Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
laca said:
The base of my speculation was that the universe does not need an explanation, i.e. god.

OK, with you so far...

The inference from your statement is that my base was unfounded, and, therefore, the universe has a cause. Is it your belief that god is the cause of our universe?

Aw, and you begun so well!

BZZZZZZ!! That's a blatant misrepresentation of tsig's statement, strawman, red herring and utter failure at using logic. Don't get me wrong, I'm not surprised. We're getting used to these from you. Keep'em coming, we'll keep batting'em out of the park!

It's actually also a blatant misrepresentation of his own theory. To bring back those fond memories, let's take a look at one of Bill's first posts in this thread:

Imagine an environment without space or time, without a universe. It has none of the limitations or laws that exist in our universe. An event can occur in this environment without cause, without limitations. Such a random event could result in the big bang that started our universe.
The is more evidence of this than of god.
Our universe had a beginning and, therefore, time and space had a beginning, and therefore, some environment did not have our universe nor time nor space.

Indeed, the base for Bill's logic was not 'the universe has no need for a cause'. This was one of the conclusions Bill drew from his theory. The base of the logic (or Bill's base, as he put it) was 'imagining an environment that has no space, no time, no universe and none of the limitations or laws that exist in our universe, but wherein events can occur'.

This 'base' is closely related to other concepts presented earlier in the thread to explain other unlikely conclusions. It is usually referred to as 'making crap up'.
 
Last edited:
The base of my speculation was that the universe does not need an explanation, i.e. god. The inference from your statement is that my base was unfounded, and, therefore, the universe has a cause. Is it your belief that god is the cause of our universe?

Bill, your response makes no sense whatsoever. Since you seem to reply almost at random I see no way to communicate with you.
 
We would have to define the "universe" also

I know it seems an obvious question, even simple. A simple answer would be appreciated.
If god is the cause of the existence of the universe, what was the cause of the existence of god?


By very definition - the Infinite Creator is the Uncaused Cause of all things.

To ask "Where did God come from?" or "What caused God?" are pseudo questions. Questions with false assumptions that God would actually "come from somewhere" or be caused.

The Infinite Creator is not only an Uncaused Cause of all finite existences, but the Infinite Creator is also atemporal and therefore would logically have NO beginning (since beginning would indicate a limitation of progressive consecutive linear duration).

Question the difference between Infinite Atemporal Existence and finite temporal existence (which moves from place to place).
 
While these five points are NOT the way I would present evidence for the Creator...Ba

1. Barney Stimson makes sense of the origin of the universe.

2. Barney Stimson makes sense of the fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life.

3. Barney Stimson makes sense of objective moral values in the world.

4. Barney Stimson makes sense of the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.

5. Barney Stimson can be immediately known and experienced.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

My argument is equally invalid to yours. Declarations do not make a valid argument.


The problem is with your "God concept." IOW, Barney Stimson is usually the name of a 'person' (English word which is problematic if not clarified and definied and differentiated from personae/hypostases) or a human being.

It makes NO sense to believe that something made up of matter can be responsible for the creation of ALL matter. That is why alluding to the Flying Spaghetti Monster or any other imaginary construct is so intellectually puerile (or utterly ridiculous). It doesn't address an Infinite Creator as a God concept NOR does it make sense.

If you wish to say that Barney Stimson is just a nomenclature for the Infinite Creator, then we would be questioning the validity of using such a label (or human name). Clearly Heavenly Father is anthropomorphic which models a relationship of Father/children and would be illogical to dissect with hyper-technicality.

Bottom line: Millions of people all over the world do NOT sing praise and worship songs to Barney Stimson (nor the Flying Spaghetti Monster)...
so these sorts of reductio ad absurdums are clearly incongruous and demonstrate disingenious investigation and analysis.
 
Last edited:
REAL Common Sense!

A better way to communicate the "common sense" of knowing that there IS indeed "a" Creator is to demonstrate the progression.

Yes, of course it is common sense to know that there is A Creator...but it is NOT common sense to know that Jesus Christ rose from the dead.

Christianity is based on faith (faith in particular evidence - which can unfortunately be denied and claimed it is not evidence) and conviction of God's Holy Spirit....

BUT!

Knowing that there is "A" Creator is indeed common sense. All you need is to NOT be indoctrinated with a philosophy in science which denies theistic implication.

Let's look at a logical progression for accumulative case argument for Christianity.

1. The Logical Fallacy of Strong Atheism which demonstrates that agnositicism or technical atheism (implicit) is the STARTING point.
- No assumptions about God or gods.

2. Evidence that first leads to "agnostic theism."

Most people in the world who have NOT been indoctrinated with circular materialistic/naturalist assumptions will indeed consider this step as common sense. It could be as basic as looking at identifiable biological information in RNA/DNA (not just a complexity argument). It could be as simple as identifying IF-THEN algorithmic programming in gene regulation of the Lactose
operon. It could be as simple as the common sense to know that factories don't build themselve and that the nano-factories of living cells and protein synthesis fully demonstrate a Factory Builder/Designer. (Not just a design
argument).

Only a person who is stuck in the circular reasoning of requiring naturalistic
explanations would be so naive as to claim this is an appeal to ignorance...
because THEY don't know the answer - because they have eliminated the
answer by eliminating theistic implication from science. Clearly, claiming
that "Intelligence" is required to do something is NOT an appeal to ignorance -especially when open for falsification at a very rudimentary level involving
any useful information or formation of any identifiable organic complex *working* system.

Yes, step # 2 WILL indeed come down to common sense once we begin to make the full blown argument...and the only ones that would resist such common sense are those who eliminate theistic implication from their search for truth in science because of invalid (and circular) definition.

Question everything.

Please note that point # 2 is NOT an argument for Christianity.
 
Progression to accumulative case argument

3. Specific scientific and mathematical evidence which leads to the conclusion of "Infinite Creator."

In step three - once we *conclude* agnostic theism through scientific observations, then we can look at the specifics in the universe which would
lead us to conclude what we would "expect" the/"A" Creator to need to be.

Not only the nature of mathematics. but also the nature of 3 dimensional existence and inner space as well as 'outer 3 dimensional existence.' This still doesn't prove that the Creator we are agnostic about is Infinite, that conclusion comes when we look that the nature of matter as well as positive and negative energies and other cosmological principles and philosophy that
demonstrate what we would expect the Creator of all matter and quantum space and (Originator of) time to be.

Clearly a more detailed argument than just the common sense of agnostic
theism.

4. Once we move from agnostic theism to Infinite Creator - then we can look at God concepts and Orthodox Monotheism and which religions had an Infinite Creator. This is a historical argument based on comparative religions.
It is under that expectation that at least one religion is correct in this world,
because God would have at some point in time communicated with at least
one of His cognitive beings. This will clearly lead us to Islam, Judaism and Christianity.

5. Will be an internal argument within Islam/Judaism/Christianity/Born-again Christianity to see which one of these belief structures is the most philosophically consistent.

We can also look at several things here... praise worship to an Infinite Creator (and who is doing it joyfully, peacefully, and with love) is one thing
we could look at. Another could be *a correct* presentation of Pascal's Wager (clearly Pascal didn't give one).

We can look at the logic of risk in that there would be no risk in believing
the truth about God...but there would be tremendous eternal risk in NOT believing the truth (especially if there is anything wrong with our own behaviors).

The real arguments in point 5 are going to be soteriological and exegetical.

Question these.
 
By very definition - the Infinite Creator is the Uncaused Cause of all things.

So you just define things into existence... Hey, I can do that too!

By very definition - the purple-farting monkey in the uncaused cause of all things!

To ask "Where did God come from?" or "What caused God?" are pseudo questions. Questions with false assumptions that God would actually "come from somewhere" or be caused.

That's called special pleading, but let's play your game...

To ask "where did the purple-farting monkey come from" or "what caused the purple-farting monkey" are pseudo questions. Questions with false assumptions that the purple-farting monkey would actually "come from somewhere" or be caused.

The Infinite Creator is not only an Uncaused Cause of all finite existences, but the Infinite Creator is also atemporal and therefore would logically have NO beginning (since beginning would indicate a limitation of progressive consecutive linear duration).

Would you mind explaining how an atemporal entity could cause anything? It being atemporal and all...

Question the difference between Infinite Atemporal Existence and finite temporal existence (which moves from place to place).

Wow that's a lot of gibberish for one post. You win!
 
Logical Justifiable Special Pleading

That's called special pleading,

The special pleading fallacy allows for justifiable special pleading. In this case - we are discussing Infinite Existence.

Any logic which FAILS to address the difference (special pleading) of Infinite Existence and finite existence - isn't logic at all.

It is rather confusion.

Purple monkeys (were they to exist) would be finite existences - that is
why your response is incongruous and illogical.

Question everything.
 
3. Specific scientific and mathematical evidence which leads to the conclusion of "Infinite Creator."

In step three - once we *conclude* agnostic theism through scientific observations, then we can look at the specifics in the universe which would
lead us to conclude what we would "expect" the/"A" Creator to need to be.

Not only the nature of mathematics. but also the nature of 3 dimensional existence and inner space as well as 'outer 3 dimensional existence.' This still doesn't prove that the Creator we are agnostic about is Infinite, that conclusion comes when we look that the nature of matter as well as positive and negative energies and other cosmological principles and philosophy that
demonstrate what we would expect the Creator of all matter and quantum space and (Originator of) time to be.

Clearly a more detailed argument than just the common sense of agnostic
theism.

4. Once we move from agnostic theism to Infinite Creator - then we can look at God concepts and Orthodox Monotheism and which religions had an Infinite Creator. This is a historical argument based on comparative religions.
It is under that expectation that at least one religion is correct in this world,
because God would have at some point in time communicated with at least
one of His cognitive beings. This will clearly lead us to Islam, Judaism and Christianity.

5. Will be an internal argument within Islam/Judaism/Christianity/Born-again Christianity to see which one of these belief structures is the most philosophically consistent.

We can also look at several things here... praise worship to an Infinite Creator (and who is doing it joyfully, peacefully, and with love) is one thing
we could look at. Another could be *a correct* presentation of Pascal's Wager (clearly Pascal didn't give one).

We can look at the logic of risk in that there would be no risk in believing the truth about God...but there would be tremendous eternal risk in NOT believing the truth (especially if there is anything wrong with our own behaviors).
The real arguments in point 5 are going to be soteriological and exegetical.

Question these.

Only if you pick the right god.

The risk of believing is that you can waste your life doing stupid things.
 
We can look at the logic of risk in that there would be no risk in believing the truth about God...but there would be tremendous eternal risk in NOT believing the truth (especially if there is anything wrong with our own behaviors).


What a disgusting statement of screwed-up values. Have you no integrity?

There is no god but, if there were, I would gladly oppose it and seek its destruction, especially if it were like your judeoxian monstrosity of a god.

Take your proselytization and insipid thinking elsewhere. Try the Sports forums - I never go there.
 
Refusing to acknowledge the right God/name calling/biblical inerrancy

Only if you pick the right god.

The risk of believing is that you can waste your life doing stupid things.

True.

And the "stupid"est "thing" you can do is NOT pray to the "right God."

Question everything!

But when you question...

pray for protection... (from that which is not from the "right God").


BTW,
"fundies" is nothing more than name calling... (especially at someone who identifies the problem with various forms of biblical inerrancy).

Name calling is sort of like saying curse words all of the time. It is really nothing more than a lazy mind trying to express itself.

Question name calling.
 
The special pleading fallacy allows for justifiable special pleading. In this case - we are discussing Infinite Existence.

Any logic which FAILS to address the difference (special pleading) of Infinite Existence and finite existence - isn't logic at all.

It is rather confusion.

Purple monkeys (were they to exist) would be finite existences - that is
why your response is incongruous and illogical.

Question everything.

All this stuff about finite/infinite existences is totally meaningless and arbitrary. Why would purple monkeys not be infinite existences?

Tell you something. They are. What is even more, they are infinitely infinite extences, in fact. Even most infinitely existingly, infinitely infinite existences.

Srsly.
 
Last edited:
The God of Abraham and His temporary creation to deal with the real problem of evil

if there were, I would gladly oppose it and seek its destruction,

This is illogical. How can you destroy infinite power?

The problem is that you have completely misunderstood the Torah/Tanakh and what God was doing with the Nation of Israel. You also don't see the philosophical inconsistency on your part of accusing an Infinite Creator of ever doing something wrong.

The problem is that your concept of God is far too small and you expect too little from Him. That is why you would hurl accusations of "murder" against the Giver and Taker of ALL life - including your own.

The LAW Giver does NOT commit unlawful killing...this too is philosophically inconsistent.

God is in control of all lifespans so to accuse Him of murder is ridiculous folly
and a demonstration that you do not understand what is really going on in this temporary creation.
 
The special pleading fallacy allows for justifiable special pleading. In this case - we are discussing Infinite Existence.

Any logic which FAILS to address the difference (special pleading) of Infinite Existence and finite existence - isn't logic at all.

It is rather confusion.

Purple monkeys (were they to exist) would be finite existences - that is
why your response is incongruous and illogical.

Question everything.

Purple monkeys typing endlessly on infinite typewriters will eventually reproduce this very thread.
 
True.

And the "stupid"est "thing" you can do is NOT pray to the "right God."

Question everything!

But when you question...

pray for protection... (from that which is not from the "right God").


BTW,
"fundies" is nothing more than name calling... (especially at someone who identifies the problem with various forms of biblical inerrancy).

Name calling is sort of like saying curse words all of the time. It is really nothing more than a lazy mind trying to express itself.

Question name calling.

You, of course, have the "right" god. Right.

Yes we're all lazy minds who would rather curse god and eat babies than pray. You might want to reconsider communication with such as we .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom