Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
In my thought experiment on the water and rock I used pure water and a rock that doesn't leech or absorb minerals or heat.

In other word something which don't ever exists. "I define sun as being of cheese in my thought experiment". You could as well put an ad-hoc statement "i am right" for anything and be ride of it, if your thought experiment does not even have a link to any reality we know of.

By even then you change the potential energy of the water. QED.
 
It's a special rock that doesn't elevate the potential energy of its environment.

So it has ZERO volume.... Great. "I have water, I add nothing, the water stay the same".

I can come up with even more stuff which make your thought experiment stupid.

There will be some isotope. They will decay. Poof , your water changed anfd is not water anymore.

Proton decay. I wait long enough. Your water change, disappear. Poof.

And then you come up with more excuse "proton don't decay, there is no isotope".

And at the very end, it become all completely childish made up stuff with no bearing on a thought experiment anymore.
 
You made the claim that it is wrong to hijack words. I made the factual counter claim that that is standard practice among physicists.

Actually I gave the recommendation that you don't hijack words, as it makes your posts appear (more) nonsensical.

You are correct in saying that physicist do sometimes use existing words to name things. However, they take care to mention that they are using those words to mean something different from the usual definition.

For example, when physicist named the quarks 'up' and 'down', they didn't just give a press release stating: "All atoms consist of up and down! There's also strange! If you don't agree, you're idiots!".

Physicists also take care to choose words that are not intentionally confusing. There's a good reason no quark is called 'grain of sand' or 'a really small ball of cheese' - because those names would be confusing.

You, however, did not take such care. You originally called your blorg an 'environment', and only at a much later time graced us with the knowledge that it was, in fact an 'environment', a word you've defined to mean something contradictory. You also deliberately chose to hijack a word that sounds kind of similar to the idea you are proposing, but is really completely different. You could have explained that as a human error. However, as you've continued to defend your idea, the only possible explanation for this is dishonesty. Well, that and insanity, but the latter should always be implied.


My refutation: It's not silly.

Your debating skills astound me. Tell me, has anyone ever agreed that your idea makes sense? Why do you think people generally don't?

Simpler is not necessarily better or truer and I have never claimed either.
My condescending tone is for those who consistently attempt to misrepresent my hypothesis and my posts.

All right, so we agree that your idea is a worse and less true explanation for the beginning of the universe than the commonly accepted ones. Great. That's progress.

As for your tone.. your condescending tone is universally dished out to everyone you engage on the forums. Your statement here suggests that everyone commenting on your posts is misrepresenting them. Again I ask of you - do you honestly believe every single person on the forums is lying to you?

I notice you like to hedge your claims with conditionals ("it seemed to me', "if I'm reading this right") so that you cannot be pinned down on an actual statement.

When I make statements concerning the intent of other posters, I consider it polite to make clear that I don't have absolute knowledge of said intents, and that my impressions could be wrong. That shouldn't be taken as meaning that I don't stand behind my statements. Despite the conditionals, I truly believe you are either a huge liar, or a seriously deluded person. I'd be happy to be proved wrong, but don't expect to.

I wonder if you are transferring a predilection for conspiracy theories onto me because I challenge your opinions.

Well, no. I have asked you an actual question: do you truly believe everyone disagreeing with you is lying? You could simply answer it.

Anyway, I don't really have a strong opinion on the beginning of the universe, and if I did, you'd have a pretty long way to go before challenging it. The reason I engage you is not because I find your theories strangely fascinating; it's because I don't like letting silly claims and dishonest argumentation go unchallenged. And the fact that you keep practicing them in one of my favourite threads.
 
In other word something which don't ever exists.

Do you wonder if maybe cosmologists use thought experiments because they don't know what exists?

"I define sun as being of cheese in my thought experiment". You could as well put an ad-hoc statement "i am right" for anything and be ride of it, if your thought experiment does not even have a link to any reality we know of.

I know of a reality where scientists think about the beginning of our universe.
What reality are you in?

By even then you change the potential energy of the water. QED.

Well, I didn't change the potential energy of real water, it was only thought water.
 
So it has ZERO volume.... Great. "I have water, I add nothing, the water stay the same".

I can come up with even more stuff which make your thought experiment stupid.

There will be some isotope. They will decay. Poof , your water changed anfd is not water anymore.

Proton decay. I wait long enough. Your water change, disappear. Poof.

And then you come up with more excuse "proton don't decay, there is no isotope".

And at the very end, it become all completely childish made up stuff with no bearing on a thought experiment anymore.

Enough already, you don't get "thought experiment", I understand.
 
Actually I gave the recommendation that you don't hijack words, as it makes your posts appear (more) nonsensical.

You are correct in saying that physicist do sometimes use existing words to name things. However, they take care to mention that they are using those words to mean something different from the usual definition.

For example, when physicist named the quarks 'up' and 'down', they didn't just give a press release stating: "All atoms consist of up and down! There's also strange! If you don't agree, you're idiots!".

Physicists also take care to choose words that are not intentionally confusing. There's a good reason no quark is called 'grain of sand' or 'a really small ball of cheese' - because those names would be confusing.

You, however, did not take such care. You originally called your blorg an 'environment', and only at a much later time graced us with the knowledge that it was, in fact an 'environment', a word you've defined to mean something contradictory. You also deliberately chose to hijack a word that sounds kind of similar to the idea you are proposing, but is really completely different. You could have explained that as a human error. However, as you've continued to defend your idea, the only possible explanation for this is dishonesty. Well, that and insanity, but the latter should always be implied.

Your debating skills astound me. Tell me, has anyone ever agreed that your idea makes sense? Why do you think people generally don't?

All right, so we agree that your idea is a worse and less true explanation for the beginning of the universe than the commonly accepted ones. Great. That's progress.

As for your tone.. your condescending tone is universally dished out to everyone you engage on the forums. Your statement here suggests that everyone commenting on your posts is misrepresenting them. Again I ask of you - do you honestly believe every single person on the forums is lying to you?

When I make statements concerning the intent of other posters, I consider it polite to make clear that I don't have absolute knowledge of said intents, and that my impressions could be wrong. That shouldn't be taken as meaning that I don't stand behind my statements. Despite the conditionals, I truly believe you are either a huge liar, or a seriously deluded person. I'd be happy to be proved wrong, but don't expect to.

Well, no. I have asked you an actual question: do you truly believe everyone disagreeing with you is lying? You could simply answer it.

Anyway, I don't really have a strong opinion on the beginning of the universe, and if I did, you'd have a pretty long way to go before challenging it. The reason I engage you is not because I find your theories strangely fascinating; it's because I don't like letting silly claims and dishonest argumentation go unchallenged. And the fact that you keep practicing them in one of my favourite threads.

I couldn't find anything with enough substance in your tirade to refute.
I wonder if you have actually engaged in a real live debate.
Your analytical abilities tell me "not with any success."

For example:
What is it that you are claiming that I have either lied about or am deluded about?

Consider this:

I presented a simple little scenario that describes an uncaused universe.
Look at how furiously many people have attacked this idea.
Look at how many directions the idea has been attacked from.
Look at how many attacks resort to an ad hominem argument (and when you substitute an insult for a rebuttal it is an ad hominem).
Look at how the attacks are against words (that I have defined) instead of ideas.
Look at how often the goal posts have been moved when I have responded to a question.
Note that many of my rebuttals have been to the effect that "it is only a thought experiment. I claim the leeway of a thought experiment, but I do not claim more than that".
I even provided the two fundamental areas of challenge to the thought experiment. No one made a challenge on either.

It is disappointing. It is amusing.
 
I couldn't find anything with enough substance in your tirade to refute.
I wonder if you have actually engaged in a real live debate.
Your analytical abilities tell me "not with any success."

Maybe we could just remove the snarking portion from our posts? It would save both of us some time. I won't use ad homs to escape your questions if you won't use ad homs to escape mine?

For example:
What is it that you are claiming that I have either lied about or am deluded about?

Again, it was a conditional statement, tied to a question you've again refused to answer. Here it is again:

Do you believe every one, or a substantial percentage of the posters disagreeing with you here are doing so dishonestly, and secretly think you're right?

Consider this:

Well, you asked for it.
I presented a simple little scenario that describes an uncaused universe.

One that was contradictory and fairly nonsensical.

Look at how furiously many people have attacked this idea.

Because it's nonsensical.

Look at how many directions the idea has been attacked from.

Because you keep dodging the issue and hand-waving arguments away.

Look at how many attacks resort to an ad hominem argument (and when you substitute an insult for a rebuttal it is an ad hominem).

After you'd already shown your dishonesty in argumentation several times, the insults started appearing. However, they usually don't substitute rebuttals, but merely flavor them. Your apparent inability to notice the difference is a part of the abovementioned dishonesty.


Look at how the attacks are against words (that I have defined) instead of ideas.

Because your idea is entirely founded on trickery with words. Sure, you can define the words to mean "I am always right", but by doing so, you make them rather meaningless.

Look at how often the goal posts have been moved when I have responded to a question.

I've seen you do it with almost every question you've been asked. Are you expecting praise?

Note that many of my rebuttals have been to the effect that "it is only a thought experiment. I claim the leeway of a thought experiment, but I do not claim more than that".

I don't recall seeing any rebuttals to the effect 'it is only a thought experiment'. I've seen many to the effect 'it is a bad thought experiment', 'it isn't a real thought experiment', 'it makes no sense' and 'it's just trickery with words'. On the other hand, your responses have indeed amounted to 'claiming the leeway of a thought experiment'. It's telling that you don't seem to see the problem in that.

Anyway, the part about thought experiments was a side-track. It may be helpful to review your main claim, which I believe to be "This theory is a possible explanation for the beginning of the universe". Now, I disagree, and so do many others, for reasons presented multiple times above. If you're willing to let go of this claim, then I have no problem with calling it a thought experiment, though a failed one.

I even provided the two fundamental areas of challenge to the thought experiment. No one made a challenge on either.

I must have missed that. Surely you meant to link to them here, and are not being intentionally vague to make it more difficult to follow your ideas?

It is disappointing. It is amusing.

I suppose I must agree with the amusingness, or I wouldn't be posting here. But luckily for me, there's not much room for disappointment anymore.
 
A thought experiment is a proposal for testing the truth of some hypothesis.

Here is an example of a thought experiments in the field of science:

Hypothesis: Light has mass.

Test for evidence of the refraction of light as it passes a very massive object: e.g.
The light from the star Vega when it emerges from behind the sun just after a solar eclipse.

Here is a hypothesis in the field of metaphysics:

Hypothesis: An infinite number of angels can dance on the head of a pin.

How does one test for evidence of this metaphysical statement?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom