Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is illogical. How can you destroy infinite power?

The problem is that you have completely misunderstood the Torah/Tanakh and what God was doing with the Nation of Israel. You also don't see the philosophical inconsistency on your part of accusing an Infinite Creator of ever doing something wrong.

The problem is that your concept of God is far too small and you expect too little from Him. That is why you would hurl accusations of "murder" against the Giver and Taker of ALL life - including your own.

The LAW Giver does NOT commit unlawful killing...this too is philosophically inconsistent.

God is in control of all lifespans so to accuse Him of murder is ridiculous folly
and a demonstration that you do not understand what is really going on in this temporary creation.

Infinite power is illogical. If it were to exist then there could be no other existences.
 
I've misunderstood nothing, you proselytizing fundie.

I have great contempt for the your conception of 'god' and would regard it as my honor-bound obligation to attempt to destroy it were it real (which it is not).

I yearn for the destruction of your religion through education, reason, and science.
 
The Right God = The Infinite Creator

You, of course, have the "right" god. Right.

There are millions of people who worship the "right" God.

Here is evidence of such worship:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejg7haph29w

The end of this song when everyone stands and worships is unique to ONE belief structure throughout the Christian denominations....

born-again Christians.

If you hate them then question "why?"

The joy, the love, the praise, the peace, etc. is unique to born-again Christians singing praise music.

Question everything....especially the end of this song!!! When he (David) sings that "were the whole realm" of the universe given to him...it would be a gift FAR TOO small in comparison to God's Eternal Love.
 
Evidence for the Existence of "a" Creator can not be denied on the basis of rejecting

the so called "bible"

I've misunderstood nothing, you proselytizing fundie.

I have great contempt for the your conception of 'god' and would regard it as my honor-bound obligation to attempt to destroy it were it real (which it is not).

I yearn for the destruction of your religion through education, reason, and science.

You can NOT destroy what is eternal...neither can you destroy the Nation of Israel (though some day the world will try and look like they are about to succeed).

You can not destroy what is experienced... neither can you destroy the Infinite All (logically) Powerful Creator.

Question everything!
 
There are millions of people who worship the "right" God.

Here is evidence of such worship:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejg7haph29w

The end of this song when everyone stands and worships is unique to ONE belief structure throughout the Christian denominations....

born-again Christians.

If you hate them then question "why?"

The joy, the love, the praise, the peace, etc. is unique to born-again Christians singing praise music.

Question everything....especially the end of this song!!! When he (David) sings that "were the whole realm" of the universe given to him...it would be a gift FAR TOO small in comparison to God's Eternal Love.

Anyone who could make a post like that needs to get out more...
 
The problem is that your concept of God is far too small and you expect too little from Him.

You have to be quite a special brand to accuse others of having too small a concept of God, and in the same sentence reference that God by using the pronoun "Him."

"Her" would be no better.

"It". Now there is something. But that would not nearly be as confusing as using this persistent anthropomorphism when referring to something which (or so I feel sought to be convinced) is not an anthropomorphic Skydaddy.


Tell you a secret. God does not have any existence independent of the paint, the metaphor when referring to ... Him.
 
the so called "bible"



You can NOT destroy what is eternal...neither can you destroy the Nation of Israel (though some day the world will try and look like they are about to succeed).

You can not destroy what is experienced... neither can you destroy the Infinite All (logically) Powerful Creator.

Question everything!

I reckon one big meteorite or comet would do it for Israel. Then maybe make the human race extinct. Where would old Jahweh be then, with no suckers around to tell Him how great He is all day long?
 
People worshiping their lot at nature's whim,
Bemoaning loss as recompense for evils dreamt,
Or wants that make us men.
 
Is sayiing God is a Heavenly Father expecting too little from God?

to accuse others of having too small a concept of God, and in the same sentence reference that God by using the pronoun "Him."

"Her" would be no better.

Clearly God is neither male nor female - BUT the Man that God became (Jesus Christ) referred to "Him" as a Heavenly Father because it spiritually models the Father/children relationship.

This concept of being revealed in the masculine in scripture, however, is not an issue - neither can it be reduced to your "sky daddy" anthropomorphism - since God doesn't just exist in "the sky."

Attempting to reduce the Infinite Creator through phrases which clearly defame Him are quite different than endearing references which personalize Him.

What I was referring to, however, was a lack of understanding with respect to theodicy and judgements (as well as biblical difficulties). Often the problem is that the person has a view of the Infinite Creator which is far too small and therefore they illogically reduce God to an evil dictator or a monster.

This is because they fail to understand what is really going on in this temporary creation and God's relationship to the finite creation.

It is often seeing the difference between responsibility or "wrong doing"..or the difference between causation verse together acting with causes (sunergeism).

Clearly I am over-simplifying for concision sake.
 
Creator/creatures Infinite/finite Logic/illogical special pleading fallacy

First "special pleading is justified for my case of special pleading" and then "one group does something unique therefore god"?

And it's only Tuesday!

Even if you confuse the novelty fallacy with a special pleading fallacy, you are still failing to address the premises of the observation(s).

You can attempt to use alleged logic all you want to...but any logic which does NOT address the difference between a "Creator" and all finite creatures isn't logic at all.

It is clearly confusion.
 
Potential infinite power VERSES an actual demonstration of infinite power that is ill

Infinite power is illogical. If it were to exist then there could be no other existences.

The problem is that we have equivocation with the English word "power" here.

If you are thinking of something materialistic like "energy" then I would agree that it would appear illogical.

Clearly there are positive and negative energies which have to be accounted for..and nothing (matter) is infinitely dense neither could you have infinite energy in the same defined "space" and have matter. This would be illogical.

So......in otherwords...I spoke imperfectly with the human language and clarification is needed lest we have equivocation on the English word "power" here in reference to an Infinite Creator.

Not everything is strictly materialistic (empirical). This adds to the complication of the spiritual dynamic.

Q.E.
 
If you use any finite example (like king or dictator) to address worship itself then

your response is incongruous to the Infinite Owner and Sustainer of the universe
I reckon one big meteorite or comet would do it for Israel.

What "if" God's protection makes such a thing impossible? You need to realize that every time you "assume" such things are possible you are actually starting with an assumption.

(responses involving assuming God here are incongruous to how God is clearly concluded and all of the alleged evidence for such conclusion).

Then maybe make the human race extinct. Where would old Jahweh be then, with no suckers around to tell Him how great He is all day long?

This is an example of a God concept that is far too small and you expect
way too little from such Infinite Creator.

God does NOT need to be worshipped. Worship doesn't appease God.

Worship is actually for "us" (but the question is "why?")

Question everything.
 
You can attempt to use alleged logic all you want to...but any logic which does NOT address the difference between a "Creator" and all finite creatures isn't logic at all.

It is clearly confusion.
So much for Boolean algebraWP, propositional logicWP, first-order predicate calculusWP, lambda calculusWP, Floyd-Hoare logicWP, TCP/IPWP, and all that rot.

Serious question for Breckmin: By what technology do you post this stuff?
 
Clearly God is neither male nor female

Strictly speaking ... No, it is not clear. At all. It is just agreed upon by the theological ivory tower.

Meanwhile, hoi polloi loves "Him." Like mad.


- BUT the Man that God became (Jesus Christ) referred to "Him" as a Heavenly Father because it spiritually models the Father/children relationship.

What does it mean to spiritually model? Apart from nothing, I mean. I could understand it were you to simply say that it models some relationship, sans the spiritual that is.

And I would even agree.


This concept of being revealed in the masculine in scripture, however, is not an issue - neither can it be reduced to your "sky daddy" anthropomorphism - since God doesn't just exist in "the sky."

Attempting to reduce the Infinite Creator through phrases which clearly defame Him are quite different than endearing references which personalize Him.

It is just different paint. No more. Just more agreeable, nicer colors.

Strip away the paint. And nothing that any atheist in the whole wide world would feel contradicted by remains.



What I was referring to, however, was a lack of understanding with respect to theodicy and judgements (as well as biblical difficulties). Often the problem is that the person has a view of the Infinite Creator which is far too small and therefore they illogically reduce God to an evil dictator or a monster.

Ha. Ha. Ha. Again, you yourself have nothing* more than your (essentially meaningless) metaphors to paint you agreeable, yet inherently misleading and confusing pictures, and yet you persist in calling others' view of the Infinite Creator too small?

Wow.




* OK, there is this theological techno-babble, eg. infinite, suregism, blah, but that is devoid of meaning too.


This is because they fail to understand what is really going on in this temporary creation and God's relationship to the finite creation.

It is often seeing the difference between responsibility or "wrong doing"..or the difference between causation verse together acting with causes (sunergeism).

Clearly I am over-simplifying for concision sake.
 
The problem is that we have equivocation with the English word "power" here.

If you are thinking of something materialistic like "energy" then I would agree that it would appear illogical.

Clearly there are positive and negative energies which have to be accounted for..and nothing (matter) is infinitely dense neither could you have infinite energy in the same defined "space" and have matter. This would be illogical.

So......in otherwords...I spoke imperfectly with the human language and clarification is needed lest we have equivocation on the English word "power" here in reference to an Infinite Creator.

Not everything is strictly materialistic (empirical). This adds to the complication of the spiritual dynamic.

Q.E.

Infinite Creator. Could you explain this term?

Yes the spiritual dynamic has the complication of never being seen.
 
There are millions of people who worship the "right" God.

Here is evidence of such worship:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ejg7haph29w

The end of this song when everyone stands and worships is unique to ONE belief structure throughout the Christian denominations....

born-again Christians.

If you hate them then question "why?"

The joy, the love, the praise, the peace, etc. is unique to born-again Christians singing praise music.

Question everything....especially the end of this song!!! When he (David) sings that "were the whole realm" of the universe given to him...it would be a gift FAR TOO small in comparison to God's Eternal Love.

The "right' god has the "right" songs?
 
The special pleading fallacy allows for justifiable special pleading. In this case - we are discussing Infinite Existence.

Haha, look what you wrote!

Any logic which FAILS to address the difference (special pleading) of Infinite Existence and finite existence - isn't logic at all.

It is rather confusion.

Who's confused here?

Purple monkeys (were they to exist) would be finite existences - that is
why your response is incongruous and illogical.

Wrong. First of all it's not "purple monkeys" but the ONE and ONLY ALMIGHTY purple farting monkey. It farts the color purple. It is special. It has infinite existence. And it farted everything into existence!

Question everything.

No. That would make life unbearable.
 
True.

And the "stupid"est "thing" you can do is NOT pray to the "right God."

No. The stupidest thing is to pray to any god without any evidence whatsoever that it even exists,let alone it being the "right" one.

Question everything!

But when you question...

pray for protection... (from that which is not from the "right God").

That doesn't even make sense.
 
This is illogical. How can you destroy infinite power?

No more illogical than infinite power. There can be no infinite power. It's self-defeating.

The problem is that you have completely misunderstood the Torah/Tanakh and what God was doing with the Nation of Israel. You also don't see the philosophical inconsistency on your part of accusing an Infinite Creator of ever doing something wrong.

No, the problem is that your god does not exist.

The problem is that your concept of God is far too small and you expect too little from Him. That is why you would hurl accusations of "murder" against the Giver and Taker of ALL life - including your own.

Again, the problem is that your god does not exist. But if it did, it would sure as hell be responsible for all the genocide, murders, rapes it committed.

The LAW Giver does NOT commit unlawful killing...this too is philosophically inconsistent.

You're basically saying that your god may do anything it wants. Most people are opposed to such extreme dictatorship. YMMV.

God is in control of all lifespans so to accuse Him of murder is ridiculous folly
and a demonstration that you do not understand what is really going on in this temporary creation.

Let me repeat: your god does not exist.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom