Everything is conjecture

e=mc2 is an abstraction derived from experience. A mathematical tool which can be applied in the known universe.

Even though we don't know anything for certain, or the basis for anything, we can derive abstract models and apply them to existence as we know it.

How many times have you experienced e=mc2?
 
Yes, that's how silly it gets, when one searches for ways to show that everything is conjecture. It's possible, but it's pointless, because then absolutely nothing can be learned, because no answer is more right than any other.

My reaction is always: yes, everything is conjecture. So what? What are you going to do now?

Despite claiming everything is conjecture, people still generally seem to act as if it's not, because they still believe in basic cause and effect, like not stepping off of high buildings if they don't want to fall.

Beautifully, wonderfully said.

And as you say people can say that all they want, but people don't really seem to act on it, except when it comes to their personal pseudo-scientific, religious, or otherwise irrational pet topics.

If someone was to ask "Hey everyone I'm thinking of painting my bedroom, should I go with cornflower blue or burnt umber?" No one is going to run screaming "No! No! You can't prove beyond any shadow of any metaphysical, solipsistic doubt that the colors I see are the colors you see! Stop talking about it! It's conjuncture! You can't be sure! I win!!! Ha-ha I win!!!" the way they do when they try to pre-load it as an argument for hooey.
 
Last edited:
What conjecture??? If I drop a sledge hammer on your foot, can you "predict" the outcome???

No conjecture involved, only following laws of basic physics.
 
What conjecture??? If I drop a sledge hammer on your foot, can you "predict" the outcome???

The... ahem "logic" as it is usually goes something like this.

Bob: I hold baseless, irrational, unsupported Opinion A. (Opinion A being something like "The Freemasons and Jews conspired with Big Pharma to destroy the Twin Towers to hide evidence they had invented an 88mpg engine that Elvis backward engineered from the spaceship that crashed in Roswell.")
Ted: I disagree with Opinion A because you have little to no real evidence for it.
Bob: But you hold well supported, well documented Opinion B, correct? (Opinion B being something like "Poking yourself in the eye with a sharp stick really hurts."
Ted: Yes I do.
Bob: Can you prove Opinion B is true beyond all possible metaphysical certainty, to a completely unreasonable level that would shutdown all intellectual growth and discourse if it were actually applied?
Ted: Errrr... no I guess I can't.
Bob: Then it's the same! Because in the fantasy world that passes for my reality, completely unsupported by any evidence other then the voices in my head and not absolutely proven to Zen Koan levels of metaphysical hair splitting are the same thing!
 
Last edited:
Or as Johnson said, "I refute it thus!" (kicking the rock being much the same as dropping a sledgehammer.)
 
Yes, everything in the human mind is conjecture, or abstraction and abstraction might contain inventions, inventive conjecture.

Including your post or it's an abstraction containing a conjecture about an invention.
 
Sure it is, if you're a brain in a vat hooked up to experience a virtual world where e=mc2 works. Prove I'm wrong. :)

I refute it thus: (whacks Pup with stone).
 
Some people simply employ a scorched earth policy to debate. If you expect whatever unreasonable idea they've pulled out of their butt to be held to any intellectual standard at all, they'll happily throw out the entire history of scientific progress by arguing you can't prove you're not a brain in a jar or a man dreaming he's a butterfly dreaming he's a man or whatever.

It's sorta sad really.
 
Some people simply employ a scorched earth policy to debate. If you expect whatever unreasonable idea they've pulled out of their butt to be held to any intellectual standard at all, they'll happily throw out the entire history of scientific progress by arguing you can't prove you're not a brain in a jar or a man dreaming he's a butterfly dreaming he's a man or whatever.

It's sorta sad really.

Reality is fascinating enough for me. The universe is a place full of wonder,who needs mysticism?
 
Ok. Now what?
So now you never have to be right about anything. If you lump every belief into the category of undifferentiated "faith," from the expectation that that big steel beam you put in the floor will resist buckling under the weight of a fly to the doctrine of the bodily assumption of the blessed virgin, you will become as a god, filled with wisdom. You will win every argument you deign to enter.

Countdown begins, how long until Larechar protests that that wasn't what he really meant.
 
Fermat's last is not.
I don't understand this.

Unfortunately, "everything is conjecture" is followed too often by, "so therefore you can't prove my pet theory wrong."
Not at all; I was stating fact. [Paradoxical conjecture]
All 'proof' is probabilistic. Anyone who will not accept a sufficiently high probability that his pet theory is wrong, is ill adapted to life in these cosmos.
Yes.

Welcome to solipsism.
Is that what that's called?! I tried to find a name for the idea when I thought of it last night.

e=mc2 is not conjecture,not unless we have conjectural atomic bombs and nuclear reactors.
It is conjecture.

Therefore: God.

Got it.
Not at all; I didn't expect so many assumptions that I was perpetuating woo when I made this thread.
Conjecture definitionGiven that definition, I call baloney on the thread title. Unless you believe the Universe doesn't exist, then evidence of/from the Universe exists.
No.
Yes, conclusions are based on incomplete evidence, but that is not the equivalent of inadequate evidence.
Yes.

Not necessarily. I'm not talking about a virtual world created in this world. I'm talking about a virtual world in which you're the only person (entity?) experiencing it. I'm made up, the idea that you ever were a human being is made up. Gravity, energy, atoms, etc.: all made up. So e=mc2 doesn't apply there, since there's not even any e or m or light to produce a c.

Yes, that's how silly it gets, when one searches for ways to show that everything is conjecture. It's possible, but it's pointless, because then absolutely nothing can be learned, because no answer is more right than any other.

My reaction is always: yes, everything is conjecture. So what? What are you going to do now?

Despite claiming everything is conjecture, people still generally seem to act as if it's not, because they still believe in basic cause and effect, like not stepping off of high buildings if they don't want to fall.
Hey, that's exactly my point! Everything is conjecture; but if we were to treat it as such then everything would suck.

What conjecture??? If I drop a sledge hammer on your foot, can you "predict" the outcome???

No conjecture involved, only following laws of basic physics.
Which is conjecture based on Faith that the constants will remain constants. That theory [definitely true; playing devil's advocate] is based on the past; and that requires Faith that what was true in the past will continue to be true in the future/present. Example: You assume gravity will continue to work when you drop the hammer. If gravity stops, the hammer will not fall.

Is the periodic table of the elements merely conjecture?

Some people simply employ a scorched earth policy to debate. If you expect whatever unreasonable idea they've pulled out of their butt to be held to any intellectual standard at all, they'll happily throw out the entire history of scientific progress by arguing you can't prove you're not a brain in a jar or a man dreaming he's a butterfly dreaming he's a man or whatever.

It's sorta sad really.
I'm not throwing anything out; I'm playing with words. It's necessary to have science as we have it.

[eta]

I wasn't stating something is true because you can't prove its inexistence; that's just irrational. I was commenting on a philosophy that can be a background to more prominent philosophy. [/eta]
 
Last edited:
Some people simply employ a scorched earth policy to debate. If you expect whatever unreasonable idea they've pulled out of their butt to be held to any intellectual standard at all, they'll happily throw out the entire history of scientific progress by arguing you can't prove you're not a brain in a jar or a man dreaming he's a butterfly dreaming he's a man or whatever.

It's sorta sad really.

Not realizing that once you throw all the rules of rationality out the window you're vulnerable to whoever has the most vivid imagination.
 
I didn't expect so many assumptions that I was perpetuating woo when I made this thread.

Because I've seen this train of though many, many, many times and every single last time it was a pre-load cop-out for some form of religious, mythical, mystical, or pseudo-scientific nonsense.

If you are different you are a first, and you have my apologies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom