Everything is conjecture

So now you never have to be right about anything. If you lump every belief into the category of undifferentiated "faith," from the expectation that that big steel beam you put in the floor will resist buckling under the weight of a fly to the doctrine of the bodily assumption of the blessed virgin, you will become as a god, filled with wisdom. You will win every argument you deign to enter.

Countdown begins, how long until Larechar protests that that wasn't what he really meant.

Haha you got me there; but honestly I just said it to propose it. If I'd wanted to use it as an argument I would have used it as an argument in the, "fasting," discussion we were having and not made a completely new thread under the, "Philosophy," section.
 
Not realizing that once you throw all the rules of rationality out the window you're vulnerable to whoever has the most vivid imagination.
The beauty of imagination is that it's creation, so you can always perform the necessary, "one-up." ;)

Because I've seen this train of though many, many, many times and every single last time it was a pre-load cop-out for some form of religious, mythical, mystical, or pseudo-scientific nonsense.

If you are different you are a first, and you have my apologies.

Not necessary; it makes sense. Thank you, though. :)
 
I don't understand this.

Really? You don't? That's surprising, considering your thread title.
Allow me to help.

Wiles' proof of Fermat's Last Theorem is a proof of the modularity theorem for semistable elliptic curves released by Andrew Wiles, which, together with Ribet's theorem, provides a proof for Fermat's Last Theorem. Wiles first announced his proof in June 1993 in a version that was soon recognized as having a serious gap. The widely accepted version of the proof was released by Andrew Wiles in September 1994, and published in 1995. The proof uses many techniques from algebraic geometry and number theory, and has many ramifications in these branches of mathematics. It also uses standard constructions of modern algebraic geometry, such as the category of schemes and Iwasawa theory, and other 20th century techniques not available to Fermat.

Does this help your understanding?
 
Really? You don't? That's surprising, considering your thread title.
Allow me to help.



Does this help your understanding?

No; I'm not a mathematician.

If Fermat proved that, 'if n is greater than [2] in the equation, "A^n+B^n=C^n," then the equation is impossible,' then he did so by using Mathematics. Mathematics is based on the conjecture that because it was so in the past it will continue to be so in the future.

H1] Universal constants will remain constant.
H2] Universal constants could change.

Because we arrived at H1 via conjecture, H2 is a possibility, regardless of how exponentially small it is. Since H2 is a possibility, Fermat's Last Theorem may not be true in the future.
 
I agree; you're not a mathematician.

Mathematics is not based on your conjecture.

That's true. It's based on the conjecture that because it was so in the past it will continue to be so.

While it's the truth, hypothetically it could cease to be so.
 
That's true. It's based on the conjecture that because it was so in the past it will continue to be so.
Larechar:

If you don't want to call this "your conjecture", and want to play word games, that's fine. But please pay attention to what I am saying.

You are saying that mathematics is based on the conjecture that because something is true in the past it will continue to be so.

I'm correcting you. I'm claiming the opposite. Mathematics is not based on the conjecture that because something is true in the past it will continue to be so.

Now I will simply ask you. What makes you think that mathematics is based on this conjecture?
 
Larechar:

If you don't want to call this "your conjecture", and want to play word games, that's fine. But please pay attention to what I am saying.

You are saying that mathematics is based on the conjecture that because something is true in the past it will continue to be so.

I'm correcting you. I'm claiming the opposite. Mathematics is not based on the conjecture that because something is true in the past it will continue to be so.

Now I will simply ask you. What makes you think that mathematics is based on this conjecture?

HILITED: Oh, that's good. That's what the thread is about. :)

ITALICIZED: Because, hypothetically, constants could change. Or, hypothetically, reality could be based on your own perception that was created for you to witness as a brain in a jar, as was mentioned earlier, and hence mathematics would be based on this reality, and not a hypothetical actual reality above your perception.

Since we can't disprove it, we can't say it's 100% impossible; hence, it becomes conjecture that mathematics is constant.

What is your reasoning behind claiming the opposite?
 
As I see it, conjecture is meaningless without its other part - refutation. I can make conjectures about anything, but without the potential for refutation, at best my conjecture might just be a pretty idea.

So we ask - what might make the conjecture untrue? If there is no answer to that question then anything is possible; and if anything is possible, then why bother thinking about it?
 
HILITED: Oh, that's good. That's what the thread is about. :)

ITALICIZED: Because, hypothetically, constants could change. Or, hypothetically, reality could be based on your own perception that was created for you to witness as a brain in a jar, as was mentioned earlier, and hence mathematics would be based on this reality, and not a hypothetical actual reality above your perception.

Since we can't disprove it, we can't say it's 100% impossible; hence, it becomes conjecture that mathematics is constant.

What is your reasoning behind claiming the opposite?

Or Descarte's Evil Demon:

It is at least possible that there is an all-powerful evil demon who
is deceiving me, such that he causes me to have false beliefs,
including the belief that there is a table in front of me and the
belief that two plus three equals five
.

As long as such a being possibly exists, even mathematical/logical truths are just conjecture. Perhaps tomorrow the evil demon will convince us 3 and 2 make 6.
 
What is your reasoning behind claiming the opposite?
Because your conjecture proposes that something is true, which is not in fact the case.
Because, hypothetically, constants could change.
This reasoning doesn't work. For a mathematical constant to change, and for the discipline of mathematics to be subject to the flaw of your conjecture, it would have to be necessary that mathematicians would be incapable of detecting that it has changed.

This cannot be the case; even if you want to propose that it is the case, then you face a severe problem with defining what constitutes a "change".
Or, hypothetically, reality could be based on your own perception that was created for you to witness as a brain in a jar, as was mentioned earlier,
Actually, this is an apt description of the current state of affairs. Our 3 pound brains are in fact in 10 pound jars, and some form of reality we don't know about is creating perceptions for us to witness.
and hence mathematics would be based on this reality, and not a hypothetical actual reality above your perception.
Said "actual reality" is already not hypothetical, and this doesn't matter as much as you're making it out to.
 
As I see it, conjecture is meaningless without its other part - refutation. I can make conjectures about anything, but without the potential for refutation, at best my conjecture might just be a pretty idea.

So we ask - what might make the conjecture untrue? If there is no answer to that question then anything is possible; and if anything is possible, then why bother thinking about it?
I didn't insinuate that it wasn't meaningless.

Or Descarte's Evil Demon:

It is at least possible that there is an all-powerful evil demon who
is deceiving me, such that he causes me to have false beliefs,
including the belief that there is a table in front of me and the
belief that two plus three equals five
.

As long as such a being possibly exists, even mathematical/logical truths are just conjecture. Perhaps tomorrow the evil demon will convince us 3 and 2 make 6.

Exactly. While the notion is dismissible because the probability of such things is 100%-(1%/almost infinity), there's no proof, and if there was, it would be conjecture, as well.
 
Because your conjecture proposes that something is true, which is not in fact the case.

This reasoning doesn't work. For a mathematical constant to change, and for the discipline of mathematics to be subject to the flaw of your conjecture, it would have to be necessary that mathematicians would be incapable of detecting that it has changed.
No, they could detect it after the fact, and that would make the previous constants conjecture. The new constants would also be conjecture.
This cannot be the case; even if you want to propose that it is the case, then you face a severe problem with defining what constitutes a "change".
"Cannot be," is still, in fact, conjecture.
Actually, this is an apt description of the current state of affairs. Our 3 pound brains are in fact in 10 pound jars, and some form of reality we don't know about is creating perceptions for us to witness.

Said "actual reality" is already not hypothetical, and this doesn't matter as much as you're making it out to.

If this, now, wasn't the, "actual reality," and there was an unperceiveable, "actual reality," is what I'm implying.

HILITE: It doesn't matter at all; it's just fact along the parameters of my conjecture that everything is conjecture.
 
No, they could detect it after the fact, and that would make the previous constants conjecture. The new constants would also be conjecture.
Let's review your conjecture:
It's based on the conjecture that because it was so in the past it will continue to be so.​
If mathematicians can detect the change, how is mathematics based on this conjecture, for any sensible definition of "based on"? I would think that the fact that mathematics could detect a change is the very definition of that conjecture being wrong (i.e., if it can detect a change it's not based on there being none). Otherwise, I don't see you as having made a meaningful claim at all.

Even in this meaningless argument where you presume your job is simply to say "you're just conjecturing that" to any rebuttal, if you should happen to make a claim and decide that it is a true claim, you need to back it up.
If this, now, wasn't the, "actual reality," and there was an unperceiveable, "actual reality," is what I'm implying.
When you say "this, now," what do you think you're referring to? What state of affairs, or presumed knowledge of allegedly "actual reality" could you be referring to?

We've confirmed recently that 4/5 of the matter in the universe is something we have no clue about. We spent 9 billion dollars recently building a machine to peel back a few layers of the "simulation", which is already many layers removed from that which we perceive. Your notion that we're running around with this idea that reality is like we perceive it, or that we know we're near the bottom of the barrel of "simulation" layers, is woefully out of date.
 
No, they could detect it after the fact, and that would make the previous constants conjecture. The new constants would also be conjecture.
"Cannot be," is still, in fact, conjecture.

If this, now, wasn't the, "actual reality," and there was an unperceiveable, "actual reality," is what I'm implying.

HILITE: It doesn't matter at all; it's just fact along the parameters of my conjecture that everything is conjecture.

We wouldn't have to be capable of recognizing changes to mathematics. A sufficiently powerful being could simply make 2 and 2 equal whatever it wants and change all our memories of it ever equalling anything else. It's possible Pi has had countless values.
 
Let's review your conjecture:
It's based on the conjecture that because it was so in the past it will continue to be so.​
If mathematicians can detect the change, how is mathematics based on this conjecture, for any sensible definition of "based on"? I would think that the fact that mathematics could detect a change is the very definition of that conjecture being wrong (i.e., if it can detect a change it's not based on there being none). Otherwise, I don't see you as having made a meaningful claim at all.
See below.
We wouldn't have to be capable of recognizing changes to mathematics. A sufficiently powerful being could simply make 2 and 2 equal whatever it wants and change all our memories of it ever equalling anything else. It's possible Pi has had countless values.

Either way is fine; there's still a way to find the possibility that mathematics is conjecture.
Even in this meaningless argument where you presume your job is simply to say "you're just conjecturing that" to any rebuttal, if you should happen to make a claim and decide that it is a true claim, you need to back it up.
It's been done, already, by Descartes in the 1600s, as was pointed out by Malerin. I didn't see the point in furthering the thought.

When you say "this, now," what do you think you're referring to? What state of affairs, or presumed knowledge of allegedly "actual reality" could you be referring to?
The Matrix.

We've confirmed recently that 4/5 of the matter in the universe is something we have no clue about. We spent 9 billion dollars recently building a machine to peel back a few layers of the "simulation", which is already many layers removed from that which we perceive. Your notion that we're running around with this idea that reality is like we perceive it, or that we know we're near the bottom of the barrel of "simulation" layers, is woefully out of date.

Thank you for the information; I was unaware of any of that.

However, that's not the notion I'm conveying. I'm portraying that this Universe, in its entirety, regardless of what we do or don't know about it yet, could be a fake, and the real one could be completely different. Since we can't disprove it, it's conjecture.
 
ITALICIZED: Because, hypothetically, constants could change. Or, hypothetically, reality could be based on your own perception that was created for you to witness as a brain in a jar, as was mentioned earlier, and hence mathematics would be based on this reality, and not a hypothetical actual reality above your perception.

Since we can't disprove it, we can't say it's 100% impossible; hence, it becomes conjecture that mathematics is constant.

What is your reasoning behind claiming the opposite?

Mathematics is based on axioms, and the truth of mathematics follows logically from those axioms. Even if there is a hypothetical actual realiy above our perception, mathematical proof will still be valid, although if the axioms are now incorrect, they may not be true. The mathematical proof will still hold.
 
The Matrix.

*Sighs* I swear that one movie has done more damage to intellectual discourse then anything else in history.

Ever since that movie has come out a legion of coffee shop intellectuals have rediscovered solipsism and using it as an argumentative blunt instrument.

However, that's not the notion I'm conveying. I'm portraying that this Universe, in its entirety, regardless of what we do or don't know about it yet, could be a fake, and the real one could be completely different. Since we can't disprove it, it's conjecture.

And that's the problem with solipsism. It negates the entire history of intellectual development.
 
Mathematics is based on axioms, and the truth of mathematics follows logically from those axioms. Even if there is a hypothetical actual realiy above our perception, mathematical proof will still be valid, although if the axioms are now incorrect, they may not be true. The mathematical proof will still hold.

This. There are no "mathematical constants" that could change. Mathematics is from the foundation built on:
1) the logical rules of inference which say which are valid steps in mathematical proof
2) set theory, e.g., ZF set theory.

Then we can build the natural numbers from there:
0 = {} (the empty set)
1 = { {} }
etc.
And on top of that, we can build the rational numbers, the real numbers and the complex numbers.

And the various branches of mathematics define their own playground by means of their axioms, whether they define a Euclidean plane, a group or a ring, a vector space or whatever. If you're a physicist and you apply Euclidean geometry to a space that is not Euclidean, yes, you get the wrong results, but that's your fault, that doesn't mean Euclidean geometry is wrong.

So, there are no "constants" that depend on our observations.
 
The... ahem "logic" as it is usually goes something like this.

Bob: I hold baseless, irrational, unsupported Opinion A. (Opinion A being something like "The Freemasons and Jews conspired with Big Pharma to destroy the Twin Towers to hide evidence they had invented an 88mpg engine that Elvis backward engineered from the spaceship that crashed in Roswell.")
Ted: I disagree with Opinion A because you have little to no real evidence for it.
Bob: But you hold well supported, well documented Opinion B, correct? (Opinion B being something like "Poking yourself in the eye with a sharp stick really hurts."
Ted: Yes I do.
Bob: Can you prove Opinion B is true beyond all possible metaphysical certainty, to a completely unreasonable level that would shutdown all intellectual growth and discourse if it were actually applied?
Ted: Errrr... no I guess I can't.
Bob: Then it's the same! Because in the fantasy world that passes for my reality, completely unsupported by any evidence other then the voices in my head and not absolutely proven to Zen Koan levels of metaphysical hair splitting are the same thing!

Ted: No, but I can add another point of evidence to my conjecture. (pokes Bob in the eye).
Bob: Aaaawwww!!!
Fixed your conversation with a more appropriate ending. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom