Everything is conjecture

We're arguing that solipsism is a useless thing for learning more about the universe.

I agree. I'm not sure how you can think I'm refuting that point?

Perhaps my play on, "useful," was the conundrum. I defined useful as, "having a use at some point."

Furthermore, relative, was the key to that comment.
 
And congratulations you've had a thought that millions of great philosophers and random stoners (two groups which are becomingly disturbingly difficult to tell the difference between) have had.

It's meaningless and self contradictory. The entire concept of reality is the idea that there is an object existence to the universe that we are experiencing through our sense. If we don't assume that then what we're discussing isn't reality. Don't let semantics over the word reality lead you to give more thought to a meaningless old riddle then it deserves. All your asking is "What would reality be like if reality didn't exist?" Well it wouldn't, problem solved.

It's the same problem with that old tired, cliched "What happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" nonsense. It's pointless. If you live in a universe that has an unstoppable force in it there can't exist an immovable object in that same universe and vice versa because the existence of one is dependent, nay in fact defined by the, the non-existence of the other. It's a stupid little vapid idea wrapped up in overly complex florid prose.

I've mentioned this several times in other recent discussions. The ability to just make a superficially contradictory intellectual idea isn't the sign of intelligence so many people seem to think it is.

People who are hostile towards philosophy probably should avoid the "religion and philosophy" forum.
 
...It's the same problem with that old tired, cliched "What happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object" nonsense. It's pointless. If you live in a universe that has an unstoppable force in it there can't exist an immovable object in that same universe and vice versa because the existence of one is dependent, nay in fact defined by the, the non-existence of the other. It's a stupid little vapid idea wrapped up in overly complex florid prose...

Very well put. Mind if I use that sometime?

Too late, already did.
 
So when the rock hits your head sufficiently hard to eliminate you from this particular reality that's just a semblance of reality?

If the answer isn't obvious, then I just don't think you're grasping the concept.

Yes, your sentence above is correct. As Larechar said, you can't even prove I actually existed in the first place.

Personally, I don't agree with the concept. Or, I should say, it's impossible to disagree with because there's no evidence that can prove or disprove it, but I don't see any point in following it any further, once one has a basic understanding of it.

Solipsim is not something that one can scoff at as wrong, because it can't actually be proven wrong. The proper way to scoff at it is because it's pointless mental masturbation. :)

It's not quite mere conjection; it is in large part definition. We are the ones formulating, refering to, and utilizing the concepts, including the concept of existence. The only criteria for something to count as a "real reality" comes from the utility that criteria gives us.

Consider for example the claim: "This thread has an initial post by Larechar". In what manner can this claim be false?

That's why mathematics and other things with postulates/axioms aren't affected. Once "thread," "post," etc. are defined, one can talk about them as if they're real. Solipsism only works at the level of "Is there really a thread?"

Dreamed of rocks could do anything in the dream, and not much to the waking world.

It's the waking rocks we worry about, so we call that real.

As an analogy, though, I think it works. The joke that's supposed to disprove solipsism, is that "unreal" rocks cause "real" injury. It ignores the fact that the injury is in the same "reality" as the rock.

In other words, we understand that a person can be hit with a rock in a dream and dream they're hurt, even though the dream rock caused no "real" injury in the "real" world.

That's exactly what solipsism says: the rock, the body, and the injury all have the same degree of reality, or lack thereof. However, unlike the dream world and the waking world, we can't contrast this degree of reality with anything else, because we have no memories of experiencing anything else.
 
If the answer isn't obvious, then I just don't think you're grasping the concept.

Yes, your sentence above is correct. As Larechar said, you can't even prove I actually existed in the first place.

Personally, I don't agree with the concept. Or, I should say, it's impossible to disagree with because there's no evidence that can prove or disprove it, but I don't see any point in following it any further, once one has a basic understanding of it.

Solipsim is not something that one can scoff at as wrong, because it can't actually be proven wrong. The proper way to scoff at it is because it's pointless mental masturbation. :)



That's why mathematics and other things with postulates/axioms aren't affected. Once "thread," "post," etc. are defined, one can talk about them as if they're real. Solipsism only works at the level of "Is there really a thread?"



As an analogy, though, I think it works. The joke that's supposed to disprove solipsism, is that "unreal" rocks cause "real" injury. It ignores the fact that the injury is in the same "reality" as the rock.

In other words, we understand that a person can be hit with a rock in a dream and dream they're hurt, even though the dream rock caused no "real" injury in the "real" world.

That's exactly what solipsism says: the rock, the body, and the injury all have the same degree of reality, or lack thereof. However, unlike the dream world and the waking world, we can't contrast this degree of reality with anything else, because we have no memories of experiencing anything else.

My point was against the title of this thread "Everything is conjecture" not solipsism.
 
People who are hostile towards philosophy probably should avoid the "religion and philosophy" forum.

I have no issue with philosophy. Just with patently useless concepts like solipsism that are obtuse and confusing for their own sake and are so often used to justify crap.
 
I agree. I'm not sure how you can think I'm refuting that point?

Perhaps my play on, "useful," was the conundrum. I defined useful as, "having a use at some point."

Furthermore, relative, was the key to that comment.

In that case I sincerely apologize for engaging in what seems to have been uncalled bickering with you.

Oh and happy birthday :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom