Everything is conjecture

...snip...

However, that's not the notion I'm conveying. I'm portraying that this Universe, in its entirety, regardless of what we do or don't know about it yet, could be a fake, and the real one could be completely different. Since we can't disprove it, it's conjecture.

And my answer to this is always a "And so what?" What difference does it make to how you and I and everyone else lives their life? It might be a virtual reality but if I stub my toe it hurts, whether that is a virtual toe or a "real" toe.
 
We wouldn't have to be capable of recognizing changes to mathematics. A sufficiently powerful being could simply make 2 and 2 equal whatever it wants and change all our memories of it ever equalling anything else. It's possible Pi has had countless values.

Which is a remarkably good argument for there being no such being.
 
ITALICIZED: Because, hypothetically, constants could change. Or, hypothetically, reality could be based on your own perception that was created for you to witness as a brain in a jar, as was mentioned earlier, and hence mathematics would be based on this reality, and not a hypothetical actual reality above your perception.

Mathematics or any logical proof that's based on postulates is an exception. As long as you accept the postulates, you avoid the brain in a jar problem. One plus one will always equal two, as long as one accepts the definition of one and two, even if there's no object permanence or some other glitch with ordinary counting of objects in a potential imaginary world, because by definition, one and two are constant.

The problem is whether the postulates correlate with the real world, and that's still conjecture, but that's outside of the logical or mathematical proof, which would still hold true.

We can even make logical proofs in this world, which are conjecture, but still proofs:

Postulate: Angels only do good.
Postulate: Causing harm is not good.
Proof: Angels will not harm you.

The only conjecture in there is about angels and the nature of goodness, but the rest is irrefutable proof.

Just finished reading the thread and saw that Mashuna said the same thing, using the term axioms instead of postulates, and some others have touched on the same point also.
 
And my answer to this is always a "And so what?" What difference does it make to how you and I and everyone else lives their life? It might be a virtual reality but if I stub my toe it hurts, whether that is a virtual toe or a "real" toe.

This has always been my angle. My reality passing the Turning Test so to speak.

Solipsism is a philosophy that can easily be proven wrong by simply whacking the claimant in question upside the head. But I find that true of most navel gazing.

There's also the valid question of why we would have sense that don't provide us with at least an attempt at a fair representation of the world. Why would we evolve sight, hearing, touch, taste, and smell if not to provide us with at least fairly accurate information about the objective world?
 
Solipsism is a philosophy that can easily be proven wrong by simply whacking the claimant in question upside the head.

That's the common joking answer, and I get it--sort of a real life version of kittening a thread. But it's not actually a serious refutation, is it? I mean, there's nothing in solipsism that says we can't feel a sensation like pain or that we don't imagine unexpected events.

I think that most materialists would accept that people can dream that they get hit and that it hurts, yet materialists wouldn't argue that therefore dreams must be real.
 
That's the common joking answer, and I get it--sort of a real life version of kittening a thread. But it's not actually a serious refutation, is it? I mean, there's nothing in solipsism that says we can't feel a sensation like pain or that we don't imagine unexpected events.

I think that most materialists would accept that people can dream that they get hit and that it hurts, yet materialists wouldn't argue that therefore dreams must be real.

True but the real problem with solipsism is that it is a complete dead-end - there is no way to refute or confirm it even in principle. So as far as we are concerned we end up (again) with acting as if everything is "real". Never met or even heard of any the folks that throw up this silly (not meaning your post) idea who acts as if they believe it to be true.
 
Last edited:
Of course the concept is meant in a humorous manner, and I am certainly not actually advocating harming people who hold annoying philosophical views as tempting as it is sometimes... but from a certain point of view I does bring an interesting point.

For instance yeah you can feel pain in a dream. But dreams only feel real while you are in them. They feel all kinds all... well wrong for a better term when you wake up and look back on them.

Reality isn't as easy to replicate as people seem to think it is. And think on a base level people do know that. I really doubt anyone actually lives their lives under the mental framework that reality is anything other then... well reality. That's why I find it being used as a cop-out for nonsense to be so frustrating.

So to paraphrase Dr. House people can talk about reality being an illusion all they want, but when it comes time to cross the street they're still gonna look both ways.
 
True but the real problem with solipsism is that it is a complete dead-end - there is no way to refute or confirm it even in principle. So as far as we are concerned we end up (again) with acting as if everything is "real". Never met or even heard of any the folks that throw up this silly (not meaning your post) idea who acts as if they believe it to be true.

I agree, which is why a response like kittening is about all that one can do.

But I've wondered if people actually believe it's a refutation, or if they're always joking, because if they actually believe it refutes solipsism, it seems they're as naive as the people who promote solipsism.
 
For instance yeah you can feel pain in a dream. But dreams only feel real while you are in them. They feel all kinds all... well wrong for a better term when you wake up and look back on them.

Reality isn't as easy to replicate as people seem to think it is.

But in solipsism, there's not necessarily any time at which you "wake up," so that seems a non sequitur. :confused:

As a joke, I totally get it. As any kind of even slightly serious point, it seems, well, pointless.
 
But in solipsism, there's not necessarily any time at which you "wake up," so that seems a non sequitur. :confused:

As a joke, I totally get it. As any kind of even slightly serious point, it seems, well, pointless.

Well then it's a perfect counter to solipsism, which somehow manages to have less point to it then even pointlessness. :D

No but seriously it's all because we only have one reality, and it's damn hard to get data from a random sampling of one.
 
See below.
See above. You didn't even address the argument you quoted when you said "see below". You completely side stepped it.
[snip malerin quote]
Either way is fine; there's still a way to find the possibility that mathematics is conjecture.
For the third time, the thing I'm addressing is your claim that mathematics is based on things staying the same. I couldn't care less about your claim that mathematics is conjecture at this point. I'm talking about your claim that mathematics is based on things staying the same.
It's been done, already, by Descartes
To my knowledge, Descartes did not address the claim that mathematics is based on things staying the same. Could you provide a reference?
The Matrix.
Then this is trivial. Only a fringe group of loonies has ever proposed that The Matrix is the "actual reality". I suspect, however, that your response of "The Matrix" is due to your not understanding the question that I asked, so let me ask it again.

What state of affairs, or presumed knowledge of allegedly "actual reality" could you be referring to?

Let me attempt to clarify the question. You are presuming that we have a concept of an "actual reality". This alleged "actual reality" is not really the real "actual reality". What I'm asking you is what you are referring to by this alleged "actual reality".
 
*Sighs* I swear that one movie has done more damage to intellectual discourse then anything else in history.

Ever since that movie has come out a legion of coffee shop intellectuals have rediscovered solipsism and using it as an argumentative blunt instrument.



And that's the problem with solipsism. It negates the entire history of intellectual development.

How so?
 
This. There are no "mathematical constants" that could change. Mathematics is from the foundation built on:
1) the logical rules of inference which say which are valid steps in mathematical proof
2) set theory, e.g., ZF set theory.

Then we can build the natural numbers from there:
0 = {} (the empty set)
1 = { {} }
etc.
And on top of that, we can build the rational numbers, the real numbers and the complex numbers.

And the various branches of mathematics define their own playground by means of their axioms, whether they define a Euclidean plane, a group or a ring, a vector space or whatever. If you're a physicist and you apply Euclidean geometry to a space that is not Euclidean, yes, you get the wrong results, but that's your fault, that doesn't mean Euclidean geometry is wrong.

So, there are no "constants" that depend on our observations.

That was never the claim. You cant "do" math without thinking. Is it possible there's a being messing with your thoughts every time you think about math? Sure.
 
True but the real problem with solipsism is that it is a complete dead-end - there is no way to refute or confirm it even in principle.

This is true of every model of reality that is logically consistent.

So as far as we are concerned we end up (again) with acting as if everything is "real". Never met or even heard of any the folks that throw up this silly (not meaning your post) idea who acts as if they believe it to be true.

What would you expect a solipsist to do differently?
 
HILITED: Oh, that's good. That's what the thread is about. :)

ITALICIZED: Because, hypothetically, constants could change. Or, hypothetically, reality could be based on your own perception that was created for you to witness as a brain in a jar, as was mentioned earlier, and hence mathematics would be based on this reality, and not a hypothetical actual reality above your perception.

Since we can't disprove it, we can't say it's 100% impossible; hence, it becomes conjecture that mathematics is constant.

What is your reasoning behind claiming the opposite?

Or Descarte's Evil Demon:

It is at least possible that there is an all-powerful evil demon who
is deceiving me, such that he causes me to have false beliefs,
including the belief that there is a table in front of me and the
belief that two plus three equals five
.

As long as such a being possibly exists, even mathematical/logical truths are just conjecture. Perhaps tomorrow the evil demon will convince us 3 and 2 make 6.

No; I'm not a mathematician.

If Fermat proved that, 'if n is greater than [2] in the equation, "A^n+B^n=C^n," then the equation is impossible,' then he did so by using Mathematics. Mathematics is based on the conjecture that because it was so in the past it will continue to be so in the future.

H1] Universal constants will remain constant. H2] Universal constants could change.
Because we arrived at H1 via conjecture, H2 is a possibility, regardless of how exponentially small it is. Since H2 is a possibility, Fermat's Last Theorem may not be true in the future.

We wouldn't have to be capable of recognizing changes to mathematics. A sufficiently powerful being could simply make 2 and 2 equal whatever it wants and change all our memories of it ever equalling anything else. It's possible Pi has had countless values.

That was never the claim. You cant "do" math without thinking. Is it possible there's a being messing with your thoughts every time you think about math? Sure.
It surely was Larechar's claim. His objections sound like "Planck's constant could change". Only there is no Planck's constant on which formulas rely in math.

And as to your evil demon: he'd have to mess with all our brains simultaneously and consistently. Otherwise, people notice. Mathematicians aren't faultless either (see e.g. Wiles' first attempt at proof of Fermat's last theorem) and check each other's work.
 
It surely was Larechar's claim. His objections sound like "Planck's constant could change". Only there is no Planck's constant on which formulas rely in math.

Maybe it wasn't his claim, but an evil demon changed the words in his post.
 
And that's the problem with solipsism. It negates the entire history of intellectual development.


Because unless we accept that there is an objective reality we can understand what's the point?

Everything from the invention of fire to string theory, from the Golden Rule to Universal Declaration on Human Rights, from flint knapped stone arrow heads to interstellar space travel is null and void if I'm just a brain in a jar.
 
Because unless we accept that there is an objective reality we can understand what's the point?

Everything from the invention of fire to string theory, from the Golden Rule to Universal Declaration on Human Rights, from flint knapped stone arrow heads to interstellar space travel is null and void if I'm just a brain in a jar.

I still don't see how that follows. Even if you're a brain-in-a-jar, you've suceeded fantastically in describing the reality you believe yourself to be in. And also discovered principles that could apply in any reality (human rights).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom