly dishonest, and a lie by some definitions, although I wouldn't call it insane (unless that someone is incapable of telling the difference).

Is this the eloquence and coherency that you would emulate?

(Note the equivalence identified between hijacking a word and the dishonesty of defending an idea.)
 
How does a thought experiment fail?

Exactly like yours. Although I'm still wary of calling it that... It just doesn't seem fair, not even to failed thought experiments.

This one question from you explains all your failures in this thread. Thank you.
 
Rebuttals like "silly" and "nonsense" do not proceed from analytical skill but from intellectual doubt.



How does a thought experiment fail?



It's on the this page that you read.

What is wrong with your brain?



You keep making rebuttals that have no content.

The main rebuttal I have heard is that you don't like that way I have used the word "environment", as if that is any kind of a rebuttal to the ideas, as if I hadn't explained my usage, as if you have been paying attention.

You have made many inane rebuttals, I challenged, and you dropped them. You should consider that a big red flag hand-waving over your skills.

It seems like you have confused "thought experiment" with "baseless speculations"
 
Exactly like yours. Although I'm still wary of calling it that... It just doesn't seem fair, not even to failed thought experiments.

This one question from you explains all your failures in this thread. Thank you.

Your answer would have been better if it answered a question.
 
It seems like you have confused "thought experiment" with "baseless speculations"

The base of my speculation was that the universe does not need an explanation, i.e. god. The inference from your statement is that my base was unfounded, and, therefore, the universe has a cause. Is it your belief that god is the cause of our universe?
 
Rebuttals like "silly" and "nonsense" do not proceed from analytical skill but from intellectual doubt.

It's been explained a dozen of times by now why your ideas are silly and nonsensical, by me and others. That you ignore and apparently immediately forget those explanations does not mean they haven't been presented, and doesn't give me an obligation to restate the same things in each of my posts.

My rebuttal was not 'your point is silly'. 'Your point is silly', however, is a fair summary of the dozens of rebuttals that can easily be found upthread.

How does a thought experiment fail?

It's illogical. It doesn't prove anything. It demonstrates a lack of understanding in an astounding selection of subjects. It appears to involve no actual thought. It doesn't constitute an experiment.

Just one of these would suffice. You, however, managed to fill these conditions, and many more. I would congratulate you if I didn't feel sorry for you.


It's on the this page that you read.

I would suggest that this is either a lie or a delusion. I'd be interested to know which, though.

What is wrong with your brain?

There's a separate thread for that.

You keep making rebuttals that have no content.

Sigh. Do you happen to know what 'irony' means?

The main rebuttal I have heard is that you don't like that way I have used the word "environment", as if that is any kind of a rebuttal to the ideas, as if I hadn't explained my usage, as if you have been paying attention.

So you haven't heard the explanations on why your environment is contradictory? How you attempt to hide this fact by tricks? How your 'thought experiment' is really no such thing? That you keep insinuating that everybody here is lying while secretly agreeing with you? And all the other valid, well-founded arguments against you?

Yeah, I suppose I can believe that.

And it's not that I 'don't like' the way you've used the word 'environment'. It's that you've used the word 'environment' like a completely insane person and proceeded to insult everyone who points that out.

You have made many inane rebuttals, I challenged, and you dropped them. You should consider that a big red flag hand-waving over your skills.

This in a post where you addressed less than a fourth of the points I raised, even though you quoted the whole thing. Do you really not see more than few sentences of each post?
 
It's been explained a dozen of times by now why your ideas are silly and nonsensical, by me and others. That you ignore and apparently immediately forget those explanations does not mean they haven't been presented, and doesn't give me an obligation to restate the same things in each of my posts.

My rebuttal was not 'your point is silly'. 'Your point is silly', however, is a fair summary of the dozens of rebuttals that can easily be found upthread.

That was your rebuttal three separate times.

It's illogical. It doesn't prove anything. It demonstrates a lack of understanding in an astounding selection of subjects. It appears to involve no actual thought. It doesn't constitute an experiment.

Just one of these would suffice. You, however, managed to fill these conditions, and many more. I would congratulate you if I didn't feel sorry for you.

You have no clue what a thought experiment is, do you?

I would suggest that this is either a lie or a delusion. I'd be interested to know which, though.

I gave you the link to the page and you refused to verify and despite the evidence you prefer to stick with insults.
You just became a troll.

There's a separate thread for that.

Sigh. Do you happen to know what 'irony' means?

Would this be an example?: How ironic that I end up debating a thought experiment with someone for whom thought is still an experiment.

So you haven't heard the explanations on why your environment is contradictory? How you attempt to hide this fact by tricks? How your 'thought experiment' is really no such thing? That you keep insinuating that everybody here is lying while secretly agreeing with you? And all the other valid, well-founded arguments against you?

Yeah, I suppose I can believe that.

And it's not that I 'don't like' the way you've used the word 'environment'. It's that you've used the word 'environment' like a completely insane person and proceeded to insult everyone who points that out.

This in a post where you addressed less than a fourth of the points I raised, even though you quoted the whole thing. Do you really not see more than few sentences of each post?

I look for rebuttable content. You present very little.
 
That was your rebuttal three separate times.

No, it was how I referred to your points being refuted in detail before. You ignore intelligent answers, we know. But unlike you seem to think, that does not make you appear smart.


You have no clue what a thought experiment is, do you?

Again, can you provide a single example of a person who would agree with your definition of a thought experiment? If not, why do you think that is? Is the entire world perhaps in a conspiracy because they envy you?

I gave you the link to the page and you refused to verify and despite the evidence you prefer to stick with insults.
You just became a troll.

This is getting ridiculous. It's plain to anyone that your post contained no links. What do you expect to accomplish with obvious lies?


Would this be an example?: How ironic that I end up debating a thought experiment with someone for whom thought is still an experiment.

I'll take that as a 'no'.


I look for rebuttable content. You present very little.

I'll assume by 'refuttable' you mean content you would be capable of intelligently responding to. I agree.
 
The base of my speculation was that the universe does not need an explanation, i.e. god.

OK, with you so far...

The inference from your statement is that my base was unfounded, and, therefore, the universe has a cause. Is it your belief that god is the cause of our universe?

Aw, and you begun so well!

BZZZZZZ!! That's a blatant misrepresentation of tsig's statement, strawman, red herring and utter failure at using logic. Don't get me wrong, I'm not surprised. We're getting used to these from you. Keep'em coming, we'll keep batting'em out of the park!
 
Shamelessly stolen from Sledge from another thread, but quite appropriate, taking into account our very own Bill's phobia of trolls, which can be traced back quite a few pages.

troll.jpg


Funny, eh? :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom