Everything is conjecture

Oh, will you look at that? It's a deflection disguised as a casual bad joke.

Deflection? That would mean that I took it as an attack... I didn't.

I tried to do the problem, realized I wouldn't be able to figure the SqRt by hand [still not a mathematician], checked my work for what I'd done so far, realized I'd fouled up on the first multiplication [what a genius, right?], gave up, and lost interest in your point.

I knew what you were getting at. We're arguing relative definitions, now. Woo hoo.
 
Deflection? That would mean that I took it as an attack... I didn't.

I tried to do the problem, realized I wouldn't be able to figure the SqRt by hand [still not a mathematician], checked my work for what I'd done so far, realized I'd fouled up on the first multiplication [what a genius, right?], gave up, and lost interest in your point.

I knew what you were getting at. We're arguing relative definitions, now. Woo hoo.

That's just your conjecture.
 
I tried to do the problem, realized I wouldn't be able to figure the SqRt by hand [still not a mathematician], checked my work for what I'd done so far, realized I'd fouled up on the first multiplication [what a genius, right?], gave up, and lost interest in your point.

How convenient: Losing interest in my point when such point proves that solipsism is a waste of time.
 
How convenient: Losing interest in my point when such point proves that solipsism is a waste of time.

I didn't realize it needed any proof? Do you read selectively; or just skip everything I say until you have something to refute?
 
I find solipsism a useful intellectual tool. I have considered the subject and reached the point where I agree with the consensus as described in this thread. I substitute a symbol for this in my mind and then I can exercise this perspective in contemplation of other subjects at the drop of a hat.

In meditation this symbol is one of the most practical means by which to quieten the mind.
 
I find solipsism a useful intellectual tool. I have considered the subject and reached the point where I agree with the consensus as described in this thread. I substitute a symbol for this in my mind and then I can exercise this perspective in contemplation of other subjects at the drop of a hat.
:eye-poppi:jaw-dropp

In meditation this symbol is one of the most practical means by which to quieten the mind.

I'll give you that conjecture.
 
Give us what conjecture? What did he say?

All he said was "I find solipsism interesting." He didn't say anything meaningful at all, lest of all anything worth jaw dropping over.

No one, not one single person, has been able to argue for any useful intellectual, philosophical, or mental use for solipsism. People keep saying "Well you can use it to look at things in a new way" but never explain what those "new ways" are.

That's been this entire conversation.

Ted: "Isn't solipsism interesting!"
Bob: "No not really."
Ted: "But it lets you look at things in new ways!"
Bob: "What new ways?"
Ted: "Ways like we're talking about now!"
Bob: "But we're not talking about any new ways of looking at things."
Ted: "Yes we are! I just said that solipsism let me look at things in new ways, and you said it didn't! We're having a philosophical discussion!"
Bob: "No we aren't Ted."

Don't mistake talking about something for discussing it. We're all just making noise here because with solipsism that's all you can do. Solipsism is an idea that begins, ends, and is forever trapped at the "Well wouldn't it be odd if..." stage. That's a fine place to start some mental stretching, pretty poor place to stall out at for it.

Don't mistake mental effort for mental value. Sure thinking about solipsism can lead to some internal gears grinding that's for sure, but it's just running in place on a treadmill. It's not going to actually go anywhere.
 
Give us what conjecture? What did he say?
In meditation this symbol is one of the most practical means by which to quieten the mind.

_____

All he said was "I find solipsism interesting." He didn't say anything meaningful at all, lest of all anything worth jaw dropping over.
The popping-eyes face and the jaw-drop face were due to the shock that he could assert that Solipsism can be used as an intellectual tool. I'm not sure how you misconstrued my intentions into anything else; but, hey, I've seen worse things. No worries.
 
I find solipsism a useful intellectual tool. I have considered the subject and reached the point where I agree with the consensus as described in this thread. I substitute a symbol for this in my mind and then I can exercise this perspective in contemplation of other subjects at the drop of a hat.

In meditation this symbol is one of the most practical means by which to quieten the mind.

You have the quietest mind that I have ever come across.
 
Last edited:
The popping-eyes face and the jaw-drop face were due to the shock that he could assert that Solipsism can be used as an intellectual tool. I'm not sure how you misconstrued my intentions into anything else.

Well because you are the one that started the thread and have been defending it as an intellectual discussion.

I get that you aren't a proponent of solipsism, but I still don't quite get your angle in this discussion.
 
Well because you are the one that started the thread and have been defending it as an intellectual discussion.

I get that you aren't a proponent of solipsism, but I still don't quite get your angle in this discussion.

It happened in this way:

Larechar A: "Hmm... a lot of things seem to be based on probability. What's the definition of fact?"
Larechar B: "Something like, 'something demonstrated to exist or known to have existed,' and, 'something believed to be true or real.'"
Larechar A: "Ah, so basically, at the most basic level, everything in reality that we know is just conjecture."
Larechar B: "I suppose so; does it matter?"
Larechar A: "Nah. I think I'll see what others have to say about it."
Larechar B: "Whatever dude."

[eta]
I suppose the aforementioned doesn't really answer your question; but, I don't really have an angle.
 
Last edited:
And congratulations you've had a thought that millions of great philosophers and random stoners (two groups which are becomingly disturbingly difficult to tell the difference between) have had.

It's meaningless and self contradictory. The entire concept of reality is the idea that there is an object existence to the universe that we are experiencing through our sense. If we don't assume that then what we're discussing isn't reality. Don't let semantics over the word reality lead you to give more thought to a meaningless old riddle then it deserves. All your asking is "What would reality be like if reality didn't exist?" Well it wouldn't, problem solved.

It's the same problem with that old tired, cliched "What happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" nonsense. It's pointless. If you live in a universe that has an unstoppable force in it there can't exist an immovable object in that same universe and vice versa because the existence of one is dependent, nay in fact defined by the, the non-existence of the other. It's a stupid little vapid idea wrapped up in overly complex florid prose.

I've mentioned this several times in other recent discussions. The ability to just make a superficially contradictory intellectual idea isn't the sign of intelligence so many people seem to think it is.
 
And congratulations you've had a thought that millions of great philosophers and random stoners (two groups which are becomingly disturbingly difficult to tell the difference between) have had.

It's meaningless and self contradictory. The entire concept of reality is the idea that there is an object existence to the universe that we are experiencing through our sense. If we don't assume that then what we're discussing isn't reality. Don't let semantics over the word reality lead you to give more thought to a meaningless old riddle then it deserves. All your asking is "What would reality be like if reality didn't exist?" Well it wouldn't, problem solved.

It's the same problem with that old tired, cliched "What happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" nonsense. It's pointless. If you live in a universe that has an unstoppable force in it there can't exist an immovable object in that same universe and vice versa because the existence of one is dependent, nay in fact defined by the, the non-existence of the other. It's a stupid little vapid idea wrapped up in overly complex florid prose.

I've mentioned this several times in other recent discussions. The ability to just make a superficially contradictory intellectual idea isn't the sign of intelligence so many people seem to think it is.

I appreciate the rationale, again; but you seem to be attached to the false impression that I think the idea warrants anymore thought than just considering it once. I don't. If I could close threads based on boredom and uselessness, I would have done so long ago. I reply based on the respect that I created the thread, only.
 
I didn't realize it needed any proof? Do you read selectively; or just skip everything I say until you have something to refute?

I don't know if it needed the proof, but it sure helps illustrate just how useless solipsism is.

Of course, you have decided to not pay attention to the point at all and claim it "bored you", because it would not be good news for you to find out just how disposable solipsism is.
 
Last edited:
I don't know if it needed the proof, but it sure helps illustrate just how useless solipsism is.

Of course, you have decided to not pay attention to the point at all and claim it "bored you", because it would not be good news for you to find out just how disposable solipsism is.

You presume I don't already know, because you, A) read selectively; or B) skip over everything I say that if you'd paid attention to would inform you that we have the same viewpoint on the matter in the first place.

You're irrationally attached to the idea that you need to debate me, contrary to all the things I've said that contradict your contrasting repudiation.
 
You presume I don't already know, because you, A) read selectively; or B) skip over everything I say that if you'd paid attention to would inform you that we have the same viewpoint on the matter in the first place.

You're irrationally attached to the idea that you need to debate me, contrary to all the things I've said that contradict your contrasting repudiation.

Well, I don't think you're correct on that. You did make an assertion to which I replied. Your assertion, which was in defense of solipsism went like this:

Originally Posted by Larechar
Eh, that's relative. Discussions are good for the intellect. This concept has given us some discussion about thinking logically. Therefore, even if only as an excercise, the concept has intellectually provided a use.

Which was a response to JoeBentley who defined solipsism as a useless concept. Here's what JoeBentley said:

It's the definition of a useless intellectual concept. It answers no questions, leaves no room for intellectual growth, and once you get there you can literally go nowhere because it redefines everywhere as nowhere, or at least redefines everywhere you could go as the same place.

Your argument is that discussions are already useful in that they are good exercises for the intellect. So they're already useful, if only as an exercise for the brain, regardless of whether or not we're making some actual progress in the conversation per se.

What I and others here are telling you is that there's lots of things that can be good exercises for the brain, but that doesn't make them useful in themselves. Sitting down to count all the leaves of grass is a good exercise of the brain. Checking to see how many cars that pass by are red is a good exercise for the brain. Playing videogames is a good exercise for the brain. So what? No one here is arguing that solipsism is not a good exercise for the brain. What we're arguing is that it doesn't lead anywhere, in the same way that my random mathematical exercise will get you nowhere. We're arguing that solipsism is a useless thing for learning more about the universe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom