Everything is conjecture

I still don't see how that follows. Even if you're a brain-in-a-jar, you've suceeded fantastically in describing the reality you believe yourself to be in. And also discovered principles that could apply in any reality (human rights).
Not only the reality you believe yourself to be in; that description also fits the reality your neighbour believes himself in, and all other humans. In other words, we all then live in the same fantasy, and the claim that we live in a fantasy has gotten pointless as we all live in the same fantasy.
 
But in solipsism, there's not necessarily any time at which you "wake up," so that seems a non sequitur. :confused:

As a joke, I totally get it. As any kind of even slightly serious point, it seems, well, pointless.

My point, again. :)
 
Not only the reality you believe yourself to be in; that description also fits the reality your neighbour believes himself in, and all other humans. In other words, we all then live in the same fantasy, and the claim that we live in a fantasy has gotten pointless as we all live in the same fantasy.

Unless, all those other people are images projected from the people who keep you in the jar, and they're not real; ie, only you're in the fantasy, and you make everything else up.

See, The Truman Show.

If the idea is around that I'm promoting solipsism, you haven't read my third post on this thread. That's just ridiculous. Solipsism doesn't prove anything. It's irrational and illogical for people to claim that, because one can't disprove something, it's real.
 
Because unless we accept that there is an objective reality we can understand what's the point?

Everything from the invention of fire to string theory, from the Golden Rule to Universal Declaration on Human Rights, from flint knapped stone arrow heads to interstellar space travel is null and void if I'm just a brain in a jar.
My exact thoughts on the matter. See below.
Not necessarily. I'm not talking about a virtual world created in this world. I'm talking about a virtual world in which you're the only person (entity?) experiencing it. I'm made up, the idea that you ever were a human being is made up. Gravity, energy, atoms, etc.: all made up. So e=mc2 doesn't apply there, since there's not even any e or m or light to produce a c.

Yes, that's how silly it gets, when one searches for ways to show that everything is conjecture. It's possible, but it's pointless, because then absolutely nothing can be learned, because no answer is more right than any other.

My reaction is always: yes, everything is conjecture. So what? What are you going to do now?

Despite claiming everything is conjecture, people still generally seem to act as if it's not, because they still believe in basic cause and effect, like not stepping off of high buildings if they don't want to fall.
Hey, that's exactly my point! Everything is conjecture; but if we were to treat it as such then everything would suck.


Ok. Now what?

Elaborate? I must have misinterpreted what you meant, because, if it was what I thought you meant, and if you read my responses, then you should know what's next. But, since you don't, and I'm assuming you read my responses, I must've misunderstood your question. Apologies for ignoring you.
 
Elaborate? I must have misinterpreted what you meant, because, if it was what I thought you meant, and if you read my responses, then you should know what's next. But, since you don't, and I'm assuming you read my responses, I must've misunderstood your question. Apologies for ignoring you.

I don't know how to simplify the question "now what?" but I'll try. If we assume your assertion is correct, what changes?
 
But in solipsism, there's not necessarily any time at which you "wake up," so that seems a non sequitur. :confused:

As a joke, I totally get it. As any kind of even slightly serious point, it seems, well, pointless.

If everything is conjecture then how did the rock hurt your head?
 
I don't know how to simplify the question "now what?" but I'll try. If we assume your assertion is correct, what changes?
Ah. I did already answer that. Nothing changes. It's just meaningless conjecture, and a play on words.

If everything is conjecture then how did the rock hurt your head?

How do you know you weren't just led to believe a rock was even in existence at the time you thought you saw one make contact?
 
How do you know you weren't just led to believe a rock was even in existence at the time you thought you saw one make contact?

You can't. But by the same logic you can't know that water is wet, fire is hot, granite is hard, or that orgasms feel good. We could all just be "led to believe" those things.

Which is why solipsism is so useless and by extension annoying. It doesn't only lead you nowhere to go it erases everywhere you've been. Plenty of navel gazing leads you into philosophical dead ends, but solipsism is rare in that it retroactively makes every thought you've ever had a dead end.

It's the definition of a useless intellectual concept. It answers no questions, leaves no room for intellectual growth, and once you get there you can literally go nowhere because it redefines everywhere as nowhere, or at least redefines everywhere you could go as the same place.
 
You can't. But by the same logic you can't know that water is wet, fire is hot, granite is hard, or that orgasms feel good. We could all just be "led to believe" those things.

Which is why solipsism is so useless and by extension annoying. It doesn't only lead you nowhere to go it erases everywhere you've been. Plenty of navel gazing leads you into philosophical dead ends, but solipsism is rare in that it retroactively makes every thought you've ever had a dead end.

It's the definition of a useless intellectual concept. It answers no questions, leaves no room for intellectual growth, and once you get there you can literally go nowhere because it redefines everywhere as nowhere, or at least redefines everywhere you could go as the same place.

Yes.

Eh, that's relative. Discussions are good for the intellect. This concept has given us some discussion about thinking logically. Therefore, even if only as an excercise, the concept has intellectually provided a use.
 
Last edited:
If everything is conjecture then how did the rock hurt your head?

Is that a serious question? It reminds me of, "If men evolved from monkeys, how come there are still monkeys?"

To answer seriously... It's like saying, "If you were only dreaming that someone threw a rock at you last night, how could you dream that it hurt you, because it was only a dream rock?"

The answer, of course, is that's the way it seems to work in this reality I'm experiencing, but it's mere conjection whether it's the real reality or just a semblance of one.

In this particular reality, apparently things that look like rocks which appear to be moving in the direction of what seems like one's head, cause a sensation called pain, but it may be no more real than a dream rock that causes dream pain.

It's a pointless philosophy, since it deadends so quickly, but objections like that are easy to answer.
 
Discussions are good for the intellect. This concept has given us some discussion about thinking logically. Therefore, even if only as an excercise, the concept has intellectually provided a use.

Not really. I mean I love a good bending thought experiment as much as the next guy but....

Well with solipsism as soon as you put forth the base concept... congratulations you're done. That's the entire possible conversation. "Well what if reality as we see it, including the most basic rules of logic and even cause and effect, are nothing but illusions that we may or may not share with other people that may or may not exist in a world that may or may not exist."

Then I guess I'll respond to that with... what exactly? What am I supposed to say to that? It's a mental state that allows, accepts, and generates no ideas, produces no usable data or ideas, and completely destroys the framework that the entire intellectual process. It's not circular logic it's Mobius Strip logic.

Solipsism doesn't even work as mental gymnastics. Even on a purely logical level it simply can't go anywhere then were you start. And anyone trying to apply it practically.... *shudder.*

I know it sounds like me and others are being overly aggressive toward this philosophy but once you advance the idea, even completely hypothetically, it leaves us nowhere to go. It shutdowns rational thought of any kind.
 
Last edited:
Ah. I did already answer that. Nothing changes. It's just meaningless conjecture, and a play on words.

So what's to discuss? "Hey guys, let's all talk about how amazing it would be if this thing that doesn't change anything was true!"
 
The answer, of course, is that's the way it seems to work in this reality I'm experiencing, but it's mere conjection whether it's the real reality or just a semblance of one.
It's not quite mere conjection; it is in large part definition. We are the ones formulating, refering to, and utilizing the concepts, including the concept of existence. The only criteria for something to count as a "real reality" comes from the utility that criteria gives us.

Consider for example the claim: "This thread has an initial post by Larechar". In what manner can this claim be false? What if I told you that matter was mostly empty space? That the copper atoms in this penny are constantly leaking into the air? What if 4/5 of matter barely reacts to us at all, or the universe were really two dimensional?

Well, those are all questions regarding what "reality" is "really like", but they seem irrelevant to the claim. The claim "bananas are ripe when they are yellow" isn't much different, in this regard; even if we know that to properly define bananas as yellow requires reference to the particulars of major chunks of the average human brain (which turns out to be the case).

The meanings here are conventional, but are also a critical piece of the puzzle. Ripeness and yellowness are conventional in the same sense that forumness is. Why would rocks be different?
In this particular reality, apparently things that look like rocks which appear to be moving in the direction of what seems like one's head, cause a sensation called pain, but it may be no more real than a dream rock that causes dream pain.
But dreams are real. The reason you claim that dream rocks aren't real is because you're contrasting the impermanence of dreamed-of objects with something you mean by the "real world", for legitimate practical reasons. But that is already buried in your meaning. You do, however, really have those dreams, and there is enough of a difference between dreaming of that rock and not dreaming of it that you can claim to have dreamed it and be lying.

The dreamed of rocks are real; they are merely of such a distinct quality that it's useful to deny their equivalence to "waking" rocks. The latter type can cause damage to your "waking" skull. Dreamed of rocks could do anything in the dream, and not much to the waking world.

It's the waking rocks we worry about, so we call that real. They still damage the thing we call a skull, even if the holographic principle is true. You should dodge them even if the TOE involves Keanu Reaves.
It's a pointless philosophy, since it deadends so quickly, but objections like that are easy to answer.

But it has a problem not many people seem to be addressing here. It presumes that there exist a priori meanings of concepts such as "real reality".

None of this addresses, or is meant to address, the concept of certainty. Meanings are conventional, but they still have requirements.
 
Last edited:
Is that a serious question? It reminds me of, "If men evolved from monkeys, how come there are still monkeys?"

To answer seriously... It's like saying, "If you were only dreaming that someone threw a rock at you last night, how could you dream that it hurt you, because it was only a dream rock?"

The answer, of course, is that's the way it seems to work in this reality I'm experiencing, but it's mere conjection whether it's the real reality or just a semblance of one.

In this particular reality, apparently things that look like rocks which appear to be moving in the direction of what seems like one's head, cause a sensation called pain, but it may be no more real than a dream rock that causes dream pain.

It's a pointless philosophy, since it deadends so quickly, but objections like that are easy to answer.

So when the rock hits your head sufficiently hard to eliminate you from this particular reality that's just a semblance of reality?
 
So what's to discuss? "Hey guys, let's all talk about how amazing it would be if this thing that doesn't change anything was true!"

It's, of course, going to be a dead-end thread, but, it's gone on for three pages; obviously people enjoy talking about how amazing it would be if this thing that doesn't change anything was true. It's kind of like, "meh," at this point.
 
So when the rock hits your head sufficiently hard to eliminate you from this particular reality that's just a semblance of reality?

Well, it may not even be that Pup is in existence, so, technically, yes.
 
Yes.

Eh, that's relative. Discussions are good for the intellect. This concept has given us some discussion about thinking logically. Therefore, even if only as an excercise, the concept has intellectually provided a use.

Okay, here's another exercise:

- Take the number 2450

- Multiply it by 7549

- Divide it by 65

- Add 4334

- Multiply by 05.7494

- Obtain its square root

- Multiply it by 759560

- Multiply that by 23934023402340



Do this all by hand and write down the results.




Now, that was some useless waste of time that got you nowhere.... but hey, at least it was a good mathematical exercise that had your brain working for quite a while, huh?
 
Last edited:
Okay, here's another exercise:

- Take the number 2450

- Multiply it by 7549

- Divide it by 65

- Add 4334

- Multiply by 05.7494

- Obtain its square root

- Multiply it by 759560

- Multiply that by 23934023402340



Do this all by hand and write down the results.




Now, that was some useless waste of time that got you nowhere.... but hey, at least it was a good mathematical exercise that had your brain working for quite a while, huh?

Woah! Actually, it proved God's existence! Good thinkin', Ron!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom