Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
saying that the water itself did not change. Well, in a sense, that's true.

That is not even fully true,depending on what he define waters. If he define it as the chemical, then really it is a useless piece of info. If he define itas the body the rock were thrown it, it is non sense, as the water body DID change :
1) leeching minerals will change solidification temperature as well as boiling one
2) the temperature of the rock will change the water temperature, it will also change the way the ice form (independently of the temperature)
3) it will change the volume occupied by the water, therefore expanding the water volume. Through trivial it is still a change (and as pointed out it will change the energy potential of it)
4) leeching mineral also change the water conductivity

Etc...

So really, he is not even correct on the "water will not change".
 
Last edited:
Billy boy, how about addressing Tricky's point, instead of conveniently ignoring it? You know who used to do that? Radrook. I wonder when you start abusing the ignore function as well.
 
That is not even fully true,depending on what he define waters. If he define it as the chemical, then really it is a useless piece of info. If he define itas the body the rock were thrown it, it is non sense, as the water body DID change :
1) leeching minerals will change solidification temperature as well as boiling one
2) the temperature of the rock will change the water temperature, it will also change the way the ice form (independently of the temperature)
3) it will change the volume occupied by the water, therefore expanding the water volume. Through trivial it is still a change
4) leeching mineral also change the water conductivity

Etc...

So really, he is not even correct on the "water will not change".

Sounding a little like a refutation of homeopathy here. :):p
 
I don't know what unique form of reasoning you used to reach this conclusion.

Yes, it's quite obvious that you don't. All I can do is suggest you learn a bit. Reasoning is really not as unique as you seem to think.



Since the topic of my thought experiment was not a common idea I used the word "environment" with a specific detailed meaning.

One that had nothing to do with the usual meaning assigned to the word 'environment'. In the future, if you're suggesting a concept for which no word exists, don't hijack an existing one; just make up a new one. How about 'Blorg'? So your theory could be:

"In the beginning, there was a non-spatial, atemporal Blorg in which nothing existed. Then something randomly started to exist within the Blorg. That something was our universe."

There. Much better.


I don't think that would lessen your confusion.

Probably not. It might lessen yours, though I'm not too optimistic on that.

Here is the cosmologist's version.

At first, there may have been nothing.
Our universe appeared without any known reason.
We don't know if it can happen again.
Let's think of some scenarios that could answer these mysteries.

Sounds ridiculous doesn't it?

That part is quite smart. Coincidentally, it's also the part someone else already thought of, not the part you introduced.

What you did was introduce a Blorg as the reason for the universe, and demand everyone accept it's the best explanation, despite it making little sense. Then you proceeded to call everyone who disagreed with you names and generally act as if you were surrounded by dirty peasants.

And that, old chap, is quite ridiculous.
 
If it is a magic man in the sky that would be a ridiculous answer because it only adds another layer to the question without telling us anything.

Paul

If it is
a magic man = James Randi
in the sky = spiritual existence
that would be a ridiculous answer = a paradox
because it only adds another layer = a second foundation
to the question without telling us anything = a mystery.

You think that James Randi, a supposed atheist, is the second coming of Christ?
:jaw-dropp
 
That is not even fully true,depending on what he define waters. If he define it as the chemical, then really it is a useless piece of info. If he define itas the body the rock were thrown it, it is non sense, as the water body DID change :
1) leeching minerals will change solidification temperature as well as boiling one
2) the temperature of the rock will change the water temperature, it will also change the way the ice form (independently of the temperature)
3) it will change the volume occupied by the water, therefore expanding the water volume. Through trivial it is still a change (and as pointed out it will change the energy potential of it)
4) leeching mineral also change the water conductivity

Etc...

So really, he is not even correct on the "water will not change".

In my thought experiment on the water and rock I used pure water and a rock that doesn't leech or absorb minerals or heat.
 
One that had nothing to do with the usual meaning assigned to the word 'environment'. In the future, if you're suggesting a concept for which no word exists, don't hijack an existing one; just make up a new one. How about 'Blorg'? So your theory could be:

"In the beginning, there was a non-spatial, atemporal Blorg in which nothing existed. Then something randomly started to exist within the Blorg. That something was our universe."

There. Much better.

I was thinking of using some words that physicists would never think of hijacking, like flavor, up, down, charm, strange, top, or bottom. Would that satisfy your disgust?

That part is quite smart. Coincidentally, it's also the part someone else already thought of, not the part you introduced.

The part I introduced fits right in with the others under "scenario".

What you did was introduce a Blorg as the reason for the universe, and demand everyone accept it's the best explanation, despite it making little sense. Then you proceeded to call everyone who disagreed with you names and generally act as if you were surrounded by dirty peasants.

Yes, I did introduce a new possibility.
No, I have never claimed this was the best explanation.

If the disagreement is an intentional falsehood then I would only call the dirty peasants liars.
 
I was thinking of using some words that physicists would never think of hijacking, like flavor, up, down, charm, strange, top, or bottom. Would that satisfy your disgust?

Tell me, do you ever answer the points people make, or do you invariably try to sidetrack the conversation?


The part I introduced fits right in with the others under "scenario".

Sure, the part you introduced loosely fits under that. The part you introduced was also very silly. Which was my original point that you are failing to even address, let alone refute.

Yes, I did introduce a new possibility.
No, I have never claimed this was the best explanation.

I do recall you saying it was a simpler explanation than any generally accepted ones, and it seemed to me you were rather heavily implying it's superiority. Perhaps your condescending tone lead me to form an unjustified opinion about the elevation whereupon you generally place yourself and your ideas. Though I doubt it.

If the disagreement is an intentional falsehood then I would only call the dirty peasants liars.

So if I'm reading this right, you actually suggest that every person on the forum who disagrees with you - a group that happens to be identical to the group of people you've spoken with - actually thinks you're right, but for some reason all of it's members consistently lie to you, pretending to consider your ideas silly?

What, pray tell, do you believe motivated us to orchestrating an operation of such scale? Or do you suggest we all decided to annoy you independently, despite the obvious truth of your statements?

Honestly, if that's even close to what you are suggesting - and I don't see how it could be far from it - then there are only two possible words for you, and I do believe 'liar' is the more desirable one.
 
It is an unnatural act of submission.



It is the sound of truth floating on the wind.

sound = sight

truth = crap

wind = water

so we have:

It is the sight of crap floating on the water.
 
Last edited:
Tell me, do you ever answer the points people make, or do you invariably try to sidetrack the conversation?

You made the claim that it is wrong to hijack words. I made the factual counter claim that that is standard practice among physicists.

Sure, the part you introduced loosely fits under that. The part you introduced was also very silly. Which was my original point that you are failing to even address, let alone refute.

My refutation: It's not silly.

I do recall you saying it was a simpler explanation than any generally accepted ones, and it seemed to me you were rather heavily implying it's superiority. Perhaps your condescending tone lead me to form an unjustified opinion about the elevation whereupon you generally place yourself and your ideas. Though I doubt it.

Simpler is not necessarily better or truer and I have never claimed either.
My condescending tone is for those who consistently attempt to misrepresent my hypothesis and my posts.

So if I'm reading this right, you actually suggest that every person on the forum who disagrees with you - a group that happens to be identical to the group of people you've spoken with - actually thinks you're right, but for some reason all of it's members consistently lie to you, pretending to consider your ideas silly?

What, pray tell, do you believe motivated us to orchestrating an operation of such scale? Or do you suggest we all decided to annoy you independently, despite the obvious truth of your statements?

Honestly, if that's even close to what you are suggesting - and I don't see how it could be far from it - then there are only two possible words for you, and I do believe 'liar' is the more desirable one.

I notice you like to hedge your claims with conditionals ("it seemed to me', "if I'm reading this right") so that you cannot be pinned down on an actual statement.

I wonder if you are transferring a predilection for conspiracy theories onto me because I challenge your opinions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom