Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
By very definition - the Infinite Creator is the Uncaused Cause of all things.

Whether that's true or not, it's irrelevant. The "infinite creation" is an invention; and an impossibility.

To ask "Where did God come from?" or "What caused God?" are pseudo questions. Questions with false assumptions that God would actually "come from somewhere" or be caused.

It's a reasonable question, since people like you continue to claim that NOTHING is uncaused.

The Infinite Creator is not only an Uncaused Cause of all finite existences, but the Infinite Creator is also atemporal and therefore would logically have NO beginning (since beginning would indicate a limitation of progressive consecutive linear duration).

And there is also no reason to assume "his" existence.
 
The special pleading fallacy allows for justifiable special pleading. In this case - we are discussing Infinite Existence.

So are we. But we don't evoke sky-daddies to plug the holes of our ignorance.

We can look at the logic of risk in that there would be no risk in believing the truth about God...but there would be tremendous eternal risk in NOT believing the truth (especially if there is anything wrong with our own behaviors).

Oh, won't you be sorry when you die and find out you should've believed in Zeus ?
 
Good god. This guy might be the most horrible fundie I've seen yet. I don't think I can bring myself to read his posts.
 
the so called "bible"



You can NOT destroy what is eternal...neither can you destroy the Nation of Israel (though some day the world will try and look like they are about to succeed).

You can not destroy what is experienced... neither can you destroy the Infinite All (logically) Powerful Creator.

Question everything!


Including your sanity.

I don't need to destroy your 'god' because it doesn't exist. It was made up by people.

You can give it whatever attributes you choose to - you are continuing to make it up, after all - but it still imaginary.

Fundies are insane.
 
By very definition - the Infinite Creator is the Uncaused Cause of all things.

To ask "Where did God come from?" or "What caused God?" are pseudo questions. Questions with false assumptions that God would actually "come from somewhere" or be caused.

The Infinite Creator is not only an Uncaused Cause of all finite existences, but the Infinite Creator is also atemporal and therefore would logically have NO beginning (since beginning would indicate a limitation of progressive consecutive linear duration).

Phew, so that's all right then. For a moment I thought we might have to think about how things came to be, or even admit to not knowing.

Question the difference between Infinite Atemporal Existence and finite temporal existence (which moves from place to place).

OK, so what is the difference between Infinite Atemporal Existence and finite temporal existence (which moves from place to place) ?

(not sure if this is a joke)
 
Any evidence for this "god" thing yet?

Our most recent wannabee is presenting evidence for a pretty pathetic and stupid thing that seems to be based on nothing more than ignorance and delusion. For some weird reason, he wants people to call this fantasy, "god".
 
Some creationist are ashamed of what some creationists will stoop down to. :)
 
OK... Some skin, crawling in certain ways, is kinda cool.

But don't tell anyone I ever said that.

Is anyone else already bored to tears with this fundie?

We deserve better fundies.
At least we're back on topic. I love cosmology(even woo cosmology) but it belongs in the science section.
 
Welcome back, Breckmin!

I hate when a fundamentalist won't believe I really don't believe in God. It's accusing me of lying just because they can't wrap their heads around my position. So, I hate to sound like I'm doing the same thing, BUT....

It seems to me that when God's defenders make up stuff about him as they go along, throwing out ad hoc attributes for him to make the concept more unfalseafiable; it's like they know God isn't really real, so they can spin him however they want. It's like asking a child how Santa Clause delivers toys to all the boys and girls in the world in one night, they'll just make up an answer if they haven't thought about it before. There's nothing in the Bible about God being atemporal, but it sounds superficially plausible, and that's all Breckmin (or the originator of this particular 'patch') needs. This is not what we do with real beings. With real beings, when someone points out an inconsistency or seeming contradiction, we examine or question the entity in question to find out the truth, and if we are unable to do that, we let it remain a mystery until further information is forthcoming. If someone says something like 'General Patton was so busy, he must never have had time to eat!', I'm not going to say 'well, he had an adjutant beside him at all times to insert food into his mouth when it wasn't busy issuing orders or grimacing determinedly'. I'll find out or say 'beats me'...and if I was interested enought, I would question the contention being made in the first place. Not so with God. There has to be an answer, and the first thing that comes to mind that seems to stick is adopted.

How can we take contentions about God seriously when there are so many ad hoc rationalizations that have no more evidential merit than 'Santa Clause can shrink himself to fit down chimneys'?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom