Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

I'm interested to read that Rustum Roy's wife is a homoeopath. That must be the connection we were looking for. I suppose he can still go on saying that he has no vested interest in homoeopathy etc., but really!!!

You've got to admire the man for still having that sort of "vested interest" at his age.
 
Looks like Wikipedia have mostly had enough of Ullman.
Dana, the agreement with your unblock was that you not edit the article space until consensus had been reached on the talk page. You've not upheld this part of the deal. For that reason, your editing of the article space is now revoked for an undetermined period of time.


He's saying he has merely been asked not to edit articles, rather than having had his editing "revoked" (as in Hig Hurtenflurst, perhaps?):
Dana Ullman said:
...it is a blessing having her as a mentor. She has asked me to not edit any article at this time, and instead, I have only written in the Talk pages.
 
I'm interested to read that Rustum Roy's wife is a homoeopath.


I've had a look, and I can't find any evidence for that. She seems to be an expert in concrete and cement (she founded and edits Cement and Concrete Research) but I haven't found anything linking her with homoeopathy other than via her husband.

Rusty is launching a new journal, by the way: The Science of Healing Outcomes
  • 1st professional scientific journal devoted to records/data on human healing, including single case studies
  • 1st peer-reviewed journal of case studies of healing using scientific criteria instead of statistical data


Anecdote-tastic!

According to the cover mock-up, it isn't peer-reviewed, but "super peer-reviewed", i.e. it relies on argument from authority rather than the merits of the actual papers.
 
Rusty is launching a new journal, by the way: The Science of Healing Outcomes

Anecdote-tastic!

According to the cover mock-up, it isn't peer-reviewed, but "super peer-reviewed", i.e. it relies on argument from authority rather than the merits of the actual papers.
:D
•1st professional scientific journal devoted to records/data on human healing​
So where have the millions of human medical research publications appeared previously - in The International Journal of Porcine Medicine?

This Journal of the Science of Healing Outcomes will have several unique features.​
  1. •It will present articles relying on current scientific criteria as in all classical engineering and science (not the statistical legerdemain of RCT)
Subtext: Since RCTs have always shown our alternative healing methods to be bunk, we will use some other way of demonstrating their magic healing powers.
And anyway this is hardly unique - most quackery-woo journals avoid RCTs like the plague.

I wonder how they persuaded Richard Smith (ex BMJ editor) to put his name forward as an editor to this drivel.
 
I wonder how they persuaded Richard Smith (ex BMJ editor) to put his name forward as an editor to this drivel.


Perhaps he didn’t need too much persuasion. Here's something he wrote back in May 2006:


Which is the quack medicine?

One of the delights of English life is watching our aging prince scrapping with doctors over integrated, complementary, alternative, or quack medicine (choose the adjective to suit your prejudices).

Read on…

http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/richard_smith/2006/05/richard_smith_on_quack_medicin.html
 
He is also an executive director of Ovations and UnitedHealth Europe both subsidiaries of UnitedHealth Group.

They advocate CAM, what a surprise :eek:
 
I see Dana has materialised over on the Science based medicine homeopathy thread.
Whack-a-mole time once more. All the old canards, and reference to his own writings yet again.
Linda has posted there too, linking back here so that peoples arms don't tire too easily with the club.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps he didn’t need too much persuasion. Here's something he wrote back in May 2006:

I'm unimpressed by someone who can't be bothered to discover that what he says is bollocks.

The US congressional report some years back estimated that only 15% of orthodox treatments are supported by solid evidence.

Contrary to the claims, evidence-based practice appears to be prevalent, and it appears to be widely distributed geographically. Evidence for evidence-based practice includes those listed in the box (q.v.).

...

• 81% of interventions in general practice (25.5% by RCT, UK)[19]

• 82% of general medical interventions (53% by RCT, UK)[20]

• 55% of general practice interventions (38% by RCT, Spain)[21]

http://www.veterinarywatch.com/CTiM.htm

Linda
 
Hi guys,

I emailed the website that posted the breast cancer case. A colleague of the homeopath replied, and I was unable to convince her to participate. She referred me to a book written by Dr. Ramakrishnan, saying that it contains the documentation of cancer cases I am looking for.

I emailed a 90-year old lady who says homeopathy cured her Non-Hodgkins Lymphoma. This is what she told me:

In '04 found itchy lump on left shoulder/back. Had sample of same sent for testing , return report as follows:

4/26/04 report from UCSF Dermatopthology Service was
Cinical Data R/R Elc, nodule
Diagnosis " B_cell lymphoid infilitrated with an aberrant immunopheniotype, consitent with b-cell Lymphoma (202.1)"

Then a genetypic analysis was done and confirmed via a PCR based method and a clonalk B cell population was found.and stems from B-cell lymphoma.

Blood test take 10/28/07-all normal.
WBC 5.6
RBC 4.33
Hemoglobin 13.9
Hermatocrit 40.6
MCV 94

from 2004-2006 took 2 daily homeopathic remedies in method used by Dr. R in his Book. Since 2007 take same 2 remedies , only each one day alternate month,

This lady apparently used the methods described in Dr. Ramakrishnan's book (which is out of print).

She is the nicest lady, but she is 90 years old and very busy. I don't feel like bothering her anymore, so I am going to stop here. No doubt it will not meet your challenge, but this is as far as I am going.

Good luck to all of you in your "quest."
 
I see Dana has materialised over on the Science based medicine homeopathy thread.
Whack-a-mole time once more. All the old canards, and reference to his own writings yet again.
Linda has posted there too, linking back here so that peoples arms don't tire too easily with the club.

" Actually, I debased against 20-40 different people concurrently and often successfully."

Calling Dr Freud. Calling Dr Freud.
 
HelenSan said:
Hi guys,

I emailed the website that posted the breast cancer case. A colleague of the homeopath replied, and I was unable to convince her to participate. She referred me to a book written by Dr. Ramakrishnan, saying that it contains the documentation of cancer cases I am looking for.

Okay, so no help there.

I emailed a 90-year old lady who says homeopathy cured her Non-Hodgkins Lymphoma. This is what she told me:

In '04 found itchy lump on left shoulder/back. Had sample of same sent for testing , return report as follows:

4/26/04 report from UCSF Dermatopthology Service was
Cinical Data R/R Elc, nodule
Diagnosis " B_cell lymphoid infilitrated with an aberrant immunopheniotype, consitent with b-cell Lymphoma (202.1)"

Then a genetypic analysis was done and confirmed via a PCR based method and a clonalk B cell population was found.and stems from B-cell lymphoma.

Blood test take 10/28/07-all normal.
WBC 5.6
RBC 4.33
Hemoglobin 13.9
Hermatocrit 40.6
MCV 94

from 2004-2006 took 2 daily homeopathic remedies in method used by Dr. R in his Book. Since 2007 take same 2 remedies , only each one day alternate month,

This lady apparently used the methods described in Dr. Ramakrishnan's book (which is out of print).

She is the nicest lady, but she is 90 years old and very busy. I don't feel like bothering her anymore, so I am going to stop here. No doubt it will not meet your challenge, but this is as far as I am going.

Good luck to all of you in your "quest."

Okay. I'm assuming that 1) she did not take conventional treatment and 2) that you think she's cured (even though you did not specify this). Unfortunately (not for her, of course), the most common type of B-cell lymphoma has an indolent course, sometimes going for years without symptoms or without progressing to a more aggressive course. And only 10 percent show involvement of the peripheral blood. So all you've really described is what we'd expect to see if the homeopathic treatment had no effect. I've had patients who have gone much longer without progression than the 3+ years she has managed.

I'm sure it's unreasonable for us to notice that, or for us to doubt that the case reports from Dr. Ramakrishnan would be convincing, though. ;)

Linda
 
Last edited:
" Actually, I debased against 20-40 different people concurrently and often successfully."

Calling Dr Freud. Calling Dr Freud.


Actually, the claim of having successfully "debased" against a large number of people for a long time, the wild claims, and the apparent inability to take notice of anyone else's argument (as well as the condescending attitude and the occasional malapropism), puts me in mind of another Californian.
 
Last edited:
I do want to learn! However, after just reviewing all of my recent contributions [[2]], I couldn't see an example of "snippiness" or new information. Even my one reference to "half-quotes create half-truths" was a good simple summary of my contribution to the Talk page. That said, I remain humble and wish to learn what errors I may have committed. Dana Ullman Talk 21:29, 5 February 2008 (UTC)

This reminds me of a certain Dickens character. Oh so humble.
 
Okay. I'm assuming that 1) she did not take conventional treatment and 2) that you think she's cured (even though you did not specify this). Unfortunately (not for her, of course), the most common type of B-cell lymphoma has an indolent course, sometimes going for years without symptoms or without progressing to a more aggressive course.

#1 is correct. She had no conventional treatment.

Do I think she is cured? She no longer has her itchy bump on her shoulder. In her words, "Yes, no more NHL, shoulder completly flat, no growth." She had a growth; now it's gone. Blood tests come back normal. Yeah, I think she is in remission. I think this is more than the lymphoma taking an indolent course.

Is this sort of remission for NHL common? I don't know. Did the homeopathy cause the remission? I don't know. Would I say "cured"? Without direct evidence of causation, I am hesitant to use such a strong word.
 
#1 is correct. She had no conventional treatment.

Do I think she is cured? She no longer has her itchy bump on her shoulder. In her words, "Yes, no more NHL, shoulder completly flat, no growth." She had a growth; now it's gone.

But that's hardly a surprise considering that she had it surgically removed (i.e. the pathology report says "nodule").

Blood tests come back normal. Yeah, I think she is in remission. I think this is more than the lymphoma taking an indolent course.

Yet, blood tests would also be normal in 90 percent of the cases anyway.

Is this sort of remission for NHL common? I don't know. Did the homeopathy cause the remission? I don't know. Would I say "cured"? Without direct evidence of causation, I am hesitant to use such a strong word.

We also have no idea whether or not the cancer is gone (i.e. the tests that would tell us have not been done (or weren't told to us)). Another reason not to say "cured".

Linda
 
But that's hardly a surprise considering that she had it surgically removed (i.e. the pathology report says "nodule").

She says, "Other than the biopsy, nothing more was removed. In a period of 2 yrs, it disappeared by itself with the treatment I was taking." I understand that to mean the entire bump was not removed for biopsy, and the rest of the bump disappeared later.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps she had the lump removed leaving a post surgical soft tissue swelling or haematoma that gradually resolved. Do you have the complete report because it might provide a clue.
 
She says, "Other than the biopsy, nothing more was removed. In a period of 2 yrs, it disappeared by itself with the treatment I was taking." I understand that to mean the entire bump was not removed for biopsy, and the rest of the bump disappeared later.

This is one of the commoner reasons for these miracles cures that aren't - lumps that are assumed to be cancerous, but are due to other normal and expected processes.

Taking a biopsy can mean taking the whole thing as well as taking a piece. The inflammation associated with healing and scar tissue can give the appearance that there is still some of the original tissue present - especially if any other lump-like complications are present like a hematoma or granulomatous inflammation (as Billy Joe mentioned). This would be expected to gradually resolve over many months to a few years.

If only part of the node was taken, then how would you know that cancer was present in the part that was left? It may have been enlarged simply as a reaction to the presence of the cancer (an expected reaction), and once that was removed, the node gradually returned to its normal, non-palpable size.

The description on the pathology report of a "nodule" suggests that the whole cancer was removed. However, whether or not it was, we have no reason to assume that the lump she continued to feel for some months afterward was cancerous. Conversely, just because she can no longer feel a lump does not mean the cancer is gone. It may not have been palpable due to the bulk of the cancer, but due to a reaction taking place in response to the cancer - a reaction that gradually resolved over time without any change in the cancer itself.

To sum up, a lump at the biopsy site that gradually resolves over 2 years is an expected outcome in the absence of an effect from magic water.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom