Mirrorglass
Illuminator
- Joined
- Mar 9, 2010
- Messages
- 3,464
laca said:The base of my speculation was that the universe does not need an explanation, i.e. god.
OK, with you so far...
The inference from your statement is that my base was unfounded, and, therefore, the universe has a cause. Is it your belief that god is the cause of our universe?
Aw, and you begun so well!
BZZZZZZ!! That's a blatant misrepresentation of tsig's statement, strawman, red herring and utter failure at using logic. Don't get me wrong, I'm not surprised. We're getting used to these from you. Keep'em coming, we'll keep batting'em out of the park!
It's actually also a blatant misrepresentation of his own theory. To bring back those fond memories, let's take a look at one of Bill's first posts in this thread:
Imagine an environment without space or time, without a universe. It has none of the limitations or laws that exist in our universe. An event can occur in this environment without cause, without limitations. Such a random event could result in the big bang that started our universe.
The is more evidence of this than of god.
Our universe had a beginning and, therefore, time and space had a beginning, and therefore, some environment did not have our universe nor time nor space.
Indeed, the base for Bill's logic was not 'the universe has no need for a cause'. This was one of the conclusions Bill drew from his theory. The base of the logic (or Bill's base, as he put it) was 'imagining an environment that has no space, no time, no universe and none of the limitations or laws that exist in our universe, but wherein events can occur'.
This 'base' is closely related to other concepts presented earlier in the thread to explain other unlikely conclusions. It is usually referred to as 'making crap up'.
Last edited: