Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Who says Homoepathy all together invalidates the allopathy system? We just say if a certain disease or condition could be cured by homoeopathy, it should be, simply because it is a safer mode of treatment compared to allopathy. And if can't be cured by Homoeopathy, one is and should refer to allopathy or any other mode of treatment for the matter of fact.


And then in the other thread you said to try homeopathy and you will be cured just the same as using evidence/reality based medicine.

Contradictory? Totally.

Homeopathy is not safer, it is the same as doing nothing. If doing nothing has the same effect as using magic water, then it is more cost effective to do nothing. Evidence based medicine will take care of what it can. Homeopathy is useless and and a waste of money.


Using the term "allopathy" is just plain outdated and bordering on totally rude.
 
{snip} One thing more I need to know, earlier it was 'New Blood' under my name. Later on, I don't know who ( may be moderator) changes it to student.
The label under your name changes according to how many posts you have made. It is meaningless.

And, as Eos said, 'allopathy' (in all forms) is long outdated and verging on insulting. It is also meaningless (it only had meaning as a marketing term for Samuel H.).
 
And, as Eos said, 'allopathy' (in all forms) is long outdated and verging on insulting. It is also meaningless (it only had meaning as a marketing term for Samuel H.).


Ironically, the systems that have most in common with the "allopathy" of Hahnemann's time, since like it they rely to some extent on the concept of "humours" (e.g. TCM or Ayurveda), rarely if ever seem to be criticised by homoeopaths.
 
Let me give you a simple example of them. When I was born, i had severe inflammed tonsilitis. Allopaths offered my father to remove my tonsils. But my father thought otherwise. When I was around 3-4 years, he made me started doing gurgles. That continued for two years uninterrupted. That day onwards, with God's grace, I had never any tonsilitis problem.

Well I freely admit that I know next to nothing about medicine, but I would have thought that a simple operation (and remving tonsils is hardly a major operation) is somwhat preferable to two years of annoying therapy.

That is only the first thing that occurs to me...
 
Tonsils are rarely removed anymore. Evidence based medicine offers therapies that will work much quicker than 2 years if it seems to need it. I would think a couple of months would be enough suffering???

Today, tonsils are recognized for their role in filtering harmful bacteria and viruses that could cause more serious infections. When tonsillitis strikes, the first line of treatment is typically self-care or antibiotics. Surgery is seldom necessary, unless tonsillitis recurs often or it interferes with breathing or swallowing.

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/tonsillitis/DS00273

It seems homeopath biases have kept our resident homeopath from learning about what real MDs ever do.
 
Last edited:
When I was born, i had severe inflammed tonsilitis. Allopaths offered my father to remove my tonsils. But my father thought otherwise. When I was around 3-4 years, he made me started doing gurgles. That continued for two years uninterrupted. That day onwards, with God's grace, I had never any tonsilitis problem.


Tonsillectomy after a single attack of tonsillitis is now recognised to be unnecessary. The modern criteria for tonsillectomy is six episodes of pustular tonsillitis in a twelve month period. For others the episodes of tonsillitis usually gradually become much less frequent and often stop at the age of about five.
So it sounds like your tonsils followed the natural history of the condition.
 
Well I freely admit that I know next to nothing about medicine, but I would have thought that a simple operation (and remving tonsils is hardly a major operation) is somwhat preferable to two years of annoying therapy.


Tonsillectomy is not a simple procedure. Children have died as a result of haemorrhage because of unrecognised bleeding disorder or of anaesthetic complication.
It should not be undertaken lightly.
 
No, you are again mistaken. I said Homoeopathy offers a great alternative to sufferers. In many cases surgery could be avoided but allopaths insist on them. Let me give you a simple example of them. When I was born, i had severe inflammed tonsilitis. Allopaths offered my father to remove my tonsils. But my father thought otherwise. When I was around 3-4 years, he made me started doing gurgles. That continued for two years uninterrupted. That day onwards, with God's grace, I had never any tonsilitis problem.The point is there are many instances, where surgery could be avoided but allopaths insists otherwise because their industry has to keep running.

I don't know anything about the other modes of treatment because have not been trained in those. So I can't comment on them. But still I respect them because I beleive patient should be cured whatever the mode of treatment is , and surgery should be done only as a last resort.

I had recurrent tonsillitis as a child and was told if I had one more episode I'd have to have them out. I never had it again. So, by your standards the threat of surgery cures tonsillitis a damn sight better than the treatment you took.
 
Tonsillectomy is not a simple procedure. Children have died as a result of haemorrhage because of unrecognised bleeding disorder or of anaesthetic complication.
It should not be undertaken lightly.

Sounds like it shouldn't. What is the comparable risk if tonsilitis is untreated?
 
No, you are again mistaken. I said Homoeopathy offers a great alternative to sufferers. In many cases surgery could be avoided but allopaths insist on them. Let me give you a simple example of them. When I was born, i had severe inflammed tonsilitis. Allopaths offered my father to remove my tonsils. But my father thought otherwise. When I was around 3-4 years, he made me started doing gurgles. That continued for two years uninterrupted. That day onwards, with God's grace, I had never any tonsilitis problem.The point is there are many instances, where surgery could be avoided but allopaths insists otherwise because their industry has to keep running.

I don't know anything about the other modes of treatment because have not been trained in those. So I can't comment on them. But still I respect them because I beleive patient should be cured whatever the mode of treatment is , and surgery should be done only as a last resort.

And how many adults do you know that suffer from tonsilitis? How may teenagers? Tonsilitis is obviously a disease that disappears with age whether you do the gurgles or not. :boggled:
 
Sounds like it shouldn't. What is the comparable risk if tonsilitis is untreated?


If you don't treat pustular tonsillitis with antibiotics, there is a risk of developing a tonsillar abscess. This is treated by lancing, usually without anaesthetic. If you ignore the tonsillar abscess, I guess you could develop septicaemia which could prove fatal. Presumably the risk is so low that tonsillectomy is not recommended as a preventative treatment because the risks of tonsillectomy must be greater.
 
I had recurrent tonsillitis as a child and was told if I had one more episode I'd have to have them out. I never had it again.


I'd never had a single attack of tonsillitis, yet mine were removed at the age of three when my brother presented to the doctor with his first attack of tonsillitis. Having decided that his needed to come out, the doctor looked at mine and said they would need to come out as well.
If that wasn't overkill for my brother, it certainly was for me. :mad:
 
I had recurrent tonsillitis as a child and was told if I had one more episode I'd have to have them out. I never had it again. So, by your standards the threat of surgery cures tonsillitis a damn sight better than the treatment you took.

So did I, but it was ignored (something to do with multiple moves and father being shipped to Vietnam, early mid-1960s). It wasn't until it was noticed I could not hear that something was done. Unfortunately I almost bled to death from the surgery. But I lived (which had something to do with my mother's reaction to the Army hospital med tech trying to treat me for just a nosebleed... my mother was not a quiet calm person, and the poor med tech was smart enough to call in a real doctor to save him from an enraged woman whose husband had just been shipped to a warzone), and regained my hearing.

The only reference I've see to tonsils is our family doctor pointing out how big they were on one of three kids. Nothing else. Though strep infections, and other problems have been checked, and no kid has lost their hearing (one kid did need tubes/grommets in his ear for a while).

I wonder if my issues with hearing loss could have been dealt with by the use of tubes/grommets in the ear drum?
 
So it sounds like tonsillectomy is pretty unnecessary, and although it has been used in the past, probably without due cause in some cases, the procedure is not as popular as it was and less invasive techniques are used - when necessary.

Sounds fair to me. I almost forget, why was this a plus for Homeopathy? It seems to me that medicine is learning and changing - as you would expect.
 
Who says Homoepathy all together invalidates the allopathy system? We just say if a certain disease or condition could be cured by homoeopathy, it should be, simply because it is a safer mode of treatment compared to allopathy. And if can't be cured by Homoeopathy, one is and should refer to allopathy or any other mode of treatment for the matter of fact.
Homeopathy invalidates conventional medicine because the paradigms are incompatible.

According to homeopathy, disease is caused by disturbances in the vital force, and only by that. Those disturbances can be caused by various things, but it is not possible to achieve cure unless you treat the vital force.

Conventional medicine holds that disease is caused by a variety of biological and mental causes, and that if you remove the cause, cure can be obtained.

Obviously, both paradigms cannot be true.

Hans
 
It seems to me that medicine is learning and changing - as you would expect.


Here is another more recent change:

It has been found that "compression only" resuscitation is more successful that "mouth to mouth/compression" resuscitation.
In a recent trial of over 800 patients, the walk out of hospital survival rate increased from about 2% to about 6% (I bet you didn't think it was that low). However, in the subgroup of patients who were observed to collapse, and on whom resuscitation was commenced immediately, the survival increased from about 5% to about 18%.

BJ
 
According to homeopathy, disease is caused by disturbances in the vital force, and only by that.

Maybe Scientology borrowed from that philosophy a bit, and that is why Hubbard came up with an e-machinethingamabob to evict those nasty aliens from your vital forceness?
 
Let me give you a simple example of them. When I was born, i had severe inflammed tonsilitis. Allopaths offered my father to remove my tonsils. But my father thought otherwise. When I was around 3-4 years, he made me started doing gurgles. That continued for two years uninterrupted. That day onwards, with God's grace, I had never any tonsilitis problem.
Let me give you a counter-example: When I was a child, I had severe inflamed tonsilitis (I do not kid: this is real). The doctor decided that we should do nothing about it. Eventually, it disappeared. What lessons do we learn from this?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom